Racial tokenism: What happened to Miranda in the Sex And The City reboot?

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

Racial tokenism: What happened to Miranda in the Sex And The City reboot?

Warning: This article contains spoilers about ‘And Just Like That …’

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

I was eager to see what the Sex and the City (SATC) franchise had to offer in its new series And Just Like That ….

Billed as a reboot, the show has us meet three of the original four women in their ’50s while attempting to address representation issues that plagued the original.

Global Tech News Daily

The show does continue its tradition of feeding us high fashion and providing humorous banter between friends, but that’s all that kept me from turning off the TV.

While much can be said about how each of the three main characters acquired a new racialised friend and the stereotypes they reproduce, I’ll focus on one storyline: what happened to Miranda?

Fumbling white woman

Global Tech News Daily

I’m not a superfan or SATC expert, but I do think Miranda’s role as the anxious, fumbling white woman is disappointing.

One of the reasons SATC was so popular was because the show depicted successful women not afraid of a challenge, willing and able to grow. It was extremely jarring to see Miranda, who was the assertive, sharp, spicy-tongued lawyer in the original series turn into a bumbling, awkward woman tripping over her words.

Miranda is now getting her masters in human rights and befriends her Black professor, Nya Wallace. The awkward conversations between these two women are emblematic of what is wrong with representation in television today — that throwing token racialised characters onto television is not enough, the way the story is told is just as important.

Miranda assumes Nya is not a professor, makes casually racist comments about Nya’s hair and behaves like a white saviour when her professor is having trouble finding her identification to pass campus security.

Some might find that Miranda is a reflection of the anxiety and fear that white women experience in our society today — trying to avoid offending racialised people, and seeking assurances that they are doing the right thing when it comes to racism.

In later episodes, we see an unrealistic development of Nya’s friendship with Miranda. We jump into the future with no depiction of any difficult conversations Miranda may have had with Nya about her white privilege in the classroom and the difficult work she needed to do to show growth to gain Nya’s trust.

Completely absent is the emotional exhaustion and intense intellectual conversations racialised professors like Nya have in educating their students. It would have been a treat to see Nya demonstrate the many anti-racism tools available in education.

Having it all

Over dinner, Nya talks about her challenges in trying to conceive and doubts on becoming a mother. While Nya is sharing intimate details, the conversation nevertheless centres on Miranda’s well-worn storyline of trying to have it all — a career while being a good mother.

This depiction of Miranda does a disservice to her original self — I expected Miranda to still be at the top of her game. But today’s version misses an opportunity to show what it means to be a good ally to our racialised friends and colleagues.

More than that, this version of Miranda harms the anti-racism project many of us are undertaking in our workplaces and social circles. Miranda’s storyline privileges her experience as a white woman encountering racial discussions as foundational, pitting the racialised figure as the source of discomfort for the white woman.

What I saw was a white woman’s reality being made visible, acknowledged and even legitimised, while a racialised woman’s struggle was situated only in relation to that of the white woman.

As feminists Audre Lorde and Mariana Ortega have written, presenting “loving, knowing ignorance” of the knowledge and experience of women of colour is not only arrogant, but reproduces a harmful and dominating relationship where knowledge about women of colour is shared from the perspective of white women.

Racialised woman's reality is invisible

Novelist Toni Morrison”s book, Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination discusses how identity is formed against a black shadow — that Black people are represented through the lens of white perception. The racialised woman’s reality is invisible, overlooked and pathologised based on how it affects the white woman.

In Miranda’s interactions, it is her discomfort that is the focal point. The experiences of racialised women are made invisible in this. Nya was experiencing microaggressions, and her behaviour was that of a woman who was used to putting up with them.

I know a television show whose primary aim is to entertain cannot be the primary source for anti-racism work, but if the show was really dedicated to bringing in more representation, inserting queer and racialised people into the mix as ancillary characters is not enough.

The show would have been an excellent platform to demonstrate healthy strategies for difficult dialogues between white women and racialised women, re-centring the experiences of others more prominently.

Miranda would have been the ideal character to show how to make space for our racialised colleagues in respectful and thoughtful ways, leading her friends through critical thinking rooted in empowerment, not guilt. Critical race theory teaches us that a key way of elevating voices from marginalised or less represented communities is to give them meaningful space.

Racial tokenism: What happened to Miranda in the Sex And The City reboot?

The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence. Read the original article.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Duchess of Cambridge visits a parental support project in London

The Duchess of Cambridge appeared in good spirits today as she visited a community parental support project in London – and interacted with children during a cooking workshop. Looking typically stylish, ... Read more »

'The Power of the Dog' leads Oscar field with 12 nominations, followed by 'Dune' with 10

LOS ANGELES — ‘The Power of the Dog’ leads Oscar field with 12 nominations, followed by ‘Dune’ with 10. Read more »

The Xbox Share button is getting more customizable thanks to controller remapping

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge Microsoft will soon allow Xbox Series X / S owners to fully customize the Share button on their controllers. While you’ve been ... Read more »

Sky Executive Jane Millichip, Distribution Leader and Key Architect of Sustainability Drive, to Step Down After 9 Years

Sky executive Jane Millichip, a distribution leader and a driving force behind the company’s sustainability drive, is leaving the company after almost 10 years. News of the executive’s departure was ... Read more »

Asteroid Named In Honor of Late Avant-Pop Musician Sophie: Sophiexeon

More than a year after futuristic, avant-garde transgender musician Sophie died at age 34 after a fall from a balcony in Athens while attempting to take a picture of the ... Read more »

Super Bowl 2022: Everything to know about the halftime show and other musical performances

The Super Bowl is more than just the biggest football game of the year. While the annually televised event may be the crown jewel in the pantheon of American sports, ... Read more »

Oscar nominations 2022: 'The Power of the Dog' leads with 12, 'Dune' scores 10

Oscar voters spread the love between multiple contenders when the Academy Awards nominees were announced Tuesday morning, though “The Power of the Dog” looked close to a front-runner with 12 ... Read more »

Oscars 2022: Andrew Garfield, Benedict Cumberbatch and Olivia Colman among Brits leading nominations

Image: Andrew Garfield in tick…BOOM! Pic: Macall Polay/Netflix Andrew Garfield, Benedict Cumberbatch, Olivia Colman, Dame Judi Dench and Kenneth Branagh lead the British charge at the Oscars, after bagging nominations ... Read more »

Art Pepper wrote Patricia for the daughter from whom he estranged

PatriciaArt Pepper (1956 & 1978) Her father made no contribution to Patricia Pepper’s happiness in life, but jazz musician Art Pepper did compose a beautiful ballad for her, Patricia. Jazz ... Read more »

List of nominees for the 94th Academy Awards

LOS ANGELES — Nominees for the 94th Academy Awards, which were announced Tuesday via a livestream. Winners will be announced on March 27 in Los Angeles. Best actor: Original screenplay: ... Read more »

Angelina Pivarnick splits from husband

© Bang Showbiz Angelina Pivarnick’s marriage is over Angelina Pivarnick has split from her husband. The ‘Jersey Shore’ star’s spouse, Chris Larangeira, filed for divorce in New Jersey on 22 ... Read more »

Oscar 2022 nominations as they happen

Oscar nominations for the 94th Academy Awards have started to be unveiled ahead of this year’s ceremony. The movies expected to be in contention include The Power of the Dog, ... Read more »

Liam Neeson's worried Seth MacFarlane’s Naked Gun reboot could end his career

© Provided by Total Film Liam Neeson in Taken 2 There’s been no official word on a Naked Gun reboot, but Liam Neeson can’t stop talking about his trepid excitement ... Read more »

Kate Middleton's latest project proves she's the 'Children's Princess'

© Provided by Woman&Home Kate Middleton’s project proves ‘Children’s Princess’ title Kate Middleton’s more recent project has proved her ‘Children’s Princess’ title as the Duchess of Cambridge has agreed to ... Read more »

Avril Lavigne pushes UK and European tour back until 2023

© Bang Showbiz Avril Lavigne postpones tour dates to 2023 Avril Lavigne has pushed back her UK and European tour to 2023. The ‘Bite Me’ star was originally set to ... Read more »

Janet Jackson gets 'embarrassed' hearing her songs on the radio

© Bang Showbiz Janet Jackson can’t stand listening to her own songs Janet Jackson gets “embarrassed” when she hears her music on the radio. The ‘Rhythm Nation’ hitmaker has confessed ... Read more »

‘The epitome of joy’: 10 of Lata Mangeshkar’s greatest songs

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: AFP/Getty Images Sitting in the back of my parents’ Peugeot 504 as a child, we listened to songs by the likes of Mukesh, Mohammed ... Read more »

Cleveland’s 2022 Blax Museum event showcases historic Black artists in virtual format

© Henryk Sadura / Getty CLEVELAND, Ohio – The pandemic led to new formats for Cleveland arts event Blax Museum, organized by local writer Michelle R. Smith. This year, the ... Read more »

Conductor Simon Rattle receives Germany's highest honor

© Provided by Associated Press Conductor Simon Rattle holds the ‘The Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany’ after he received it by German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier during ... Read more »

2022 Oscar nominations to be announced: WATCH LIVE

© shalunts / Getty Oscar nominations are about to be announced, and this year, a major change takes effect for the coveted best picture category. The nominees for the 94th ... Read more »

Brit Awards nominations 2022: Full list of Brits nominees and what time to watch the ceremony on TV tonight

© Provided by The i Adele makes a return to the stage for the Brits. (Photo: CBS/Getty/Cliff Lipson) Music fans are in for a night of big name performances, as ... Read more »

Austin ISD to remove sixth grade from Martin, Mendez middle schools

© Rodolfo Gonzalez/Special to American-Statesman Volunteers head out to block-walk as part of the Austin school district’s Operation Reconnect last June at Mendez Middle School. The district is taking a ... Read more »

Pandora Sued By Estates of Robin Williams, George Carlin & Other Comedians Over Joke-Writing Licensing Fees

Pandora is accused of shortchanging comedians by neglecting to obtain the proper copyrights to stream their works, according to a series of lawsuits filed on Monday (Feb. 7) in California ... Read more »

Mandy Moore Talks Self-Care, Motherhood, and the End of 'This Is Us'

© Provided by Health Ben Watts There’s something sweetly poetic about this time in Mandy Moore’s life. The 37-year-old star is wrapping the final season of NBC’s hit show This ... Read more »

Lemondrop and Fireball review: Impossibly small, surprisingly powerful synths

Korg jump-started the craze for affordable, portable synths when it launched the Volca series in 2013. Major players like Roland got in on the action. As did more niche companies ... Read more »

Red Hot Chili Peppers may release another album this year

The Red Hot Chili Peppers have tentative plans to release another album this year. The American band, who released his record on April 1 Unlimited Love releases has enough material ... Read more »

Zac Brown is first to sign up for 2022 State Fair Grandstand show

© Provided by WCCO Radio Minneapolis Zac Brown The Minnesota State Fair on Tuesday announced the Zac Brown Band is the first to sign up for a Grandstand show at ... Read more »

Capital Chordsmen, Barbershop Ladies present singing valentine's for sweethearts

Once again this year, The Capital Chordsmen and their sister chorus, The Barbershop Ladies of Tallahassee, will send their quartets to Tallahassee and surrounding counties to sing serenades for  Valentine’s ... Read more »

Elton John ‘Farewell’ tour in Detroit: How to get last-minute tickets for tonight, tomorrow

DETROIT – This could be one of your last chances to see Elton John live in concert. The Rock and Roll Hall of Famer brings his “Farewell Yellow Brick Road ... Read more »

RIT/NTID grad will sign language-interpret Super Bowl halftime show

© Noah Elliott Morrison Deaf rapper Sean Forbes performs at Third Man Detroit on Feb. 21, 2020, during a release party for his album “Little Victories.” Super Bowl LVI will ... Read more »

What to watch for Black History Month: 10 movies, TV shows that celebrate Black joy

Black History Month is a time to learn and reflect about the impact historical figures have made and the struggles they’ve overcome. But it’s also important to make time this ... Read more »

First University Challenge host Bamber Gascoigne dies aged 87

TV presenter and author Bamber Gascoigne has died at the age of 87 following a short illness. Gascoigne, best known as the original host of BBC’s University Challenge, died at ... Read more »

Oscar predictions 2022: who is likely to win the biggest awards?

© House of Lady Gaga in House of Gucci House of Gucci It’s ‘inevitable’ that some of the big films will miss out this year Oscar nominations are to be ... Read more »

Coleen Nolan opens up about heartbreak following loss of 'second mum'

Coleen Nolan has shared her heartbreak following the loss of her “second mum”. The singer and TV personality appeared on Monday’s Loose Women along with Ruth Langsford, Linda Robson, and ... Read more »

UK festival line-ups 2022: The best tickets to buy now, from Parklife to Victorious

© Press image GreenManFestival1509 There were times when it didn’t look like it would happen, but the UK’s festival summer finally arrived in 2021 — and what a blast it ... Read more »

McMahon wants metric to end masks in schools; more top stories (Good Morning CNY for Feb. 8)

© Dennis Nett | dnett/syracuse.com/TNS Subscribe to get the Good Morning, CNY newsletter delivered to your email inbox weekday mornings. Weather High: 33; Low: 16. Cloudy, colder, snow showers. See ... Read more »

Looking for things to do in Sioux Falls? Here are 7 winter events to check out

It may be freezing outside almost everyday, and the TV might seem inviting, but Sioux Falls knows how to make the season entertaining with both indoor and outdoor events. Go ... Read more »

Musicians union: Casa Mañana violating contract by using recorded score for ‘Matilda’

© Nate Hovee / Getty Casa Mañana is presenting Matilda the Musical without a live orchestra, which violates the Fort Worth theater’s contract with the local chapter of the American ... Read more »

Want to help decorate Panama City Beach? Officials have launched a public art project.

SeeLife Statues were unveiled at the Panama City Beach City Hall on Friday. SeeLife Statues were unveiled at the Panama City Beach City Hall on Friday. SeeLife Statues were unveiled ... Read more »

As Britt Daniel returns to Austin, Spoon revisits its rock 'n' roll roots

© Photo: Oliver Halfin Spoon Britt Daniel knew he wanted to record Spoon’s 10th album in Austin, Texas. After recording the band’s previous two albums in rural upstate New York, ... Read more »