Polygenic screening of embryos is here, but is it ethical?

Asia's Tech News Daily

The birth of the first IVF baby, Louise Brown, in 1978 provoked a media frenzy. In comparison, a little girl named Aurea born by IVF in May 2020 went almost unnoticed. Yet she represents a significant first in assisted reproduction too, for the embryo from which she grew was selected from others based on polygenic screening before implantation, to optimise her health prospects.

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Science Photo Library/Alamy

For both scientific and ethical reasons, this new type of genetic screening is highly controversial. The nonprofit California-based organisation the Center for Genetics and Society (CGS) has called its use here “a considerable reach by the assisted-reproduction industry in the direction of techno-eugenics”.

The polygenic screening for Aurea was provided by a New Jersey-based company called Genomic Prediction. The gene-sequencing company Orchid Biosciences in California now also offers an embryo-screening package that assesses risks for common diseases such as heart disease, diabetes and schizophrenia.

Genetic screening of IVF embryos for health reasons, known as preimplantation genetic diagnosis or PGD, is not new in itself. In the UK, it is permitted by the Human Fertilisation & Embryology Authority (HFEA), which regulates assisted conception technologies, to look for specific gene variants associated with around 500 diseases, including cystic fibrosis and Tay-Sachs disease.

The diseases conventionally screened with PGD are mostly caused by a mutation in only a single gene. They can be nasty but are typically rare. In contrast, most common health problems, such as heart diseases or type 2 diabetes, are polygenic: caused by complex interactions among several, often many, genes. Even if particular gene variants are known to increase risk, as for example with the BRCA1/2 variants associated with breast cancer, such links are probabilistic: there’s no guarantee that people with that variant will get the disease or that those who lack it will not.

© Photograph: Science Photo Library/Alamy A light micrograph showing embryo selection for in vitro fertilisation.

That’s simply how most genes work: in complex, interconnected and often poorly understood ways, so that the gene variants an individual carries don’t guarantee which traits they will develop. And environmental factors such as upbringing and diet, as well as unpredictable quirks of embryo development, also have a role. We’re products of (genetic) nature, nurture, chance and an interplay between all three.

Yet the availability today of genetic data for many thousands of individuals, thanks to the plummeting costs of genome sequencing and the popularity of genomic profiling companies such as 23AndMe and Orchid, has transformed our understanding of how genes relate to traits. The technique known as a genome-wide association study (GWAS) can sift through vast databanks to look for statistical associations between an individual’s gene variants and pretty much any trait we choose. Such studies have found that often substantial amounts of the differences between individuals can be linked to different variants (alleles) of many genes. Each gene might contribute only a tiny effect – too small to be apparent without plenty of data – but added together, the influence of the genes can be significant.

So someone’s genetic profile – the variants in their personal genome – can be used to make predictions about, say, how likely they are to develop heart disease in later life. They can be assigned a so-called polygenic risk score (PRS) for that condition. Aurea’s embryo was chosen because of low PRSs for heart disease, diabetes and cancer. PRSs can be used to predict other things too, such as a child’s IQ and educational attainment.

But such predictions are probabilistic, both because we can’t say exactly how our genes will “play out” in influencing that trait and because genes aren’t the only influence anyway. So there’s nothing inevitable or deterministic about a PRS. An individual with a high PRS for skin cancer might never develop it, while someone who scores low might do so. Someone with a genetic profile that predicts a modest IQ might turn out to be brilliant.

This is one reason why using PRSs in embryo screening – which is legal and largely unregulated in the US – is controversial. Unlike single-gene diseases, where the health outcome can be almost certain, it’s not clear how much faith we can put in predictions for polygenic traits. Yet we make choices based on probabilities all the time. We can’t be sure that a particular school will be best for our child’s education, but we may decide it will improve the chances of a good outcome. If one embryo has low PRSs for common diseases and another has high ones, doesn’t it make sense to pick the first? Aurea’s father, North Carolina neurologist Rafal Smigrodzki, has argued that part of a parent’s duty “is to make sure to prevent disease” in their child. Polygenic testing, he says, is just another way of doing that.

Embryo screening is already used for BRCA1 and 2, even though it is by no means certain that women who carry them will develop breast cancer. Advocates of PRS screening say that it merely improves the risk assessment by widening the genetic factors considered. “Most families with a history of breast cancer do not carry the BRCA allele and would benefit from polygenic screening,” says Genomic Prediction’s founder, Stephen Hsu, a professor of physics at Michigan State University. “The potential public health benefits are huge.” Ethics philosophers Sarah Munday and Julian Savulescu have argued in favour of allowing polygenic screening for any trait that can be shown to be “correlated with a greater chance of a life with more well-being”.

What’s to stop a company offering to screen for a non-disease trait such as height or intelligence?

“There’s a scientific basis to the concept [of PRSs] and it’s a type of genetic assessment that has a future in medicine,” says bioethicist Vardit Ravitsky of the University of Montreal. Yet most regulators and many experts feel that there is not yet any justification for using them to try to improve the health outcomes of IVF children. “It’s not seen as ready for primetime use,” says Ravitsky. “It’s still at a research stage. So when you start jumping straight into implementation, especially in a reproductive context, you’re in a minefield.” An article in the New England Journal of Medicine in July pointed out that benefits of PRS embryo selection are likely to be very small, all the more so for people not of European heritage, for whom genomic data are less extensive and so less reliable for prediction.

“If PRS gives you the power to reduce your offspring’s lifetime risk of type 2 diabetes from 30% to 27%, is that worth the time, money, and emotional investment?” asks bioethicist Hank Greely of Stanford University in California. “And to whom?” That’s very different, he says, from the confidence with which single-gene diseases can be screened and avoided.

And once such screening methods are permitted, where does it stop? Already, American couples can screen embryos for gender, complexion and eye colour. What’s to stop a company offering to screen for a non-disease trait such as height or intelligence? “There’s no reason to think polygenic embryo screening will end with conditions like heart disease and diabetes,” says Katie Hasson, associate director of the CGS. “Screening for schizophrenia and other mental illnesses is already on offer. These directly echo eugenic efforts to eliminate ‘feeble-mindedness’. We are talking about deciding who should be born based on ‘good’ and ‘bad’ genes.”

Genomic Prediction has previously offered to screen for gene variants associated with “intellectual disability”, but Hsu stresses that now the company only offers the service for serious disease risks. “We decided that traits like height and cognitive ability are too controversial and detract from our ability to help families reduce disease risk,” he says.

It’s not clear that screening for such non-disease traits would work anyway. “I think the things that parents are most interested in, like intelligence, sports and musical ability, will have extremely small to nonexistent convincing PRS results,” says Greely. A study in 2019 suggested that using polygenic screening to select embryos for height and IQ would be likely to make only a tiny difference on average – and there’s a fair chance you wouldn’t end up picking the “best” embryo.

So what should be permitted? Hsu says: “We hope that in the future, society as a whole, perhaps on a nation-by-nation basis, will reach a consensus on which non-disease traits are acceptable for embryo screening.” Some have objected to his implication that, say, welfare dependence or criminality are “in the genes”. Hsu has also attracted controversy because of his comments on whether there are genetically based differences in IQ between racial groups, although he says he is “agnostic” on the issue. An outcry about his remarks on such matters compelled him to resign in 2020 as his university’s senior vice-president of research and innovation.

Hsu was also one of the scientists suggested by Dominic Cummings to run the UK’s new Advanced Research and Invention Agency. In 2014, Cummings blogged about how the NHS should cover the cost of selecting embryos for IQ; in 2019, he was pictured outside 10 Downing Street with Hsu.

To avoid any Gattaca-style genetic stratification of society, Hsu has expressed the hope that “progressive governments will make this procedure free for everyone”. But Hasson believes that this wouldn’t solve the problems of inequality that such techniques could exacerbate. Even if PRSs for smartness, say, have little real predictive value, she says that “belief in genomic predictions can itself be a driver of intense inequalities in society” by reinforcing ideas of genetic determinism. “Families that invest their money, time and hopes in this kind of screening and selection will have children they believe are genetically superior and those children will be treated as superior by their parents, care-givers and educators.”

Social pressure could make it hard to resist polygenic screening in our hyper-competitive societies

Social pressure could make it hard to resist polygenic screening if it’s on offer in our hyper-competitive societies. “Once you do IVF, you feel pressure to use any add-on service or test that the clinic offers you,” says Ravitsky. “Look at what happens today when a woman declines prenatal screening or amniocentesis. Many women feel judged, not just by peers but by healthcare providers.” The idea that it’s all about autonomy of choice can be an illusion, she says.

Even if PRSs have little real value in forecasting the prospects of a child, evidently a market exists for them. In countries such as the US where assisted conception is weakly regulated, companies can make unrealistic and exploitative promises. Couples might even elect to have a child via IVF specifically to avail themselves of such opportunities. It’s a gruelling process that carries risks in itself, but women might feel compelled to use it, even though Ravitsky thinks that allowing someone to do so for this reason alone would be “borderline malpractice”.

Yet the genie is out of the bottle. “I believe that polygenic screening will become very common in the near future,” Hsu says. “Reasonable people will wonder why the technology was ever controversial at all, just as in the case of IVF.” The HFEA is still considering its implications, says its chief executive, Peter Thompson, who stresses that it is currently illegal in the UK. Even if there were more scientific consensus about the value of PRSs, he adds, “there is an important distinction between embryo selection to avoid serious harm and for so-called ‘enhancement’, like greater intelligence. The latter would represent a fundamental public policy shift.” It raises a range of ethical concerns and could only be contemplated if it has the backing of society more generally, he says.

“We urgently need public and policy conversations about polygenic embryo screening,” says Hasson. Finding the right balance between autonomy and social responsibility is the fundamental dilemma of liberal democracies. “We let people spend their money, and make decisions powerfully affecting their kids, on far more clearly bogus information than PRS,” says Greely.

“As a society, we’re very far from knowing how we want to use these potential technologies,” says Ravitsky, but, she adds, “we are already living in the grey zone”.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


All arrivals to the UK required to take pre-departure Covid tests, Government announces

International travellers required to take pre-departure Covid tests (PA Wire) International travellers to the UK will be required to take pre-departure Covid-19 tests, the Government has announced. The new measure, ... Read more »

Boris Johnson gets Tory candidate's name wrong during by-election visit

(PA) Boris Johnson gave his party a campaign boost with a visit to a byelection constituency – but then got the Tory candidate’s name wrong. On a whistle-stop visit to ... Read more »

Cambo oilfield: Does Shell withdrawal spell end for the controversial project?

Shell has scrapped its plans to develop the Cambo North Sea oilfield, throwing the future of the controversial project firmly opposed by climate activists into doubt. The oil giant said ... Read more »

'Huge explosion' heard near Iran's Natanz nuclear facility

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A ‘huge explosion’ heard near a nuclear facility in Iran is reported to have been part of a military exercise.  There had been reports ... Read more »

St John's Wood fire: 60 firefighters tackle blaze at flat on Abbey Road

Eight fire engines and around 60 firefighters have been called to a flat fire on Abbey Road in St John’s Wood. © PA Archive Firefighter stock Part of a four-roomed ... Read more »

Video: Divock Origi bags last-gasp winner to send Liverpool TOP of the Premier League and break Wolves hearts after Bruno Lage's side frustrated Jurgen Klopp's title contenders at Molineux

Read more »

Covid news: pre-departure tests return for all UK arrivals to tackle Omicron, Sajid Javid confirms

© Photograph: Filip Singer/EPA Germany is increasing Covid restrictions amid rise cases of the Omicron variant. LIVE – Updated at 18:14 Follow all the day’s coronavirus news from around the ... Read more »

Pope Francis hits out at EU migration divisions on visit to Greece

© Yorgos Karahalis/Pool via Reuters Pope Francis on Saturday blamed the EU‘s nationalist divisions for a lack of coordination on migration as he began a landmark trip to Greece, aiming ... Read more »

Nobel winner: ‘We journalists are the defence line between dictatorship and war'

The last time a journalist won a Nobel prize was 1935. The journalist who won it – Carl von Ossietzky – had revealed how Hitler was secretly rearming Germany. “And ... Read more »

Public sexual harassment to be made a crime

Pestering women in the street with lewd comments could become a crime under plans to outlaw “public sexual harassment” to be announced next week. © Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. ... Read more »

How to maximise your ability to go 'out out' and not feel awful the next day

© Provided by Metro Eat some salmon two hours before heading out (Picture: Getty) Let’s face it, sometimes we go out and drink on nights we shouldn’t. © Provided by ... Read more »

Oxford school shooting: ‘Distressed' fugitive parents of Ethan Crumbley were found ‘hiding in warehouse'

The fugitive parents of Michigan high school shooting suspect Ethan Crumbley were found hiding out in a warehouse and may have been trying to flee to Canada to escape charges ... Read more »

Hibs boss Jack Ross knows league form must pick up as team stuck in 'difficult run'

Jack Ross admits Hibs are in the midst of “difficult run” and need to change their fortunes around swiftly if they are to mount a challenge for a top-four place. ... Read more »

Report: Conte gifted chance to sign ‘world-class' £165k-p/w beast for Spurs, he wants to move

As per Foot Mercato, Tottenham Hotspur, and by extension Antonio Conte, have been offered the chance to sign Paris-Saint Germain striker Mauro Icardi. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Mauro Icardi ... Read more »

Ollie Robinson hoping to emulate Andrew Flintoff as he looks to make Ashes mark on Australia return

© Getty Images Ollie Robinson.jpg Ollie Robinson’s first summer of Test cricket – and his experience in Australia – makes a compelling case for an Ashes debut in Brisbane on Wednesday. ... Read more »

Soccer-Marseille's second place under threat as Brest claim sixth win in a row

(Reuters) – Olympique de Marseille’s second place in Ligue 1 came under threat on Saturday when they slumped to a 2-1 home defeat against in-form Stade Brestois. Marseille wasted their ... Read more »

Northampton brush Bath aside in bonus-point win - and set sights on tougher tests ahead

Northampton made short, clinical work of an out of sorts Bath with a six-try beating but Chris Boyd remains realistic about the European battles that now lay ahead for his ... Read more »

A plumber found envolopes of cash and checks behind a loose toilet in Joel Osteen's Houston mega-church

A plumber doing repair work at pastor Joel Osteen’s Lakewood Church found hundreds of envelopes of cash and checks hidden in a wall that police think is connected to a ... Read more »

Hamilton auf Pole, Verstappen crasht - GP Saudi-Arabien 2021 - Ergebnis Qualifikation

© Motorsport Images Lewis Hamilton – Mercedes – Formel 1 – GP Saudi-Arabien – Jeddah – Freitag – 3.12.2021 Es war eine ereignisreiche Pause zwischen drittem Training und der Qualifikation. ... Read more »

Biden, Putin set Tuesday video conference as Ukraine invasion fears loom

President Joe Biden will meet with Russian President Vladimir Putin in a video conference on Dec. 7, 2021. AP Photo/Evan Vucci President Joe Biden will sit down for a video ... Read more »

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes: Lessons must be learned after six-year-old's murder, says Boris Johnson

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes (Family handout/PA) (PA Media) Boris Johnson has said ministers will leave “absolutely no stone unturned” to establish what went wrong in the case of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. The six-year-old’s ... Read more »

Wilson strike seals Newcastle's first PL win of season

© Getty Callum Wilson celebrates after scoring Newcastle’s winner in the first half Callum Wilson’s first-half strike handed Newcastle their first Premier League win of the season, beating relegation rivals ... Read more »

Moyes eyeing ‘unbelievable' colossus likened to John Stones; West Ham checks already made

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Fulham’s Harry Wilson holds off Dael Fry As per 90min, West Ham United manager David Moyes is eyeing a move for Middlesbrough’s Dael Fry amid ... Read more »

PICS: Rashmika Mandanna flaunts bright smile & no make up look as she gets spotted at gym after Paris vacation

Rashmika Mandanna as we all know is a gym freak. She is quite particular about her fitness and diet and makes sure to hit the gym even in the night ... Read more »

Capitals place defenseman Trevor van Riemsdyk in COVID protocol

Another day, another member of the Capitals in COVID protocol.  After center Nic Dowd was placed in the protocol on Friday, Washington announced that defenseman Trevor van Riemsdyk has been added to ... Read more »

Won 92% of duels: Wolves' "superb" 8-tackle machine pocketed Liverpool's £90m man - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Rayan Aït Nouri Wolves Having scored just once in their previous four Premier League outings, you would’ve forgiven Wolves fans for fearing the worst ahead ... Read more »

50 Cent apologises to Madonna after making fun of her Instagram pictures

© Bang Showbiz 50 Cent has told Madonna he is sorry 50 Cent has apologised to Madonna for making fun of her racy Instagram pictures. The ‘Material Girl’ hitmaker posted ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing 2021: quarter-final – live

© Photograph: Guy Levy/BBC/PA Craig Revel Horwood, Motsi Mabuse, Shirley Ballas, Anton Du Beke on Strictly Come Dancing. LIVE – Updated at 18:20 As we reach week 11, John and ... Read more »

Luca Brecel relishes ‘special' achievement after sinking Kyren Wilson to reach UK Championship final

© PA Wire Luca Brecel compiled four centuries to beat Kyren Wilson in York (Zac Goodwin/PA) – PA Wire Belgium’s Luca Brecel compiled four centuries to sink Kyren Wilson and ... Read more »

Canadiens to activate Mike Hoffman off injured reserve

It has been a tough season for the Canadiens.  After making the Stanley Cup Final, they’ve struggled mightily out of the gate this season and have been hit hard with ... Read more »

David McGoldrick scores second goal of season as Sheffield United win

© PA McGoldrick celebrates as United win. VETERAN STRIKER DAVID McGoldrick scored just his second goal of the season as Sheffield United defeated Cardiff City today. The 34-year-old – who ... Read more »

History of Cristiano Ronaldo's iconic celebration as Manchester United forward passes 800 goals

Cristiano Ronaldo scored two goals against Arsenal on Thursday to secure the win for Manchester United and also to put himself on 801 career goals. Of course, both times he ... Read more »

David de Gea warned Man Utd career is "probably going to end" under Ralf Rangnick

David de Gea ‘s reign as Manchester United ‘s first-choice goalkeeper could be drawing to a close with the arrival of new interim manager Ralf Rangnick. That is according to ... Read more »

Klopp namechecks transfer target who caused havoc in thrilling win; notes new trend among Liverpool opponents

Jurgen Klopp lauded transfer target Adama Traore for his part in making Liverpool’s life difficult, and noted a trend among the Reds’ opponents. © PA Images Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp ... Read more »

Ball numbers for FA Cup third round draw as 13 more sides book their place in hat

The much-anticipated FA Cup third round draw is on Monday night. And there will definitely be at least two non-league sides in the hat. Kidderminster play FC Halifax Town whilst ... Read more »

Iran walks back prior nuclear concessions -U.S. official

© Reuters/Leonhard Foeger FILE PHOTO: The Iranian flag waves in front of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) headquarters in Vienna WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Iran walked back any compromises it made ... Read more »

NYC lawyer's feathers ruffled over false ads' poultry condition claims

Manhattan debt lawyer Jesse Langel has filed four lawsuits in Manhattan Supreme Court accusing businesses of false advertising in how they describe the treatment of animals. J.C. Rice for NY ... Read more »

More than half of Omicron cases in the UK are among fully vaccinated people

Being double-vaxxed doesn’t always protect people from the Omicron variant. AP Being double-vaxxed doesn’t always protect people from the Omicron variant, UK health officials said. A total of 134 cases ... Read more »

I spent £30k building my new business & it's almost finished – but now I face going bankrupt in planning permission row

A FATHER has told how he spent £30,000 building his new business – but now faces going bankrupt because of a planning permission row. Jamie Fuller, from Llanelli, Wales thought ... Read more »

17 samples of Mumbai residents under genome sequencing

© Provided by Hindustan Times A total of 17 samples of suspected Omicron variant from Mumbai residents have been sent for genomic sequencing as of Saturday, according to the Brihanmumbai ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic