Ponniyin Selvan 1: Mani Ratnam is no SS Rajamouli or Shankar, but he’s fearless

Ponniyin Selvan: 1 was a dream of Mani Ratnam, which he nurtured for about 40 years. And finally, when he put his visual interpretation of the epic novel on the big screen one can’t help but wonder, what occurred in his mind when he saw the finished film for the first time. Did he enjoy the show or was he slapping his head in silence over little niggles that we would perhaps not even notice. What is going on in the mind of this ingenious and one of the most sincere filmmakers of Indian cinema now that his magnum opus belongs to the audience? PS: 1 marks the culmination of a collective dream of so many great minds of Tamil cinema. And Mani Ratnam has been very respectful of that opportunity by presenting this film in the most dignified manner possible.

Mani Ratnam is not in the league of Shankar or SS Rajamouli. When it comes to making his films ‘commercial’, he can only go till a certain point. It’s like there is an invisible line that he won’t cross while pandering to the masses. He’s among the handful of Indian filmmakers who enjoys the distinction of having cracked the formula of striking a balance between arts and commerce in mainstream movies. But, as Mani Ratnam gets older, he started tilting more toward arts than commerce (maybe it started with Iruvar) and upset the balance. It may have even cost him big openings but that didn’t stop him from making the kind of films he did. In that sense, PS: 1 was a huge gamble. How would a filmmaker like him adjust his methods to appeal to a wider range of audiences to recoup the investments?

Make no mistake, PS: 1 has plenty of moments that would have been exploited to their full potential for delivering spectacle to the masses if it were any other filmmaker. But, not him. He ensured that his big screen adaptation won’t dishonor Kalki Krishnamurthy’s sprawling drama.

ponniyin selvan 1: mani ratnam is no ss rajamouli or shankar, but he’s fearless
Mani Ratnam on the sets of PS:1.

Mani Ratnam has not written this film as a typical tentpole movie made in India. It sort of feels like watching a Denis Villeneuve film. It’s massive on budget, scale and star power. But, it doesn’t come with a sense of rush that we would generally experience, say, in a comic book movie. There is a strong sense of calm in the way the narrative builds up. We know there is a storm is brewing but this filmmaker isn’t willing to jump to the fun parts without first asking the audience to understand where these characters are coming from. He’s not covering a character’s transformation arc in a scene or a lengthy monologue. He’s letting us in on the micro changes in characters for us to see there is more to them than meets the eyes.

For example, Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s Nandini has the reputation of being as poisonous as a snake. Mani Ratnam could have taken the easy way out feeding off Nandini’s presumed maliciousness, making it easier for us to pick a side. You know most of us invariably end up identifying with the “good guys.” Instead, he does a sleight of hand, and in a few montage shots, show us a part of Nandini’s tragic backstory.

Nandini is plotting to overthrow the Chola empire, and her deception works on multiple levels. By conventional thinking, she is the villain of the story. But to be fair, Nandini is more sinned against than sinning among those who are plotting the end of Sundara Chola’s clan. She was chased away at a very young age from Thanjavur for falling in love with the heir to the throne, Aditha Karikalan (Vikram). And later in her life, her presumed lover Veerapandiya Kattabomman is slaughtered without mercy in front of her eyes despite her repeated prayers to spare him. The Cholas give her enough reason to seek revenge against them.

Also Read |Tracing the journey of Ponniyin Selvan – one big dream of MGR, Kamal Haasan and Mani Ratnam

And there is Trisha’s Kundavai. She seems like a wise, kind-hearted, person with great political acumen, but she is deeply prejudiced. “We didn’t know Nandini’s lineage. I could have never allowed her to become the queen,” Kundavai reasons with Aditha, who is aware of her role in denying him the life he desired with Nandini.

ponniyin selvan 1: mani ratnam is no ss rajamouli or shankar, but he’s fearless
Trisha, and Aishwarya Rai Bachchan in PS: 1. (Photo: PR Handout)

There is also this beautifully shot life-altering moment. After defeating the Pandya army, Aditha chases Veerapandiya, who runs into the forest seeking safety. Aditha tracks his rival down to a hut in the middle of the forest. When he kicks open the door, the image that he sees rewires every fibre in his body and turns him into a killing machine. Aditha sees Nandini intimately nursing a heavily wounded Kattabomman (we don’t know the full story yet. At least for those who haven’t read the five books). Aditha was determined to kill Kattabomman as dictated by his warrior code. But, when he delivers a final death blow to Kattabomman, he was not a warrior. He was simply a miffed lover who couldn’t stand the sight of another man in the arms of the woman he loves. His killing of Kattabomman was not an act of valour or duty, it was personal and dishonourable. Perhaps, he knows that deep down in his heart and that’s why he runs away from all the comforts of a king toward pain, suffering and death.

Mani Ratnam’s treatment of PS:1 is path-breaking in the history of modern Indian tentpole movies. He is changing the grammar and redefining the meaning of a big-budget spectacle. They don’t always need to be overly saturated with actions, which is mindless at times, to keep the audience hooked. Things don’t need to be blown up every 10 minutes to retain the attention of the audience. Mani Ratnam wants to be poetic and re-introduce us to the pleasures of delayed gratification.

Only a director who has nerves of steel can make a movie like this without knotting and crumpling the narrative to play to the gallery. Mani Ratnam is not guided by fear but by his love for making a sincere movie. He is fearless.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

ECU vs SEN FIFA World Cup prediction: Can Enner Valencia & Co. seal Round of 16 berth vs AFCON champions?

ecu vs sen fifa world cup prediction: can enner valencia’s ecuador defeat senegal to confirm spot place in knockout stage? Ecuador will play against Senegal on Tuesday in the Group ... Read more »

Most airports and nearby areas unlikely to get 5G connectivity and services anytime soon. Here's why.

Fearing that 5G bands that are being used by telecom companies might interfere with the navigation instruments on board most common aeroplanes, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation and the ... Read more »

Portuguese FA to submit proof to FIFA claiming Cristiano Ronaldo scored goal despite snickometer intervention

Portuguese FA to submit proof to FIFA claiming Cristiano Ronaldo scored goal despite snickometer intervention Portugal’s football association will reportedly submit data to FIFA in an attempt to prove that ... Read more »

Toyota Motor VC Vikram S Kirloskar dies due to heart attack

Toyota Motor VC Vikram S Kirloskar dies due to heart attack New Delhi/Bengaluru: Toyota Kirloskar Motor Vice Chairman Vikram S Kirloskar has died due to a heart attack, the automaker ... Read more »

Thane: 4th lane on new Kalwa Bridge opened for traffic from November 30

Thane: 4th lane on new Kalwa Bridge opened for traffic from today Thane: The Thane Municipal Corporation ( TMC) commissioner, Abhijit Bangar, announced on Tuesday, November 29, that the lane on the Thane ... Read more »

Bengaluru, home to 1.5 million IT workers and called 'the world's back-office,' has dodged the tech winter ripping through Silicon Valley — but experts warn it may not last

Bengaluru, home to 1.5 million IT workers and called ‘the world’s back-office,’ has dodged the tech winter ripping through Silicon Valley — but experts warn it may not last Indian ... Read more »

Pisces to Aquarius: 5 Zodiac signs who are the meanest co-workers

hides a nasty side beneath their superficially charming exterior. Some zodiac signs take great satisfaction in their capacity to support coworkers and function as a team. Others, however, believe that ... Read more »

Leo Horoscope Today, November 30, 2022: Personality will get strength!

Leo Horoscope Today, November 30, 2022: Personality will get strength! What will your day look like in terms of health, romance, finance and fortune? Read everything here. Monetary gains: You ... Read more »

'Rahul Baba once advised people against...': Amit Shah's BIG attack on Congress in Gujarat

‘Rahul Baba once advised people against…’: Amit Shah’s BIG attack on Congress in Gujarat Thasra: Amid hectic campaigning for the crucial Gujarat Assembly Election 2022, Union Home Minister Amit Shah ... Read more »

Mumbai: Khar woman loses Rs 2.90L in 41 fraudulent credit card transactions

Representative Image Mumbai: A 57-year-old education consultant lost Rs2.90 lakh in 41 transactions after her credit card details were allegedly cloned. The complainant was attending a yoga camp in Mangalore ... Read more »

Samantha Ruth Prabhu Headed To South Korea For Advance Myositis Treatment? Here's What We Know

Samantha Ruth Prabhu is allegedly leaving for South Korea to seek advanced treatment for Myositis, a new report has claimed. The actress opened up about her Myositis diagnosis in October, ... Read more »

Bank holidays in December 2022: Banks to remain closed on 14 days; here's full list

bank holidays in december 2022: banks to remain closed on 14 days; here’s full list New Delhi: In the upcoming month i.e. in December, banks across the country will observe ... Read more »

Vikram S Kirloskar, Vice Chairperson of Toyota Kirloskar Motor, passes away at 64

Vikram S Kirloskar, Vice Chairperson of Toyota Kirloskar Motor, passes away at 64 Vikram S. Kirloskar, Vice Chairman of Toyota Kirloskar Motor passed away on Tuesday at the age of ... Read more »

Lavani Artist Meena Deshmukh Dies in Car Accident Near Pandharpur

The Marathi entertainment industry plunged into grief following the demise of veteran Lavani artist Meena Deshmukh. This unfortunate incident took place when Meena’s Fortuner fell into a 50 feet deep ... Read more »

'Had world-class vision; tall statesman': Netizens pay last respects to Toyota Kirloskar Motor's Vikram Kirloskar

‘Had world-class vision; tall statesman’: Netizens pay last respects to Toyota Kirloskar Motor’s Vikram Kirloskar Soon after the news of Toyota Kirloskar Motor vice chairperson Vikram Kirloskar’s passing made headlines, ... Read more »

'When MS Dhoni was speaking, it literally felt like it was Gaikwad': Ruturaj's teammate reveals stunning similarity

Ruturaj Gaikwad has captured the imagination of one and all following his incredible knock of 220 for Maharashtra against Uttar Pradesh in the semifinal of the Vijay Hazare Trophy on ... Read more »

Nadav Lapid reveals why he called The Kashmir Files ‘vulgar', says ‘someone needs to speak up'

Nadav Lapid reveals why he called The Kashmir Files ‘vulgar’, says ‘someone needs to speak up’ Israeli filmmaker Nadav Lapid, who was a part of the jury at the 2022 ... Read more »

Caught on cam: Lady crushed to death by speeding truck in Tamil Nadu's Thiruvaiyaru; 6 injured

caught on cam: lady crushed to death by speeding truck in tamil nadu’s thiruvaiyaru; 6 injured Thiruvaiyaru: In yet another tragic incident, one woman was crushed to death after a ... Read more »

'In my opinion, the most impressive batter...': Ajit Agarkar's massive remark on India star amid New Zealand ODIs

After India’s second meeting with New Zealand was abandoned due to persistent rain in Hamilton, the Shikhar Dhawan-led side is hoping to restore parity in the ongoing third and final ... Read more »

NDTV founders Prannoy Roy, Radhika Roy resign from RRPRH board

ndtv founders prannoy roy, radhika roy resign from rrprh board New Delhi: Prannoy Roy and his wife Radhika Roy, founders and promoters of news broadcaster New Delhi Television (NDTV), have ... Read more »

WhatsApp to roll out ‘Message Yourself’ feature for Android and iOS users; check how you can access it

In addition to traditional instant messaging, WhatsApp also provides a variety of features including e-commerce and online payments. A further highly anticipated element has been added. For users in India, ... Read more »

US Capitol Hill Riots: Members of Right-wing Militia Oath Keepers Found Guilty of Sedition

US Capitol Hill Riots: Members of Right-wing Militia Oath Keepers Found Guilty of Sedition Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes, charged with seditious conspiracy following a two-month trial and has been ... Read more »

IAS officer shares video of elephants enjoying breakfast in Tamil Nadu's Mudumalai Tiger Reserve. Watch

IAS officer shares video of elephants enjoying breakfast in Tamil Nadu’s Mudumalai Tiger Reserve. Watch IAS officer Supriya Sahu shared a video from Tamil Nadu’s Mudumalai Tiger Reserve where several ... Read more »

Mahindra XUV 400 electric SUV special edition unveiled, gets exclusive features

Mahindra XUV 400 electric SUV special edition unveiled, gets exclusive features Mahindra XUV 400 electric SUV is slated to launch in India in 2023 and ahead of the launch, the ... Read more »

IFFI jury distances itself from Nadav Lapid’s criticism of The Kashmir Files; Sudipto Sen says ‘completely his personal opinion’

IFFI jury distances itself from Nadav Lapid’s criticism of The Kashmir Files; Sudipto Sen says ‘completely his personal opinion’ The jury board of the 53rd International Film Festival of India has ... Read more »

Kerala HC dismisses govt plea questioning KTU acting V-C’s appointment by guv

In a setback to the Kerala government, the state high court on Tuesday dismissed its petition questioning the appointment of acting vice-chancellor Ciza Thomas in APJ Abdul Kalam Technical University ... Read more »

Hindi Language Row: 'Sahyog' Signboard Removed at Tamil Nadu Railway Station

Hindi Language Row: ‘Sahyog’ Signboard Removed at Tamil Nadu Railway Station A signboard displaying the Hindi word “Sahyog,” was brought down at the Tiruppur railway station in Tamil Nadu after commuters ... Read more »

WATCH: Marcus Rashford's spectacular free kick goal in England's stunning 3-0 win over Wales in FIFA World Cup

watch: marcus rashford’s spectacular free kick goal in england’s stunning 3-0 win over wales in fifa world cup In a FIFA World Cup Group B match on Tuesday (Wednesday IST), ... Read more »

Arianna Huffington slams Elon Musk and Sam Bankman-Fried as 'burnout deniers' whose intense approach is actually harming their companies

Arianna Huffington slams Elon Musk and Sam Bankman-Fried as ‘burnout deniers’ whose intense approach is actually harming their companies Arianna Huffington rebuked Elon Musk and Sam Bankman-Fried as “burnout deniers.” ... Read more »

Petrol Diesel Price: Know latest petrol, diesel prices in your city

Petrol Diesel Price: Know latest petrol, diesel prices in your city Petrol Diesel Price Today: Indian oil marketing companies have released the latest prices of petrol and diesel today amidst ... Read more »

India Defence Exports Cross Rs 7,000 Crore Till Nov, Pending Major Deals to Take Figures Higher

India Defence Exports Cross Rs 7,000 Crore Till Nov, Pending Major Deals to Take Figures Higher India has achieved defence exports over Rs 7,000 crore till November 1 so far, ... Read more »

Vikram Kirloskar, Toyota Kirloskar vice-chairman, dies of cardiac arrest at 64

Vikram Kirloskar, Toyota Kirloskar vice-chairman, dies of cardiac arrest at 64 Vikram Kirloskar, an eminent industrialist and the vice-chairman of Toyota Kirloskar Motors, died after suffering a cardiac arrest late ... Read more »

BJP attacks Congress after Medha Patkar participates in Rahul Gandhi-led Bharat Jodo Yatra

BJP attacks Congress after Medha Patkar participates in Rahul Gandhi-led Bharat Jodo Yatra Ahmedabad: The BJP has targeted the Congress after Medha Patkar participated in the Rahul Gandhi-led ‘Bharat Jodo ... Read more »

'Bhai ke paas kaunsa video hai': RR shut down user who questioned Riyan Parag's retention by Sanju Samson and Co.

‘bhai ke paas kaunsa video hai’: rr shut down user who questioned riyan parag’s retention by sanju samson and co. The ongoing Vijay Hazare Trophy has thrown up some outrageous ... Read more »

"Your daughter is also virgin...": Finfluencer PR Sundar faces MASSIVE backlash for using foul language on social media

“Your daughter is also virgin…”: Finfluencer PR Sundar faces MASSIVE backlash for using foul language on social media New Delhi: Finfluencer PR Sundar is facing massive backlash in the social ... Read more »

Daler Mehndi's 1.5 Acre Farmhouse Sealed in Gurugram, Authorities Say Constructed Illegally

Authorities sealed three illegally constructed farmhouses, including one belonging to Punjabi singer Daler Mehndi, located near Damdama lake at Sohna, Gurugram on Tuesday, a senior official of the department of ... Read more »

Is Qatar propagating Islam to FIFA World Cup visitors? - Reports

is qatar propagating islam to fifa world cup visitors? – a report Doha: Qatar is reportedly introducing Islam to FIFA World Cup visitors by placing multiple electronic boards about the ... Read more »

Telangana cops tow away SUV with AP CM's sister inside, arrest her

Telangana cops tow away SUV with AP CM’s sister inside, arrest her HYDERABAD: The Hyderabad police on Tuesday towed away YSR Telangana Party leader and Andhra Pradesh CM YS Jagan ... Read more »

Tunisia vs France FIFA World Cup 2022 LIVE Streaming: How to watch TUN vs FRA and football World Cup matches for free online and TV in India?

Defending champion France has not won all three of their World Cup group matches since claiming their first title in 1998. Tunisia hasn’t even won three matches in their World ... Read more »

FIFA World Cup 2022: Christian Pulisic fires USA past Iran into Round of 16 before being sent to hospital, WATCH

FIFA World Cup 2022: Christian Pulisic fires USA past Iran into Round of 16 before being sent to hospital, WATCH Christian Pulisic kicked the ball, scored the goal and then ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network