Policy failure to tame soaring home prices brings social mobility crisis

Policy failure to tame soaring home prices brings social mobility crisis


Many young people feel that the ladder to socioeconomic mobility has crumbled

By Yoon Ja-young

Every year since his inauguration in 2017, President Moon Jae-in has vowed in his New Year’s speech to narrow the income gap between the rich and poor, and to provide a chance for low-income households to move up the ladder of socioeconomic mobility.

However, the gap has widened drastically due to the government’s failure to tame soaring housing prices. Those who listened to the government’s pledges to provide affordable homes and put off borrowing money to buy an apartment ended up being unable to afford one, while those who took out bank loans and purchased a home ended up profiting hugely as residential property prices rose to record highs across the country. This situation has left those who listened to the government being unable to afford a home, feeling deprived of the chance to bolster their wealth and climb the socioeconomic ladder. In fact, many people who listened to the government say they feel as if this ladder itself has crumbled.

One bank worker in Seoul, who wished to be identified only by his surname Ahn, bought an apartment in Yongsan district for slightly less than 900 million won ($772,000) five years ago when he got married. He used his savings and took out a mortgage, while his parents and parents-in-law funded the rest. The apartment is now valued at around 2 billion won and the young couple in their mid-30s have already amassed a sizable amount of assets.

On the other hand, the owner of a small repair shop in Changwon, South Gyeongsang Province, surnamed Han, lives in a rental apartment with his parents. The family has never owned a house and their assets haven’t increased much during the past few years. Now in his early 40s, Han hopes to purchase a new apartment with 100 million won that he has in his savings account, along with money his parents saved. But the amount is not enough.

“The gap between those who have assets and those who don’t has expanded dramatically. The gap has also widened among those who do have assets, depending on where they own property,” said Kim Jin-bang, a professor of economics at Inha University.

“In the past, a person could accumulate assets by saving their income, but now it has become almost impossible to make up for that gap through earned income or savings,” he said.

According to KB Kookmin Bank, the price income ratio (PIR) in Seoul rose to 17.4 in the first quarter of this year from 13.9 last year. This figure means that one needs to save their entire salary for 17.4 years without spending a dime in order to afford a house in Seoul. In a joint report submitted to the National Research Council for Economics, Humanities and Social Sciences under the Prime Minister, state-run think tanks define the administration’s real estate policy as a failure, pointing out that it worsened public distrust in government policy as residential property prices only skyrocketed, despite more than a dozen policies announced by the government to stabilize the real estate market.

One’s socioeconomic status is now determined by how much real estate one has, rather than how much one earns, and statistics show that it is becoming more difficult to climb up the socioeconomic ladder.

According to a report by LAB2050, a private think tank, those households in the top 2-percent bracket in terms of real estate assets owned on average 3.08 billion won ($2.63 million) worth of real estate as of March 2020. Eighty percent of these households live in the Seoul metropolitan area. However, at the bottom, 30% of households own no real estate at all.

The top 2 percent saw the value of their real estate assets increase by 555 million won during the past three years, thanks to skyrocketing housing prices. Between 2017 and 2020, those in the bottom 30 percent, meanwhile, saw their average real estate assets dip to zero from 9 million won.

There have been periods in the past when housing prices rose sharply, but it is different this time around because many people feel that their chances of climbing up the socioeconomic ladder have not only lessened but completely disappeared. Young people are pessimistic about future opportunities. The Seoul Institute surveyed 1,000 people between the ages of 20 and 39 and found that only 24.8 percent were positive when asked if they expect to be better off in terms of their socioeconomic status if they make an effort. Also, 87.2 percent of them said that Korea has become inequitable socioeconomically during the past 10 years, and 86.9 percent expected this inequality to get even worse over the next 10 years.

Policy failure to tame soaring home prices brings social mobility crisis

Left out of game from the start

Economists point out that people perceive asset inequities differently from disparities of earned income.

“When equal opportunity is guaranteed, a gap in earned incomes is generally accepted by society,” Lee Jin-hee, a senior researcher at the Korea Institute for International Economic Policy, noted in a report.

“In the case of assets, however, inequality can snowball through speculation, on top of inheritance. As those who had no assets to begin with didn’t even have an opportunity to participate in the game, it is difficult for them to accept this kind of inequality from the start.”

Professor Kim said that inequality in assets negatively affects the economy, while inequality in earned incomes can in some ways work positively.

“Instead of trying to improve their economic benefits through efforts to boost their earned incomes, people will only focus on ways of earning rental income through real estate speculation, expecting asset prices to rise. This situation ends up pulling down economic productivity.”

Lee Won-jae, trustee and CEO of Lab2050, noted that the gap in real estate asset prices can lead to disparities in the education of children. The top 2-percent bracket earned 20.35 million won in rental income each year on average, which means they have more money to spend on their children’s education. In fact, they spend four times more on education than those in the bottom 30 percent.

“Most of those in the top real estate bracket are highly educated people. They are increasing their real estate holdings faster than others, and they are investing more in the education of their children. In other words, both real estate and education are inherited. This situation is especially true among those in their 40s or 50s,” he points out.

Lee said that there used to be a belief among Koreans that everyone can earn income and buy a home under the same conditions.

“The possibility of moving up the socioeconomic ladder through savings and purchasing a home used to be a source of strong motivation for individuals, and it became a driving force of economic development as a result,” he said.

“Being able to purchase real estate, which was once a means to climb up the socioeconomic ladder, is now only widening the gap between classes and making that gap permanent,” Lee added.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Doctors at top hospitals spend only 4 minutes per patient: data

gettyimagesbank By Yoon Ja-young Patients who go to the top hospitals in Korea usually wait for more than an hour but they usually see their doctor for only about four ... Read more »

Lotte Chemical invests 100 mln euros in global hydrogen fund

By Kim Seung-yeon SEOUL, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — Lotte Chemical Corp., a South Korean petrochemical company, said Thursday it will invest about 100 million euros (US$116 million) in a global ... Read more »

Pianist Evgeny Kissin to hold solo recital in Seoul for just one day

A poster for pianist Evgeny Kissin’s piano recital / Courtesy of Lotte Concert Hall By Park Ji-won Pianist Evgeny Kissin will be playing the famous piano works of legendary composers, ... Read more »

El Salvador disables Bitcoin price visibility on the app to stop scalping

Chivo is working on adding a trading feature that will let operators trade with BTC with any modality, but with the asset’s price display in real-time. Chivo App, El Salvador’s ... Read more »

IMM PE primes pump for Able C&C deal

Shin Yoo-jung By Lee Kyung-min IMM Private Equity (IMM PE) is accelerating efforts to bolster the corporate value of Able C&C, a Seoul-based cosmetics and household goods manufacturer, in hopes ... Read more »

Naver, Kakao ask Netflix to pay for network usage

Naver Founder Lee Hae-jin, left, and Kakao Founder Kim Beom-soo speak during a National Assembly audit, Thursday. Yonhap By Kim Yoo-chul The founders of Naver and Kakao asked global content ... Read more »

Wemade CEO joins Bithumb Korea's board of directors

Wemade CEO Chang Hyun-guk / Courtesy of Wemade By Anna J. Park Wemade CEO Chang Hyun-guk became a member of Bithumb Korea’s board of directors earlier this month, hinting at ... Read more »

Nuri readies for space

Fuel and oxidizers are injected into the locally-developed Nuri satellite launch vehicle, erected on a launch pad, at the Naro Space Center in Goheung, South Jeolla Province, Thursday, before its ... Read more »

Pacific Fleet's ecologists collect more than 450 tonnes of waste on Wrangel Island

The Wrangel Island is not permanently populated, and the temporary population are meteorologists, staff of the nature reserve and the military Read more »

Samsung SDI begins test run of cathode factory in S. Korea

SEOUL, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — South Korean battery maker Samsung SDI Co. said Thursday it has began its test run of a cathode-producing factory, jointly set up with a local ... Read more »

Hainan's economy grows 12.8% in the three quarters of 2021

According to Wang Yu, deputy head of the region's bureau of statistics, Hainan's economy is showing "obvious intensive growth". Read more »

Gov't aims to shift to 'living with COVID-19' phase from Nov. 1

Minister of Health and Welfare Kwon Deok-cheol, right, and Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency (KDCA) Commissioner Jeong Eun-kyeong attend the National Assembly’s audit of the health ministry and the ... Read more »

KB Financial Group Q3 net profit up 9.3 pct. to 1.3 tln won

SEOUL, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — KB Financial Group Inc. on Thursday reported its third-quarter net profit of 1.3 trillion won (US$1.1 billion), up 9.3 percent from a year earlier. The ... Read more »

North Korea says SLBM test didn't target US

This combined photo, released Korean Central News Agency on Wednesday, shows a SLBM being fired in waters off the east coast the previous day. (KCNA-Yonhap)North Korea on Thursday defended its ... Read more »

Seoul city govt. to report all participants of Wednesday labor rally to police

Members of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions stage a rally to demand improved working conditions for laborers in Seodaemun-gu, western Seoul, Wednesday. (Yonhap)The Seoul city government said Thursday it ... Read more »

LG CNS helps Korean Air shift IT system to Amazon's public cloud

LG CNS has transitioned Korean Air’s IT system to Amazon Web Services’ (AWS) public cloud. This move comes three years after the two companies signed an agreement to make the ... Read more »

Canadian Bruce Liu wins 2021 Chopin Competition; Lee Hyuk finishes without prize

Bruce Xiaoyu Liu of Canada reacts after being announced as the winner of the 18th International Fryderyk Chopin Piano Competition in Warsaw, Poland, Thursday, local time. Reuters-Yonhap By Park Ji-won ... Read more »

Hainan's January-September tourism revenues grew 136.9% year-on-year

The province’s total revenue amounted to $16.7 billion Read more »

China power crisis boosts coal imports from Indonesia to record

BEIJING (BLOOMBERG) – Indonesia is now overwhelmingly China’s biggest overseas supplier of coal, with shipments hitting a record last month after Beijing loosened curbs on imports to tackle its power ... Read more »

Media: Hainan National Park to be an important link in a new model of green development

According to the Hainan Daily newspaper, the protected rainforest area will be an important strategic factor which will considerably raise tourism standards Read more »

Cancer slows down surgeon's dream to build eco-village on Jeju

Surgeon Hong Seung-jig poses in front of a tree native to Jeju Island, called the “dampatsu” in Korean (Elaeocarpos sylvestirs var. ellipticus), which he had planted three decades ago to ... Read more »

N. Korea's SLBM in early development stage, likely can be intercepted: defense minister

Defense Minister Suh Wook attends a parliamentary audit session at the National Assembly in Seoul on Thursday. (Yonhap)North Korea’s recently tested submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) appears to be in an ... Read more »

Dollar rises to 70.86 rubles

The euro remained unchanged, amounting to 82.5 rubles Read more »

Number of chickens dips 4.2 pct in Q3 due to bird flu

SEJONG, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — The number of layer chickens raised in South Korea dropped 4.2 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier due to the impact of ... Read more »

Donald Trump creates his own media group and social network - statement

The Trump Media and Technology Group will launch the TRUTH Social network soon Read more »

Bitcoin storms $66,000 for first time

A representation of the virtual cryptocurrency bitcoin is seen in this picture illustration taken Oct. 18. Reuters-Yonhap Bitcoin stormed above $66,000 for the first time on Wednesday, riding a wave ... Read more »

Govt. committed to increase support for police: PM

  The government is committed to expanding support for police to beef up public safety, Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum said Thursday, as it vowed to increase the law enforcement agency’s ... Read more »

Yoon expresses regret over controversial remarks on ex-President Chun

SEOUL, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — Yoon Seok-youl, a leading presidential contender of the main opposition People Power Party (PPP), expressed regret Thursday after coming under intense criticism for his remarks ... Read more »

South Korea exports jump in early October data despite supply chain woes

SEOUL (BLOOMBERG) – South Korea’s early trade report showed exports continued to post strong gains in October, weathering headwinds from global supply chain snags and China’s slowdown. Shipments grew 36.1 ... Read more »

N. Korea says its recent SLBM test-launch not targeting US

this photo captured from North Korea’s Korean Central TV Broadcasting Station on Wednesday a new type of a submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) is test-fired from waters the previous day. The ... Read more »

US remains consistently open to dialogue with N. Korea: Psaki

White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki is seen answering questions in a daily press briefing at the White House in Washington on Tuesday in this image captured from the website ... Read more »

(LEAD) Exports rise 36 percent in first 20 days of Oct.

(ATTN: UPDATES with more details from para 3)By Kim Soo-yeon SEOUL, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s exports rose 36.1 percent on-year in the first 20 days of October on ... Read more »

Greenflation feared in S. Korea amid carbon-neutral transition

According to industry sources, South Korea “has plenty of reasons to be nervous” about soaring utility costs. “Greenflation” or price hikes in renewable technology resources such as metals, minerals, and ... Read more »

Assembly audit to have little impact on big tech firms' march into banking industry

Kakao CEO Yeo Min-soo, right, and Yoo Bong-seok, head of Naver’s media platform center, sit side by side as witnesses during an audit run by the National Assembly’s Agriculture, Food, ... Read more »

(EDITORIAL from Korea JoongAng Daily on Oct. 21)

Calm the inflationary pressure Prices are skyrocketing. The inflation rate in October is expected to rise into the three percent range for the first time in ten years. To make ... Read more »

Producer prices up for 11th month in September

SEOUL, Oct. 21 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s producer prices gained 0.2 percent on-month in September due to a rise in prices of energy-related products, extending their monthly gains for the ... Read more »

Supply bottlenecks, labour shortages slowed US growth: Fed

WASHINGTON (AFP) – Supply bottlenecks and labour shortages have slowed US economic growth and contributed to a sharp rise in prices, the Federal Reserve said on Wednesday (Oct 20). The ... Read more »

DHL combating fraudsters using corporate name — VP

Fraudsters often attempt to act under the DHL logo Read more »

Rosneft launches petrochemical production program in India — CEO

Leading oil and gas companies of India are proactively investing in the largest Russian projects of Rosneft Read more »

US employers may have to 'pay more' amid labor shortage: Janet Yellen

US employers especially in the service sector may have to raise wages as the economy adjusts to a labor shortage, but that would be a “good thing” for workers, Treasury ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic