Remembering the substitution that showed Louis van Gaal's off-cuff genius

© PA Images louis-van-gaal-tim-krul

It’s football’s latest fashion accessory and demonstration of managerial strength – bringing substitutes off the bench solely to take a penalty.

In theory, it should be a genius ploy. A player who hasn’t seen their legs reduced to sawdust during the game is required only to stick the ball in the net from 12 yards.

Recent evidence would suggest the folly of this practice. Mark Noble became the dictionary definition of hubris when his sole contribution to West Ham’s defeat to Manchester United was to have a penalty saved by David de Gea.

And who could forget late substitutes Marcus Rashford and Jadon Sancho infamously missing their spot-kicks in the Euro 2020 final?

But what about bringing on a goalkeeper to save penalties? Plenty have argued that Dave Beasant, who memorably saved John Aldridge’s spot-kick in the 1988 FA Cup final, should have replaced Peter Shilton in Turin two years later.

While, after United’s defeat against Villarreal in May 2021, Chris Sutton said: “Ole Gunnar Solskjaer missed a trick here. Dean Henderson’s record of saving penalties is ridiculously better than David De Gea’s.

“Yet while Villarreal were burying all of their spot-kicks beyond De Gea in Wednesday night’s shootout, Henderson was watching on from the sidelines. Solskjaer could have copied Louis van Gaal.”

Ah, yes. It’s about time we introduced Van Gaal into our conversation.

© Provided by PlanetFootball

Possessing the self-confidence that makes Boris Johnson look like Mark Corrigan, the Dutch manager has never been shy about bigging himself up.

And, despite winning the Champions League with Ajax among other triumphs, it’s hard to escape the feeling his whole managerial career had been leading up to the World Cup quarter-final in Salvador in July 2014.

The Netherlands weren’t fancied to do well in Brazil. Their squad was a mishmash of genuine star players – Arjen Robben, Wesley Sneijder, Robin van Persie – and decent, but limited, players from the Eredivisie.

Van Gaal thought differently. He weaned his squad off their traditional 4-3-3 formation, lining up with wing-backs instead, and produced a stunning 5-1 win over Spain in their opener.

They continued winning while playing progressively worse – a dodgy late penalty was needed to see off Mexico in the last 16 – and they played out 120 scoreless minutes with Costa Rica in their quarter-final.

Something was needed to break the stalemate and Van Gaal knew exactly what. As penalties loomed, Tim Krul was bought on to replace first-choice goalkeeper Jasper Cillessen.

It was a decision based on logic – Cillessen had never saved a first-class penalty while Krul had at least managed to save two.

“We thought this through beforehand,” the Netherlands boss told reporters after the game. “Every player in my squad has certain skills and qualities. They don’t always overlap but all thought that Tim would be the most appropriate keeper to stop penalties because he has a long reach.”

In classic Van Gaal style, he neglected to tell Cillessen about the plan. Upon being withdrawn, the Ajax man inadvertently soaked team-mate Bruno Martins Indi after booting a water bottle in disgust.

The BBC pundits were beside themselves with excitement. Gary Lineker called it a ‘staggering substitution’ while Rio Ferdinand astutely observed that: “In a penalty shootout, keepers can’t lose normally because the pressure is on the strikers. Now Krul is going in there and he is under pressure.”

We all know what happened next. Krul saved two Costa Rican spot-kicks and Van Gaal had demonstrated what Arjen Robben had once memorably called his ‘golden willy’.

Tim Krul (Netherlands) vs Costa Rica

Madness? Or Genius?

In the 2014 World Cup, the Quarter Final between the Netherlands and Costa Rica was just seconds from a shoot-out. The Dutch took the unusual step of replacing their keeper, and it worked wonders.

— Top Bins Talk (@TopBinsTalk) April 26, 2020

The assorted BBC line-up were so worked-up it’s quite possible that one of them did an excited wee in the melee that followed.

“What a performance, and what a piece of management by Louis van Gaal,” said Lineker. “We said he would live or die by that decision, well he lives and he lives into the semi-finals.”

Ferdinand, demonstrating why fortune-telling was not his career forte, said: “Manchester United fans will be buzzing to see Louis van Gaal making big decisions like that and them coming off. They will be thinking, ‘what a manager we have got coming in’”. 

Even pragmatism’s Alan Hansen was moved to say: “Penalty shootouts are always exciting, but there were so many added ingredients to this one. We have never seen the like of it before.”

For his part, Krul was possessed by a sense of destiny after his heroics. “I psyched them out. You try to do everything you can without being too aggressive. I tried to get in their minds,” he told BBC Sport.

“It is something I have dreamed about since I was a little boy – to have that moment when you make the crucial save and then all the boys are running towards you.”

While David Moyes and Gareth Southgate have attempted to repeat the trick since, maybe it took somebody of Van Gaal’s bravado and single-mindedness to pull it off.

Not everybody can have a ‘golden willy’ after all.

By Michael Lee

More from Planet Football

Fallen Giants: Remembering Louis van Gaal’s amazing Ajax team of the 90s

13 of Louis van Gaal’s funniest moments: Sex masochism, fat man…

Can you name every player who’s won Champions League & World Cup?

The incredible XI of players handed their senior debuts by Louis van Gaal

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


EXCLUSIVE: 'I have never been scared of anything... but I'm scared now': Rugby League legend Bobbie Goulding's dementia diagnosis at just 49 has left him angry at the game's failings on head injuries

Rugby League legend Bobbie Goulding opens up on his dementia diagnosisGoulding admits he is scared after being diagnosed with early onset dementiaHis diagnosis was a shock despite his increasing forgetfulness and mood swingsThe 49-year-old's condition comes as little surprise due to the rough treatment he received on the pitch – and the lack of treatment off itFormer pros Jason Roach, Ryan MacDonald and Mickii Edwards all speak out on the disease and lack of intervention from the League authories  Read more »

Sunderland dump QPR out on penalties

Sunderland reached the quarter-finals of the Carabao Cup for the first time since 2014 with a 3-1 penalty shootout win over QPR after their fourth-round tie ended goalless. QPR had ... Read more »

Rugby League in the dock: 10 former players hit by brain injuries - including legend Bobbie Goulding - are suing the governing body for neglect

Bobbie Goulding is one of 10 former rugby league stars suing the RFL for neglectThe 10 stars are suffering from brain injuries and say the RFL could have helpedGoulding has been diagnosed with probable chronic traumatic encephalopathyThis is the first time British league stars have been diagnosed with the disease  Read more »

Ploeggenoot Haps krijgt bizar rood: scheids negeert VAR na keurige sliding

© ProShots Ploeggenoot Haps krijgt bizar rood: scheids negeert VAR na keurige sliding Voetballers zijn tijdens en na wedstrijden nogal eens boos over arbitrale beslissingen, maar Ethan Ampadu heeft dit ... Read more »

CHRIS SUTTON: What the Glasgow football divide can agree on is our admiration for the very warm and chatty Walter Smith... He could inspire a team like few other coaches

Former Rangers manager and director Walter Smith passed away aged 73Smith had two memorable and trophy-laden spells at Ibrox during his careerThere is a deep respect for Smith no matter what your Glasgow allegiances are  Read more »

Pioli: "Soddisfatto del mio Milan"

“Sono molto soddisfatto, abbiamo controllato la partita perché è difficile giocare contro il Toro. Avevo diversi giocatori alla quarta gara di fila e abbiamo rischiato solo alla fine. Mi è ... Read more »

Paedophile Barry Bennell 'quite clearly' had a Manchester City role and 'everyone knew him', a High Court hears from one of the eight men taking legal action against the top-flight club

Eight men are suing Man City after being abused by ex-coach Barry BennellCity deny Bennell was an employee or in a relationship 'akin to employment'According to one of the men, Bennell clearly had a role at the Manchester clubThe former coach was known by everyone at City, according to the same man  Read more »

Milan mai così bene da 67 anni, Pioli: "Rosa completa"

© Fornito da Il tecnico del Milan: “Mi è piaciuta la voglia di portare a casa una vittoria difficile ma comunque meritata”. Stefano Pioli ha commentato la vittoria del ... Read more »

England captain Owen Farrell hails Marcus Smith as a 'massive talent' who can open up a game... Saracens star relishing new partnership for autumn Tests despite coveting No 10 shirt

Marcus Smith is destined to wear the England No 10 shirt in autumn Tests Harlequins prodigy set to line up with Owen Farrell at inside centre England captain Farrell admitted his recent form had been sub-standard Read more »

Juric: "La nostra miglior partita della stagione"

“Abbiamo fatto una grandissima partita in tutti i sensi. Il Milan ha fatto un solo tiro. E’ girata male oggi, i ragazzi hanno dato tutto. La miglior partita fatta finora ... Read more »

White Sox: Ozzie Guillen posts tweet in memory of 2005 World Series team

© Provided by Fansided It wasn’t all too long ago Ozzie Guillen and his Chicago White Sox were the champions. On Tuesday afternoon, former Major League Baseball manager Ozzie Guillen ... Read more »

Report: Padres interviewed Ozzie Guillen for manager

© David Banks-USA TODAY Sports Ozzie Guillen surprisingly received an interview for the Padres’ managerial opening. San Diego Padres fans may have to buckle up if the candidate that the ... Read more »

Tom Glavine calls out Astros sign-stealing critics

© Provided by Fansided Atlanta Braves legend Tom Glavine is not about to call out the Houston Astros for stealing signs years ago ahead of his former club’s first trip ... Read more »

Tennis: Unvaccinated players at Australian Open must undergo quarantine, says PM

Novak Djokovic has declined to disclose his vaccination status and says he might not play at the tournament, “things being as they are”. SYDNEY (REUTERS) – Australian Prime Minister Scott ... Read more »

Player ratings: Arsenal defenders shine as Gunners progress past Leeds to quarter-finals

© PA Images Arsenal vs Leeds, Calum Chambers and Emile Smith Rowe celebrate, October 2021 Arsenal progressed to the last eight of the Carabao Cup as their defenders shone in ... Read more »

Ex-Magpie urges Newcastle to appoint Gerrard as manager

© PA Images Steven Gerrard shakes hands with Connor Goldson Ex-Newcastle United right-back Ryan Taylor has urged his former club to appoint Rangers boss Steven Gerrard as manager. The Saudi-led ... Read more »

Let's shoot the messenger: The Loeries 2021 reframe creative excellence

This year’s awards underscored the need for media people to think differently: they not only need to understand tech, but also the value of radical collaboration. © Copyright (c) Daily ... Read more »

Tsunamis of aid can be a force for good if used for real development

Expensive Poverty: Why Aid Fails and How It Can Work by Greg Mills is a timely and thoughtful book about an important issue. © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All ... Read more »

Chelsea wirft Hasenhüttls Southampton aus dem Liga-Cup

© APA/AFP Ralph Hasenhüttl verabschiedet sich aus dem Liga-Cup Der englische Tabellenführer Chelsea hat sich ins Viertelfinale des englischen Liga-Cups gezittert. Die Londoner kamen gegen den von Ralph Hasenhüttl betreuten ... Read more »

Jon Jones drops two places as UFC releases latest pound-for-pound rankings

Jon Jones has dropped from second position to fourth in the UFC pound-for-pound rankings this month. The American star has been out of action since his decision victory over Dominick ... Read more »

Giants put Jabrill Peppers on IR, waive Josh Jackson and David Sills

The Giants will be without safety Jabrill Peppers for at least the next three games. Peppers was placed on injured reserve on Tuesday. Peppers has knee and ankle injuries that ... Read more »

Jets put Blake Cashman, Jamien Sherwood on injured reserve

© Provided by NBC Sports The Jets placed a pair of linebackers on injured reserve Tuesday. Jamien Sherwood tore his Achilles in Sunday’s loss to the Patriots and Cashman injured ... Read more »

Il Milan supera l'ostacolo Torino, Pioli: "Vittoria difficile, ma meritata"

Il Milan supera 1-0 il Torino a San Siro e in un colpo solo centra la nona vittoria in dieci partite di campionato, inanella il quinto successo consecutivo in casa ... Read more »

Eurolega: prima sconfitta per Milano, vince il Bayern 83-77

La A|X Armani Exchange Milano dice addio alla sua imbattibilita’ in Eurolega sul parquet dell’Audi Dome di Monaco di Baviera. © Fornito da Rai Sport Bayern – Milano 83-77 Priva ... Read more »

Giroud piega il Toro, Milan in testa aspettando il Napoli

MILANO (ITALPRESS) – Il Milan supera a San Siro il Torino per 1-0 al termine di una sfida molto combattuta e poco spettacolare, decisa di fatto alla prima occasione utile ... Read more »

Recap & Highlights: Athenea Picks Up Assist In 6-0 Win Over Ukraine

© Photo by Stanislav Vedmid/DeFodi Images via Getty Images Spain continued their strong run of results in the FIFA Women’s World Cup Qualifiers with a 6-0 win over Ukraine, making ... Read more »

Revivez l'épisode 9 de Koh-Lanta, la légende

© Fournis par Sofoot Pas de Ligue des champions, pas de Ligue 1, vous n’avez donc pas la moindre excuse pour rater Koh-Lanta ce soir. Et ne me parlez pas ... Read more »

Unggutt og Arsenal-helt bommet da Chelsea vant straffedrama

© (NTB scanpix) Chelseas Kai Havertz feirer sitt mål mot Southampton i ligacupen. Foto: Ian Walton / AP / NTB Unggutt og Arsenal-helt bommet da Chelsea vant straffedrama Unggutten Will ... Read more »

Robin Goodfellow's racing tips: Best bets for Wednesday, October 27

Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Wednesday’s meetings at Kempton, Nottingham, Taunton and Fakenham.  Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Wednesday’s meetings ... Read more »

Solskjaer stays... FOR NOW: Manchester United boss given more time to turn things around after 5-0 Liverpool mauling - but he fears for his long-term future with board reviewing his position in December

Manchester United will keep Ole Gunnar Solskjaer at the club - for now The Norwegian oversaw an 'embarrassing' 5-0 home loss to Liverpool last week The United board planned to review him in December and that is still the sameSir Alex Ferguson paid a visit to Manchester United training on Tuesday  Read more »

Chelsea player ratings vs Southampton: Chalobah stars as Barkley struggles

© Getty Images ChelseavsSouthampton2610F Chelsea advanced to the quarter-finals of the Carabao Cup after another win on penalties at Stamford Bridge. Reece James netted the decisive penalty to down Southampton ... Read more »

Arsenal 2-0 Leeds LIVE! Nketiah, Chambers goals - Carabao Cup result, match stream and latest updates today

© Getty Images eddienketiaharsenal26102021A.jpg LIVE – Updated at 22:10 Arsenal vs Leeds – LIVE! The Gunners will be favourites to reach the quarter-finals of the Carabao Cup on Tuesday night. ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta hoping Eddie Nkeitah stays at Arsenal

Mikel Arteta has backed Eddie Nkeitah to become a “top, top player” and is hoping that will be at Arsenal after he struck in the Carabao Cup fourth-round win over ... Read more »

Spanish bars 'could run out of whisky, gin and rum'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Spanish bars could run out of whisky, gin, vodka and rum due to international transport issues, industry leaders have warned.  The Mediterranean country is ... Read more »

Chelsea edge past Southampton on penalties to reach Carabao Cup quarter-finals

Chelsea needed another shootout to earn a place in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals with Southampton beaten 4-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw in the 90 minutes at Stamford Bridge. ... Read more »

Chelsea 1-1 Southampton: Second-string fail to impress in penalty shoot-out win

Prior to the start of the season, much was made about the depth in Chelsea’s squad. © Getty Images ChelseavsSouthampton2610G Indeed, after a summer in which they followed the substantial ... Read more »

Ards 1 Cliftonville 4: Reds tee up BetMcLean League Cup quarter-final with Portadown

Cliftonville cruised into the quarter-finals of the BetMcLean League Cup with a 4-1 win over Ards at Clandeboye Park. Jonny Addis, Chris Gallagher, Ryan Curran and Joe Gormley were all ... Read more »

Arsenal och Chelsea vidare i ligacupen

© Frank Augstein Chelseas Reece James. Arkivbild. Arsenal är klart för kvartsfinal i den engelska ligacupen. Detta efter att ha slagit ut Premier League-kollegan Leeds med 2–0 i fjärde omgången. ... Read more »

Il Milan non si ferma, batte il Torino 1-0 con Giroud

Il Milan non sbaglia contro il Torino e, seppur con qualche difficoltà in più del previsto, centra l’ennesima vittoria di questo inizio di campionato. Granata sconfitti di misura 1-0 con ... Read more »

Blackhawks GM Stan Bowman resigns, senior VP of hockey operations also out amid sexual assault investigation

Chicago Blackhawks general manager and president of hockey operations Stan Bowman resigned on Tuesday after investigators released their findings regarding how the organization handled sexual assault allegations in 2010. Senior ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic