Race-blind redistricting? Democrats incredulous at GOP maps

Asia's Tech News Daily

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A decade ago, North Carolina Republicans redrew their legislative districts to help their party in a way that a federal court ruled illegally deprived Black voters of their right to political representation. A state court later struck down Republican-drawn maps as based on pure partisanship.

Race-blind redistricting? Democrats incredulous at GOP maps
© Provided by Associated Press FILE – In this Sept. 12, 2019, file photo, state Rep. John Szoka, of Fayetteville, looks over a redistricting map during a committee meeting at the Legislative Office Building in Raleigh, N.C. After lawsuits alleging racial gerrymandering, Republicans drawing legislative redistricting maps in Texas, Ohio and North Carolina this year say they won’t use racial or partisan data in making their determinations. (Robert Willett/The News & Observer via AP)

So, as the GOP-controlled legislature embarks this year on its latest round of redistricting, it has pledged not to use race or partisan data to draw the political lines. Still, the maps Republicans are proposing would tilt heavily toward their party. Several publicly released congressional maps dilute Democratic votes by splitting the state’s biggest city, Charlotte — also its largest African American population center — into three or four U.S. House districts and giving the GOP at least a 10-4 advantage in a state that Donald Trump narrowly won last year.

As the once-a-decade redistricting process kicks into high gear, North Carolina is one of at least three states where Republicans say they are drawing maps without looking at racial and party data. But those maps still happen to strongly favor the GOP.

Democrats and civil rights groups are incredulous, noting that veteran lawmakers don’t need a spreadsheet to know where voters of various races and different parties live in their state. Plus, under certain scenarios, the Voting Rights Act requires the drawing of districts where the majority of voters are racial or ethnic minorities.

“This is the first redistricting round I’ve ever heard of this,” said Thomas Saenz, president of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, which is suing Texas Republicans over maps that the GOP said it drew without looking at racial data. “I suspect they’re trying to set up a defense for litigation. Because they know the race data — they know where the Black community lives. They know where the Latino community lives.”

Jason Torchinsky, general counsel to the National Republican Redistricting Trust, said ignoring racial data is proper in certain circumstances, as in the cases of North Carolina and Texas.

“It depends on where you are,” Torchinsky said.

The drawing of legislative lines is often a raw partisan fight because whichever party controls the process can craft districts to maximize its voters’ clout — and scatter opposing voters so widely they cannot win majorities.

In 2019, the U.S. Supreme Cour t ruled that federal courts cannot overturn unfair maps on the basis of partisanship. But state courts still can void maps for being too partisan and race remains a legal tripwire in redistricting.

If mapmakers explicitly try to weaken voters’ power based on race, they may violate the U.S. Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection under the law. But the Voting Rights Act requires them to consider race if the state has “racially polarized” voting, in which white people consistently vote against candidates backed by a minority racial or ethnic group. The mapmakers must then create a district in which that minority comprises a plurality or majority of voters so they can elect their preferred candidates.

Republicans complain they cannot win.

“It’s truly a conundrum and has been for the last decade for the GOP, because when we look at race, we were told we shouldn’t have, and those maps were struck down,” said North Carolina state Sen. Paul Newton, who co-chairs that state’s redistricting committee. “Now that we’re not looking at race, the Democrat Party is telling us, ‘Oh, you should be looking at race.’”

North Carolina’s redistricting legal fight is part of why the new race-blind approach caught on.

The Republican-controlled legislature has complete control of redistricting; its maps cannot be vetoed by its Democratic governor. A federal court in 2016 found North Carolina Republicans improperly crammed Black voters into two congressional districts to dilute African American votes elsewhere. It ordered the map redrawn. That updated map was the basis of the 2019 Supreme Court case.

But, barely two months later, a North Carolina state court found the GOP advantage in some of the redrawn state legislative maps still violated the state constitution. Based on this and other rulings, Republicans redrew the maps once again in late 2019, this time saying they weren’t looking at racial or partisan data, and they passed legal muster.

Then, in August, the legislature formally adopted a rule that it wouldn’t consider race or partisanship in its latest line-drawing that would begin after the U.S. Census Bureau released data on population changes over the past decade. Lawmakers noted that, during the epic litigation of the prior decade, a federal court had found the state didn’t have racially polarized voting and didn’t require special attention to racial data.

Democrats and civil rights groups strenuously objected. The Southern Coalition for Social Justice wrote Republicans a letter warning they would be disenfranchising Black and Latino voters. “They’re not listening,” said Allison Riggs, head of the group’s voting rights program.

Other GOP-controlled states have followed North Carolina’s example. For the past five decades, Texas has been found to have violated federal law or the U.S. Constitution in redistricting, including by shortchanging Black and Latino voters. This time, Republicans who control the state Legislature said they wouldn’t consider racial data and their lawyers said that was OK.

“I’ve stated it, and I’ll state it again — we drew these maps race blind,” Texas state Sen. Joan Huffman, a Republican who drew that state’s maps, said in one Senate hearing.

Although almost all of Texas’ population growth has come from Latinos, African Americans and Asian Americans, the maps do not create any new majority Black or Latino districts. That latter omission is at the heart of suits by Latino civil rights groups last week as Texas approved its maps.

“The only time that communities of color can get justice is going to the courthouse,” said Democratic state Rep. Rafael Anchia, chair of the Mexican American Legislative Caucus.

Ohio Republicans are also enmeshed in litigation over their state legislative plan, which they said was drawn with no racial or partisan data. “It’s illegal to use race in drawing districts. That’s a violation of federal law,” Republican state Senate President Matt Huffman told reporters last month.

Ohio Republicans said that even though they didn’t use partisan data, they were targeted in a suit by several community and anti-gerrymandering groups for drawing a partisan map anyway.

“The way the map performs is to really skew partisan outcomes in Ohio,” said Freda Levenson, legal director of the ACLU of Ohio, one of the plaintiffs. “It’s very likely they did use partisan data.”

___

Riccardi reported from Denver. Associated Press writers Acacia Coronado in Austin, Texas, and Julie Carr Smyth in Columbus, Ohio, contributed to this report.

___

Anderson is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Universal basic income in Wales ‘would cut poverty in half'

© PA Archive the Welsh Assembly Poverty in Wales would be halved if the Welsh Government established a universal basic income (UBI) system in the country, a major study has ... Read more »

Perjanjian ialah 5% royalti minyak, bukannya wang ehsan, kata Ku Li

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah berkata, Putrajaya perlu menghormati perjanjian antara kerajaan negeri dan Petronas berhubung pembayaran tunai 5% royalti minyak kerana menyerahkan hak minyak dan ... Read more »

American vaccine misinformation and extremism are infiltrating New Zealand

CHRISTCHURCH, New Zealand — When Josephine Bartley, a member of the city council in Auckland, New Zealand, heard that a local Covid-19 vaccination clinic had been vandalized early this month, ... Read more »

Waukesha held a moment of silence Sunday, one week after a man plowed a vehicle through a Christmas parade

The city of Waukesha, Wisconsin, held a moment of silence and lit the city up in blue Sunday, marking one week since a man drove a vehicle through a city ... Read more »

Trump challenges media and Democrats to debate his electoral fraud lie

Donald Trump has challenged leading editors and politicians to debate him in public over his lie that Joe Biden beat him in 2020 through electoral fraud. © Provided by The ... Read more »

Campbell inactive for Ravens against Cleveland running game

BALTIMORE (AP) — Ravens defensive tackle Calais Campbell is inactive for Sunday night’s game against Cleveland. Campbell missed practice this week because of a concussion, and his absence is a ... Read more »

Georgia's Smart dismisses 6-game losing streak against Tide

ATLANTA (AP) — Even with Georgia undefeated in 2021 and unanimous No. 1 in The Associated Press Top 25 for the eighth consecutive week, Nick Saban and Alabama still cast ... Read more »

Jurgen Klopp discusses 'wrong' Liverpool decision as transfer questions raised

Another week, another big Liverpool win in the Premier League. Jurgen Klopp’s men secured a 4-0 win over Southampton on Saturday thanks to goals from Thiago Alcantara, Virgil Van Dijk ... Read more »

Drug gang behind attack that killed feminist in north Mexico

MEXICO CITY — Authorities in northern Mexico said Sunday that a drug gang was behind the shooting attack on a city hall that killed a feminist activist and a bodyguard. ... Read more »

Canada confirms country's first two cases of omicron COVID-19 variant among two people who had recently visited Nigeria

TORONTO — Canada confirms country’s first two cases of omicron COVID-19 variant among two people who had recently visited Nigeria. Read more »

It's not just ‘stuff' — the goods people work hard for matter, despite left lunacy

Actor Seth Rogen received backlash after downplaying crime in Los Angeles like people breaking into cars. Photo by APU GOMES/AFP via Getty Images How important is your stuff? Over the ... Read more »

Steve Cohen trying to replicate Dodgers' roster, reputation with Mets: Sherman

The old owner squeezed nickels despite running a huge-market franchise. The new owner told baseball operations to spend what is necessary to change not just the talent level, but perceptions ... Read more »

Three Omicron cases in UK & 225 more ‘likely' but new rules ‘won't ruin Christmas'

HEALTH chiefs last night confirmed a third case of the new Omicron Covid strain in the UK — amid fears there are already hundreds of others. More than 75 “probable” ... Read more »

More than 17 million have used buy now, pay later

© Getty Images More than 17 million UK customers have now used a buy now pay later (BNPL) company to make an online purchase, company data shows. The payment method ... Read more »

Letters: New restrictions show that Britain still hasn't learnt to live with Covid

People wearing face masks cross Westminster Bridge, with St Thomas’s hospital in the background – Getty SIR – The Prime Minister’s suggestion that travel restrictions are needed to “buy more ... Read more »

R20bn life extension of Koeberg power station poses significant risks for South Africa

Preparations are under way for the replacement of the six steam generators at Eskom’s 1,840MW Koeberg nuclear power station, in what South Africa’s national electricity utility says is the most ... Read more »

Celtic 2-1 Barcelona hailed as club's standout score of all time - but do you agree?'

Celtic 2 Barcelona 1, November 7, 2012 “This was one of the greatest nights in the club’s recent history. It is up there with anything I have done in my ... Read more »

Britain and Israel to sign trade and defence deal

Britain and Israel will sign a 10-year trade and defence pact in London on Monday, promising cooperation on issues such as cybersecurity and a joint commitment to prevent Iran from ... Read more »

BA suspends Hong Kong flights as crew reportedly taken to quarantine camp

© Getty Images BA said a member of staff tested positive on arrival in the region after testing negative before departure – Getty Images British Airways has suspended flights to ... Read more »

Coronavirus set to hammer foreign tourists' Christmas visits, warns industry

The number of overseas tourists to Britain in the run-up to Christmas is expected to plunge by three quarters compared with 2019, research reveals today. International visitor numbers are expected ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's 'disrespectful' Peppa Pig speech 'jeopardised foreign investment'

Boris Johnson’s “totally disrespectful” Peppa Pig speech to business chiefs may have jeopardised foreign investment in Britain, Labour has warned. Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves said “f*** business” – as the ... Read more »

Watch: Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher have heated Cristiano Ronaldo debate

© Alamy Stock Photo ROY KEANE and Jamie Carragher got into a heated debate during Sky Sports’ coverage of Chelsea-Man United today. The Corkonian was critical of the decision to ... Read more »

Omicron response should focus on global vaccine equity, not travel bans: scientists

As Canada confirms its first cases of the Omicron COVID-19 variant, scientists say banning travellers from southern African countries in an effort to curb its importation is wishful thinking that ... Read more »

Sadis, kanak-kanak 10 tahun dirogol, dibunuh, disumbat ke dalam guni selepas pulang mengaji. Kisah ini buat ramai sebak

Amaran: Kandungan artikel ini mungkin menganggu perasaan pembaca. KETAGIHAN pornografi atau menonton video lucah mampu mendorong seseorang melakukan sesuatu di luar batasan sehingga sanggup membunuh! Insan yang tidak berdosa termasuk ... Read more »

As Barbados heads toward a republic, some wonder why it matters

© Reuters/POOL COP26 in Glasgow By Julio-Cesar Chavez BRIDGETOWN (Reuters) – As Barbados prepares to form a republic and remove the British queen as its sovereign, some residents in the ... Read more »

Passenger from S Africa lands in Mumbai via Delhi, tests positive

© Provided by The Indian Express A 32-year-old resident of Dombivili in Mumbai, who arrived from South Africa via Delhi on November 24, tested positive upon arrival in the national ... Read more »

Prince of Wales to reaffirm ‘affection' for Barbados at republic ceremony

Charles and Camilla at Sandringham – Geoff Robinson The Prince of Wales is to “reaffirm” the “admiration and affection” between Barbados and Britain as he visits the Caribbean island to ... Read more »

Black Friday Isn't Over Yet — Almost Everything is Still 50% Off at Kate Spade's Blowout Black Friday Sale

© Ringo Chiu via AP. If there’s one designer brand that constantly takes our breath away with their uniquely adorable designs, it’s Kate Spade. We regularly find ourselves fighting the ... Read more »

The best things you can buy at the Lululemon Cyber Monday sale

© Reviewed / Lululemon The best things you can buy at the Lululemon Cyber Monday sale — Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links ... Read more »

Amazon Cyber Monday Deals: Shop 1 Carat Diamond Earrings Under $600

© Amazon Each product has been independently selected by our editorial team. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian & Pete Davidson Take Selfies With Dutch Tourist During Beverly Hills Outing

© etonline A trip to truly remember. During a visit to Beverly Hills, one Dutch tourist got a real thrill when he ran into Pete Davidson and Kim Kardashian. Paul ... Read more »

Stocks, oil regain some composure after Omicron battering

© Reuters/KIM KYUNG-HOON A man wearing a protective face mask amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, looks at an electronic board displaying Japan’s Nikkei Index outside a brokerage in Tokyo ... Read more »

Apple AirPods Pro are selling for an epic $70 discount ahead of Cyber Monday—but they keep selling out

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Cyber Monday is tomorrow—but this deal on the Apple AirPods Pro ... Read more »

Later life UK mortgages decrease as stamp duty holiday ends

Lending to older borrowers, those aged over 70, was stable across the period due to them accessing the market primarily through products that are not related to house purchase. Photo: ... Read more »

Vaccine experts expected to give advice on expanding boosters to all adults

Millions more people could be offered booster jabs as advisers consider extending them to all adults under emergency measures to limit the spread of the Omicron variant. A decision from ... Read more »

Police: Officer in Maryland fatally shoots man with knife

GLEN BURNIE, Md. (AP) — A police officer in Maryland fatally shot a knife-wielding man and later found a woman dead inside the same home, authorities in Anne Arundel County ... Read more »

Charles to highlight UK bonds as Barbados becomes a republic

The Prince of Wales will highlight the shared goals and enduring bonds between Barbados and the UK during a ceremony marking the Caribbean country’s transition to a republic. Charles will ... Read more »

Woman attacks Spirit Airlines flight attendants, restrained by passenger with zip ties

A woman attacked two flight attendants on a Spirit Airlines flight to Nashville on Saturday night, was restrained by a fellow passenger, and then yelled at police officers to “shoot ... Read more »

JDT masih pilihan juara

KEINGINAN setiap pemain untuk muncul juara menjadi formula terbaik memacu Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT) ketika berdepan Kuala Lumpur (KL) City FC pada aksi final Piala Malaysia di Stadium Nasional, Bukit ... Read more »

Manchester United, Chelsea sama gagah di London

© Provided by Sinar Harian MANCHESTER United mengetepikan prestasi tidak menentu saingan liga apabila mengecewakan pendahulu Liga Perdana Inggeris (EPL), Chelsea dengan keputusan seri 1-1 di Stamford Bridge pada Ahad ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic