Politician is forced to make a grovelling apology after Jacqui Lambie is interrupted by 'growling dog noises' during a fiery speech to parliament

Senator Sarah Hanson-Young said senators made dog noises during a speechIndependent senator Jacqui Lambie had just finished speaking in the chamber Liberal Senator David Van later issued an apology - but denied he made noises

A Liberal Senator has issued a grovelling ‘unreserved apology’ after Jacqui Lambie was interrupted by ‘growling dog noises’ during a fiery speech to parliament on Tuesday. 

David Van admitted to interjecting against independent Jacqui Lambie when she was asking a question – but denied he was the crass individual who growled or made crude dog noises.

‘I acknowledge that interjections are always disorderly and also acknowledge that I was making interjections while Senator Lambie was asking a question during Question Time,’ he told the Senate.

‘And while I do not accept the characterisation of my interjections in a manner that was raised in points of order at that time, by other senators, I do regret the interjections now.



Liberal Senator  David Van (pictured) has issued an 'unreserved apology' after Jacqui Lambie was interrupted by 'growling dog noises' during a fiery speech to parliament on Tuesday

Liberal Senator  David Van (pictured) has issued an ‘unreserved apology’ after Jacqui Lambie was interrupted by ‘growling dog noises’ during a fiery speech to parliament on Tuesday

‘I apologise to Senator Lambie into the Senate and reserve it was present, I commit to holding myself to the highest standards in the future.’

Senator Van later said if the noise actually was him, it was the fault of his mask distorting how his voice sounded when interjecting.

‘I was just interjecting with a gruff voice and I think with the mask and everything, in all the noise that was going on, it was that,’ he told News Corp.

‘It was in no way an animal noise or meant to be disrespectful to (her) in any sort of gendered way.

‘I was not mocking her voice. I was doing an angry voice. I misbehaved and I’ll leave it at that. It was just the heat of Question Time. It wasn’t an animal noise. I’ve got a deep voice. With a mask on it came up.’

Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young was fuming at what unfolded, chastising fellow senators after interrupting Ms Lambie’s speech.

Independent Jacqui Lambie was insulted during parliament on Tuesday - but no one was willing to fess up to the crude growling and dog noises

Independent Jacqui Lambie was insulted during parliament on Tuesday – but no one was willing to fess up to the crude growling and dog noises

The accusation came on the day a landmark report by Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins found widespread bullying and sexual harassment of women in the nation’s parliament. 

‘I don’t think it is appropriate given what has been handed down today to have growling and dog noises coming from this side of the chamber while a female member in this place is on her feet,’ Senator Hanson-Young said after Senator Lambie had sat down.   

‘It happened. I don’t know who is responsible for it, but it is inappropriate and if we are going to change culture from the top, that means all of us.’

Labor’s Senate Leader Penny Wong was also seething, as she supported Ms Hanson-Young’s accusation.  

‘I did [hear it] because I asked, who’s growling? I would ask one of the senators at that end perhaps to do the right thing and withdraw,’ she said, gesturing in the direction of smaller party senators.

'I don't think it is appropriate given what has been handed down today to have growling and dog noises coming from this side of the chamber while a female member in this place is on her feet,' Senator Sarah Hanson-Young said in the Senate

‘I don’t think it is appropriate given what has been handed down today to have growling and dog noises coming from this side of the chamber while a female member in this place is on her feet,’ Senator Sarah Hanson-Young said in the Senate

I would ask one of the senators at that end perhaps to do the right thing and withdraw,' Labor's Senate Leader Penny Wong said in support of Ms Hanson-Young's accusation

I would ask one of the senators at that end perhaps to do the right thing and withdraw,’ Labor’s Senate Leader Penny Wong said in support of Ms Hanson-Young’s accusation

‘At least ‘fess up. Gee, you’re tough aren’t you… happy to dish it out but not to accept responsibility.’ 

Senate President Slade Brockman insisted he had not heard the growling that Senator Wong referred to and therefore could not ask for it to be withdrawn.

The Senate incident came as Ms Jenkins’s report found young women in parliament are treated like ‘fresh meat’, people often cry in the toilets and one third of workers in the building are sexually harassed, according to a damning report.

Some 37 per cent of parliament workers have been bullied and 77 per cent have heard about cases of bullying and harassment, the report by Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins found.  

The report contained damning anecdotes from anonymous participants, one of whom said it was the ‘most sexist’ place they had ever worked in. 

Scott Morrison announces the release of the 400-page report into harassment in Parliament House

Scott Morrison announces the release of the 400-page report into harassment in Parliament House

‘I guess there is a workplace culture of drinking. There’s not a lot of accountability. The boys are lads. And that behaviour is celebrated and… they do treat women, our female staffers and female admin staff, quite differently,’ the interviewee said. 

‘Young women, particularly media advisers coming in, particularly the younger women coming in, were like fresh meat and challenges.’

The report found 40 per cent of women and 26 per cent of men were sexually harassed while 42 per cent of women and 32 per cent of men were bullied.

Young women, particularly media advisers coming in, particularly the younger women coming in, were like fresh meat and challenges 
One interviewee in the report 

A total of 61 per cent of bullies were women while 81 per cent of sexual harassers were men. 

One in four people who experienced sexual harassment said they were harassed by a politician and only 11 per cent of people who experienced sexual harassment reported it. 

Prime Minister Scott Morrison said he was shocked by the statistics but not surprised.

‘Like anyone who works in this building, I find the statistics that are presented there, of course appalling and disturbing. I wish I found them more surprising. But I find them just as appalling,’ he said. 

Ms Jenkins said she was not surprised by the stats because one in three Australian workers around the country suffer sexual harassment. 

The report was commissioned nine months ago after former Liberal staffer Brittany Higgins, 26, alleged she was raped in Parliament House after a night out in 2019. 

Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins gave a press conference about her report on Tuesday

Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins gave a press conference about her report on Tuesday

The report was commissioned nine months ago after former Liberal staffer Brittany Higgins (pictured), 26, alleged she was raped in Parliament House after a night out in 2019

Ms Jenkins made 28 recommendations including a 10-year plan to have the same number of male and female politicians and a clearer alcohol policy with set times when drinking is acceptable. 

Other interviewees who spoke to Ms Jenkins said there is a ‘work hard, play hard’ culture in parliament which features regular drinking.

One said politicians have even gone on to the floor of Parliament while drunk. 

‘Members of Parliament have gone onto the floor of Parliament to vote under the influence of alcohol – something that would be illegal in most workplaces,’ the submission said.  

The report said bullying was exacerbated by the culture of working hard. 

‘Extreme expectations, long hours, small offices and office politics, and constantly proving one’s worth – was seen to foster environments in which people take their stress out on each other and bullying is accepted,’ Commissioner Jenkins wrote. 

Ms Jenkins spoke to 1,723 people for the report.

Another interviewee, who no longer works in parliament, said they were in awe of the parliament when they arrived but left feeling they would never set foot in the building again.

‘And I do remember the very first time I walked in there… we got into the Member’s Hall and we stood directly sort of under the flagpole and sort of looked up. 

‘You can look up through the glass ceiling and the flagpole is there. And it was like… I work in Parliament House. 

‘You know, I actually teared up. I remember tearing up… It was just a pride to be able to work there because to me, that’s the ultimate place of public service. And can I tell you, when I left there… I would never, ever set foot in the place again,’ the interviewee said.

Another said they regularly heard people crying in the toilets.

‘So often I heard people crying in the toilets and felt bad for that person wondering what had happened,’ the interviewee said.

‘Sometimes it might have just been the pressure of the high stress work environment, but I never asked because I was just trying to survive myself and fight my own battles.’ 

Another said the pressure was so high that people would get yelled at for ‘unnecessary reasons’. 

‘Because it’s so high pressure… if something goes wrong, people’s reactions are quite unreasonable. Lots of shouting and yelling for just unnecessary reasons,’ they said. 

Ms Jenkins found several drivers of bullying and harassment including power imbalances, gender inequality and a lack of accountability.

Power imbalance came from an ‘inherent focus on the pursuit and exercise of power’ and a ‘misuse of power and sense of entitlement’ as well as insecure work.

Staffers can be fired by their politician bosses much more easily than workers in other industries. 

Ms Jenkins said young staffers and women were most at risk.

One interviewee said: ‘It is a man’s world and you are reminded of it every day thanks to the looks up and down you get, to the representation in the parliamentary chambers, to the preferential treatment politicians give senior male journalists.’ 

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Video: Japan continues aid deliveries to tsunami-ravaged Tonga

Read more »

Video: At least eight people dead and multiple supporters hospitalised after 'stampede' ahead of Africa Cup of Nations hosts Cameroon's match against Comoros at the Olembe Stadium in Yaounde

Read more »

Video: Three ex-Minneapolis cops 'watched as George Floyd suffered a slow and agonizing death' and should be held to account for 'choosing to do nothing', prosecutor tells jury in civil rights trial

Read more »

Video: The frustration and anger at No.10 over partygate is growing and poses the question - will Boris Johnson ever get out of this mess? asks JASON GROVES

Read more »

‘You guys are all corrupt': Denis Shapovalov rants at umpire over Rafael Nadal's play at Australian Open

Nadal and Shapovalov clashed in Melbourne (AFP via Getty Images) Denis Shapovalov accused a match umpire of being “corrupt” over what he thought was Rafael Nadal’s slow play at the ... Read more »

Video: Awkward moment a furious Carrie Bickmore RIPS into Peter van Onselen for blasting Grace Tame as 'immature' after her meeting with the PM - leaving a guest close to tears

Read more »

For the seventh time the Week of the Gifted in the Netherlands

People who exhibit the characteristics of giftedness can mean a lot to their environment or society, if they can develop and use their knowledge and skills optimally. It is therefore ... Read more »

Having his cake and eating it! 'Upset' Cabinet minister refuses to 'defend' Boris's June 2020 birthday 'party' in No10 and admits being 'asked questions I can't answer' - with warnings PM could face POLICE probe

ITV claims PM attended gathering organised by his wife Carrie in the Cabinet Room in No10 on June 19, 2020They are said to have celebrated his 56th birthday after his return from a visit to a school in HertfordshireMPs lashed out at latest allegation, with one saying there are 'presumably more being stored up for release'  No 10 said staff 'gathered briefly' in the Cabinet Room after a meeting and the PM stayed for only 10 minutes Read more »

'She didn't deserve to die': Devastated son of woman, 43, stabbed to death in school-run horror says 'keep her in your prayers' after she and knifeman were both hit by car of 'vigilante' driver who was 'trying stop attack'

Motorist was arrested on suspicion of murder after children and parents witnessed the horrific double killingBystanders had tried to stop knifeman after he pounced on his 43-year-old victim, stabbing her over 10 times But the attack was only halted when motorist ran over the 41-year-old on the pavement, also hitting the victimWitnesses said the attacker was left pinned under the vehicle and the woman's coat trapped under a wheel Do you know anyone involved? Would you like to pay tribute to the victim? Email tips@dailymailcom  Read more »

Princess Charlene celebrates her 44th birthday alone: Royal shares slideshow of snaps from happier times featuring Prince Albert, their children and her swimming career as she continues to receive treatment outside of Monaco

Princess Charlene is celebrating her 44th birthday away from her family The Monaco royal posted a slideshow of photos celebrating her lifeSnaps included ones with Albert, their children and her Olympics victory  Read more »

Video: Julia Fox officially coins couple name for herself and rapper boyfriend Kanye West: 'Juliye'

Read more »

Barcelona 'are offered the biggest kit sponsorship package in football history, with money-spinning deals set to total over £67m every year - with cryptocurrency companies VeganNation and Polkadot in talks'

A host of big companies are keen on sponsoring Barcelona's kits next season Rakuten and Beko are currently working with the club, but will soon step away Reports say VeganNation and Polkadot are locked in talks with Joan Laporta Spotify are also interested in a deal, and Barcelona are now weighing up options  Read more »

Francis Ngannou reveals he has already lost out on over £5MILLION from the UFC amid tense contract negotiations as heavyweight champion insists 'freedom doesn't work with money'

Francis Ngannou says he has already lost $7m (£5m) amid failed UFC talks Ngannou, 35, completed his last fight with the UFC after his win over Ciryl Gane The Cameroonian has been locked in negotiations with the UFC over a new dealHowever, the UFC will not give him the freedom to take on boxing matches  Read more »

Missile crisis II? Kremlin reveals Putin has discussed 'strategic partnership' with Cuba days after fears were raised Russia will deploy military to Latin America

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Cuban President Miguel Díaz-Canel reaffirmed their 'commitment to strengthen bilateral relations' in phone callIt comes after fears were raised that Russia would deploy military to Cuba and Venezuela if tensions with the US over Ukraine escalatedRussian foreign minister said he could 'neither confirm nor exclude' possibility Read more »

World no.1 Ash Barty STUNS Australian Open crowd as she steams towards the semi-finals with resounding first set victory - but there's a tough battle ahead after unseeded American's shock win

The Ashleigh Barty party continues at the Australian Open as she fights for a place in the final four at her home grand slam. The Australian world number one has ... Read more »

WA premier going to NSW for Palmer lawsuit

Clive Palmer's defamation lawsuit against the WA premier set to begin next week has been delayed, but Mark McGowan will have to attend in person when he takes the stand. ... Read more »

Awkward moment a furious Carrie Bickmore RIPS into Peter van Onselen for blasting Grace Tame as 'immature' after her meeting with the PM - leaving a guest close to tears

Tame avoided eye contact with Scott Morrison at morning tea on TuesdayVan Onselen wrote a piece calling the Australian of the Year winner 'childish'Bickmore and guest Amy Remeikis unleashed on van Onselen about his opinionBickmore said time when Tame should've been childish was taken away from her Read more »

Premier League clubs are giving young, homegrown players more opportunities with the top flight recording a 50 per cent increase in playing time among U23s during the Covid-affected 2019-20 season

Premier League report shows more chances for young players during CovidEY report reveals 16% of all minutes were played by U23s coached in EnglandThis was more than a 50% increase on the average of the previous three seasonsQuality of young English players rising due to Elite Player Performance PathwayEnglish top flight clubs now spend more on youth development that Euro rivals  Read more »

Vodafone to begin switching off its 3G network in 2023 to improve 4G and 5G

Vodafone will start turning off its 3G network in 2023 as part of plans to improve 4G and 5G services for customers, the mobile operator has announced. The telecoms firm ... Read more »

The CHICKEN Big Mac: McDonald's is set to sell classic burger with a poultry twist from February... after removing bagels and wraps from breakfast menu

Chicken Big Mac features two fried chicken patties instead of the normal beef Burger will be launched from February 2 but only for six weeks until March 15Chicken Big Mac will cost £4.09 for the sandwich and £5.59 for medium meal McDonald's also confirms Chicken Legend will be returning from next month Read more »

How to create a royally happy household! Norland Nanny reveals 15 hacks to 'fix any family' - from 7pm bedtimes for all under 7s to a morning board game to make getting ready for school a breeze

Louenna Hood, 37, a former Norland nanny, has given her tips to help your familyShe has worked for several high-profile and royal families for over 17 yearsThe maternity nurse has launched an app to help parents get the best advice Read more »

Denim brand ditches 'outdated' traditional sizing and replaces it with FLOWER names because women 'shouldn't be labelled by numbers'

Denim brand ditched traditional sizing and replaced numbers for flowers The Aussie brand believes that a woman's body should not be numberedPeachay designs their jeans for women with pear and hourglass body shapesThe brand was founded back in 2018 by 26-year-old Bella Sen   Read more »

Daddy's girl who became a terrorist: German woman who joined ISIS in Syria aged 15 and became a high-profile jihadi bride goes on trial accused of aiding crimes against humanity

Leonora Messing fled to Syria at just 15 and met Jihadi Martin Lemke, in 2015 She ran from the small town of Sangerhausen, Germany to shock of her family Now 21, German national faces trial accused of aiding crimes against humanity She and Lemke are charged with enslaving a Yazidi woman in Syria in 2015Messing will also be tried on charges of joining IS and weapons law violations Read more »

German wonderkid Karim Adeyemi 'has chosen Borussia Dortmund as his next destination but the Bundesliga club are far apart from Red Bull Salzburg's £33.5m valuation' for the striker  

Wonderkid Karim Adeyemi has been in electric form for RB Salzburg this seasonThe 20-year-old has 14 goals in 17 league matches in the Austrian top-flightAdeyemi has reportedly chosen Borussia Dortmund as his next destinationThe German would follow Erling Haaland in swapping Salzburg for DortmundSalzburg reportedly want as much as £33.5million for their star asset this season  Read more »

Lionel Messi makes surprise return to Barcelona to celebrate Xavi's 42nd birthday with old team-mates Sergio Busquets and Jordi Alba - and even stops to sign shirts for fans waiting for him outside the restaurant

Lionel Messi has a free week after being left out of Argentina's squad this week He headed back to Barcelona to celebrate old team-mate Xavi's 42nd birthdayMessi made his PSG return on Sunday after catching Covid-19 on January 2  Read more »

Manchester United 'boosted in pursuit of Endrick' after 15-year-old Palmeiras wonderkid reveals Cristiano Ronaldo is his idol ahead of Neymar and Lionel Messi

Endrick is the 15-year-old sensation making headlines in Brazil with PalmeirasYoungster is attracting interest from Europe already despite his tender age Manchester United are understood to be among the interested parties  His father has spoken about how much Endrick idolises Cristiano Ronaldo   Read more »

‘Pupils can calculate the final exams in this way'

Under the scheme, a pupil can cross out a subject if it should fail, with the exception of the core subjects of Dutch, English and mathematics. Although this is not ... Read more »

Claudio Ranieri sacked by Watford after less than four months in charge

Claudio Ranieri has been sacked by Watford (PA Wire) Claudio Ranieri has been sacked by Watford after less than four months in charge, the Premier League club has confirmed. Watford’s ... Read more »

Tyson Fury, Dillian Whyte and the sound of heavyweight chaos

Any silence during the endless negotiations for a difficult fight is always a good sign and right now the silence surrounding the Dillian Whyte and Tyson Fury fight is deafening. ... Read more »

Rafael Nadal survives scare to battle to five-set win over Denis Shapovalov

Rafael Nadal shows his delight after beating Denis Shapovalov (Andy Brownbill/AP) (AP) An ailing Rafael Nadal battled to a five-set victory over Denis Shapovalov in a dramatic Australian Open quarter-final. ... Read more »

Claudio Ranieri becomes latest victim of Watford's extreme short-termism

Claudio Ranieri was sacked by Watford on Monday (PA Wire) Claudio Ranieri was always doomed to failure at Watford. The 70-year-old has been sacked after a shambolic run that generated ... Read more »

Jadé Tuncdoruk appears downcast as she arrives at her Sydney home amid backlash over her honeymoon refund and racism controversies

Jadé Tuncdoruk has been making headlines for all the wrong reasons.  The 26-year-old has been battling through her honeymoon refund and racism controversies, and appeared downcast as she arrived at ... Read more »

Tour de France 2019 winner Egan Bernal is in intensive care after suffering a punctured lung, fractured kneecap and broken leg after he crashed into a PARKED BUS on a training ride in his native Colombia

Bernal, 25, was training close to his home in Bogata, Colombia when he crashed2019 Tour de France winner was involved in a collision with a parked busHe underwent surgery on fractures in his right leg and kneecapBernal also suffered a collapsed lung and needed surgery on spinal fractures  Read more »

Transfer news LIVE: Man United send scouts to watch Porto's £67m-rated winger Luis Diaz while Sevilla tell Newcastle they want £40m for Brazilian defender Diego Carlos as the January window enters its final week

The January transfer window is open and active for Premier League sides Clubs will have until 11pm on Monday, January 31 to complete their signings A number of high-profile players have been linked with big-money transfers Catch all the latest transfer news and done deals from around the world here  Read more »

A QUARTER of sliced ham, poultry and beef products sold in UK supermarkets are saltier than the Atlantic ocean, campaigners say

UK research found some supermarket meats had more than 2.5g of salt per 100gSome products were so highly salt-packed they were twice as salty as seawaterHigh salt diets are a leading cause of  high blood pressure, which kills thousandsGroups are calling for voluntary salt reduction targets to be made compulsory  Read more »

PICTURED: Mikel Arteta racks up the air miles by flying to the US to meet Arsenal owner Stan Kroenke before the end of the January transfer window, as they watch hockey together before team's Dubai camp

Mikel Arteta has been pictured standing alongside Arsenal owner Stan KroenkeThe pair were seen in Denver, Colorado at a National League hockey gameThey were watching Colorado Avalanche beat Chicago Blackhawks 2-0It came after it was revealed that Arsenal would offer Arteta a new contract Their meeting also took place six before the end of the January transfer window Read more »

Any healthcare worker worthy of the name should have a jab — or change their career, writes Dr NIGHAT ARIF

Back in October, an 86-year-old patient I’ve looked after for many years as his GP went into hospital for a hip replacement. It’s a big operation, but it should have ... Read more »

Rebel Wilson showcases her slimmed-down physique in Los Angeles as she stops for a snack at Starbucks while waiting for her car to get washed

She was recently in Melbourne, enjoying the world class tennis on display at the Australian Open. But by Monday, Rebel Wilson was nearly 13,000 kilometres away, enjoying a slice of ... Read more »

BUSINESS LIVE: Investors brace after ‘Black Monday'; FCA warns firms on insolvency rules; Hut Group slumps again

Investors are braced for the opening bell after global equities tumbled and bitcoin crashed to a six-month low yesterday as fears of conflict in Ukraine and the prospect of higher ... Read more »

New York judge strikes down state mask mandate ruling that Gov. Kathy Hochul overstepped her authority in imposing a rule that needed to have been passed by the state legislature

Judge Thomas Rademaker of New York State Supreme Court on Long Island struck down the state's mask mandate on MondayHe said the governor overstepped her authority in imposing a rule that needed to have been passed by the state legislatureGovernor Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, vowed to fight back against the ruling  Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic