Prosecutors apologise after failing to consult victim’s family over murder plea deal

Prosecutors have apologised to the ‘devastated’ family of a FIFO worker for accepting a guilty plea to manslaughter, instead of murder, without consulting them.

A man accused of murdering his colleague at a mine site has instead pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter, angering the victim’s heartbroken family who were “blindsided” by the plea deal.

Troy Adam Hausler, 32, was charged with murdering fly-in, fly-out worker Tobias Richter, 40, at Pilbara Minerals’ Pilgangoora site in November 2019.

But on the first day of his trial in the West Australian Supreme Court on Monday, prosecutors revealed the state wanted to discontinue the murder charge because there were no reasonable prospects of conviction.

The court was told there was insufficient evidence to prove an intention to kill.

Hausler’s lawyer Rebekah Sleeth told the court her client had experienced his first psychotic episode at the time, but he was not the direct cause of Mr Richter’s death.

His mental condition will be a factor in sentencing, but Ms Sleeth said he would not have been able to use the defence of insanity.

Prosecutors apologise after failing to consult victim’s family over murder plea deal

Tobias Richter, 40, died at a WA mine site in 2019. Troy Adam Hausler has now pleaded guilty to manslaughter. Picture: Supplied/Facebook via NCA NewsWire

Outside court, Mr Richter’s sister Vanessa said the family had not been consulted about the plea deal.

“We were totally blindsided. We are devastated. My family is broken, absolutely broken,” she said.

Ms Richter described her brother as a good guy and a hard worker.

“He wasn’t a fighter, he wasn’t confrontational,” she said.

Toni Dodd, whose sister Hayley Dodd was killed in 1999, is Mr Richter’s ex-partner and the mother of two of his children.

“We’ve been through this before and not got the result we wanted,” she said.

Ms Dodd said she was hoping for a “good sentence” but was concerned that would not happen.

The family has started a campaign for justice, including an online petition that has more than 8000 signatures so far.

Prosecutors apologise after failing to consult victim’s family over murder plea deal

Tobias Richter’s family have been left devastated. Picture: Supplied/Facebook via NCA NewsWire

In a statement, the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions said Mr Richter’s family was consulted in October and their views were known.

“However, following a case review in early 2022, it became apparent that there were no reasonable prospects of conviction on the charge of murder and that the prosecution would only be able to prove manslaughter, even if it could overcome the defence of insanity,” the statement read.

The ODPP said it would have been “inappropriate” to proceed with the charge of murder.

“Due to a regrettable misunderstanding, however, the family was not further consulted prior to the acceptance of the plea offer in this case,” the statement read.

“While in this case the family’s views could not overcome the absence of sufficient evidence, they were entitled to be heard prior to the decision being made.

“The DPP appreciates that the frustration and anger which Mr Richter’s family feel as a result of the decision, its timing and the most regrettable oversight in the ODPP’s communication with the family.

“Upon the family’s request for a review of the decision, the DPP personally met with the family, during which she apologised to Mr Richter’s family and took responsibility for the lack of proper communication.”

Hausler will face court again next month.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

St. Bernard upsets Bishop Montgomery behind 34 points from Tyler Rolison

With four brothers and four sisters walking him onto the court for senior night, Tyler Rolison of St. Bernard told coach Tony Bland before its game Monday night against 24-1 ... Read more »

Best streaming devices 2023

Some major networks offer free limited content viewing via their apps even if you don’t have a TV provider. Typically, you’ll need to wait a day or week to view ... Read more »

Best vacuum cleaners 2023

If you purchase a Roomba, make sure to consider where it will charge, as it needs a charging station that has access to an outlet. (BestReviews) Vacuuming might not be ... Read more »

Trouble in paradise: the dark anxiety at the heart of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma!

Oklahoma! at The Young Vic in London – Marc Brenner “Wonderful is the nearest adjective,” swiftly decided The New York Times’s reviewer on seeing Oklahoma! for the first time on ... Read more »

Tesla ‘spontaneously’ bursts into flames on Sacramento County highway

A Tesla Model S “spontaneously caught fire” on a Sacramento County highway last weekend after its battery compartment overheated, authorities said. The car was traveling at “freeway speeds” on Highway ... Read more »

Swiss Bank UBS Gets a Boost From Higher Interest Rates, Beats Expectations in Fourth Quarter

UBS beat expectations by reporting $1.7 billion of net income for the fourth quarter of last year, bringing its total annual profit to $7.6 billion in 2022. Analysts expected UBS ... Read more »

Avatar's Jon Landau Teases A Journey To Earth In The Franchise's Future

20th Century There’s no questioning how above and beyond James Cameron and his team went to craft the world of “Avatar.” The realm of cinematic science fiction and fantasy has ... Read more »

Taiwan, Czech leaders affirm ties in defiance of Beijing

Taiwan, Czech leaders affirm ties in defiance of Beijing Taiwan says its president has affirmed ties with the Czech Republic in a phone call with the Central European nation's President-elect ... Read more »

China claims Covid wave is ‘coming to an end’ as tourism and factory activity rebound

Photograph: Mark R Cristino/EPA China’s wave of Covid is “coming to an end”, health officials have claimed, saying there had been no sign of a new surge from the lunar ... Read more »

Pakistani hospital spokesman says the death toll from previous day's suicide bombing at a Peshawar mosque has reached 83

Pakistani hospital spokesman says the death toll from previous day's suicide bombing at a Peshawar mosque has reached 83 Pakistani hospital spokesman says the death toll from previous day's suicide ... Read more »

Death toll from Pakistan mosque suicide bombing rises to 83

Death toll from Pakistan mosque suicide bombing rises to 83 Pakistani officials say the death toll from the previous day’s suicide bombing at a mosque in the northwestern city of ... Read more »

Brandon Figueroa enfrentará a Mark Magsayo en Ontario

En un duelo de excampeones mundiales, Brandon Figueroa se enfrentará a la sensación filipina Mark “Magnifico” Magsayo por el título vacante interino de peso pluma del Consejo Mundial de Boxeo ... Read more »

European Markets Head for Lower Open Ahead of Euro Zone GDP Data, Fed Meeting

This is CNBC’s live blog covering European markets. European markets are heading for a lower open Tuesday as attention turns to the U.S. Federal Reserve’s latest policy meeting kicking off ... Read more »

Showtime Starts Removing Short-Lived Series From Its Streaming Platform

Jeff Daniels as Del Harris in American Rust. Showtime The purge of some of Showtime’s less popular series from the network’s streaming service has gotten underway. According to sources, the ... Read more »

Trump says public education taken over by ‘pink-haired communists,’ plans to give power back to parents

Trump said he will cut federal funding for any school or program pushing critical race theory. Getty Images Former President Trump on Friday released a video blasting public education for ... Read more »

California Man Gets 90 Days in Jail After Chihuahua Bites His Finger

A 36-year-old man was sentenced to 90 days in jail for breaking the neck of a Chihuahua who bit his finger while he was dog-sitting in 2018. Read more »

Chinese factory activity rebounds, adding to recovery signs

Chinese factory activity rebounds, adding to recovery signs A survey shows Chinese factory activity rebounded in January, adding to signs the world’s second-largest economy might be recovering from a painful ... Read more »

Mexicans relish tamales, savoring tradition and nostalgia

Mexicans relish tamales, savoring tradition and nostalgia At least three times a week, Mexico City bus driver Nicolás Cuatencos stops by a stand selling tamales MEXICO CITY — At least ... Read more »

Missing 15-year-old girl Adriana Davidson found dead near Michigan high school

Adriana Davidson body found near her Michigan High School. Washtenaw County Sheriff’s Offic A 15-year-old Michigan girl who disappeared Friday was found dead near her high school Monday afternoon, local ... Read more »

Singapore ranked least corrupt Asian country but overall score slides to lowest since 2012

SINGAPORE – Anti-graft watchdog Transparency International has ranked Singapore as the least corrupt Asian country, with the Republic emerging fifth overall in the group’s corruption perception index (CPI). However, it ... Read more »

Woman killed lookalike to fake own death, say German prosecutors

A young woman in Germany is accused of seeking out a lookalike on social media and murdering her in order to fake her own death. The case began when the ... Read more »

Can you teach a computer common sense?

Dr. Yejin Choi University of Washington Professor and MacArthur Fellow, works to improve AI’s understanding of common sense. John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation hide caption toggle caption John ... Read more »

Highlights from the 2023 Sundance Film Festival

Priya Kansara stars in Polite Society, directed and written by Nida Manzoor. Parisa Taghizadeh/Courtesy of Sundance Institute hide caption toggle caption Parisa Taghizadeh/Courtesy of Sundance Institute Over 100 feature films ... Read more »

A meal prep influencer shares 6 of his favorite cooking hacks

boonchai wedmakawand/Getty Images When Kevin Curry was growing up, he never had to think about cooking meals for himself. His parents were in charge of dinner. And at school, lunch ... Read more »

US births increased in 2021 for 1st time in 7 years: CDC

US births increased in 2021 for 1st time in 7 years: CDC There were 3.66 million babies born in 2021, according to the report. The number of births in the ... Read more »

‘The Last Of Us’ Causes Linda Ronstadt’s ‘Long, Long Time’ To Surge In Streams On Spotify

Liane Hentscher/HBO The Last of Us aired a pivotal episode and caused Linda Ronstadt’s “Long, Long Time” hit song to surge in streams on Spotify. Nick Offerman (Bill) and Frank ... Read more »

Dispute over US$100 repair bill may have sparked Half Moon Bay gun massacre

The suspected gunman accused of killing seven people last week at two farms in California’s Half Moon Bay told investigators a dispute with his supervisor over a bill for machinery ... Read more »

Footage captures boulder nearly crush woman inside Honolulu home

Footage shows the woman walking down a hallway when the boulder breaks through a wall. KHON2 via maxrrrod/Twitter A massive boulder crashed into a Hawaii home over the weekend, narrowly ... Read more »

Death toll in Pakistan mosque blast rises to 83

PESHAWAR, Pakistan – The death toll in the suicide bombing in the northwestern Pakistani city of Peshawar rose to 83 while at least 57 people were injured, several of them ... Read more »

Morrissey, Scheifele each score twice in the third as Jets rally to beat Blues 4-2

For a healthy chunk of the Winnipeg Jets tilt with the St. Louis Blues Monday night, it looked like they were destined for a fourth straight loss to head into ... Read more »

Priscilla Presley disputes Lisa Marie Presley's trust

Lisa Marie Presley made a 2016 amendment to her living trust, removing Priscilla and a former business manager as trustees, replacing them with her children, Riley and Benjamin Keough Read more »

Family of amputee killed by police has a message for officers: ‘Anthony was loved’

Dorothy Lowe wept as she stood outside the Huntington Park Police Department on Monday, struggling at times to speak before a bank of television cameras. It had been four days ... Read more »

‘I Did Him So Bad': Did Alex Murdaugh Admit to Killing His Son?

The quote is debated. Murdaugh either said to police "I did him so bad" or "they did him so bad" in relation to his murdered son not long after his death Read more »

Lisa Marie Presley's trust papers challenged by mother Priscilla Presley

LOS ANGELES — Priscilla Presley is challenging a purported amendment to the trust of her daughter, late singer Lisa Marie Presley, that would give her grandchild control of rock ‘n’ ... Read more »

3 Injured After Speeding Vehicle Hits Sedan, Pedestrians in Chatham

At least three people were injured after a speeding vehicle blew through a red light and slammed into a sedan, which then struck multiple pedestrians on Chicago’s South Side Monday ... Read more »

Bridges scores 29, Suns pull away late, beat Raptors 114-106

PHOENIX (AP) — Mikal Bridges scored 29 points, Deandre Ayton added 22 points and 13 rebounds and the Phoenix Suns pulled away late to beat the Toronto Raptors 114-106 on ... Read more »

Germany made 'painful choices' in clearing village to make way for coal mine, climate envoy says

In an interview with Sky News, Germany's climate envoy Jennifer Morgan admitted Germany was "vulnerable" to the energy crisis, saying it had "learned the hard way" to reduce dependence on fossil fuels or on any one country. Read more »

Mesquite Nonprofit Provides Hotel Rooms for Those Experiencing Homelessness

NBCDFW.com The freezing temperatures change the pace of services for nonprofits across North Texas. Some of the North Texas Food Bank’s partner food pantries, like Sharing Life Community Outreach, have ... Read more »

Monterey Park shooter voiced paranoid threats to police years before opening fire, records show

Three decades before he shot 11 people to death in a Monterey Park ballroom, Huu Can Tran told police he believed relatives of a woman he’d been dating had threatened ... Read more »

Princess of Wales's bold Bafta fashion shows she is confident in her cause

Princess of Wales – Getty We’re used to seeing the Princess of Wales pull dazzlingly classic, princessy styles out of the bag, but last night she looked different. This is ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự