Readers reply: which monarchs would have lived longer if modern medicine had been available?

Asia's Tech News Daily

The long-running series in which readers answer other readers’ questions on subjects ranging from trivial flights of fancy to profound scientific and philosophical concepts

Which British monarchs would have survived their illness or wounding if today’s medical knowledge had existed then? (Bonus question: which monarchs would we have had but for illnesses that are now easily preventable?) Jane Shaw

Send new questions to nq@theguardian.com.

Readers reply

Richard I died of sepsis and gangrene 11 days after being shot in the shoulder with a crossbow bolt; modern antibiotics would almost certainly have saved his life. If he had lived, John would not have come to the throne and lost most of England’s holdings in France, nor would the barons have rebelled and forced John to seal Magna Carta (and subsequent kings to reissue it). The modern world, not just England, would be a very different place as a consequence. RichWoods

Richard was 41 when he died, with no legitimate heirs. If he hadn’t died then, there’s a high chance he’d have got himself killed in some other military misadventure and John would have ended up in charge anyway. Plus, a large part of why John lost so much French territory was that he couldn’t afford to defend it, in large part because of debts Richard had accrued by getting captured on the way home from the Crusades. It’s not really clear whether Richard living a few years longer would have made any difference to that. Also, John got a papal bull nullifying Magna Carta almost immediately. Subsequent kings only reissued it as a means of placating rebellious barons – they would presumably have had to have signed a similar treaty with the barons if it had never existed.

As to which people might have become monarchs if they’d had access to modern medicine, Edward the Black Prince died from the effects of dysentery he contracted on campaign. He was an extremely popular figure in England and presumably would have made an effective (if brutal) ruler, and his disease could be easily cured today. Prince Arthur Tudor – Henry VIII’s older brother – died aged 15 at Ludlow castle after contracting some kind of respiratory infection, possibly tuberculosis or influenza. He’d have a high chance of survival today. Prince Henry Stuart – Charles I’s older brother – died of typhoid fever aged 18, so never got to reign as King Henry IX. He would probably have been put right by a strong course of antibiotics. It’s fascinating to think that two of the most pivotal rulers in English history only became king through their elder brothers’ misfortune. There are some obvious forks British history could have taken given modern medical intervention. ProjectXRay

John, signing a treaty and immediately trying to nullify it? He wasn’t an ancestor of our current leader, was he? tpnrty

If Arthur had not died we’d all still be speaking Latin and divorce would be illegal. Plus, Hilary Mantel might not have won two Bookers. lisamarie3

Had Edward I’s eldest surviving son not died at the age of 10, England would have had a King Alfonso and we would all be significantly better at football. ButtockMcscruttock

Albert, Queen Victoria’s consort, would have almost certainly have survived his tragic early death with modern medicine and treatment. If he had lived, maybe Victoria wouldn’t have been such a misery and maybe Albert’s diplomatic skills would have eased some of the tensions in the wider European family of monarchy, which contributed to the first world war. Cassandraknows2

I’m less interested in monarchs and more in composers. Mozart and Mahler almost certainly died of eminently treatable infective illnesses that would have been easily survivable today. Imagine all that music that we have never heard. Peter Neville, Powys

William the Conqueror ruptured his internal organs on the pommel of his saddle when his horse jumped a wall in Normandy and he subsequently died. Surgical intervention would almost certainly have saved him. But that’s only the beginning of the story. By the time he was transported to Caen Cathedral for his funeral he was as ripe as a camembert. While lying in state there, the gases trapped in his abdomen escaped with a loud hissing sound and the stench sent the crowd of assembled mourners fleeing from the cathedral. rumblestrips

Henry V died of dysentery at 35 during the siege of a French castle. Despite all the lionising of him by Shakespeare and the rest, he remains a might-have-been of history. Had he lived, he would have become king of both England and France within a year. The Wars of the Roses would have been much less likely and the Tudors certainly wouldn’t have risen to the throne. It’s unlikely an English-French dual monarchy would have endured beyond his death, but it’s certainly an interesting what-if. Ionic_bond

Alexander, prince of Scotland – son of King Alexander III of Scotland – died of an unspecified fever in 1284 at the age of 20. Although I don’t know what kind of fever it was, I assume that modern medicine could have saved him. He would have succeeded his father as king, the Scottish lords wouldn’t have asked Edward I of England to choose a new king for them, William Wallace would have lived his life out as a minor member of the Scottish nobility and Braveheart would never have been made. BellaTheCook

Folic acid added to her diet might have prevented Elizabeth of York, wife of Henry VII, from succumbing to anaemia and dying in childbirth. Which might in turn have prolonged Henry’s life, stopped him from relying on Empson and Dudley, and perhaps given him a clearer, less grief-addled head when it came to preventing Catherine of Aragon from marrying his second son. She could have been sent back to Spain, Henry VIII could have made a better marriage, had a son, and … perhaps no Reformation. Not that I’m against the Reformation. Asurea

Supposing Richard III’s wife and son could have been cured of whatever natural cause they died of? Nobody able to spread nasty rumours about how he had murdered his wife in order to marry his niece; a legitimate male heir still around; Henry Tudor might have thought twice, and we’d have had the King in the North for a bit longer than two years. SpoilheapSurfer

Edward VI, the male heir that Henry VIII so desired, died at 15 most probably of TB, which could be easily treated today. A longer reign would have avoided the subsequent bloody turmoil of his successor, Mary, and perhaps led to a more Protestant religious settlement (compared with the compromise enacted under Elizabeth I) being established in England with the survival of its most vocal proponents (Cranmer, Latimer and Ridley, all executed by Mary). Even more critically, if he had wed and sired an heir, the Tudor dynasty might have continued for a lot longer, and the Stuarts would probably have never come to the throne (and hence no subsequent personal or political union with Scotland, or civil war/Cromwell). deepsubs

The accounts of Queen Caroline’s death are harrowing (wife to George II). She had suffered an umbilical hernia at the birth of her final child in 1724 and, in November 1737, it was discovered that part of her small intestine was poking through the opening. Her doctors cut off the part that was protruding, thus making it impossible for anything to pass through her body. She died days later, in agony. It was definitely a case of “died of the doctors”. One of her daughters suffered from the same condition. PMWoolley

Princess Charlotte, the daughter of George IV, died in childbirth along with her son. If she had survived, there would have been no Queen Victoria whose numerous children married into all the European royal families. Imagine: no Kaiser Wilhelm of Germany and no Tsarina Alexandra bringing haemophilia into the Russian royal family. Whatduck

Mary II died at age 32 from smallpox; her husband, William III, five years later from pneumonia. If they had lived much longer it is possible that the house of Hanover might not have ascended the English throne. Floppyears

Modern medicine might actually have saved Anne Boleyn. Henry is thought to have suffered a brain injury in a fall, which affected his temperament. Before it, he was intelligent, reasonable and generous. After his fall he suddenly became suspicious and aggressive. An MRI scan and brain surgery might have succeeded. Anne would not have been executed and might have had a healthy son. No Bloody Mary with Catholic persecutions but sadly no Elizabeth I either. But we might still be ruled by Tudors now instead of a German family. Shân Morgain, Newport

Surely King Arthur would have been fine with modern antidepressants and psychotherapy: “No Arthur, there is no (living) lady in the lake, no magic sword and Merlin is a wise man, not a ‘wizard’.” Walter Mennekens

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Mayo Clinic Minute: Why Black women need to be screened for cervical cancer

© Dreamstime/Dreamstime/TNS Non-Hispanic Black women are more likely to be diagnosed and die of cervical cancer, compared to white women in the U.S.. While all women can develop cervical cancer, ... Read more »

Consumer Health: Blood donation saves lives; are you a donor?

© Patrick T. Fallon/AFP/Getty Images North America/TNS A person donates blood during a Children’s Hospital Los Angeles blood donation drive in the LA Kings blood mobile outside the Crypto.com Arena ... Read more »

Africa CDC says it will talk to Merck about COVID pill, Pfizer talks 'advanced'

FILE PHOTO: John Nkengasong, Africa’s Director of the Centers for Disease Control, speaks during an interview with Reuters at the African Union Headquarters in Addis Ababa (Reuters) -Africa's top public ... Read more »

Parents slam school for serving only POTATOES every single lunch time

A parent has hit out at her child’s school after drastic changes to its lunch menu left children with “constant potatoes”. Richmond Primary School, in Hinckley, Leicestershire, warned parents about ... Read more »

Royal Family: Kate Middleton can't stand Prince William's annoying food habit

The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have been married for over a decade but one of Prince William ‘s messy food habit leaves a sour taste in Kate ‘s mouth. ... Read more »

When you can and can't leave Covid isolation – after major rule change

SELF-ISOLATION rules have changed over the past month, so you’ll be forgiven for being confused.  It is a requirement to self-isolate when you test positive for Covid, or get symptoms, ... Read more »

Premiership rugby strike new deal with ITV with final among games to be televised live

Terrestrial television audiences will enjoy an increase in their rugby viewing options after ITV struck a new deal to begin broadcasting live Premiership fixtures as soon as this month. The ... Read more »

COVID-19: Lifting of England's rules over face masks, passports and work from home announced - with self-isolation set to go in March

Work from home guidance, COVID passports and mandatory wearing of face masks are being scrapped in England, as Boris Johnson announced the lifting of Plan B measures. The prime minister ... Read more »

Why Do Cats Suck on Blankets? Usually, It's Harmless, But Here's How to Make Sure

© Provided by Daily Paws Nina Pearman / Getty When a sweet kitty is ‘making biscuits’ on a blanket—or on us!—it prompts all the feels. We perceive this particular cat ... Read more »

Health campaigners urge England to follow Scotland and adopt a minimum alcohol price as study reveals heaviest drinkers bought MORE booze during lockdowns

Britain's heaviest drinkers bought 17-times more alcohol in 2020 than lightestThose in Scotland and Wales — which have minimum unit pricing — bought leastHealth campaigners say study finding calls for same approach in England  Read more »

Rowing vs running: Which is the best cardio workout?

© Provided by T3 Rowing vs Running: image shows women rowing and running in gym Rowing vs running: this is the question anyone who wants to get fit and lose ... Read more »

Add This Scandi-Style Salmon & Broccoli Traybake To Your Shopping List, ASAP

© Hannah Hall This salmon and broccoli traybake is a delicious and low-effort recipe that is impressive enough for a dinner party, as it is a midweek meal. This salmon ... Read more »

Australia vs England, Womens' Ashes 2022 first T20 live: score and latest updates

Australia vs England, Womens’ Ashes 2022 live: score and latest updates First of three T20s in much-anticipated Ashes 08:14 AM England looking for fast start Heather Knight has urged England ... Read more »

Europe considers new COVID-19 strategy: accepting the virus

MADRID — When the coronavirus pandemic was first declared, Spaniards were ordered to stay home for more than three months. For weeks, they were not allowed outside even for exercise. ... Read more »

Kenneth Branagh: ‘Nobody in my family talked about the riots in Belfast, or the wrench of leaving’

“It was a defining moment in my life,” says Kenneth Branagh, “and it became clear to me, that that was the last point at which I happily knew who I ... Read more »

Saint Peter's visits Niagara following Thomasson's 20-point game

Saint Peter’s Peacocks (6-6, 4-1 MAAC) at Niagara Purple Eagles (8-8, 3-4 MAAC) Lewiston, New York; Friday, 7 p.m. EST BOTTOM LINE: Niagara plays the Saint Peter’s Peacocks after Noah ... Read more »

Coronavirus digest: Germany sees another record high in daily cases

© Abdulhamid Hosbas/AA/picture alliance Germany has implemented tighter COVID-19 measures over the last few days. Daily COVID-19 infections and the seven-day incidence rate have reached a new high in Germany. ... Read more »

Christmas cauliflowers delayed by poor growing conditions are finally harvested

Half a million cauliflowers that flowered too late for Christmas are to be sold at a reduced rate from January, following “some of the worst growing conditions for many years”. ... Read more »

Is Virgil Abloh’s last Louis Vuitton collection inspired by Salvador Dali?

Even in death, Virgil Abloh continues to excite and inspire the fashion world. Louis Vuitton staged a memorable presentation of Abloh’s Spring/Summer 2022 menswear collection — the last fashion show ... Read more »

Want a pair of Louis Vuitton x Nike Air Force 1 sneakers? Try Sotheby’s

The Air Force 1 sneaker collaboration between Nike and Louis Vuitton is finally being released — through an auction. The limited-edition shoes, which were designed by the late Virgil Abloh, ... Read more »

US children’s Covid vaccinations lag despite record infections

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Jeff Kowalsky/AFP/Getty Images As the Omicron variant rips through the US, children are being infected with Covid-19 in record numbers – yet their rate ... Read more »

Is headache a symptom of the omicron COVID variant?

© Provided by KLAS Las Vegas Is headache a symptom of the omicron COVID variant? (NEXSTAR) – The omicron variant is forcing us to rethink what COVID-19 looks and feels ... Read more »

Thailand to resume quarantine waiver for arrivals from February

1 / 2Thailand to resume quarantine waiver for arrivals from FebruaryA man is tested as a mandatory measure for arriving passengers to prevent the spread of the coronavirus disease at ... Read more »

Peter Dutton's cheeky sledge about Clive Palmer's vaccine status

Defence Minister Peter Dutton has dropped his boot into Clive Palmer twice during a cheeky radio interview. Mr Palmer insists he is not vaccined against Covid-19. But Mr Dutton said ... Read more »

Memory problems seen months after mild COVID-19 infections, researchers say

© Getty Images Memory problems seen months after mild COVID-19 infections, researchers say People who experienced mild COVID-19 infections demonstrated attention and memory issues, but those problems appeared to be ... Read more »

Here's How to Order Your Free At-Home COVID Tests

© Violeta Stoimenova / Getty Images On Tuesday, the White House officially launched a website to have rapid at-home COVID tests shipped to your home for free.  The Biden administration ... Read more »

The cost of an orange may be going up. Here's why.

Americans love oranges and orange juice, but they may soon see their love tested by the rising cost of citrus. Growers in Florida and the U.S. Department of Agriculture warned ... Read more »

Why People Who Eat This Type Of Bread In The Morning Struggle To Lose Weight

© Provided by SheFinds Toast is a classic and versatile breakfast staple that many people don’t want to give up when trying to lose weight. The good news is, you ... Read more »

The recipient of a historic pig-heart transplant stabbed a man years ago. Ethicists say criminal history shouldn't affect who gets live-saving organs.

© Provided by Business Insider David Bennet (right) with his surgeon, Dr. Bartley Griffith, at University of Maryland Medical Center. University of Maryland School of Medicine A man with a ... Read more »

Research Suggests Emotions Like Anger and Depression Can Impact Stroke Risk

© Photo: Stocksy/ Guille Faingold Back view of unrecognizable sad woman with head down sitting at workplace with notebooks scattered around. Changes in emotion are often expected after a stroke, ... Read more »

All Weapons available during Prime Resurgence Week Two

© Provided by Progameguides This last week of Prime Resurgence is featuring all of the rest of the unvaulted gear from the event that Week One didn’t feature. You can ... Read more »

Could the Epstein-Barr virus, found in 95% of adults, cause multiple sclerosis? Researchers think so.

Multiple sclerosis, a chronic disease of the central nervous system, could be caused by infection from the Epstein-Barr virus, a common herpes virus, according to a new study.  The research, ... Read more »

Why Ziopharm Oncology Shares Rose 10.5% on Wednesday

What happened Shares of Ziopharm Oncology (NASDAQ: ZIOP) jumped by 10.8% on Wednesday. The clinical-stage biopharmaceutical company is examining non-viral T-cell receptor therapies (TCR-T) to fight cancer. Its shares closed on ... Read more »

Your Jan. 16 Weekly Horoscope Predicts a Major Transformation Coming

Stop what you’re doing and take a look around. Did you know that the metamorphosis you’re experiencing on an individual level is a reflection of the collective shifts currently at ... Read more »

Once and For All: This Is How Often You Should Shampoo Your Hair

One of the most hotly debated topics in haircare is how often you should shampoo. If you’re most guys I know, you shampoo every single day. And if you’re like ... Read more »

Silk’s plant-based ‘Nextmilk’ hits stores nationwide this week

A popular non-dairy alternative has literally called next in the milk market. The Broomfield, Colo.-based Dan0ne rolled out its new Silk Nextmilk nationally Wednesday — promising a beverage that offers ... Read more »

Why Cardiff Oncology Shares Are Falling

© Provided by Benzinga Cardiff Oncology Inc (NASDAQ: CRDF) shares are trading lower after the company announced data from its lead clinical program evaluating onvansertib in combination with standard-of-care FOLFIRI/bevacizumab. ... Read more »

Overnight Health Care — White House boosts mask availability

Welcome to Wednesday’s Overnight Health Care, where we’re following the latest moves on policy and news affecting your health. Subscribe here: thehill.com/newsletter-signup. Supply chain issues are even affecting Girl Scouts, ... Read more »

I Have High-Risk HPV. Now What? Doctors Share Advice (and Assurance)

Ways to Help a Loved One Who Has Cancer See more videos What to watch next How to Cut Plywood After watching this video, you will be able to make ... Read more »

Which Neurological Conditions Cause Spasticity?

© Carol Yepes / Getty Images Spasticity is a common symptom for numerous neurological conditions. Anyone who has had tight muscles or a muscle spasm knows how uncomfortable and limiting ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic