Raab's negligence over Kabul is now clear. If he had any honour, he'd quit

Asia's Tech News Daily

Dominic Raab is a clever man, but not perhaps a wise or especially honourable one. Chronic misjudgments over Britain’s withdrawal from Afghanistan necessitated his sacking as foreign secretary. Yet Boris Johnson, his Brexiter pal, immediately gave him another cabinet plum and made him deputy prime minister. For those he had failed, it was a contemptuous slap in the face.

Instead of clinging to office, Raab should have resigned from government. It’s not too late to do so. Official cables from Britain’s ambassador in Afghanistan, published last week, confirm that Raab, if he had been fully paying attention, could have foreseen and more effectively managed the consequences of the rapid Afghan government collapse and the fall of Kabul on 15 August.

If Raab had done his job properly in crucial preceding weeks, and not compounded his neglect by going on holiday to Crete on 6 August, the final evacuation from Kabul might have been less chaotic. Fewer Afghan nationals who loyally served Britain might have been left to the Taliban’s mercy. Thousands of emails pleading for help might have been acted on. The UK’s reputation as a trustworthy, competent ally might not have been so thoroughly trashed.

It’s impossible to turn back the clock. But it’s important to set the record straight, and it’s simply untrue to say, as Raab, senior officials and government spokespersons do, that no one saw the collapse happening so quickly. Sir Laurie Bristow, the UK ambassador, did. On 28 June, he warned the Taliban were making rapid territorial gains and “seem to be positioning … to take major population centres”. On 13 July, he reported they held Afghanistan in an “economic noose”.

On 2 August, four days before Raab headed for Crete, Bristow rang the alarm bells more loudly still. Afghan security forces were unable to hold back the insurgents, he cabled. “We are entering a new, dangerous phase.” He stressed the need to focus on relocating “those who have worked for us” since 2001.

Raab was by no means short of additional advice and expertise, domestic and foreign. In April, Gen Sir Nick Carter, chief of the UK general staff, voiced serious misgivings about the withdrawal. Gen Kenneth McKenzie, commander of US central command, says he warned both Donald Trump and Joe Biden of an “inevitable” collapse. In June, Robert Gates, a former US defence secretary, urged a rethink.

In the months before Kabul fell, Raab did not visit the region, nor did he speak to his ambassadors there

In July, the CIA’s view that President Ashraf Ghani’s government was in “serious jeopardy” leaked to US media. Ben Wallace, the defence secretary, said he concluded that same month that the “game was up”– and that evacuation plans must be accelerated. Military leave was cancelled on 23 July. Yet following Raab’s example, top Foreign and Commonwealth Office officials looked the other way and went on holiday.

In the months before Kabul fell, Raab did not visit the region, nor did he speak to his ambassadors there. He either ignored or did not read the Foreign Office’s own risk assessment, dated 22 July, that warned the Taliban advance could lead to “fall of cities, collapse of security forces, Taliban return to power, mass displacement, and significant humanitarian need”. Why?

Even Observer readers were more up to speed than Britain’s foreign secretary. On 20 June, under the headline “Catastrophe stalks Afghanistan,” I wrote in this column: “Kabul itself may not be safe for long, according to gloomy CIA and military intelligence assessments … [But] western politicians, including in the UK, shield their eyes. They don’t want to see, let alone discuss, what’s about to happen.” I was of course referring to Raab.

The mishandling of the withdrawal aside, Raab’s arguably more fundamental Afghan blunder was his apparent failure to oppose, or even query, Trump’s foolish 2020 decision to cut and run or Biden’s subsequent, reckless adoption of a September 2021 deadline. Military chiefs and senior Tories complained the Afghan people were being abandoned. Wallace believed Trump had made a “rotten deal”.

Yet possibly out of excessive deference to Washington, or because Johnson needs a post-Brexit US trade deal, or because he believed the Afghan project was unviable, Raab failed to speak out. Sir Iain Duncan Smith, a former Conservativeleader, says the US closure of its Bagram airbase, for example, was a key tactical error that gave free rein to Taliban ground forces, as Bristow had warned it would.

“The question now is what did the foreign secretary do and did anybody in the government say to the Americans, ‘This is going to be a disaster if you close Bagram’?”, Duncan Smith said in the Times last week. Another question is why Raab did not support Wallace’s unsuccessful attempt to persuade other Nato countries to maintain a presence after the Americans left.

The deteriorating, post-withdrawal situation in Afghanistan is a daily rebuke to Raab and Johnson’s government. The Taliban’s political isolation, a freeze on $9bn (£6.5bn) in national assets, foreign aid cuts, and the onset of winter foreshadow a humanitarian catastrophe and economic collapse.

A new refugee crisis threatens to engulf Europe’s borders, terror groups operate with impunity, women’s and civil rights are overturned, and China, Russia and Iran are plotting a future dictated by them. Hundreds of people for whom Britain has responsibility remain trapped and desperate.

Meanwhile, the House of Commons foreign affairs committee is pursuing its inquiry into what its chair, Tom Tugendhat, describes as Britain’s “single biggest foreign policy disaster since Suez”. Addressing an initial hearing last month, Raab –unrepentant, arrogant, tetchy – said: “I struggle with the Suez analogy.”

Perhaps Britain’s august deputy PM would be more comfortable with a different historical parallel: the failure to foresee Argentina’s invasion of the Falklands in 1982. As foreign secretary at the time, Lord Carrington took full responsibility and resigned. He was an honourable man.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

What are the symptoms of the Omicron variant? According to the doctor who discovered it

Photo credit: Getty Images In the last week, talk of the new COVID-19 variant Omicron has been getting louder and louder, since it was first reported to the World Health ... Read more »

4 unanswered questions about the new Omicron variant that scientists are racing to answer

President Joe Biden and Dr. Anthony Fauci discuss the omicron COVID-19 variant at the White House on November 29, 2021.Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images Dr. Anthony Fauci says it will take roughly ... Read more »

Cyber Monday Oculus Quest 2 deals: all the sales available now

The Cyber Monday Oculus Quest 2 deals may be winding up, but you still have a chance to make some savings if you’re quick off the mark – the best ... Read more »

Biden discusses supply chain issues with CEOs of Samsung, other global firms

WASHINGTON, Nov. 29 (Yonhap) — U.S. President Joe Biden met with chief executives of several major retailers and other companies, including Samsung Electronics Co. of South Korea, Monday to discuss ... Read more »

What is the James Webb Space Telescope and when will it launch?

Nasa is preparing to launch a space telescope that will see further into the Universe than anything else ever built. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has taken 30 years ... Read more »

The best HSN Cyber Monday deals to shop now: Save on fashion, kitchen and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Celebrate Cyber Monday this year with one of the original online ... Read more »

(LEAD) Industrial output falls by most in 18 months in Oct.

(ATTN: UPDATES with more details in paras 2, 5, 6, 10-20; RECASTS lead; ADDS photo)By Kim Soo-yeon SEOUL, Nov. 30 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s industrial output fell by the most ... Read more »

Yes, Prince Charles Really Is the ‘Royal Racist,' Author Christopher Andersen Insists

Samir Hussein/Samir Hussein/WireImage Prince Charles is the member of the royal family who raised questions about the likely color of Meghan Markle and Prince Harry’s babies’ skin, the author of ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett had ‘a secret plan' for hate crime on himself, prosecutor says as trial begins

CHICAGO — After years of controversy and roller-coaster twists and turns, the trial of Jussie Smollett began Monday with prosecutors alleging the actor faked a hate crime that grabbed the ... Read more »

Save up to $160 on these popular meal kits with Cyber Monday sales: Home Chef, HelloFresh and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Meal kits provide easy-to-prepare meals delivered straight to your door. One ... Read more »

Keurig K-Cups are down to just 38 cents a pod at Bed Bath & Beyond during Cyber Monday 2021

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. We’re taking advantage of hundreds of incredible Cyber Monday deals right ... Read more »

CDC strengthens its stance on boosters, saying everyone should get an extra shot to protect against the Omicron variant

Director of the CDC Rochelle Walensky and Sec. of Education Miguel Cardona at a forum held at the Yawkey Boys & Girls Club on August 6, 2021 .Stuart Cahill/MediaNews Group/Boston ... Read more »

Yellowstone Recap: You Can't Wash Lonely Off

© Cam McLeod/Paramount Cam McLeod/Paramount Last week, I wrote about Yellowstone’s tendency to cram half a dozen stories into one episode. That technique can work well if the stories are ... Read more »

France calls on Britain to do more on Channel migrant trafficking

Following a meeting of European ministers in charge of migration in Calais, France has urged Britain to help more with cracking down on people-smuggling gangs after a row between the ... Read more »

Amnesty proposals a denial of the rule of law, says former police ombudsman

© PA Archive Former Northern Ireland Police Ombudsman Nuala O’Loan (Niall Carson/PA) – PA Archive Former police ombudsman Baroness Nuala O’Loan has called the British Government’s proposals for a so-called ... Read more »

Industrial output falls by most in 18 months in Oct.

By Kim Soo-yeon SEOUL, Nov. 30 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s industrial output fell by the most in 18 months in October in the latest sign that economic recovery momentum has ... Read more »

Face masks will not be in place ‘a day longer' if Omicron is no more dangerous than Delta, Sajid Javid says

Extra measures to tackle the Covid strain Omicron coming into force on Tuesday will not be in place for “a day longer than is necessary” if the variant turns out ... Read more »

Save hundreds on Cyber Monday headphone deals from Bose, Sony and AirPods

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Winter’s here, which means you’ve got plenty of time to cozy ... Read more »

The best QVC Cyber Monday deals to shop on KitchenAid, Dyson and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re in the market for something to get your home ... Read more »

Amazon set to become the largest delivery service in the US

UPS and FedEx could soon be beat at their own game by Amazon as the ecommerce giant is set to become the largest package delivery service in the US next ... Read more »

Crocodile Dundee Actor David Gulpilil Dead at 68: 'One of the Greatest Artists Australia Has Ever Seen'

David Gulpilil Don Arnold/WireImage David Gulpilil Ridjimiraril Dalaithngu has died at age 68 after a four-year battle with lung cancer. The Crocodile Dundee star was known as a beloved indigenous ... Read more »

(URGENT) Industrial output falls 1.9 pct on-month in Oct.: statistics agency

(END) Read more »

'Data Nerd' Lou Stagner On How Arccos Is Ready To Take Golf To The Next Level

Picture the scene: you are out with your regular fourball when one of your partners ‘flushes’ a 9-iron that takes off and hooks viscously into trees. They fling their arms ... Read more »

Is MANSCAPED™ REALLY that good? We spoke to five guys who have been using the grooming products and they shared their thoughts on why male hygiene MATTERS

MANSCAPED products are designed to help men stay buffed, trimmed and feeling their bestFive guys discuss how The Performance Package 4.0, the MANSCAPED Body Wash and the Manscaped 2-In-1 Shampoo + Conditioner have helped them maintain peak hygiene DailyMail.com readers can get 20 per cent off at MANSCAPED by shopping here  Read more »

This Robot Vacuum-Mop Is at Its Cheapest Price Ever for the Next 9 Hours

roborock vacuum Amazon If you're still hauling out an upright vacuum to tackle everyday messes, now's the best time to invest in a cleaning gadget that will do the work ... Read more »

Researchers built an AI that automatically generates movie trailers

You can have Citizen Kane andThe Godfather. Keep your 3D films and IMAX experiences. Miss me with epics, sequels, and experimental cinema. The only real film-based art form is movie ... Read more »

More details revealed about Chris Cuomo's role as advisor to brother, former governor

The CNN anchor offered to tap his journalistic "sources" to find how many women would be accusing Andrew Cuomo of sexual harassment. Read more »

Evgeni Malkin skates with Penguins for first time since offseason knee surgery

Pittsburgh Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan told reporters last week there was “no set target date” for when star center Evgeni Malkin could skate with the team as he works ... Read more »

Fauci responde a Ted Cruz y le dice que debería ser procesado: “¿Qué pasó el 6 de enero, senador?”

© CBS/Face the Nation Captura de pantalla 2021-11-28 a las 15.48.02.png Anthony Fauci, el principal experto en enfermedades infecciosas del gobierno de EE.UU., sugirió que el senador republicano Ted Cruz ... Read more »

Israel warns that Iran is preparing to enrich weapons-grade uranium

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Israel reportedly shared intelligence with the U.S. and European allies suggesting that Iran is preparing to enrich uranium to 90 percent purity – ... Read more »

Photos from the Great Barrier Reef show corals unleashing a colorful storm of eggs and sperm

Coral spawning in the Great Barrier Reef on November 23, 2021.Gabriel Guzman/Calypso Productions Corals in Australia's Great Barrier Reef spawned last week — a mysterious synchronized ritual. Photos and video ... Read more »

Everything at New Balance is 25% off for Cyber Monday—shop the best deals on sneakers, shorts and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. ‘Tis the season for holiday shopping and saving. With Cyber Monday ... Read more »

(EDITORIAL from Korea Herald on Nov. 30)

Perils of smart technologyHacking of apartments via wallpad lays bare lax security, calls for proper measures South Korea’s new apartment complexes increasingly adopt the Internet of Things, or IoT, in ... Read more »

Does the right to bear arms cover AI guns and killer robots?

The right to keep and bear arms was added to the Constitution in 1791. In the two centuries since, firearm technology has changed significantly. But the 2nd Amendment hasn’t. In ... Read more »

Why China's strategy for avoiding the middle-income trap is a challenging one

Almost a decade ago, the World Bank and the Development Research Centre of China’s State Council published a report titled China 2030: Building a Modern Harmonious and Creative Society. While ... Read more »

AirPods Cyber Monday deals 2021: Amazon slashes the price of the pro and 3rd gen earbuds

A deal that sounds as good as the earbuds themselves (iStock/The Independent) The final day of the Black Friday shopping bonanza, otherwise known as Cyber Monday, is here, bringing with ... Read more »

Joe Biden: The omicron variant is no cause for panic

Joe Biden said: ‘If people are vaccinated and wear their mask, there’s no need for lockdowns’ – Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images Joe Biden on Monday said there was “no need” for ... Read more »

Lenovo laptop Cyber Monday deal: Save £830 on this top-of-the-range thinkpad

There’s a stonking 45 per cent off this nifty machine until midnight (iStock/The Independent) Black Friday may have been and gone, but don’t despair if you’ve missed out on the ... Read more »

Trump stopped receiving presidential intelligence briefings after the Capitol riot, new book says

Former President Donald Trump speaks to supporters during a rally at the Iowa State Fairgrounds on October 09, 2021 in Des Moines, Iowa.Scott Olson/Getty Images Trump stopped receiving presidential intel ... Read more »

Rihanna receives mixed reviews over ‘open-back' Savage X Fenty pyjama pants: ‘Makes no sense to me'

Rihanna sparks confusion with new ‘open-back’ pyjama pants (Instagram / Savage X Fenty) Rihanna fans are sharing their confusion over the latest Savage X Fenty pyjama set after the singer ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic