Prosecution ban will comply with international human rights laws, says Lewis

Asia's Tech News Daily

The Northern Ireland Secretary has insisted the Government’s proposed ban on Troubles prosecutions will comply with international human rights laws.

Answering MPs’ questions on the controversial plan, Brandon Lewis rejected claims the statute of limitations would put a “coach and horses” through the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

In July, the Government published a command paper outlining its intention to prohibit future prosecutions of military veterans and ex-paramilitaries for Troubles incidents predating April 1998.

Contending the criminal justice route was not delivering for victims, it said it wanted to move to a new truth recovery model to help bereaved families gain information about the deaths of their loved ones.

DUP MP Ian Paisley said the plan could put a ‘coach and horses’ through the European Convention on Human Rights (Liam McBurney/PA)

The Government has not yet tabled the draft legislation before Parliament.

On Wednesday, Mr Lewis told the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee that he hoped the Bill would be tabled this autumn and said it was “feasible” the legislation could be passed before summer recess next year.

Several members of the committee challenged Mr Lewis on the plan and argued that access to criminal justice was a key plank of the ECHR.

DUP MP Ian Paisley was among committee members who raised concerns during the two hour question and answer session.

“Do you not recognise that this is potentially putting a coach and horses through the European Convention which you’re signed up to?” he asked Mr Lewis.

Alliance MP Stephen Farry said many legal experts felt the Government’s plan would become “unstuck” in regard to compliance with Article Two of the ECHR.

“My understanding and the understanding I had from numerous legal experts in Northern Ireland, including prosecutors, is that for an investigation of any nature to be compliant with Article Two the very least it has to have is the theoretical possibility of a prosecution being taken,” he said.

“And if it doesn’t have the prospect of a prosecution being taken, then it cannot be an Article Two compliant investigation.”

Mr Lewis insisted the proposals would comply with the ECHR.

He said a ban on prosecutions did not mean the Government was “closing the book” on unsolved cases.

He said those cases would be rigorously investigated in line with ECHR requirements as part of the information retrieval process, albeit without the prospect of a resultant prosecution.

“We’ve got to ensure that what we do with the information recovery body and how it works is Article Two compliant, that’s an onus on us,” he said.

“Obviously we will be challenged around that, so it’s absolutely paramount for us to ensure that it is.”

Mr Lewis added: “I would hope that when we eventually come forward with final proposals once we’ve made final decisions around these things, that people will see that what we are looking to do is compliant, will be compliant, because it is taking forward investigations in a proper way.”

Claire Hanna raised concerns that the information recovery body would not be able to access classified state files (Liam McBurney/PA)

SDLP member Claire Hanna was also critical of the Government plan.

On the proposed information recovery model, she said it was important that any new independent body had powers to compel disclosure of documents and access classified security information.

“If this is really about truth recovery, and not about stopping the embarrassment of people who were engaged in a very, very dirty war, what possible reason would there be not to give those powers?” she asked.

Mr Lewis declined to confirm whether or not the Government would give the body those powers.

“I avoid hypotheticals – I’m not saying that we won’t, I’m not saying that we definitely will,” he replied.

On a number of occasions, Mr Lewis stressed that a statue of limitations was different from an amnesty, though he acknowledged that many had chosen to describe the plan as such.

Boris Johnson has claimed the Government plan will allow Northern Ireland to “draw a line under the Troubles”.

The proposals also envisage an end to all legacy inquests and civil actions related to the conflict.

The plan has been heavily criticised by all the main political parties in Northern Ireland, as well as the Irish Government and a range of victims and survivors groups.

Mr Lewis told the committee that there had been a lot of “noise” generated by the Government’s announcement in the summer.

He acknowledged that there was opposition to the statute of limitations, but he insisted there were others who were supportive.

The cabinet minister said one of the reasons the draft legislation had not yet been finalised was because the Government wanted to keep receiving feedback from victims and other interested parties on the plan.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

I'm A Celebrity fans spot secret ‘feud' in the castle after Adam Woodyatt makes sly dig at campmate

I'M A Celebrity fans are convinced that they've spotted a secret “feud” between Naughty Boy and Adam Woodyatt after the soap star made a sly dig at his campmate. The ... Read more »

South African economy expected to contract in third quarter, underlining dismal jobless data

When Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) releases the gross domestic product (GDP) reading for the third quarter (Q3) of this year on 7 December, it is widely expected to show ... Read more »

Finding peace on the water, meeting Sly Stallone, and enjoying the pressure of being Katie Taylor

Katie Taylor and Sylvester Stallone sharing a laugh in October. AFTER SHE DEFENDED her lightweight title for a fourth time with a shutout victory over Jennifer Han in Leeds, Katie ... Read more »

Hannah Betts's Better...not younger: What should be on your wish list this year...

Hannah Betts shares advice for purchasing a memorable beauty gift this Xmas UK-based columnist reveals a selection of party hair accessories Dior’s Lip Glow Colour Reviver Balm is this week's cosmetic craving  Read more »

Vile couple who killed Arthur Labinjo-Hughes are pictured relaxing in garden hot tub weeks before their boy's awful death

Posing in a hot tub without a care in the world – evil Emma Tustin and Thomas Hughes relax in the garden just weeks before killing Arthur. The couple bought the ... Read more »

BREAKING NEWS: Victoria reports 1073 new Covid cases and six deaths and NSW 208 infections as states pledge to keep borders open over Omicron

Victoria and NSW vow to keep borders open to reunite families for ChristmasPremiers will put on a united front and stick to plans to ease Covid restrictionsNSW to do away with masks, density limits and vax certificates on December 15  Read more »

Separate Clearwater shootings leave man and child injured

A man was shot Sunday afternoon in Clearwater. An hour later, about two miles away, a child was shot in an unrelated incident, Clearwater police said. The first shooting occurred ... Read more »

Joe Root declares himself ready for Ashes series that will 'define my captaincy'

England captain Joe Root has declared himself ready for an Ashes series that he admitted would “define my captaincy”. © PA Joe Root declares himself ready for Ashes series that ... Read more »

Pipeline in Canada's west reopens after storm-linked closure

© Jason Redmond The Trans Mountain pipeline has been closed since mid-November 2021, following record storms in Canada, prompting fuel shortages throughout British Columbia Canada’s Trans Mountain pipeline, closed since ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb camp at breaking point as Danny Miller and Matty Lee slam Naughty Boy as a ‘boring fake'

I'M A Celebrity's Danny Miller and Matty Lee made their displeasure at Naughty Boy clear in the clearest sign yet there is a fracture in camp. The Emmerdale star slammed ... Read more »

Dan Walker voted off Strictly Come Dancing

© Bang Showbiz Dan Walker misses out on Strictly semi-final Dan Walker has been voted off ‘Strictly Come Dancing’. The ‘BBC Breakfast’ presenter and his professional partner Nadiya Bychkova have ... Read more »

You Don't Know Me review: A clever courtroom drama with a canny star performance at its centre

Adewunmi stars as ‘Hero’ in ‘You Don’t Know Me’ (BBC/Snowed-In Productions) Showtrial has barely finished and already the Beeb is doling up another courtroom drama about an unreliable suspect. How ... Read more »

Australia news live update: diplomat says Omicron travel ban ‘discrimination'; Birmingham supports Berejiklian candidacy; NSW transport strike

LIVE – Updated at 22:12 Follow all the day’s news.   22:12 Ivanhoe MP @ACarbinesMP has this morning been sworn in by @VicGovernor as a minister in the Andrews Government, ... Read more »

ED records former top cop's statement in laundering case against Deshmukh

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: TheEnforcement Directorate (ED) recorded the statement of former Mumbai police commissioner Param Bir Singh on Friday, in a money laundering case it ... Read more »

Hovland wins Hero World Challenge thriller

Viktor Hovland fired back-to-back eagles on his way to snatching a dramatic victory after a remarkable final round at the Hero World Challenge. The Norwegian overturned a six-shot deficit on ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Delhi man held for duping Manimajra resident of r₹r8K

© Provided by Hindustan Times As per police, the Delhi man had contacted the Manimajra, Chandigarh, resident after she made a profile on a job listings site. (HT Photo/ Representational ... Read more »

Trenton Cannon taken off field in ambulance after scary 49ers collision

Former Jets running back Trenton Cannon was taken off the field in an ambulance Sunday afternoon after taking a scary hit during the 49ers-Seahawks game in Seattle. Cannon, now with ... Read more »

Winter session: In 1st week, Rajya Sabha lost over 50% of sitting time

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: The Rajya Sabha lost more than half of its scheduled sitting time in the first week of the winter session of ... Read more »

Vulnerable Prince William reveals the future of royalty: As the Duke wins praise for discussing mental health on podcast, Princess Diana's aide PATRICK JEPHSON hails a PR coup

As part of the quietest revolution in royal public relations, Prince William’s Time To Walk podcast avoids the usual marketing hype. It’s just a man walking alone chatting with an imaginary ... Read more »

Chandigarh Ward 29: These footpaths no cakewalk for pedestrians

© Provided by Hindustan Times Garbage strewn all over, open manholes and broken footpaths greet residents of Ward number 29 in Chandigarh. (Sanjeev Sharma/HT) In Ward number 29, parks are ... Read more »

Santa's grotto branded worst in country after Father Christmas turns up in Land Rover with no beard

FURIOUS parents have slammed a town’s shambolic Christmas grotto amid a building site — with a grumpy beardless Santa sat in a stairwell. Hundreds of excited families had flocked to ... Read more »

Param Bir Singh not whistleblower, says Maharashtra government affidavit in apex court

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: The Maharashtra government has filed a counter-affidavit before the Supreme Court seeking dismissal of the special leave petition (SLP) submitted by former ... Read more »

Sun launches Christmas campaign to bring smile to faces of the nation's sick children – and we need your help

TODAY, The Sun launches its annual Christmas appeal – and we are asking YOU, our army of generous readers, to help out. Our Joy To The Ward campaign aims to ... Read more »

Lady Gaga's hairstylist says he cried after she asked him to dye her hair brown for 'House of Gucci'

© David Crotty/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images Frederic Aspiras and Lady Gaga attend The Daily Front Row Fifth Annual Fashion Los Angeles Awards in 2019. David Crotty/Patrick McMullan via Getty ... Read more »

Spreading Christmas cheer around ahead of 2022 polls

© The Manila Times IT’S CHRISTMAS Santa Rosa town Mayor Josefino Angeles; his wife, Marita Angeles; their daughter, Councilor Apple Angeles; Councilor Irene Bernardo; vice mayoral candidate Ethel Angeles; Association ... Read more »

Israeli ready to advance trade ties with Manila

© The Manila Times NEW Israeli Ambassador to the Philippines Ilan Fluss New Israeli Ambassador to the Philippines Ilan Fluss is looking forward to Israel advancing its partnership and friendship ... Read more »

Zemmour lässt sich feiern – und wird geschlagen

Der rechtsradikale Publizist hat zum Start seines Präsidentschaftswahlkampfs in Frankreich Anhänger und Gegner zu Tausenden mobilisiert. Es kam zu Handgreiflichkeiten. © Foto: Keystone Sprach vor 15’000 Anhängern: Eric Zemmour bei ... Read more »

Krimi in Dschidda: Hamilton gewinnt gehässiges Rennen und vertagt WM-Entscheidung

© keystone Max Verstappen (links) und Lewis Hamilton lieferten sich ein höchst grenzwertiges Duell in Saudi-Arabien. Lewis Hamilton gewinnt den ersten Grand Prix von Saudi-Arabien. Der Titelverteidiger im Mercedes verweist ... Read more »

Democratic Socialists' drive to boot Bowman for visiting Israel reveals their intolerance — and bigotry

Democratic Socialists of America want Rep. Jamaal Bowman booted because he visited Israel. AP Photo/Mark Lennihan, File Democratic Socialists of America members are furious with Rep. Jamaal Bowman and want ... Read more »

Tiger Woods hints at possible comeback with son Charlie at PNC Championship later this month

© Getty Images tigerwoods.jpg Tiger Woods could make his golf comeback later this month alongside his son Charlie at the PNC Championship. The tournament, open to major winners and a ... Read more »

Jack Dempsey brings an edge to Glasgow Warriors which will be crucial in bid to upset La Rochelle

Danny Wilson will put his trust in Jack Dempsey’s animal instincts as Glasgow Warriors go big-game hunting in Europe this month. © Glasgow Warriors No 8 Jack Dempsey celebrates his ... Read more »

Mike Glennon suffers concussion as Giants' quarterback situation gets bleaker

Mike Glennon suffered a concussion Sunday against the Dolphins and the woeful Giants offense could be about to start a recent fourth-string quarterback. Already without Daniel Jones because of a ... Read more »

Over 70 serving Met officers have faced sex offence and domestic violence claims

MORE than 70 serving Met officers have faced sex offence and domestic violence claims, The Sun can reveal. Their cases are now being reviewed to ensure they were dealt with ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity shock as Strictly's Arlene Phillips is evicted in first brutal public vote

I'M A Celeb said goodbye to its first star tonight – as Arlene Phillips was given the boot from the TV castle. Ant McPartlin and Dec Donnelly revealed the former ... Read more »

I'm a self-made millionaire at 25 – here are my top tips for saving money, including a ‘secret' Amazon refund hack

A MONEY-SAVING fanatic has revealed her top tips for getting refunds, including how to ensure you get compensated when it is due from Amazon. 25-year-old Addison Jarman, from the US, ... Read more »

RUTH SUNDERLAND: I am not starry-eyed about mutuals nor am I blind to the many shortcomings, but I hope the LV vote is a wake-up call

Mutual building societies, insurance companies and co-ops were a potent force They were an effective form of Levelling Up, to use today's parlanceThey enabled ordinary people to begin the slow ascent from grinding poverty Read more »

Ministers standing by to intervene in any attempted takeover of BT with tycoon Patrick Drahi reportedly plotting to double his 12.1% stake in the group

A lockup period stopping Drahi from buying more shares is coming to an end It comes after India's richest man denied reports he was planning a bidBT's shares stayed elevated as investors still expect bidders on the horizon BT is a 'huge asset' and key to Government's of roll out of gigabit broadband Read more »

Astonishing story behind the new Queen of the High Street: You've probably never heard of Marta Ortega Perez, but her clothes are almost certainly in your wardrobe. As she takes the helm of Zara, we reveal the succession saga that's worthy of its own TV series

High Street brand Zara has become the largest clothes retailer in the worldDuchess of Cambridge is among celebrities spotted wearing designs from ZaraMarta Ortega Perez, 37, will replace Pablo Isla as chairman in April She started out on the shop floor 14 years ago at the King’s Road branch  Read more »

Now you can RENT the perfect Christmas: Thanks to eco awareness, you can now hire everything from party frocks to table settings... even your children's presents. It's better for the planet — but how do you tell your four-year-old to give it all back?

The average person is likely to spend £1,275 on festive purchasesDinah Van Tulleken reveals how to put on an extravaganza for less than £1,000 Fashion editor hired tree lights, toys to entertain children and tableware   Read more »

Life sciences group that has developed treatment to kill Covid with laser light will become latest firm to list in London when it goes public

A life sciences group that has developed a treatment to kill Covid with laser light will become the latest firm to list in London when it goes public today.  Ondine ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic