Kristia holds her youngest child in her arms while her eldest child jumps on the backyard trampoline, in Birmingham, Alabama, U.S., February 23, 2024. Kristia Rumbley of Birmingham used in vitro fertilization to have three children, and has kept two embryos on ice for eight years, just in case she wants another. But an Alabama supreme court ruling that embryos are children cast doubt over the future legality of the procedure in the state, and prompted Rumbley to start planning to ship her embryos overseas. REUTERS/Dustin Chambers
By Kimberley Vinnell and Julia Harte
(Reuters) – Three of Kristia Rumbley’s embryos created at a clinic became her 7-year-old twins and 2-year-old son, while three have sat in freezers at the University of Alabama at Birmingham for eight years in case she and her husband decide to have another kid.
Kristia snuggles with her eldest son in their home as her youngest child toddles around, in Birmingham, Alabama, U.S., February 23, 2024. Kristia Rumbley of Birmingham used in vitro fertilization to have three children, and has kept two embryos on ice for eight years, just in case she wants another. But an Alabama supreme court ruling that embryos are children cast doubt over the future legality of the procedure in the state, and prompted Rumbley to start planning to ship her embryos overseas. REUTERS/Dustin Chambers
After Alabama’s supreme court ruled on Feb. 16 that embryos were children, leaving it unclear how to legally store, transport and use them, Rumbley, 44, is seeking legal and medical advice on sending her last two embryos out of state as soon as possible.
“We’re hoping to move them to another country,” the Birmingham mother said in an interview on Friday. “I don’t want to risk anybody else making decisions for our embryos.”
The University of Alabama at Birmingham was the first of at least three in vitro fertilization providers in the state to halt treatments after the court ruling, saying it feared “our patients and our physicians could be prosecuted criminally or face punitive damages for following the standard of care for IVF treatments.”
Kristia holds her youngest child up, in Birmingham, Alabama, U.S., February 23, 2024. Kristia Rumbley of Birmingham used in vitro fertilization to have three children, and has kept two embryos on ice for eight years, just in case she wants another. But an Alabama supreme court ruling that embryos are children cast doubt over the future legality of the procedure in the state, and prompted Rumbley to start planning to ship her embryos overseas. REUTERS/Dustin Chambers
The Alabama case was brought by three couples seeking damages from a Mobile, Alabama, center storing their frozen embryos after a patient accessed and destroyed them.
Kristia speaks to her eldest son while she changes her youngest son’s diaper with the help of her husband, in Birmingham, Alabama, U.S., February 23, 2024. Kristia Rumbley of Birmingham used in vitro fertilization to have three children, and has kept two embryos on ice for eight years, just in case she wants another. But an Alabama supreme court ruling that embryos are children cast doubt over the future legality of the procedure in the state, and prompted Rumbley to start planning to ship her embryos overseas. REUTERS/Dustin Chambers
The high court ruled that Alabama’s constitution clearly considered embryos “unborn children,” citing a constitutional amendment that Alabama voters approved in 2018 which granted fetuses full human rights, including the right to life.
Rumbley said she hopes to move her embryos outside the United States because she fears the Alabama court’s decision could be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court and upheld there, throwing the legality of IVF into doubt across the country.
Health advocates have warned that by enshrining the idea of “fetal personhood,” the Alabama court ruling could inspire other states to similarly restrict women’s reproductive freedom around the United States.
Some IVF patients in other states are already trying to protect their stored embryos from such outside interference.
Amanda Zurawski, one of several plaintiffs suing Texas over its abortion ban after she was denied the procedure following a pregnancy complication, causing her to develop a life-threatening case of sepsis, said on Friday she was moving her embryos out of state for fear Texas would copy Alabama.
“We don’t know how far this is going to go. The slope here is so slippery and it’s so steep and it’s terrifying,” she told MSNBC in an interview on Friday, echoing Rumbley’s concern that the U.S. Supreme Court could replicate Alabama’s court ruling at the national level.
Kristia walks in her yard with her youngest son, born via IVF, in Birmingham, Alabama, U.S., February 23, 2024. Kristia Rumbley of Birmingham used in vitro fertilization to have three children, and has kept two embryos on ice for eight years, just in case she wants another. But an Alabama supreme court ruling that embryos are children cast doubt over the future legality of the procedure in the state, and prompted Rumbley to start planning to ship her embryos overseas. REUTERS/Dustin Chambers
The process of moving embryos out of Alabama is complicated for parents such as Rumbley because the court decision may have created legal risks for transporters if the embryos are damaged during travel, as can happen if they thaw due to accidents or delays.
“If something happened along the way and maybe there was a long plane layover or the (transfer) tank malfunctioned, would I be criminally liable for ‘killing a child?'” Rumbley said. “I don’t know.”
Cryoport Systems, a logistics company that ships embryos and other temperature-controlled material around the world, paused operations in Alabama on Friday, according to The New York Times. Cryoport did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
(Reporting by Kimberley Vinnell in London and Julia Harte in New York; editing by Donna Bryson and Rosalba O’Brien)
News Related-
Russian court extends detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Gershkovich until end of January
-
Russian court extends detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, arrested on espionage charges
-
Israel's economy recovered from previous wars with Hamas, but this one might go longer, hit harder
-
Stock market today: Asian shares mixed ahead of US consumer confidence and price data
-
EXCLUSIVE: ‘Sister Wives' star Christine Brown says her kids' happy marriages inspired her leave Kody Brown
-
NBA fans roast Clippers for losing to Nuggets without Jokic, Murray, Gordon
-
Panthers-Senators brawl ends in 10-minute penalty for all players on ice
-
CNBC Daily Open: Is record Black Friday sales spike a false dawn?
-
Freed Israeli hostage describes deteriorating conditions while being held by Hamas
-
High stakes and glitz mark the vote in Paris for the 2030 World Expo host
-
Biden’s unworkable nursing rule will harm seniors
-
Jalen Hurts: We did what we needed to do when it mattered the most
-
LeBron James takes NBA all-time minutes lead in career-worst loss
-
Vikings' Kevin O'Connell to evaluate Josh Dobbs, path forward at QB