Priti Patel's new powers to push back Channel crossing boats breach human rights

Priti Patel’s controversial plans to turn back small boats in the Channel “endanger lives” and are likely to breach human rights laws, a prominent committee has warned.

So-called pushbacks are “not the solution” to curbing the number of desperate people trying to reach Britain and would “do the opposite of what is required to save lives”, the Joint Committee on Human Rights warned.

It described the proposed Nationality and Borders Bill as “littered” with measures which are “simply incompatible” with the UK’s international obligations.

Committee chairman Harriet Harman said: “The Government is determined to prevent these crossings, but pushbacks are not the solution.

“They will not deter crossings, the seas will become even more dangerous and the people smugglers will continue to evade punishment.

Priti Patel's new powers to push back Channel crossing boats breach human rights
© PA Home Secretary Priti Patel has been under pressure over the number of people trying to claim asylum in the UK by making the Channel crossing

“Current failures in the immigration and asylum system cannot be remedied by harsher penalties and more dangerous enforcement action.

“The Bill is littered with measures that are simply incompatible with human rights law and the UK’s obligations under international treaties.

“That is why we have called on the Government to amend the Bill by clearly setting out how any new measures can be carried out with respect to human rights law. Any measures that cannot meet these standards should be removed from the Bill completely.”

The legality and effectiveness of the tactic has been repeatedly called into question ever since it was first proposed, with campaigners threatening legal action against the Home Secretary.

But Priti Patel has insisted the plan has a “legal basis”, although the Home Office’s permanent secretary Matthew Rycroft previously conceded that only a “small proportion” of boats could be turned back.

The committee’s report said: “A policy of pushbacks would likely be incompatible with the UK’s obligations under international human rights law and maritime law.”

It added: “Pushbacks are known to endanger lives at sea. This is even more so when dealing with people on small, unseaworthy vessels, in a busy shipping lane, often with rough waters, without appropriate life-saving equipment, as is the case for migrants in small boats in the Channel.

Priti Patel's new powers to push back Channel crossing boats breach human rights
© Dan Kitwood Labour’s Harriet Harman warned the policy was potential a breach of human rights laws

“A policy of pushbacks fails to comply with the obligations to save those in distress, contrary to the right to life and international maritime law. Moreover, pushbacks would do the opposite of what is required to save lives.

“Pushbacks would create a situation where state actors were actively placing individuals in situations that would increase the risk to life. Under the current conditions, we cannot see how a policy of pushbacks can be implemented without risking lives, contrary to the UK’s obligations under the right to life and international maritime law.”

Plans to “criminalise” those arrive in the UK without a visa or through other approved immigration routes are “inconsistent” with the United Nations Refugee Convention, which “explicitly prohibits refugees being penalised for unauthorised entry”, the committee said, adding: “Given the limited options refugees have for entering the UK via legal routes the Government should reconsider these measures.”

The group of MPs and peers also called for reassurance that border officials will not be granted immunity from prosecution where criminal offences are committed leading to loss of life at sea.

A Home Office spokesman said: “As part of our ongoing operational response and to prevent further loss of life at sea, we continue to evaluate and test a range of safe and legal options to find ways of stopping small boats making this dangerous and unnecessary journey.

“These all comply and are delivered in accordance with both domestic and international law.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Hunarbaaz: Judges get teary as contestant pays tribute to trans mom; Karan Johar says 'I saw true humanity'

© Provided by Pinkvilla Hunarbaaz Desh Ki Shaan has featured many remarkable stories of contestants that would leave you speechless The show, which just kicked off last week is off ... Read more »

Appeals court upholds California's net neutrality law

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge California can enforce its net neutrality law A federal appeals court on Friday ruled that California’s net neutrality law can remain in ... Read more »

Girl Scouts' first Asian American CEO credits her diverse girlhood

Unlike many of her predominantly white peers, Sofia Chang, the new CEO of the Girl Scouts, had an unique upbringing, spending much of her childhood working at her parents’ Chinese ... Read more »

U.S. House to take up bill next week on China competition, chips industry

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. House of Representatives will take up next week a massive bill aimed at increasing competitiveness with China and supporting the U.S. chip industry, including $52 ... Read more »

Ontario Progressive Conservatives pick their 2022 candidate for Hamilton-Centre riding

Ontario’s Progressive Conservatives have picked their candidate to run in the riding of Hamilton-Centre for the provincial election in June. © Press Release Sarah Bokhari is running for the Ontario ... Read more »

IS conspiracy case: NIA files charges against ex-Cong MLA's kin, others

© Provided by The Indian Express THE NIA has filed a chargesheet against a family member of former Congress MLA from Karnataka, late B M Idinabba, among others, in connection ... Read more »

I started a fake Rent-a-Hitman website as a joke & helped bust dozens trying to order horrific assassinations

AN IT whizz who created a spoof assassin-hiring website as part of a school project has helped to thwart dozens of would-be murder-for-hire plots, potentially saving the lives of more ... Read more »

Everybody will be streaming the heartwarming hit ‘Cha Cha Real Smooth'

Cooper Raiff and Dakota Johnson star in “Cha Cha Real Smooth.” Courtesy of the Sundance Institute Cooper Raiff is the fresh comedic talent we’ve been waiting for. A new one ... Read more »

Nearly 411,000 Kias recalled for airbag issue

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on Tuesday announced Kia is recalling nearly 411,000 vehicles for a potentially gnarly defect. A damaged airbag circuit board could prevent the safety restraints from ... Read more »

The ACLU's hypocrisy over school transparency is a danger to free speech

Over the years, the ACLU has demanded curriculum transparency for religious studies and sex education, while demanding the opposite for critical race theory. Getty Images In at least a dozen ... Read more »

Judge sides with Treasury in tribes' coronavirus relief case

FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. — A federal judge has sided with the Treasury Department in a case that challenged the distribution of coronavirus relief aid to Native American governments. Tribal governments had ... Read more »

Where to find a Shiny Stone in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur Like the Dawn and Sun Stones, the Shiny Stone is in Pokémon Legends: Arceus will only evolve a couple of Pokémon, but it is practically a ... Read more »

Why isn't Sjokz hosting the LEC in week 3?

Eefje “Sjokz” Depoortere has announced that she won’t be hosting the LEC in week 3 of the spring split. Sjokz is likely the single most recognizable and well-known host in ... Read more »

Olivier Giroud FIFA 22 Moments SBC Apparently Leaked

A cult favorite player for many football fans over the years has been the big Frenchman, Olivier Giroud. The striker has played for many clubs throughout his career, and in ... Read more »

How to evolve Eevee into Espeon in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur Eevee is a Pokémon with eight unique evolutions, and you can acquire all of them in Pokémon Legends: Arceus. For those who want to go after ... Read more »

Where to find Johtonian Sneasel in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by Dot Esports Multiple Pokémon received new forms and evolutions in Pokémon Legends: Arceus, but that doesn’t mean Game Freak skipped out on bringing at least a few ... Read more »

How to use/throw balms in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur Trainers venturing into Pokémon Legends: Arceus will have to get familiar with several new features and items that have been introduced. One of the items that ... Read more »

Netflix Cheer Season 2 Star Lexi Reveals Why She Abruptly Exited The Show

© Provided by CinemaBlend Lexi Brumback in Cheer. Netflix’s popular docuseries Cheer first came onto the stage in 2020 and highlighted one of the most competitive cheer programs in the ... Read more »

Stu Cowan: Uncertainty turns to excitement for Canadiens' Rem Pitlick

© Provided by The Gazette Montreal Canadiens’ Rem Pitlick during first-period action against the Anaheim Ducks in Montreal on Jan. 27, 2022. Imagine getting a call from your boss telling ... Read more »

O'Neill's Stoke strike late to secure point at Huddersfield in battle of play-off hopefuls

SUBSTITUTE JACOB BROWN struck a late equaliser to secure Stoke a 1-1 draw at fellow play-off hopefuls Huddersfield. Josh Koroma had earlier ended a 19-game run without a Championship goal ... Read more »

Gareth Bale will get slice of £2.3m in taxpayer cash to build golf course

TYCOON footballer Gareth Bale is getting taxpayer cash to build an indoor golf course. The Wales and Real Madrid star will receive a slice of £2.35million towards the project. When ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Registering and Licensing Authority to render all services from January 31

© Provided by The Indian Express The Registering and Licensing Authority (RLA) will be functioning with all services from January 31, though with prior appointments. The RLA office had limited ... Read more »

MVA says will discuss with legal experts on next course of action

© Provided by The Indian Express THE MAHARASHTRA Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government on Friday hinted that the Supreme Court’s decision to quash the suspension of 12 BJP MLAs was a ... Read more »

Gov. Kathy Hochul extends NY's mask-or-vax mandate through Feb. 10

New York’s indoor “mask-or-vax” mandate for businesses and schools will be extended an extra two weeks through Feb. 10 despite a legal challenge and “positive” COVID-19 case trends, Gov. Kathy ... Read more »

Teams of CPCC and SDM conduct raid at Sector 26 mandi, seize 350 kg plastic

© Provided by The Indian Express In an attempt to curb single-use plastic pollution in Chandigarh, teams of the Chandigarh Pollution Control Committee (CPCC) and of SDM (east) conducted a ... Read more »

It's The Year of the Tiger: What Does This Mean for Your Chinese Zodiac in 2022?

© Amy Schupruk A graphic of a tiger for Lunar New Year 2022 Ready to roar your way into a new lunar year? Good news: it just might be your ... Read more »

Bungling cops take out seven innocent drivers with stinger while trying to catch ‘suspect vehicle'

BUNGLING cops took out seven innocent motorists with a stinger. Officers laid the device — designed to puncture tyres — on a busy A-road to stop a “suspect vehicle”. Officers ... Read more »

Manchester City to make decision over teenage midfielder

Read more »

Governor enlists pet bulldog to tell Bette Midler to ‘kiss her hiney'

© ASSOCIATED PRESS West Virginia governor Jim Justice tells actor Bette Midler and other detractors to the state to kiss his dog’s “hiney” – ASSOCIATED PRESS West Virginia Governor Jim ... Read more »

Do sharks crave human blood?

Do sharks crave human blood? A man in Magsingal, Ilocos Sur, had his arm severed after he was allegedly bitten by a shark. On “24 Oras” Friday, Ruben Unabia said ... Read more »

Jordan Peterson got his climate info on controversial Joe Rogan podcast from an Exxon-funded climate denier

© The Joe Rogan Experience/Spotify Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson – The Joe Rogan Experience/Spotify Jordan Peterson, a Canadian academic and philosopher popular among the alt-right, has come in for ... Read more »

McFarland proud after Ulster's young guns come out on top of 'arm-wrestle'

ULSTER HEAD COACH Dan McFarland praised his inexperienced team for coming out on the right side of an “arm-wrestle” as they battled past Scarlets for a 27-15 bonus-point win on ... Read more »

Death in Paradise fans left heartbroken over character exit

Death in Paradise spoilers follow. Death in Paradise finally said goodbye to much-loved character DS Florence Cassell (Joséphine Jobert) in tonight’s episode (January 28). Last week, Florence made the tough ... Read more »

Flying Squad detectives tie up innocent chauffeur in probe

Bungling Flying Squad detectives raided an innocent chauffeur’s home and held him down on a chair because they mistakenly thought he was selling jewellery stolen in a £25million raid on ... Read more »

Farmers alarmed as NY looks at expanded overtime for workers

SCHUYLERVILLE, N.Y. (AP) — The thousands of people paid to plant corn, pick apples and milk cows in New York often work long days, six days a week — and ... Read more »

Mail began to pile up at an elderly woman's home. The local mail carrier then became a hero

A New Hampshire postal worker is now a local hero after she helped save a woman’s life. © Courtesy Kayla Berridge Kayla Berridge has been a mail carrier for four ... Read more »

12 kematian baharu Covid-19

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Jumlah kumulatif kematian Covid-19 kini mencecah angka 31,952. PETALING JAYA: Kementerian Kesihatan (KKM) melaporkan 12 kes kematian Covid-19 semalam, menurut perincian dikeluarkan GitHub. Daripada ... Read more »

Rakhi Sawant takes a dig at Abhijit Bichukale over his comments on Salman Khan; Says ‘He's taken Samadhi'

© Provided by Pinkvilla After his elimination from Bigg Boss 15, former contestant Abhijit Bichukale opened up over his dislike towards the reality show’s host Salman Khan. In an interview, ... Read more »

Aamir Khan-Kiran Rao to Dhanush-Aishwaryaa, 8 couples who parted their ways in recent past

‘Lived Happily Ever After’ sounds all good, however, it only exists in the fictional world. Just like life, beauty, even relationships tend to fall apart. Sometimes they’re unfortunate, but other ... Read more »

Montana curbs wolf hunt after 23 from Yellowstone killed

BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — Montana wildlife commissioners on Friday moved to shut down gray wolf hunting in a portion of the state around Yellowstone National Park, amid mounting criticism over ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic