Prospects of ESG Investing in India, explained by Ruchit Mehta of SBI Mutual Fund

Asia's Tech News Daily

#ESG, #ESG fund, #SBI AMC, #SBI Magnum

ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) based investing, which focuses extensively on evaluating a company’s social consciousness rather than simply considering the bottom line for making investment decisions, has been catching up fast, especially with young investors, who want to move beyond quantitative aspects to assess the prospects of a business.

Per data, inflows in ESG funds to Rs 3,686 crores, a 76 percent rise in 2021, as against a base of Rs 2,094 crores in 2020. We catch up with Ruchit Mehta, Fund Manager, SBI Mutual Fund, as he elaborates on the potential and scope of this branch of investing in India.

How do you view the prospect and potential of ESG investing in India? What are some of the trends you’ve noticed in recent times and in the next five-10 years to come?

While ESG investing is currently viewed as simply a thematic way of investing by most investors, it is essentially an extension of the research process needed to determine good investments and a very important way to understand rising risk factors to business sustainability from various global issues such as climate change and income inequality, challenges, and risks, among others. ESG will soon become mainstream and a popular investing approach rather than simply remaining thematic over the next five-10 years.

Each country will have to approach ESG in its own manner, best suited to the need of that country. For example, the western world is seeing a shunning of investments in fossil fuels. But for a country like India where there is still inequality of energy availability, shunning fossil fuels outright may not make sense. It is better to engage with companies in that space and work with them so that they develop a transition path to a more sustainable and equitable future.

Having said that, there are a few trends that are specific to India. For instance, responsible investing and ESG integration has been adopted more proactively and quickly by the asset managers here rather than the asset owners as has been the convention in most developed countries.

Do you think the environmental aspect of the ESG is highlighted and more emphasized than the Social and Governance aspect of the three when it comes to evaluating investments on these parameters? How do we ensure that all these parameters are holistically included in scoring?

Generally, environmental aspects tend to get highlighted more as they are global in nature and affect every human being. This is good as it is a pressing matter and affects all regardless of where you live, or the business operates. There is a downside to this as it leads to ESG being termed simply as reen investing. Most investors have a false notion of ESG investing is about investing in renewable energy firms, recycling firms, etc.

But, nothing can be further from the truth. ESG investing is about looking at all three aspects equally and holistically. There will be nuances in each sector, like environmental matters are crucial in the mining sector and labor issues most important for the textile sector.

Investors will do well to look comprehensively at the business a company is in and evaluate the operating parameters and consequently, judge which aspect of ESG deserves greater scrutiny or analysis. Also, we believe that Governance factors have an extremely important interplay here.

A well-governed business, run by a competent, ethical, and responsible management team will certainly incorporate environmental and social factors in their decision-making processes. This is why, while environmental and social factors may differ or have a higher/lower relevance based on the industry sector, governance factors stay constant and highly relevant.

Valuation giant Aswath Damodaran termed ESG investing as a mistake, as he said, “If being good makes companies less risky, investors in good companies will earn lower returns than investors in bad companies, before adjusting for risk, and equivalent returns after adjusting for risk”. There is an increasing list of experts who are growing skeptical of ESG investing? Why? What are the potential downfalls and risks associated with this kind of investment?

Professor Damodaran is right in the way he has framed the problem. If doing good leads to lower risk-taking, it will mean lower returns for investors. Many like him are skeptical about ESG investing, and that has got more to do with the way the investing community has approached ESG than the fundamentals of ESG.

The investing industry has jumped onto the bandwagon of ESG as it is a new rising trend, something which is attracting a lot of assets. This has led to many instances of greenwashing, green labeling, and a host of uncharitable practices which do more harm to the furtherance of ESG than any purported good.

However, this does not mean the concept of ESG is immaterial. Following good ESG practices does not necessarily lead to lower risk-taking or lower returns for companies. Companies adopting more sustainable business practices tend to see material benefits as well. This can range from the lower cost of capital (which can encourage risk-taking), better employee retention, and better consumer demand (theoretically with an ability to charge more).

Look no further than a metals and mining firm from India’s largest conglomerate. They have had some of the best labor relations over a century, all because they have had one of the best employment practices. In a business fraught with labor disputes, they have had very minimal disruptions. And whilst the benefit of this is not quantified, it does accrue.

Also, this is a perception because the most common way of creating ESG Funds is via exclusion/negative screening of companies by sectors. It may lead to exclusion of sectors like coal or oil which may be major revenue earners for governments, or not investing in sectors like tobacco, alcohol, etc which may be more profitable than some other sectors. However, increasingly, funds are adopting an ESG integration approach rather than an exclusionary approach.

From that perspective, it is just logical to keep very risky companies out of the portfolio, just like you would anyway keep bad companies out of your portfolio. The sustainability of long-term rewards is also material to investors, which is what ESG funds focus on.

Data on ESG funds has shown that these funds have performed equivalent to other funds and have at times outperformed the benchmarks. More conclusive data would emerge when the funds will be older enough to assess the data in a meaningful way in the Indian context.

The ESG momentum is being driven by the millennials who are distilling their social consciousness in their investments. But since the parameters are so abstract and evolving, concrete, conclusive data is hard to find and understand for an individual investor. How do you think investors can truly assess the impact and performance of these funds accurately?

ESG investing is still an evolving area. There are issues of quality data, and not all of it is objective. This has led to a disparity in the views held by investors and service providers. It is well documented that two rating agencies looking at the same company can have very different ESG Ratings.

It is therefore natural for investors to be confused or feel unable to assess the performance of ESG funds. The key here lies in assessing the ESG process followed by the asset manager. The robustness of the ESG evaluation process, the level to which ESG is integrated into investment research and the commitment of the firm (such as are they a UNPRI signatory? Do they have a dedicated ESG team?) are important factors to evaluate.

Also, with the regulators like SEBI laying stress on increased transparency in the form of BRSR, we expect the data unavailability, standardization, and assessment issues will get mitigated over time as companies will be expected to provide quantitative data in the public domain. This will make them more accountable to the millennials, and easier for fund managers to access data and integrate it into their decision-making process. However, even with data availability, the concepts around ESG assessment themselves are dynamic.

For instance, today, we may want to see the historical performance of a company to assess whether it has demonstrated responsible behavior. However, in a few years, we might want to look at future strategies and changes brought in the company’s process in recent years – a concept known as the ESG improvers. So, it largely depends on how fund managers decide to integrate the assessment in their decision-making process and how they evolve their understanding and frameworks over time.

What are the parameters and selection criteria that the SBI Magnum Equity ESG fund follows for selecting companies? What factors are predominantly important?

Let me talk about the selection procedure we follow here at SBI. The Magnum Equity ESG fund has a two-step process to determine security selection. First, we narrow down the universe of stocks covered by the research team using a set of filters that focus on ESG factors. The negative screening is focused on three areas.

First, it is revenue exposure for companies (greater than 5 percent) to Tobacco, Alcohol, Adult Entertainment, Gambling, and Controversial weapons (anti-personnel mines, cluster munitions). Second, is high unresolved controversies pertaining to material ESG factors. Third, are companies that score poorly on their ESG rating, where we have a minimum cut-off. The second process is security selection based on our fundamental view of the business, the attractiveness of the growth opportunity, valuations, and ESG performance (leaders or scope for material improvement).

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Rotterdam central now really closed

They thought it would take a few weeks in 2020, but only after thirteen months of negotiations could the closure of the Onyx coal-fired power station be announced on Tuesday. ... Read more »

ESG Book aims to 'disrupt' sustainability sector with free data

FILE PHOTO: A leaf sits on top of a pile of coal in Youngstown, Ohio By Huw Jones LONDON (Reuters) – HSBC, Deutsche Bank and Swiss Re have thrown their ... Read more »

Elizabeth Holmes admits whistleblower was right and reporter was ‘mishandled'

The former Theranos CEO testified under cross-examination that her company “messed up” interactions with the reporter whose investigations ultimately led to her downfall. Read more »

Economizing EasyJet reduces loss – NRC

Airline easyJet is currently seeing the demand for airline tickets slump due to the emergence of the new variant of the corona virus. “People are waiting to book until more ... Read more »

Sports bettors dream: 86 able to bet on game after it ended

The Associated PressFILE – Manchester United’s Marcus Rashford, top, scores his side’s second goal during the English Premier League soccer match between Manchester United and Liverpool at the Old Trafford ... Read more »

Global luxury giants LVMH, Hermes eye expansion on China's Hainan Island in blow to shopping hotspot Hong Kong

In a blow for Hong Kong, global luxury goods companies such as LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton (LVMH), Hermes and Richemont are exploring opportunities in China’s Hainan province, as they ... Read more »

CPN sets aside B3bn for 6 projects

Mr Nattakit (left) and Mr Kree at CPN’s press conference held for the grand opening of Central Ayutthaya. SET-listed retail and property developer Central Pattana (CPN) plans to spend 3 ... Read more »

Majority of Internet-connected household appliances

Photo: ANP The Netherlands is a European leader in the use of household appliances that are connected to the internet. According to Statistics Netherlands (CBS), nearly three quarters of residents ... Read more »

Cabinet allots B141bn for rice, rubber

The cabinet on Tuesday approved a combined 141 billion baht to support an income guarantee scheme for rice and rubber farmers in the 2021-22 season. According to government spokesman Thanakorn ... Read more »

B20bn loans to bolster diesel subsidy

The Oil Fuel Fund Office (Offo) is preparing to obtain loans worth 20 billion baht from 10 commercial banks, following the government's approval to seek loans to support its subsidy ... Read more »

Oxfam Novib provides information about loans from development bank FMO

Photo: ANP The Dutch development bank FMO is not transparent enough about financing and investments. This makes it impossible to check whether investments have negative consequences for people and the ... Read more »

Swift selling local media assets to Ogden Newspapers

ASPEN, Colo. — Swift Communications, which owns a range of daily and weekly newspapers across the American West, announced Tuesday it is selling its local media and publishing businesses to ... Read more »

Bitkub rises up the ranking Daily trading value now stands at B28bn

Bitkub, a local digital asset exchange, ranked as the 10th largest cryptocurrency exchange in terms of trading value on on Nov 29, spurred by a chain of successful partnerships ... Read more »

NBTC panned over budget

Bangkok Post file photo The Office of the Auditor-General (OAG) criticised the National Broadcasting and Telecommunications Commission's (NBTC) budget spending as not being cost-effective, noting it often resorted to special ... Read more »

Mall Group, Bitkub form digital community Each firm has 50% stake in joint venture

Mr Jirayut (left) and Ms Supaluck at ‘The Pinnacle of Prosperity’ press conference. Ms Supaluck said the partnership scheme starts with the cooperation between The Mall Group and Bitkub before ... Read more »

UK economy could get $5.3 billion boost from hosting major sports events: report

The UK is eyeing to host the 2030 FIFA World Cup The UK's economy could get a US$5.3 billion boost through soft power, trade and investment benefit by hosting major ... Read more »

Why is China's growth rate falling so fast?

In early 2021, the consensus forecast for Chinese gross domestic product (GDP) growth this year among 25 major global banks and other professional forecasters was 8.3%. In contrast, the Chinese ... Read more »

BoT keeping close eye on impact of Omicron

A man is tested for Covid-19 at Phuket airport on Monday. The swab tests are a mandatory measure for arriving passengers to prevent the spread of the disease. REUTERS The ... Read more »

Dutchman owns smartest home

This is apparent from an overview from the publication The Netherlands in Figures of the Central Bureau of Statistics, which looked at, among other things, ICT use by households and ... Read more »

Oil slumps on Omicron fears; posts biggest monthly fall in 20 months

Crude futures ended November with their biggest monthly declines since the outset of the pandemic. NEW YORK] (REUTERS) – Oil prices tumbled on Tuesday (Nov 30) after Moderna’s chief cast ... Read more »

Ex-Disney CEO Bob Iger interested in buying NBA team Phoenix Suns

Phoenix Suns players in a huddle. Former Disney chief executive Bob Iger expressed interest in buying the National Basketball Association’s (NBA) Phoenix Suns, if the NBA franchise becomes available. The ... Read more »

China's growing control of global minerals supply leaves the US in the dust

If oil was the buzzword of geopolitics in the previous century, the key to global influence in an era of climate change will lie elsewhere: minerals that power green technology. ... Read more »

Korea Communications Commission hints action against Netflix

Netflix does not pay telecom companies for network use, which has become an issue for the network operators as the traffic surge required network upgrades that incurred costs. South Korea's ... Read more »

Irish golf resort Trump loses millions due to corona

Photo: ANP The Irish golf resort owned by Donald Trump suffered an operating loss of €2 million last year as a result of the corona crisis. The Trump International Golf ... Read more »

The final settlement of the derivatives scandal: Vestia splits up and the name disappears

It must be the final settlement of one of the largest speculation scandals in the world: the fraud with derivatives (interest insurance) at housing corporation Vestia, with a total damage ... Read more »

Virus fear and Fed provide strong negatives on Wall Street

Stock markets in New York closed with heavy losses on Tuesday. Investors are still concerned about the impact of the new Omikron variant of the coronavirus, especially as current vaccines ... Read more »

Wall Street closes sharply lower after hawkish Fed signals

Traders work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on Nov 30, 2021. NEW YORK (AFP) – Comments from the Federal Reserve chief signalling the US central bank ... Read more »

House concerned about the consequences of higher inflation for purchasing power

Photo: ANP The House of Representatives is concerned about the consequences of the sharp rise in inflation for the purchasing power of households. The left-wing opposition, but also the PVV ... Read more »

RR Donnelley, Lithia Motors rise; Intuit, Moderna fall

NEW YORK — Stocks that traded heavily or had substantial price changes Tuesday: Intuit Inc., down $42.36 to $652.30. Entities affiliated with Mailchimp co-founder Dan Kurzius priced a secondary offering ... Read more »

The day the Lamborghini engine no longer roars

‘Welcome to Sant’Agata Bolognese, home town of Lamborghini’, reads the proud message on the place name sign of the small municipality near Bologna. Everything in the surrounding area, in the ... Read more »

An update for traffic thugs – NRC

Fifty is the new thirty, they say. And then of course ‘they’ are the people of fifty. In built-up areas it is the other way around: there thirty is the ... Read more »

Cryptocurrency Shiba inu pops 30 percent after listing on Kracken exchange

Not going begging: Shiba Inu overwhelmingly beat out other currencies in Tuesday trading. NurPhoto via Getty Images Shiba inu, the meme cryptocurrency inspired by Dogecoin, shot up by nearly 30 ... Read more »

Fintech director Marcus leaves Facebook

Photo: ANP Facebook sees its fintech director David Marcus leave at the end of the year. Marcus is responsible for the development of the digital currency Diem and digital wallet ... Read more »

EU parliament committee wants clarification on European Court of Auditors

Photo: ANP It is crucial for the credibility of the European Court of Auditors that there is no doubt whatsoever about the integrity of the auditing EU institution. An independent ... Read more »

Jewelery and branded bags: after a ‘disaster year' the luxury market is recovering

Bad news for fans of Chanel bags: they are suddenly a lot more expensive. In 2020 you paid 6,050 euros for one of their most popular models (the one with ... Read more »

South Korean legislators seeks delay of crypto tax

The Democratic Party pushed for the delay as cryptocurrency investments have become popular with young voters, arguing that Korean tax authorities need more time to establish a proper tax system ... Read more »

Prices keep rising, should we be concerned?

Inflation rose to 5.6 percent in November, the highest level since the European statistical office Eurostat was first measured 24 years ago. The price increases have been going on for ... Read more »

States: Sackler family members abusing bankruptcy process

The Associated PressFILE – In this Aug. 9, 2021, file photo, fake pill bottles with messages about OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma are displayed during a protest outside the courthouse where ... Read more »

Record inflation is mainly due to energy prices

You can call it impressive, spectacular or shocking. The Netherlands had an inflation rate of 5.6 percent in November compared to a year earlier, according to the so-called HICP index, ... Read more »

Omicron and inflation did not stop shoppers on Black Friday and Cyber Monday

Amid supply chain snarls and fears that gifts shipped to homes would arrive too late, more holiday shoppers made their purchases in stores than online this year. Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic