Progressives are wrong, the ‘forever war' is not over

© Provided by Al Jazeera People carry the national flag at a protest held during the Afghan Independence Day in Kabul, Afghanistan August 19, 2021. [Stringer/Reuters]

Days after the last US troops left Afghanistan, Afghans who fear for their lives continue sending SOS messages to anyone they think might be able to help evacuate them. The Afghan state has collapsed, the healthcare system is in tatters, prices have soared leaving many hungry, as even the people with means do not have access to their cash.

Reports continue to come of Taliban fighters assaulting and arresting Afghan journalists across the country, making it clear that free speech will no longer be tolerated. In its first decree, the Taliban interior ministry issued a ban on protests without prior approval. There is no describing the fear and the uncertainty that engulfs Afghanistan.

It is hard to imagine that this chaos is what a group of progressive Democrats have lobbied for. Alexandrea Ocasio-Cortes, Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are just some of the Democrats who pushed for a withdrawal without considering the consequences.

These are figures who many young Afghans and Afghan Americans would naturally see as their allies. They promote progressive, justice-orientated policies that are anti-racist, and they seem unafraid to speak truth to power. But their rhetoric on Afghans and Afghanistan has left us doubting their agenda.

The most vocal supporter of President Joe Biden’s policy on Afghanistan is House Representative Ilhan Omar, a woman I share much in common with. We are both former refugees from countries that have disproportionately borne the consequences of the “war on terror” and we both advocate for refugee rights.

Her election to Congress was an important moment for all who have defied odds while carrying uncompromising values to get to a position of power. And yet it seems that even these experiences have not inoculated Omar and the rest of the progressive Democrats against the short-sightedness that plagues American public discourse and policy.

Omar’s tweet just as the last US troops left Afghanistan – “Ending wars is good actually” – left me and many Afghans speechless. Aside from the fact that it ignored Afghans mourning the killing of several children by a US war drone attack, just as the final US planes took off, it also betrayed a willingness to disregard the lives of Afghan people.

The war has not ended, neither has the US interests in Afghanistan or the involvement of its neighbours or regional powers like Russia and China. Instead, the abrupt and disastrous US departure signals what many of us who are concerned with ending violence and upholding human rights have been afraid of – privatisation and automation of war. The forever war will continue but it will be less visible and even less accountable to the American public. Biden has already indicated that drone warfare will continue.

The progressive wing of the Democratic Party had an opportunity to engage honestly with the fallout of the biggest failure of American foreign policy in the last 20 years based on their “values” of human rights and justice. The “war on terror” changed the world for the worst, displacing more than 37 million people, leaving hundreds of thousands dead and exacerbating the already fraught dynamics of the Greater Middle East.

In the US, counterterrorism legislation has created massive infringement on civil rights and has been used as a blueprint for many authoritarian regimes around the world to subjugate their minority Muslim communities.

The right way to end the war would have been to take responsibility for the enormous footprint that the US has had in Afghanistan for more than four decades. This would have involved supporting the Afghan state and its institutions, human rights defenders and Afghan women who have done so much to promote justice. It would have meant the pursuit of peace-making through diplomacy and long-term support for the Afghan people.

Instead, the Biden administration backed by the progressive Democrats wanted to wish a new reality into existence – a reality that does not reflect the developments of the past 20 years and the role the US played in shaping the country.

Let me be clear: the Afghan position was never to have American troops stay in Afghanistan forever. What we had asked for was a genuine path to peace that would have included security guarantees and support for the democratic state and would not have handed over the country to a hardline group renowned for its egregious abuses of human rights – a group that has never governed or represented the interests of common Afghans.

What we asked for was long-term diplomacy and support for Afghans who had worked so hard in the past 20 years to establish institutions of democracy, human rights and education.

The value-based approach to power, which progressive Democrats profess, should respect and acknowledge the rights and dignity of all people. It should take note of the power dynamics that have shaped and continue to shape the world today. It should recognise that dismantling the military-industrial complex is a slow, fraught process that has to be conscious of the people it affects the most – people with very little choice in starting wars or ending them.

Instead, progressive Democrats completely ignored the pleas of women, young people and defenders of human rights in Afghanistan, choosing to ally themselves instead with the like of the Koch brothers, towing the simplistic and ill-informed line: end the forever wars.

You cannot snap your fingers and reify a world in which the US has not meddled in other peoples’ fates. Progressive Democrats would have done well to listen to the speeches of Martin Luther King Jr who implored those standing for justice in the US to stand with the people of the world. His stark warning that “mankind must put an end to war or war will put an end to mankind” seems more relevant today than ever. The progressives did not stand for justice or ended a war.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Reman anggota tentera bunuh lelaki disambung

© Provided by Sinar Harian TAIPING – Anggota tentera yang menjadi suspek utama kes bunuh seorang lelaki apabila mayatnya ditemui di kawasan semak di Bukit Sumpitan dekat Selama pada minggu ... Read more »

Bekalan air di Sepang, Kuala Langat pulih

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Bekalan air di 145 kawasan di wilayah Sepang dan 11 kawasan di wilayah Kuala Langat kembali pulih pada Rabu selepas insiden paip ... Read more »

Majoriti pemimpin Umno Melaka tolak langkah solo Zahid

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Presiden Umno Ahmad Zahid Hamidi berdepan kesukaran meyakinkan pemimpin parti itu di Melaka untuk bergerak bersendirian dalam pilihan raya negeri (PRN) yang akan diadakan bulan depan, ... Read more »

Kemba Walker knows what playing at Garden means: ‘dream come true'

So often, they feel compelled to say what they say, as if they understand that there’s a required reverence for walking through the doors at Madison Square Garden, a necessary ... Read more »

JUST IN: Filipino American Wesley So wins back-to-back US Chess Championship

© Provided by Good News Pilipinas Wesley So fights to keep his title in the final round of the US Chess Championship. Photo courtesy of Saint Louis Chess Club, Lennart ... Read more »

DOT advises public to be responsible tourists amid easing of COVID-19 restrictions

© Danny Pata Visitors check out the man-made dolomite beach at the Baywalk of Manila Bay on Saturday, October 16, 2021 under the watchful eyes of police to ensure minimum ... Read more »

Deaths among the double vaccinated: what is behind the Australian statistics?

Photograph: Richard Wainwright/AAP On Tuesday, there were 356 Covid-19 patients being treated in intensive care wards throughout Australia. Of those, 25 were fully vaccinated. While the data points to the ... Read more »

Poland will pay price for defying EU law: EU chief

Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal ruled last week that parts of EU law are incompatible with the Polish constitution, undermining the legal pillar on which the union stands and raising fears that ... Read more »

Scott Disick's ex Amelia Hamlin shows appreciation for Kourtney & Travis' engagement with THIS gesture

© Provided by Pinkvilla Amelia Hamlin was all about love and appreciation when it came to Kourtney Kardashian and Travis Barker’s engagement. The model reportedly showed her support for Kourtney ... Read more »

I made Ina Garten's easy cinnamon-sugar doughnuts, and I didn't need a fryer or any special ingredients

© Paige Bennett; Noam Galai/WireImage I made Ina Garten’s easy cinnamon-sugar doughnuts, and I didn’t need a fryer or any special ingredients I made Ina Garten’s easy no-fry cinnamon doughnuts ... Read more »

Meet the king of Halloween, who spends six weeks creating his macabre displays

There’s a good reason Ammon Smith’s neighbors are shy about decorating their homes for Halloween: a sparse jack-o’-lantern is spotted here, a modest faux spiderweb dangling from a tree there. ... Read more »

Industry and experts call for mandated national approach to green buildings and homes

© Provided by ABC Business A national energy efficiency ratings scheme is being expanded to cover existing homes, but it will be voluntary. (Unsplash: ulleo: Public Domain) Jason York says ... Read more »

The seven steps Australia needs to take to boost its economy

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Australia can’t assume its 28 years of uninterrupted economic expansion will continue forever and must act now to security its, experts warn. Deloitte warns ... Read more »

Christian Aid Ministries faced close calls and threats before Haiti abduction

The danger was visible all around them, long before a group of Christian Aid Ministries missionaries and children were abducted from the road in Haiti. © CNN In one 2019 ... Read more »

Stars' Pavelski, Radulov edge Penguins 2-1 in shootout

PITTSBURGH (AP) — The Dallas Stars are built to win tight games, and they’re certainly wasting little time getting comfortable with them. © Provided by The Canadian Press Joe Pavelski ... Read more »

Haiti kidnapping: '400 Mawozo' gang wants $17 million ransom for American and Canadian missionaries

The gang that kidnapped a group of 17 American and Canadian missionaries in Haiti has asked for $1 million each for their release, a top Haitian official told CNN Tuesday. ... Read more »

Man Alleges NYPD Officers Shoved Him Out of Subway After He Asked Them To Wear Masks

A New York City man alleges he was shoved off of a subway platform by a pair of New York Police Department (NYPD) officers Tuesday after he asked them to ... Read more »

Rudy Giuliani Accuses Terry McAuliffe of 'Pay For Play Scheme' in Abe Lincoln Filter Video

Ex-Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani, in a video altered to make him appear as former President Abraham Lincoln, has accused Democratic Virginia gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe of orchestrating a “pay for ... Read more »

PH risiko rosakkan imej jika calon 4 bekas ADUN dalam PRN

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Tindakan itu tidak memberi sebarang manfaat kepada PH sebaliknya hanya memakan diri selepas ini, menurut penganalisis politik. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING JAYA: Pakatan Harapan (PH) ... Read more »

Apple AirPods 3 mirip versi Pro tetapi masih tiada satu fungsi penting

Apple Airpods adalah fon telinga TWS paling banyak dijual di dunia. Apple kini telah melancarkan generasi ketiga AirPods, dengan rupa serba baharu yang lebih mirip dengan AirPods Pro, tanpa bud ... Read more »

Animal shelter hounded by woes and has nowhere to go

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today The road, which is the only access to the shelter, has been blocked by contractors laying sewer pipes. (Badirol Hisham pic) ALOR SETAR: There ... Read more »

San Francisco's only In-N-Out location was temporarily closed for refusing to check patrons for proof of vaccination

© Photo by Alex Tai/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images American regional chain of fast food restaurants In-N-Out Burger sign seen at the San Francisco site. Photo by Alex Tai/SOPA Images/LightRocket ... Read more »

Health District pilot project launched in ageing Queenstown

SINGAPORE — Residents of Queenstown – Singapore’s oldest satellite town – can look forward to more fitness stations and green spaces, better connectivity to parks and green corridors, as well ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's Alleged Breach Of Lockdown At Christmas Leaves People Infuriated

Boris and Carrie Johnson are thought to have invited a friend round last Christmas (Photo: Ian Forsyth via Getty Images) Boris Johnson has been accused of breaching lockdown rules last ... Read more »

Call of Duty: Mobile season 9 roadmap revealed

© Provided by Dot Esports Halloween has arrived into Call of Duty: Mobile with season nine, called Nightmare. While the content update for the ninth season has already dropped in-game, ... Read more »

Fox's Neil Cavuto tests positive for COVID-19

Fox News anchor Neil Cavuto announced that he tested positive for COVID-19 on Tuesday. In a statement released by Fox News Media, Cavuto — who has previously opened up about ... Read more »

Beijing rolls out Covid-19 booster shots ahead of Olympics

Beijing is starting to offer residents booster jabs for Covid-19, local media said Wednesday, as the Chinese capital gears up to host a tightly controlled Winter Olympics in February. © ... Read more »

Sounders training notebook: Rocky Road

© Miki Turner The Sounders finished up training Tuesday before taking a charter to Colorado to face the Rapids. Nico Lodeiro (R) also made his return to Starfire. TUKWILA, Wash. ... Read more »

Micron to build $7 billion plant in Japan's Hiroshima - report

TOKYO (Reuters) – U.S. chip supplier Micron Technology Inc is set to invest 800 billion yen ($6.99 billion) in building a new factory in Hiroshima, western Japan, the Nikkan Kogyo ... Read more »

Raymond scores 1st NHL goal, Red Wings top Blue Jackets 4-1

DETROIT (AP) — Lucas Raymond made his first NHL goal a big one for the Detroit Red Wings, breaking a scoreless tie at 6:38 of the third period on the ... Read more »

China's new home prices stall for first time since COVID-19

BEIJING (Reuters) -China’s new home prices stalled for the first time since February 2020 in September, official data showed on Wednesday, as the chill in the property market intensified amid ... Read more »

New Splinter Cell Game Allegedly In The Works At Ubisoft

© Provided by Geek Culture When you are a fan of a franchise or property, you always want to reminisce about the good old days and look forward to the ... Read more »

18 kelab tolak penajaan berkaitan pemilik

© Provided by Sinar Harian SEBANYAK 18 kelab Liga Perdana Inggeris (EPL) memutuskan mengenakan larangan sementara terhadap kelab daripada menandatangani perjanjian komersial dan penajaan yang mempunyai hubungan dengan pemilik kelab ... Read more »

Anggota polis maut dilanggar bas

© Provided by Sinar Harian BENTONG – Seorang anggota polis maut apabila motosikal ditunggangnya dipercayai terbabas dan terjatuh di laluan bertentangan, sebelum dia dilanggar sebuah bas di Kilometer 16, Jalan ... Read more »

Baling, Sik tumpuan pengeluar lateks utama negara

© Provided by Sinar Harian Keluasan penanaman getah di Baling dan Sik sebanyak 21,470 hektar merupakan kawasan antara terbesar di Semenanjung Malaysia berpotensi menjadi pengeluar utama lateks negara. Baling mempunyai ... Read more »

Brazil's Bolsonaro should face COVID charges: Senate inquiry

© Provided by Al Jazeera More than 600,000 people in Brazil have died from COVID-19, the second highest toll in the world after the United States [File: Ueslei Marcelino/Reuters] The ... Read more »

Weather Updates: 'Worst Over' for U'khand, 3-day Rain Alert in Kerala; IMD Says Rainfall Will Now Shift Towards UP, Bihar, Bengal

© Provided by News18 Weather Updates: ‘Worst Over’ for U’khand, 3-day Rain Alert in Kerala; IMD Says Rainfall Will Now Shift Towards UP, Bihar, Bengal Kerala, Uttarakhand Rain Updates: The ... Read more »

Under the radar but in-form South Africa exude quiet optimism

© AFP/Getty Images South Africa enter the T20 World Cup on the back of three successive series wins © AFP/Getty Images Big picture This is the first time South Africa ... Read more »

Happy Birthday, Virender Sehwag: Here are some Hilarious Tweets by 'Nawab of Najafgarh'

© Provided by News18 Happy Birthday, Virender Sehwag: Here are some Hilarious Tweets by ‘Nawab of Najafgarh’ Turning 43 on October 20, Virender Sehwag has left his mark both on ... Read more »

Bangladesh Durga Puja attacks: Death toll in communal violence rises to 5

© Provided by DNA The death toll in Bangladesh communal violence rose to five on Tuesday after another person succumbed to his injuries after clashes between police and attackers at ... Read more »