Retrospective seniority can't be claimed from date when employee is not even borne in service:Supreme Court

supreme court, Retrospective seniority, Subhash Reddy and Hrishikesh Roy, service, high court

Retrospective seniority cannot be claimed from a date when an employee is not even borne in service, the Supreme Court Tuesday said while allowing an appeal by the Bihar government challenging retrospective seniority to a man. The apex court said it is also necessary to bear in mind that retrospective seniority unless directed by the court or expressly provided by the applicable Rules, should not be allowed, as in so doing, others who had earlier entered service will be impacted.

“The jurisprudence in the field of service law would advise us that retrospective seniority cannot be claimed from a date when an employee is not even borne in service,” a bench of Justices R Subhash Reddy and Hrishikesh Roy said.

The top court was hearing an appeal filed by the Bihar government challenging the order of the Patna High Court which allowed a plea by a state resident seeking retrospective seniority.

The top court noted that his father was working as a Home guard and after he died in harness, the son applied for a compassionate appointment.

The concerned Committee recommended his name along with others in 1985 as one of the persons shortlisted for appointment on a compassionate basis.

After being found unfit on physical standards, he moved to the high court which allowed his appointment for Class IV post.

As he was shortlisted for the post of Adhinayak Lipik, he challenged the High Court order which was allowed by the apex court and he was appointed on February 27, 1996, by the order issued by the Commandant of the Bihar Home Guard.

Six years after joining service, an application was made in 2002 by him claiming seniority from December 5, 1985, but the authorities rejected the claim on the ground that he was appointed in 1996 and that he was not borne in service as of 1985.

The rejection order was then challenged and the Patna High Court directed the authority to consider his seniority from December 5, 1985.

The apex court noted that the compassionate appointment of the respondent is not being questioned here but importantly he is claiming seniority benefit for 10 years without working for a single day during that period.

“In other words, precedence is being claimed over other regular employees who have entered service between 1985 to 1996. In this situation, the seniority balance cannot be tilted against those who entered service much before the respondent. Seniority benefits can accrue only after a person joins service and to say that benefits can be earned retrospectively would be erroneous,” the bench said.

The bench said that the present is not a case of recruitment by selection and is a compassionate appointment made on this court’s order.

The court’s direction to the State was to appoint within one month without specifying that the appointment should have a retrospective effect, it said.

The bench said that the respondent never raised any claim for relating his appointment to an earlier date.

“Six years later, only on September 10, 2002, he made a representation, and the same was rejected with the observation that in 1985, the respondent was yet to enter service.

“Proceeding with these facts, it is clearly discernible that the respondent has slept over his rights, and never earlier pointedly addressed his present claim either to the Supreme Court (in the earlier round) or to the State, soon after his appointment,” the bench said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

TV stars Ridhiema, Adhvik on why 'Karwa Chauth' matters to both men and women

© IANS TV stars Ridhiema, Adhvik on why ‘Karwa Chauth’ matters to both men and women. Mumbai, Oct 24 (IANS) Sunday is Karwa Chauth, a very auspicious day for all ... Read more »

Docu-series on Salman Khan to Feature Director Sanjay Leela Bhansali?

© Provided by News18 Filmmaker Sanjay Leela Bhansali, back in 2019, announced In-shaa-Allah starring Salman Khan and Alia Bhatt. However, a few days before it was set to roll, the ... Read more »

Die Atlanta Braves folgen den Houston Astros in die World Series

© KEYSTONE/AP/John Bazemore Die Atlanta Braves ziehen zum ersten Mal seit 1999 wieder in die World Series der Major League Baseball ein. Die Braves gewannen das sechste Spiel der Finalserie ... Read more »

Gogglebox Welcomes New Additions Simon And Jane To The Couch After Cast Departures

Simon and Jane on Gogglebox (Photo: Channel 4) There were some new faces as Gogglebox continued on Friday night, with two additions to the cast. The Channel 4 show welcomed ... Read more »

Report: PAS deputy president moots six-14-eight formula to win Melaka with Umno and Bersatu

© Provided by Malay Mail PAS deputy president Datuk Mohd Amar Nik Abdullah has proposed a formula for his party, Umno and ally Bersatu in next month’s Melaka election. — ... Read more »

India moving ahead with new energy after 1 billion Covid vaccinations: PM Modi

© Provided by Hindustan Times Stating that he is aware of the capabilities of the people of the nation, Modi said he knows that the healthcare workers would leave no ... Read more »

Fox News anchor Chris Wallace dubs White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki 'one of the best press secretaries ever'

© AP Photo/Evan Vucci White House press secretary Jen Psaki speaks during a press briefing at the White House, Friday, Oct. 22, 2021, in Washington. AP Photo/Evan Vucci Fox News ... Read more »

Cargo ship catches fire after dozens of shipping containers fell off

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Dozens of shipping containers have fallen from a ship into Canadian waters, and the cargo ship carrying them has caught ablaze amid the ... Read more »

Civilian killed in firing incident in Shopian in J&K

Srinagar, A civilian was killed in a firing incident in Shopian district of Jammu and Kashmir on Sunday, officials said. The incident took place in Zainapora area of Shopian in ... Read more »

David Beckham bags £150million to be face of the Qatar World Cup

DAVID Beckham will be unveiled as the face of the Qatar World Cup next month — netting £150million. The former England captain, 46, nicknamed Goldenballs, signed a deal worth £15million ... Read more »

Paresh Rawal: I don't support vulgar comedy that runs down people and makes fun of their physical deformity

© Provided by Pinkvilla Paresh Rawal has always upped his own game when it comes to the genre of comedy. But there is one thing he is not in support ... Read more »

Peter Scolari, Newhart and Bosom Buddies actor, dies of cancer at 66

Peter Scolari died Friday morning in New York after fighting cancer for two years, Peter Scolari, a versatile character actor whose television roles included a yuppie producer on Newhart and ... Read more »

Pratik Gandhi wants to be equally open to all roles: I should be known by my character, not by my name

© Provided by Pinkvilla Actor Pratik Gandhi, who gained stardom overnight with his portrayal of Harshad Mehta in the web-series ‘Scam 1992’, says he has one wish and that is ... Read more »

Arjun Kapoor, Kareena, Karishma attend Malaika Arora birthday bash at her mom's residence - See Pics!

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: On the occasion of Malaika Arora’s 48th birthday, the beautiful diva celebrated her day with her special ones. Malla was spotted with her ... Read more »

Shakur Stevenson scores stoppage of Jamel Herring to claim WBO junior lightweight title

In the breakthrough performance of his young career, Shakur Stevenson became a two-division champion on Saturday in a master class of a performance.   © Provided by CBS Sports Stevenson ... Read more »

Covid cases going down fast – OCTA

© The Manila Times Local tourists take a group selfie in Fort Santiago in Intramuros, Manila on October 23, 2021. PHOTO BY RENE H. DILAN Cases of Covid-19 are declining ... Read more »

Light at end of Covid-19 tunnel is still faint and flickering

© The Independent Singapore Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft. ... Read more »

Man United in discussions over the major redevelopment of Old Trafford

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Manchester United have opened discussions on a major redevelopment of Old Trafford that could see the stadium’s capacity increase to 80,000.  The club ... Read more »

YOURSAY | Why is rape considered a joke by some men?

© Malaysiakini (English) YOURSAY | ‘Sadly, the local culture ‘permits’ such sexual remarks as bantering.’ Actor slammed for allegedly making jokes about rape Mahishasura Mardhini: “Mistakes” like rape jokes should ... Read more »

Rajinikanth says October 25 is an important occasion for two reasons. This is why

Rajinikanth will be conferred with the Dadasaheb Phalke Award on October 25 in New Delhi. Superstar Rajinikanth, in a statement on Sunday, said that October 25 is an important occasion ... Read more »

Flood situation improves in 3 states

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: The situation in food-hit areas in Selangor, Melaka and Perak has continued to improve, with the number of evacuees and relief centres ... Read more »

Industri seni kehilangan sebutir bintang: PM

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA LUMPUR- Pemergian pengarah filem Mamat Khalid satu kehilangan sebutir bintang kepada dunia seni tanah air, kata Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob. Ismail ... Read more »

Key West Brom talking points vs Bristol City as new partnership pays off

After the midweek display against Swansea City, West Bromwich Albion needed to head into the game with a different approach. The Baggies delivered just that as they saw off Bristol ... Read more »

"The bottom line of it is" - Graham Roberts drops encouraging Hotspur Way claim involving Nuno

Former Tottenham Hotspur player Graham Roberts believes that the players are starting to believe in what Nuno Espirito Santo is doing. After being appointed in the summer, Espirito Santo got ... Read more »

Barcelona hero's surprise Ronald Koeman verdict ahead of El Clasico clash vs Real Madrid

Barcelona legend Albert Ferrer has somewhat surprisingly lauded manager Ronald Koeman for the job he is doing in Catalonia – and believes the Dutchman is the perfect figure to help ... Read more »

Former athletics world medallist Quinonez shot dead

Ecuadorian Olympic sprinter Alex Quinonez was shot dead in the port city of Guayaquil, authorities announced, sparking a nationwide state of emergency beginning Monday in a bid to track down ... Read more »

Samsung Users Alert! Samsung will close their cloud services soon: Here's how to save your data

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Samsung Galaxy users are getting pop-up notifications to migrate their photos from Samsung Online, the company’s cloud storage. In addition, the corporation has ... Read more »

WhatsApp is going stop working on these old phones Samsung and Apple

WhatsApp, the most popular messaging application used daily by hundreds of millions of people will stop working for certain old phones. Come 1st of November the instant messaging application will ... Read more »

Fisdom Launches Stock Broking Services: Industry-first Features with Subscription, Know More

© Provided by News18 Fisdom Launches Stock Broking Services: Industry-first Features with Subscription, Know More One of the leading wealth-tech firms, Fisdom, has stepped into the stockbroking space and has ... Read more »

Pakistani girl told Dhoni to lose against Pakistan, his response goes VIRAL

© Provided by DNA Several vlips and videos of funny banter from the venue of the big match have been going viral. One such short clip of terrific banter between ... Read more »

LaLiga, El Clasico: When and where to watch live telecast of Barcelona vs Real Madrid

© Provided by Firstpost LaLiga, El Clasico: When and where to watch live telecast of Barcelona vs Real Madrid Barcelona can’t be afraid of Real Madrid when the teams meet ... Read more »

Indian Navy Sailor (MR) recruitment begins on October 29

The Indian Navy will begin the registration process for enrolment as sailors for matric recruit for course commencing from April 2022. The registration process will begin on October 29 and ... Read more »

LIC Jeevan Umang Policy can Get you up to Rs 28 lakh Return for Rs 1,302 per Month

© Provided by News18 LIC Jeevan Umang Policy can Get you up to Rs 28 lakh Return for Rs 1,302 per Month Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) of India regularly launches ... Read more »

T20 World Cup 2021: Rohit Sharma vs Shaheen Afridi, Virat Kohli vs Shadab Khan and other player battles

© Provided by Firstpost T20 World Cup 2021: Rohit Sharma vs Shaheen Afridi, Virat Kohli vs Shadab Khan and other player battles Not too long for the Battle Royale as ... Read more »

Celebrity birthdays for Oct. 24

Celebrity Birthdays for Oct. 24:   Former Rolling Stones bassist Bill Wyman is 85. Steel guitarist Santo Farina, of the duo Santo and Johnny, is 84. Actor F. Murray Abraham ... Read more »

Sen. Bernie Sanders said expansions to medicare are 'not coming out' of spending bill, contradicting Biden

© Andrew Harnik/AP Photo Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., speaks to reporters as he leaves a Democratic strategy meeting at the Capitol in Washington, Tuesday, Oct. 19, 2021. Andrew Harnik/AP Photo ... Read more »

Hungary's Orban, opposition rival hold rallies as election race heats up

© Marton Monus, Reuters Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban and newly elected opposition leader Peter Marki-Zay held separate rallies in Budapest on Saturday six months from an election expected to ... Read more »

‘Celtic have begun talks…' - Journalist lifts lid on exciting development out of Parkhead

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Anthony Ralston in training for Celtic Taking to Twitter, reporter Ekrem Konur has lifted the lid on an exciting development out of Parkhead involving Celtic ... Read more »

India to bargain for undelivered cargoes for renewing LNG import contract with Qatar

Reuters India will bargain for supply of undelivered gas quantities of past years when it negotiates renewal of its multi-billion dollar LNG import deal with Qatar, an official said. Petronet ... Read more »

Pacers overcome Heat in overtime for first win of season

© Provided by SPIN.ph By PHILLIP B. WILSON INDIANAPOLIS — After not playing much defense in the season’s first two games, the Indiana Pacers were far more stingy against the ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic