R. Kelly was convicted. What happens to his music on streaming platforms?

The disgraced R&B singer's music is still easily accessible on the major streaming services.

In May 2018, Spotify removed R. Kelly’s music from its official playlists. The biggest music streaming app in America said it wanted its “editorial decisions — what we choose to program — to reflect our values.”

Three years later, Kelly’s tracks are still absent from Spotify’s influential curated packages. But the disgraced superstar’s full discography was still available on the service’s app as of Tuesday morning, a day after he was found guilty on all counts in a sex-trafficking trial.

Kelly’s music was also easily accessible on Spotify’s major competitors, including Apple Music, Amazon Music and the Google-owned provider YouTube Music.

In the wake of Monday’s verdict, some on social media redoubled their efforts to push the major music streaming services to pull Kelly’s discography, arguing in part that it was wrong to provide a global platform — and possible royalty revenues — to a convicted serial sexual predator.

Spotify, Apple, Amazon and YouTube did not immediately respond to questions Tuesday about what they planned to do with Kelly’s music library and what criteria they might consider for removing the entirety of an artist’s work.

Kelly, 54, was trailed by troubling accusations of sexual misconduct and abuse for decades even as he climbed the Billboard charts, won Grammy Awards and entered the R&B pantheon with smash hits like “I Believe I Can Fly.”

But with the rise of the #MeToo movement in 2017, the artist started to face deeper scrutiny. #MuteRKelly, a grassroots campaign co-founded by Oronike Odeleye and Kenyette Tisha Barnes, worked to stop his music from being played on the radio or via streaming services.

“I started #MuteRKelly in July 2017 out of a feeling of outrage. After decades of blatantly abusing Black women and girls, R. Kelly was going on with his life with our community-sanctioned support,” Odeleye, who is Black, told HuffPost in February.

The campaign has been successful in certain clear ways. Kelly’s music is said to have largely vanished from the radio, and songs that were once mainstays of graduation ceremonies, weddings and backyard parties have faded.

But data on streaming platforms suggests that the appetite for his 1990s and 2000s-era hits has not waned. He racks up nearly 5 million monthly listeners on Spotify, according to information at the top of his artist page on the app.

George Howard, a professor of music business and management at Berklee College of Music, told NBC News he believes the need to remove Kelly’s music from streaming services has become even more urgent since the jury in the artist’s federal trial returned a guilty verdict.

“I think it became far less problematic with the decision that went down [Monday],” Howard said. “We are now dealing with a different class of decision-making.”

“I think, from an ethical framework, we as a society have to decide at what point we divorce an artistic output from a creator,” he said. “I think we can all agree that at no point in modern history has it ever been acceptable to sexually abuse children.”

“It’s a no-brainer to me,” he added, “and that behavior far outweighs any sort of artistic merit.”

Kelly, who has vehemently and repeatedly denied any wrongdoing, was found guilty of being the orchestrator of a long-running scheme to recruit women and underage girls for sex.

The campaign to excise Kelly’s body of work still raises thorny questions about where streaming services draw the line. The top streaming destinations continue to promote albums by other artists who have been accused of sexual misconduct and abuse or other crimes, for example.

The New York Daily News editorial board, for its part, cautioned against dumping Kelly’s work in an article published Tuesday.

“When you patronize an artist, you elevate him; when you patronize a living artist, you help her profit. Similarly, it is the right of the companies that showcase creative products to refuse to stock any given individual on their real or virtual shelves,” the editorial board wrote.

“But for bookstores, galleries and streaming services to begin morally judging the lives of all those they feature? Down that road madness lies,” the board added.

In some respects, #MuteRKelly echoes the debate over the digital futures of other artistic creations, including films and television shows.

In summer 2020, for instance, HBO Max briefly pulled “Gone With the Wind” amid renewed scrutiny over the Oscar-winning film’s racist content. The movie has long been criticized for romanticizing the Confederacy and denying the horrors of slavery.

“Gone With the Wind” has since been restored to HBO Max with an introductory video message from TCM host Jacqueline Stewart that explores the film’s context and racial politics.

The issue also highlights the unprecedented power of Silicon Valley tech giants.

In the era of physical media, consumers purchased vinyl records or CDs and owned them in perpetuity. In the streaming age, subscribers pay for access to media floating in the proverbial “cloud” that could disappear overnight.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Brian Laundrie - update: Fugitive's father tears protest sign from lawn as Petito parents demand ‘justice'

© YouTube Captura de pantalla 2021-09-20 a las 9.32.47 AM.png LIVE – Updated at 18:53 Gabby Petito’s parents have said that they “want vengeance and justice” for the loss of ... Read more »

Killed in the line of duty: David Amess's final day in democratic service

Photograph: Tolga Akmen/AFP/Getty Images Sir David Amess made no secret of where he would be on Friday 15 October – details of his constituency surgery at Belfairs Methodist church were ... Read more »

How much money does MOONMOON make streaming? – Twitch leaks 2021

© Provided by GamePur Twitch was recently hacked, and the personal information of every user on the platform was leaked by an unidentified hacker. Despite the fact that the majority ... Read more »

Kane beendet gegen Newcastle seine Torflaute +++ Atalanta schlägt Empoli souverän

© PETER POWELL/keystone-sda.ch Getroffen – Harry Kane darf im siebten Saisonspiel endlich aufatmen. Premier League Newcastle – Tottenham 2:3 Newcastle United verpasst auch im ersten Spiel nach der Übernahme durch ... Read more »

Get paid to sleep and watch Netflix - the dream job with a £24,000 salary

However, Crafted Beds insists that this role is a vital part of their team to ensure customer satisfaction and product quality checking. This new role will see one UK resident ... Read more »

Lucabe Coffee Company opens in mid-century Indiana bank building

The Irwin Union Bank building in Columbus, Indiana, originally designed by notable American architect Harry Weese, has reopened as a coffee shop. © Provided by Dezeen The exterior of the ... Read more »

Uranium in the water: remote NT community wants answers about safety

Jack Cool is looking to hitch a lift out of town. The 71-year-old former stockman has lived in Laramba, a remote Indigenous community in the Northern Territory, for most of ... Read more »

U.S. should free missionaries in Haiti without ransom -lawmaker

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The United States must find up to 17 U.S. missionaries reported kidnapped in Haiti and see if it can negotiate their release without paying a ransom or ... Read more »

Jordan, Saudi investors launch Fly Aqaba

Jordan announced Sunday the signing of an accord to launch an airline financed by investors in the kingdom and Saudi Arabia to serve the Red Sea resort area of Aqaba. ... Read more »

Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed hails UAE as global leader for tech innovation on Gitex tour

© Provided by The National Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed, Crown Prince of Dubai, officially opened Gitex at Dubai World Trade Centre. Photo: Wam Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed said the UAE ... Read more »

Jaguars snap 20-game losing streak with last-second win over Dolphins in London

LONDON — The Jacksonville Jaguars ended their 20-game losing streak when Matthew Wright kicked a 53-yard field goal as time expired in a 23-20 victory over the Miami Dolphins on ... Read more »

BCCI invites applications for job of India head coach, Rahul Dravid frontrunner for job

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: In one of the biggest developments in Indian cricket, Rahul Dravid has agreed to become the coach of the Indian senior ... Read more »

Ban vs Sco Highlights: ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2021 Qualifier, Match 2, Group B

© Provided by News18 Ban vs Sco Highlights: ICC Men’s T20 World Cup 2021 Qualifier, Match 2, Group B In the second match of the ICC Men’s T20 World Cup ... Read more »

Two Americans detained by police in Greece for protesting Beijing Olympics

Two Americans were detained by police in Greece on Sunday after they staged a protest against the Beijing Winter Olympics, The Associated Press reported. © The Hill Two Americans detained ... Read more »

Just bought an iPhone 13? This iOS 15 trick gives you more iCloud storage for free

Did you just buy a new iPhone 13, 13 Mini, 13 Pro and 13 Pro Max or maybe one of Apple’s older phones like the iPhone 12, iPhone 11 or ... Read more »

IONITY Is First In Europe To Offer Plug & Charge At All Stations

ABB’s high-power chargers at IONITY fast charging station ABB’s high-power chargers at IONITY fast charging station ABB’s high-power chargers at IONITY fast charging station IONITY fast charging station IONITY fast ... Read more »

Sir David Amess murder: Terror suspect being held by police is named Ali Harbi Ali, Sky News understands

The terror suspect held on suspicion of murdering Sir David Amess is named Ali Harbi Ali, Sky News understands. The 25-year-old, who is a British citizen with Somali heritage, is ... Read more »

Yorkshire Regiment names soldier who died on army exercise on Salisbury Plain

1 / 2Yorkshire Regiment names soldier who died on army exercise on Salisbury Plain A soldier who died during an army training exercise on Salisbury Plain on Friday has been ... Read more »

‘Our hearts are shattered': Family of David Amess plea for ‘some good from this tragedy'

© Independent Breaking News The family of Sir David Amess praised the murdered MP as a ‘wonderful and inspiring man’ on Sunday as they issued a powerful plea: ‘Please let ... Read more »

Newcastle-Tottenham game resumes after medical emergency

© Alamy Stock Photo A member of the Newcastle United medical team runs to assist a fan in the stands. Updated at 17.38 TODAY’S PREMIER LEAGUE fixture between Newcastle and ... Read more »

Moyes names best player in West Ham win, reveals January transfer plan

© PA Images David Moyes ahead of West Ham match at Elland Road David Moyes has named the best player in West Ham’s narrow victory over Everton and suggested what ... Read more »

Brentford 0-1 Chelsea: Romelu Lukaku pushed into offside position by Mathias Jensen

© GiveMeSport Chelsea’s Romelu Lukaku pushed into offside position by Brentford’s Mathias Jensen Romelu Lukaku‘s bad luck continued as Chelsea beat Brentford 1-0 in the late kick-off on Saturday. Last ... Read more »

Er hatte heuer viele Rückschläge, jetzt ist er Weltmeister

Der Berner belegt in Argentinien in der Supersport-WM die Ränge 5 und 3 und hält damit seinen Hauptrivalen entscheidend auf Distanz. © Foto: Javier Cebollada (Keystone). Er beendet ein schwieriges ... Read more »

Späte Niederlage für Sion am Tag der Comebacks

© KEYSTONE/JEAN-CHRISTOPHE BOTT Sion kassiert gegen den FC Basel beim dritten Einstand von Trainer Paolo Tramezzani und der Rückkehr der Fans ins Tourbillon ein bitteres 0:1. Edon Zhegrova schiesst den ... Read more »

Breitenrain jubelt weiter

Der FC Breitenrain bezwingt Biel. Der EHC Thun feiert ein seltenes Erfolgserlebnis. Marlen Reusser und Marc Hirschi stehen auf dem Podest. Neuigkeiten aus der Region. © Archivfoto: Claudio De Capitani/Freshfocus ... Read more »

St. Galler Siegestor nach 93 Minuten

© KEYSTONE/CHRISTIAN MERZ Der FC St. Gallen kann in der Meisterschaft doch noch gewinnen. Nach acht Spielen ohne Sieg bezwingen die Ostschweizer Servette daheim vor fast 14’000 Zuschauern 2:1. Das ... Read more »

Töff-Pilot Dominique Aegerter ist Weltmeister der Supersport-Serie

Im argentinischen San Juan sicherte sich der 31-jährige Berner den WM-Titel. Aegerter ist der dritte Schweizer, der in dieser Rennserie den Titel holt. Ronaldo entscheidet das Spiel In seinem Rekordspiel ... Read more »

Roxy Horner is the cream of the crops in an off-white mini-skirt

ROXY Horner is the cream of the crops in an off-white miniskirt. The model, girlfriend of comedian Jack Whitehall, wore the thigh-skimming design with a white, lace bustier and matching ... Read more »

NHL Betting Picks: Dallas Stars at Ottawa Senators

And we’re back! The 2021-22 NHL season is in full swing, and I’ll be sharing my betting picks every Sunday — chase (or fade?) at your own risk! All betting ... Read more »

Parris Campbell's 51-yard touchdown catch gives Colts 7-0 lead

© Provided by NBC Sports The Colts punted after their first drive but finally got it going on their second chance of the day. Indianapolis went 92 yards on seven ... Read more »

Cardinals vs. Browns odds, line, spread: 2021 NFL picks, Week 6 predictions from proven computer model

When the Cleveland Browns (3-2) host the Arizona Cardinals (5-0) on Sunday afternoon, the result may have more to do with who is not on the field than who is. ... Read more »

Newcastle 2-3 Tottenham: Harry Kane scores first Premier League goal of season as Newcastle lose first game under new owners

Report and free match highlights as Harry Kane, Tanguy Ndombele and Heung-Min Son score for Spurs; Callum Wilson fires Newcastle ahead inside two minutes; Jonjo Shelvey sent off late on before Eric Dier own goal; Play had been suspended after a medical emergency Read more »

Western Ghats Ecology report unimplemented, Jairam Ramesh on Kerala floods

© IANS Western Ghats Ecology report unimplemented, Jairam Ramesh on Kerala floods New Delhi, Oct 17 (IANS) In wake of heavy floods battering Kerala again, former Union Environment Minister Jairam ... Read more »

Non-recognition of govt in Afghanistan is benefitting ISIS-K: Taliban

© Provided by WION The Taliban have said that not recognising the new government in Afghanistan is benefiting Islamic State Khorasan (ISIS-K). However, the outfit dismissed concerns that the terrorist ... Read more »

Yuvraj Singh arrested and released on bail by Haryana police for using casteist slur against Yuzvendra Chahal

Former India cricketer Yuvraj Singh was arrested and released on interim bail by Haryana Police for using a casteist slur against spinner Yuzvendra Chahal. Yuvraj was reportedly arrested and questioned ... Read more »

Delhi's air quality ‘steadily deteriorating', says Kejriwal; reason to worry

© Provided by Hindustan Times Delhi’s air quality has been deteriorating to ‘very poor’ category. (Picture for representation only/HT_PRINT) Delhi’s air quality has dropped to ‘very poor’ levels and is ... Read more »

The Week Ahead: Mumbai gears up to reopen colleges and cinemas; ICC Men's T20 World Cup begins

© Provided by Hindustan Times Security staff checks temperature of a student after schools reopen with all Covid-19 protocols in place in Mumbai on October 04. (Pratik Chorge/HT PHOTO) Mumbai ... Read more »

The Guardian view on French politics: the great moving right show

Since the election of Emmanuel Macron as president in 2017, it has been tempting to view French politics in somewhat Manichean terms. Four years ago, Mr Macron won by (comfortably) ... Read more »

Here we go again! Councils order schools to reintroduce Covid restrictions as cases rocket

Amid rising case levels in some areas of the country, councils have now issued advice to schools concerning 12-18-year-olds. Although the Government has lifted measures such as mandatory face-coverings, some ... Read more »

Ex-I.Coast leader launches new quest for presidency

Former Ivory Coast president Laurent Gbagbo on Sunday launched a new political party he hopes will return him to the presidency. © Sia KAMBOU Gbagbo, with a decade-long exile behind ... Read more »