Raab threat to ‘correct' court judgments is ‘deeply troubling', warn legal experts

Asia's Tech News Daily

Legal experts have responded with alarm to suggestions from justice secretary Dominic Raab that he will legislate to “correct” court judgements on human rights cases that go against the government.

© PA Wire

Mr Raab announced the plans at the Conservative Party conference in Manchester earlier this month

– PA Wire

The former head of the government’s legal service, Jonathan Jones, branded the deputy prime minister’s proposals “muddled”, while a professor of public law at Cambridge University said they were “deeply troubling” and that they threatened to undermine basic standards of good governance.

Mr Raab announced plans to “overhaul” the Human Rights Act to reduce the influence of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) at the Conservative Party conference in Manchester earlier this month.

In an interview with the Sunday Telegraph, he said that he was devising a mechanism to allow ministers to introduce ad hoc legislation to “correct” court judgments, whether passed by the ECHR in Strasbourg or by UK judges, which he regards as creating new law through “judicial legislation” rather than the decisions of elected politicians.

“We will get into the habit of legislating on a more periodic basis and thinking about the mechanism for that,” he said. “Where there have been judgments that – albeit properly and duly delivered by the courts – we think are wrong, the right thing is for parliament to legislate to correct them.”

Mr Raab said it was wrong for the European judges to “dictate” to the UK on how its armed forces, police, welfare system and health service should operate.

“We want the Supreme Court to have a last word on interpreting the laws of the land, not the Strasbourg court,” he said.

“We also want to protect and preserve the prerogatives of parliament from being whittled away by judicial legislation, abroad or indeed at home.”

Human rights lawyer Jessica Simor QC, of Matrix Chambers, said that Mr Raab was peddling a “false narrative” that foreign judges were ruling over the UK court system, when in fact the Human Rights Act was introduced specifically to ensure that British people were able to have their rights upheld in a domestic court rather than having to go to the ECHR.

Watering down its provisions would simply mean more complaints going to Strasbourg and more rulings against the UK, unless the government intended to pull Britain out of the European Convention on Human Rights altogether, which would be “a step into a dark place for this country and the world”, warned Ms Simor.

Mr Jones – who quit as the government’s top lawyer in 2020 in protest at Boris Johnson’s plans to breach international law in the row over the post-Brexit Irish border – said there was “lots of muddle” in Mr Raab’s proposals.

As parliament is already able to legislate to correct flaws in the law, it appeared Mr Raab was trying to use a new mechanism to allow ministers to take this step without obtaining MPs’ approval, he said.

“We’ve had (Brexit minister) Lord Frost proposing a ‘tailored mechanism’ for accelerating changes to retained EU law,” said Mr Jones.

“Now Mr Raab suggests a mechanism for ‘correcting’ court judgments. What can such mechanisms mean other than more hasty policy, less scrutiny, a reduced role for parliament?”

Cambridge professor of public law Mark Elliott pointed to a recent Supreme Court ruling, saying that allowing a minister to overrule a decision of the judiciary simply because he did not agree with it would cut across “principles that are fundamental components of the rule of law”.

Mr Raab appeared to be suggesting changes that would give the government the power to correct court decisions through secondary legislation, which does not have to be subjected to scrutiny or votes in parliament.

“If that is what is in contemplation, then that is profoundly problematic,” said Prof Elliott. “Indeed it turns constitutional principle on its head.

“Ministerial power to do this would itself be deeply troubling. It would reassign a basic judicial role – interpreting the law – to ministers.

“Ultimately, this all strikes me as part of a project to enhance executive supremacy by treating courts, whether foreign or domestic, as unwelcome interlopers.

“And yet all of this masquerades as an attempt to protect parliament. The reality of this executive power project, as we might call it, is that it will be the executive that is the principal beneficiary of such changes, and the loser will be basic standards of good governance.”

Labour’s shadow justice secretary David Lammy accused Mr Raab of reviving long-standing Tory assaults on human rights legislation as a way of diverting attention from the dire state of the criminal justice system under his watch.

“Rape convictions are at historic lows and women are rapidly losing faith in the criminal justice system, while record backlogs have left the courts at breaking point,” said Mr Lammy.

“And yet the priority for Dominic Raab seems to be undermining vital human rights legislation that protects us all.

“Instead of trying to weaken the rule of law, the Tories need to set out how they plan to fix the chaos they have created in the justice system.”

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Palampur: Fire breaks out at laboratory in Institute of Himalayan Bioresource Technology laboratory

© Provided by Hindustan Times A fire broke out in the chemistry laboratory of the Institute of Himalayan Bioresource Technology, Palampur, in the wee hours of Sunday. (HT Photo) Laboratory ... Read more »

Himachal: 64 Covid cases surface, 2 dead; Shimla reports maximum cases

© Provided by Hindustan Times With 62 fresh Covid- cases on Sunday, Himachal’s case tally rose to 2,27,003.The highest of 35 cases were reported from Shimla, 11 from Kangra and ... Read more »

Himachal governor inaugurates state conclave of Arogya Bharti Sanstha in Una

© Provided by Hindustan Times Himachal governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar stressed on documentation of medicinal plants found in the state. He was speaking after inaugurating the state convention of Arogya ... Read more »

Watch: Viking defender Brekalo sent off for attacking his own goalkeeper in Norwegian league game

Viking defender David Brekalo was sent off during Sunday’s Eliteserien match against Kristiansund after attacking his own goalkeeper in the 95th minute. Brekalo repeatedly pushed goalkeeper Patrik Gunnarsson during the ... Read more »

Soccer-Tuchel hails courage of captain Jorginho after howler

LONDON (Reuters) – Chelsea coach Thomas Tuchel praised his captain Jorginho for overcoming a howler of a mistake that gifted Manchester United a breakaway goal, and recovering his confidence to ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic's father claims he is being 'blackmailed' over Australian Open

Novak Djokovic‘s father has slammed the “embarrassing” way he feels his son has been treated by officials in Victoria as the row over unvaccinated players being banned from the Australian ... Read more »

Man Utd legend Roy Keane disagrees with Michael Carrick comments after Chelsea draw

© Provided by Metro Man Utd legend Roy Keane was surprised by Michael Carrick’s comments (Pictures: Sky Sports) Roy Keane disagreed with ‘everything’ interim manager Michael Carrick said after Manchester ... Read more »

"Could end up being embarrassing" - Journo reacts to "surprise" report on big-money Arsenal ace

Journalist Paul Brown reckons that it would be “embarrassing” if Arsenal sold Nicolas Pepe to another Premier League club and he started performing. © GiveMeSport p1fle9bbsc1og21dvt1s80hqb1tecb.jpg The Ivorian has shown ... Read more »

Video: Voters give their views on Boris Johnson ahead of a by-election

It’s been a difficult three weeks for the government, with the migrant crossings in the Channel, the shift of promises on HS2, social care, and sleaze, but does any of it make a difference to the voters? Read more »

Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher's heated debate on whether Cristiano Ronaldo should start for Man Utd

Cristiano Ronaldo was benched for Man Utd's 1-1 draw with Chelsea; Roy Keane: "Ronaldo has not come back to Manchester United to sit on the bench"; Jamie Carragher: "I don't think it should be a big story if Ronaldo doesn't start every game" Read more »

I quit my job to travel and work remotely 5 years ago — here's what I wish I knew before

© Provided by Business Insider Stephanie Smolders recommends saving as much as possible before starting a digital nomad lifestyle. Stephanie Smolders Stephanie Smolders is a marketing and business coach, writer, ... Read more »

'From credible people' - Devlin's claim as Celtic close in on another J1 League star in January

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Celtic, Hoops, SPFL, Reo Hatate Reliable Celtic correspondent Kieran Devlin has had his say on the Hoops’ reported move for Kawakasi Frontale left-back Reo Hatate. ... Read more »

Ranboo breaks 4 million Twitch followers

© Provided by Dot Esports Twitch streamer and content creator Ranboo surpassed four million followers on Twitch today. The American streamer has seen a sudden rise on the platform since ... Read more »

Tilly Ramsay becomes the latest celeb to leave Strictly

© Bang Showbiz Tilly Ramsay and Nikita Kuzmin have left Strictly Tilly Ramsay is the latest celebrity to be eliminated from ‘Strictly Come Dancing’. The 20-year-old YouTuber – who reduced ... Read more »

Punjab polls: CM Channi announces to set up research centre on Ramayana, Mahabharat, Bhagvad Geeta

On the backfoot for not considering a Hindu Congress leader, Sunil Jakhar, as the Punjab Chief Minister, the Congress on Sunday went on a spree of announcements to woo the ... Read more »

Australia Covid live update: Omicron detected in NSW, states tighten border restrictions; ABC announces new RN Breakfast host

LIVE – Updated at 21:18 Follow all the news live.   21:18 Scott Morrison is now speaking to the Nine network (he declined to appear on the ABC) about the ... Read more »

'It's ARROGANCE': Chelsea star Jorginho criticised by Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink for error in miscontrolling long ball which led to Jadon Sancho's opener for Manchester United

Chelsea dropped points as they drew 1-1 with Manchester United on Sunday Jorginho's error handed Jadon Sancho to hit Chelsea on the counter and scoreBut the Italian redeemed himself after levelling for the hosts from the spotJimmy Floyd Hasselbaink branded the error as 'silly' and labelled him 'arrogant' Read more »

Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher descend into FURIOUS row as Sky Sports pundits clash over Cristiano Ronaldo - with former United captain saying he must start the biggest games as Liverpool icon insists he's 'not the player he was'

Cristiano Ronaldo was left on the bench for Manchester United against ChelseaRonaldo came on as a substitute and showed visible signs of frustration Roy Keane questioned why Ronaldo was left out of such an important gameCarragher in response said Ronaldo's omission shouldn't be 'big news'Keane and Carragher were involved in a screaming match afterwards  Read more »

Calls for unvaccinated Australians to pay higher Medicare fees because they place more of a 'burden on the medical system'

Lead economist called for unvaccinated residents to pay higher medicare feesSaul Eslake said decision to not get vaccine placed burden on healthcare systemTreasurer Josh Frydenberg has dismissed calls to introduce a medicare levy  Read more »

Video: Outrageous row erupts at McDonald's between a FURIOUS worker and customer in front of shocked diners

Read more »

Video: Burnley's clash with Tottenham is POSTPONED less than an hour before kick-off due to huge snowfall, with the undersoil heating at Turf Moor unable to help clear the pitch... despite being left on overnight!

Read more »

MATT BARLOW: Thomas Tuchel was going mad about a refereeing decision late on but the real source of his frustration is failing to put away a Manchester United side managed by a caretaker crew

Thomas Tuchel went through the whole Basil Fawlty repertoire on the sidelines He was angry with the referee but really his frustration is with missed chancesChelsea's lead at the top of the Premier League has been cut to just one pointAnd German boss Tuchel knows the Blues must win the games they dominate  Read more »

Giants defense saves the day in win over Eagles

The Giants are in no position to rank any victories. They are all precious gems to them because they are all so rare. And so, another offensively challenged and unsightly ... Read more »

Michael Strahan tells fans Giants ‘will be back' in No. 92 retirement ceremony

In a ceremony to honor his great past, Michael Strahan promised a better future for the Giants. The Giants retired Strahan’s No. 92 on Sunday during halftime against the Eagles, ... Read more »

You've been using credit cards all wrong – how to use them correctly and it could save you THOUSANDS of pounds

CREDIT cards are a handy tool for your wallet but only if you use them correctly – get it wrong and you could end up spending thousands more in interest ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity set for further delays as Storm Arwen destroys show's studios with castle looking like a ‘war zone'

I’M A Celebrity bosses are braced for more weather chaos after Storm Arwen destroyed pop-up studios at Gwrych Castle. The weekend weather bomb was said to have left the venue ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity's Frankie Bridge begs bosses to let her wash her dirty knickers as they smell like FISH

FRANKIE Bridge begged I’m A Celebrity bosses to wash her dirty knickers after the stars were removed from the castle – admitting they stank of fish guts and offal from the trials. The ... Read more »

Israel okays immigration for thousands of Ethiopians

© AHMAD GHARABLI In this file photo, members of Israel’s Ethiopian community hold photographs during a demonstration demanding the rescue of their relatives from the conflict in Ethiopia, in Jerusalem ... Read more »

B.C. set to use Alert Ready system when next storm strikes in days ahead

VICTORIA — British Columbia says it’s prepared to use a national emergency alert system should the third in a trio of ongoing storms pose a risk to life and safety ... Read more »

Brazil burns boats in crackdown on wildcat Amazon gold miners

Brazilian authorities burned more than 60 river-dredging boats in a crackdown on wildcat miners drawn to a major Amazon tributary by rumors of a gold find, the government and Greenpeace ... Read more »

Covid: Britons who refuse to wear a mask ‘face fines of £200' as ministers tighten rules

Britons who refuse to wear a face mask could face fines of £200 as the Government tightens Covid restrictions to contain the Omicron variant, according to a report. © PA ... Read more »

Jennifer Jones beats Tracy Fleury in women's final at Canada's Olympic curling trials

SASKATOON — Jennifer Jones defeated Tracy Fleury 6-5 in the women’s final at Canada’s Olympic curling trials to secure a berth at the Beijing Games.  © Provided by The Canadian ... Read more »

Five people reported for driving under the influence in the Western Police District

During the night between Saturday and Sunday, five people were arrested for driving under the influence in Bergen and the surrounding area. One of the cars hit a wall in ... Read more »

Trial of Ghislaine Maxwell, alleged accomplice of Jeffrey Epstein, set to start Monday

The trial of British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, who is accused of helping her close confidant Jeffrey Epstein recruit and sexually abuse underage girls, is set to begin on Monday, more ... Read more »

Australia confirms two cases of Omicron COVID-19 variant

Travelers stand at a Virgin Australia Airlines counter at Kingsford Smith International Airport in Sydney MELBOURNE (Reuters) -Australia confirmed on Sunday that two people arriving from southern Africa over the ... Read more »

South African president calls for lifting of Omicron travel bans

© Provided by Al Jazeera Ramaphosa said his government was considering making vaccines mandatory for certain activities and locations in a bid to increase uptake [Maja Hitij/Getty] South African President ... Read more »

Christmas holidays abroad under threat as tourist hotspots tighten their borders

Hopes of Christmas holidays overseas have suffered a blow after popular destination countries imposed tougher border restrictions. © Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg Heathrow – Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg Spain, Portugal, Switzerland, Morocco and Israel ... Read more »

'Imagine the sauce', 'Are you serious...' - Many Newcastle fans react as transfer news emerges

© Provided by This is Futbol Ousmane Dembele Newcastle United fell further towards the drop with another defeat at the weekend to Arsenal, with attentions moving to the transfer window ... Read more »

Rangnick has tools to work with at Man Utd

It was apparent within a few seconds of kick-off that Manchester United intended to approach their game at Chelsea a little differently. Ralf Rangnick has not taken charge yet – ... Read more »

Remote hand of Rangnick already in play as Ronaldo feels the chill

As Cristiano Ronaldo prepared to enter the pitch with an hour gone at Stamford Bridge, having performed a dutiful kind of warm-up, meandering along the touchline like a venerable old ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic