Reshuffles make great theatre, but a few new players on the Westminster stage give me very little to applaud

© Getty/AP

Left to right: Dominic Raab, Liz Truss and Michael Gove

– Getty/AP

Cabinet reshuffles are like political Christmas in Westminster. As a spectator there is an almost carnival atmosphere as you sit around gossiping about who is going to get what, an anticipation of a much hoped for sacking and the giddy expectation of a new shiny gift that you had hoped would be a Playstation, but is actually a disappointing pair of novelty socks, which will be amusing for the one day, but then you wake up every day with a dreadful foreign secretary and you realise the joke was very much on you.

The firings and hirings are the meat of the meal in a government reshuffle, but they are not the best bit. The best bit is watching junior ministers in the tea rooms trying valiantly to pretend that they are “honestly not fussed at all”. They are all really fussed. They must, however, act casual, nonchalant and disinterested while never being 30cm away from their phones in case that special call might come. Being in the Commons tea room during this reshuffle was like watching an amateur dramatic production where a group of fully grown men had been cast as listless teenage boys.

We opposition MPs are no better. In this particular political ballet we play the part of imp, where if you see any would-be-promoted you jeer, “Hoping for home sec?” I have watched many government reshuffles, but the very best performance of “not bothered” came from Shailesh Vara, who I was in a meeting with in 2018 when Theresa May was in the  middle of a reshuffle. His phone rang to much embarrassment on his part and he ended the call and apologised. I played my part and ribbed him gently that we were happy for him to take the call, after all it might be the prime minister offering him a job. He responded by jokingly saying, “I assure you that will not be the case”. We continued the meeting. It transpired after the meeting that it had in fact been a call offering him the job of under secretary of state in Northern Ireland. That is true commitment to nonchalance. Luckily for him they called back.

The purpose of this week’s reshuffle, and all those that have gone before, is to give the sense of a new broom sweeping away the problems of the recent past. This one seemingly has, like everything the Tories do, been trailed with a natty slogan. It is apparently a “levelling up” reshuffle – although not if you are Robert Jenrick of course. There is very little for me to delight in in the new line up. Alas the organ grinder remains the same. A few new faces will do little to give me any faith that this new team of people will try to reimagine governance as something that is open and honest, nor will it reinstall some of the principles of decency that I have felt to be so very lacking of late.

There is one very big reason to be cheerful though and that is the loss of Gavin Williamson from senior office. Surely he wears the crown of worst education secretary in history, at a time when we really needed a good one. Never trust a man who needs props to look commanding. I cannot count the ways in which his position has worried me. He failed the kids in my constituency, he seemingly took no interest in the plight of children with special educational needs, he appeared to care more about ensuring racists could speak at universities than he did about sexual abuse on campus, but for me it was even more personal. I feel as if he failed my own children.

I always thought it was dumb luck that my son was born under the last Labour government, who provided him with the first ever free nursery places. We received tax credits as well to help pay for childcare so I could afford to work and for him to be cared for. My son also has a savings account that the Labour government gave him and put money into, so it wasn’t just trust fund kids who had a nest egg. Together we played together at our local Sure Start children’s centre and when things were tough, they were there to help me out. My eldest was a kid born at the right time – that was until he found himself doing his GCSEs under the unwatchful eye of Williamson. Boy did I feel as if we were paying back some of that good policy debt.

All the shiny new ministers will no doubt say “levelling up” more than they actually do any of it. Until they are inevitably levelled down themselves, when they will pretend very nonchalantly to be completely fine about it all. Vive la difference.

Jess Phillips is the shadow minister for domestic violence and safeguarding and Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


DRDO successfully flight-tests Abhyas High-Speed Expendable Aerial Target vehicle

© Provided by DNA The Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) on Friday successfully flight-tested ABHYAS – the High-speed Expendable Aerial Target (HEAT) from the Integrated Test Range (ITR), Chandipur ... Read more »

Poll: The Hafeez-Haider question and the spin dilemma - what should Pakistan do against India?

© AFP Can both Shoaib Malik and Mohammad Hafeez find places in the XI? © AFP Pakistan could scarcely have dreaded being handed as tough a start to the T20 ... Read more »

Natural gas prices fall 19% from multi-year highs in US; why and what it means for India

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Natural gas prices are sliding, at least in the US. The commodity dropped 19 percent from its 13-year high recorded earlier in the month. In Europe, ... Read more »

No Salary But Other Benefits: Mohammad Amir Counters Ramiz Raja's Claim of Not Taking Salary as PCB Chairman

© Provided by News18 No Salary But Other Benefits: Mohammad Amir Counters Ramiz Raja’s Claim of Not Taking Salary as PCB Chairman Ramiz Raja, after becoming the new chairman of ... Read more »

Apple Recruitment: iPhone maker is hiring for engineers, interns in India, check vacancies

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: iPhone maker Apple is planning to hire a few engineers and interns in India that are expected to work from its Bengaluru-based office. ... Read more »

Covid panic: Boris calls vaccine superwoman back to lead jabs 'This is how serious it is!'

© Getty Emily Lawson Boris Johnson has called the former head of the vaccine programme, Emily Lawson, back from her new job at No10 to take charge of the booster ... Read more »

Ruthie Tompson, animator who worked on classic Disney films including Snow White, Pinocchio, Fantasia and Dumbo – obituary

© Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for TCM Ruthie Tompson in 2018 at a screening of the film An Invisible History: Trailblazing Women of Animation – Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for TCM Ruthie ... Read more »

What Is Prince Regent Cake, As Seen on ‘The Great British Bake Off'?

The fun of watching The Great British Bake Off is yes the competition, yes the British humor, but mainly the chance to learn about an entirely new baked good popular ... Read more »

Ben Simmons meets with Sixers teammates, reports to shootaround

NBA fans shouldn’t expect to see Philadelphia 76ers point guard Ben Simmons on the court for Friday’s clash with the Brooklyn Nets, but it appears that some progress has been ... Read more »

Take 20% Off Rugs, Furniture, Tableware, and More During Revival's Anniversary Sale

In honor of Revival’s fourth anniversary, the company is hosting a major sale, which includes 20 percent off everything sitewide when you use the code “THANKS4FOUR” at checkout. Not only ... Read more »

Ex-Raiders coach Jon Gruden says, 'The truth will come out' about email scandal

Jon Gruden hasn’t said a word since resigning as Las Vegas Raiders head coach earlier this month, after the New York Times exposed racist, misogynistic, and anti-gay opinions he shared ... Read more »

Free community college expected to be cut from spending bill

President Joe Biden’s long-sought goal of free community college appears to be a victim of cost-cutting in his social spending plan, dealing a major blow to his vision for a ... Read more »

Pelosi: Democrats within striking distance of deal

© Greg Nash Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) addresses reporters during her weekly press conference on Tuesday, October 12, 2021. Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said Friday that Democrats are within striking ... Read more »

West Lothian: Three cars seriously damaged by fire in what police believe was deliberate incident

© West Lothian: Three cars seriously damaged by fire in what police believe was deliberate incident. Police Scotland received a report that a car was on fire on Turnhigh Road, ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin speaks out after prop gun incident: 'There are no words to convey my shock'

Alec Baldwin and his family are reacting after the 63-year-old actor discharged a prop gun on the set of the movie “Rust” killing a cinematographer and injuring the director. “There are ... Read more »

Billionaire investor Paul Tudor Jones tests positive for Covid day after attending star-studded charity event

Longtime investor Paul Tudor Jones tested positive for Covid-19 after attending a dinner benefiting the Robin Hood Foundation. © Provided by TODAY “I tested positive for COVID Thursday afternoon, the ... Read more »

EU leaders give Merkel an ovation at final summit

Last week I waited in a packed press pen for German Chancellor Angela Merkel to descend the stairs at the Egmont Palace in Brussels. She’d already had lunch with King ... Read more »

Tennis legend Andy Murray gives frank answer to question on Emma Raducanu's next coach

© GiveMeSport Andy Murray gave a frank answer when asked if he had any advice for fellow British star Emma Raducanu, who is currently on the lookout for her next ... Read more »

The Future of Brunch Is in Asia

© Photo by Mai Bach Brunch outside of Ooh Cha Cha in Taipei When Mai Bach opened her restaurant in Taiwan in 2013, she noticed a peculiar pattern among her ... Read more »

Images of the Air Jordan 4 ‘Where the Wild Things Are' Surface

© Courtesy of Nike Air Jordan 4 ‘Where the Wild Things Are’ Social media is going crazy over an upcoming Air Jordan 4 release that appears to draw inspiration from ... Read more »

Dublin Budget Buddy: The properties you can buy in Portobello, Ballsbridge, Drumcondra and Balbriggan for €700k

When it comes to scouring the Dublin property market, your budget alone doesn’t always mean very much – it all depends on where in the city and county you’re searching, ... Read more »

Savings rates: New 1.9% account launches but you must act fast - Britons urged to switch

Savings rates have been increased by Paragon Bank and Secure Trust Bank, with interest of up to 1.9 percent being available. For those looking for tax efficient options, ISA deals ... Read more »

Wolverhampton Covid PCR testing lab blunder began a WEEK earlier

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Mistakes at a disgraced Covid testing laboratory that incorrectly told up to 43,000 people they were not infected with the virus began a ... Read more »

German hard coal imports pegged at 38-39 million T -industry group VDKi

FRANKFURT (Reuters) – Germany’s hard coal imports could rise to 38-39 million tonnes in 2021, coal importers group VDKi said on Friday, raising an August forecast for 35 million to ... Read more »

Leigh Centurions snap up highly-rated Championship starlet

Leigh Centurions have signed highly-rated youngster Luis Roberts. Rugby League Live understands the Centurions have snapped up the young outside back, who was nominated for the young Championship player of ... Read more »

Back-to-work protocol updated in wake of decision to delay wide-scale office return

© SAM BOAL Sam Boal File photo THE GOVERNMENT HAS updated the Work Safely Protocol to take into account changes to its reopening plan unveiled this week. In August, it ... Read more »

Meghan and Harry: a couple of bankers

Honestly, do Meghan Markle and Prince Harry ever have a day off? We only ask because – in the 19 months since they shirked their royal titles and left the ... Read more »

Angela Merkel receives fond farewell at final EU summit

© Provided by Although Angela Merkel could still be the chancellor of Germany the next time European Union leaders meet, her colleagues decided to give her an official send-offon ... Read more »

Arsenal icon David Seaman hails Aaron Ramsdale for "proving fans wrong" over transfer

Arsenal legend David Seaman has hailed Aaron Ramsdale for proving the supporters wrong after an impressive start to his career with the club. The 24-year-old arrived at the Emirates Stadium ... Read more »

Climate activists rally to pressure German post-Merkel government

© Provided by Demonstrators gathered in Berlin to call a climate protection commitment from the new government Thousands of climate activists from the global Fridays for Future movement gathered ... Read more »

Forget Keita: Klopp must unleash £120k-p/w LFC outcast on Sunday, he impressed v Atleti -opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Premier League – Watford v Liverpool Liverpool face another tough task at the weekend with a trip to Old Trafford to take on Manchester United ... Read more »

‘No one should be killed on set': tragic history of fatalities during filming

Safety on film and TV sets is under renewed scrutiny following the fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins by actor and producer Alec Baldwin during production on Rust, a western ... Read more »

Benitez confirms return of key man amid a number of injury issues

Rafael Benitez has provided a injury round-up ahead of Saturday’s clash with Watford as Richarlison is set for a return but another of key men remain unavailable. © PA Images ... Read more »

Adele cheekily chooses Prince Harry over William in Vogue interview

© Vogue/DOMINIC LIPINSKI/POOL/AFP via Getty Images adwh.png Adele welcomed Vogue into her gorgeous LA home to participate in the magazine’s 73 Questions series and made an interesting choice when posed ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic