Player retention is key to South Africa's success

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

The United Rugby Championship (URC) has highlighted several of South African rugby’s weaknesses and shortcomings. As experts lament a shortage of experienced players across the Bulls, Lions, Sharks and Stormers squads, a closer look at the player rosters of premier league clubs in Europe and Japan reveals that nearly 200 of SA’s best players are currently plying their trade overseas.

It would be possible to field three starting XVs comprising players who have represented the Springboks or trained with the national team in recent years.

One could compile 10 starting XVs of players who boast Super Rugby and Currie Cup experience – those who have left SA franchises and now turn out for elite clubs in England’s Premiership, France’s Top 14, Japan’s Top League, and the URC.

It would be possible to compile another XV of South Africans who currently represent countries such as England, Italy, Japan, Scotland and the US at Test level. That representation looks set to rise, with Edinburgh prop Pierre Schoeman (formerly of the Bulls) and Sharks flank Dylan Richardson invited to a Scotland training camp this past week.

Depth depleted by exodus

When you get your head around these numbers, you begin to understand how the franchises have been depleted and why the standard of SA rugby has dropped.

Even more depressing to note is that these numbers don’t take into account those plying their trade in second- and third-divisions overseas, or in the less-prominent club rugby regions of North America and eastern Europe.

It’s hard to say exactly how many South Africans are contracted to clubs around the world. In 2017, the SA Rugby annual listed 332 players at various overseas clubs. When contacted for verification, researchers confirmed that access to data was limited, and that it was more than likely that the number of professional players competing abroad is north of 500.

The world has changed over the past three or four years. The Covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated the financial situation in SA, and has given professional players more reasons to pursue opportunities overseas.

Although the European and Japanese leagues continue to welcome a steady stream of South Africans, there has been a new surge of players heading to less traditional regions such as the US – following the launch of the inaugural Major League Rugby competition in 2018 – and Russia. As a result, the franchises in SA – and even the teams that compete in lower tiers like the Currie Cup First Division – have been severely diluted.

Some might point to the success of the Springboks during this period and declare that the problem has been blown out of proportion. The Bok coach is free to select as many overseas-based players as he wishes. Since 2018, the national side has enjoyed one of its most successful runs in history, winning the 2019 Rugby Championship, the 2019 Rugby World Cup and the recent series against the British & Irish Lions. SA currently sits at the top of the World Rugby rankings. The optics, in that sense, are great.

The severity of the situation in South African rugby, however, has been highlighted during the initial rounds of the URC. Relatively young teams have battled to come to terms with the playing styles, referee interpretations and weather conditions in the northern hemisphere. 

Boks: More than 50% based abroad

Some commentators have insisted that the franchises will be a different prospect once the Boks – on duty in the Rugby Championship and subsequently a three-Test tour of Europe – return to their respective clubs in December. This may be true for the Sharks, who will welcome back Siya Kolisi, Lukhanyo Am and several others.

Overall, it’s worth noting that 23 of the 42 Bok squad members who toured Australia recently are contracted to overseas clubs. The likes of Duane Vermeulen, Handré Pollard and others who formed the core of the side that won at the World Cup and beat the Lions are not based in SA.

In short, the overseas clubs, rather than the South African franchises, will receive the biggest boost when the Boks eventually return. 

© Provided by Daily Maverick Cheslin Kolbe of Toulouse runs with the ball during the Heineken Champions Cup final match between La Rochelle and Toulouse at Twickenham Stadium on 22 May 2021 in London, England. (Photo: David Rogers / Getty Images)

‘Something that needs to change’

Schalk Brits began his career at Western Province and later went on to play for Saracens in England for nine years. He represented the Boks at two World Cups, and hung up his boots after the team’s success in Japan.

Since then, the former Bok hooker has pursued a career in finance. He is well placed to comment on why players go abroad, as well as the financial situation in SA.

The Bulls, Lions, Sharks and Stormers have taken some time to adapt in the initial rounds of the inaugural URC tournament, but that is only part of the problem. The real issue is that so many of SA’s top players have moved to overseas clubs over the past few seasons.

“It’s certainly something that needs to change if the SA teams are going to be more competitive in the years to come,” Brits told DM168. “Player retention, especially retention of top players, will allow the better teams to improve and build.”

Although SA boasts outstanding junior structures and evidently a top Test side, there is a concern that the franchises don’t retain more of their best players.

This is especially concerning for teams that are hoping to make an impact on the URC in the long term, and to qualify for major tournaments like the Champions Cup and Club World Cup. The latter is yet to be confirmed, but may kick off in 2024.

Will the SA teams stand a chance in these elite tournaments with the current personnel? Perhaps. Can they keep most of their personnel in the years leading up to the Club World Cup? That is arguably the most important question they will face.

Brits points out that as many as nine South Africans are contracted to Sale Sharks. Leicester also boasts a healthy contingent, as do Edinburgh and Glasgow, but South Africans are certainly prevalent in teams across other elite leagues.

“If all of those players were available for an SA team, it follows that they would improve that team,” Brits said. “South African rugby has lost a number of players to overseas clubs – and you can understand why, given the money on offer abroad.” 

SA’s mass exodus since 2016

The four SA franchises competing in the inaugural URC are almost completely unrecognisable from the teams that did duty in the 2016 Super Rugby tournament.

The Bulls have retained three out of 40 players who featured in that competition, the Lions two out of 44, the Sharks three out of 38, and the Stormers seven out of 41. The retention rate for all franchises – the four big teams plus the Cheetahs and now defunct Kings – over a period of five years is 7.5%.

It’s important for top players to go overseas and broaden their horizons. The Boks who play abroad will eventually return to the national set-up with new intelligence on foreign players and playing styles.

In the past, the same was true of franchise players who would enjoy sabbaticals in the northern hemisphere and then return to their teams in SA with new skills and information.

Sadly, this is no longer the case, with fewer and fewer players returning from overseas to bolster their local teams. Of the 240 players who represented the six franchises in 2016, 148 (61%) went abroad in subsequent seasons. As many as 130 (54%) are still overseas. Only 18 (7.5%) have returned from abroad to play for a local franchise.

© Provided by Daily Maverick

The Lions are the best example of a top team that has been stripped of its top personnel. The Johannesburg-based franchise featured in three consecutive Super Rugby finals between 2016 and 2018. Following a mass exodus over the next few years, only two members of their 2016 squad remain at the union.

The Lions failed to qualify for the Currie Cup playoffs recently. They were lucky to avoid a last-place finish in the South African pool of the URC. The Stormers, who have faced significant challenges off the field, will also battle to compete.

 Bulls, Sharks can tackle problems

Brits is optimistic that the Bulls and Sharks will address the issue in the coming seasons. Both teams are now privately owned, and it’s fair to say that the structural changes made over the past two years will benefit these franchises in future.

On the other hand, some feel that SA rugby’s venture into the northern hemisphere will lead to more departures than ever.

Elite clubs won’t need to send scouts down to South Africa to assess promising youngsters or established veterans competing in the Super Rugby tournament or Currie Cup, as they will have the benefit of watching those players compete in the URC or Champions Cup.

One would hope that the franchises find a way to retain their best players – and indeed their best youngsters. It would be a tragedy if Elrigh Louw, Wandisile Simelane and Evan Roos – to name a few – find themselves abroad rather than at a local franchise in three years’ time.

The Bulls, Lions, Sharks and Stormers won’t keep all of their players over the next five years.

They will have to do better than a 7.5% retention rate during that period, however, if they are going to challenge for a major title and realise their potential in Europe. DM168

© Provided by Daily Maverick

This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper which is available for R25 at Pick n Pay, Exclusive Books and airport bookstores. For your nearest stockist, please click here.

© Provided by Daily Maverick

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Ulster forwards coach keen to work with Duane Vermeulen

© PA Images Rugby – 2021 British and Irish Lions Tour – 3rd Test – South Africa v BI Lions – Cape Town Stadium New Ulster signing Duane Vermeulen has ... Read more »

Ballon d'or: Pedri, pépite du Barça et de l'Espagne, décroche le Trophée Kopa

© ICON Sport Pedri remporte le Trophée Kopa 2021 Si l’Angleterre arrivait en force avec trois nommés pour le Trophée Kopa, la prestigieuse récompense va rejoindre l’Espagne. Et plus précisément ... Read more »

Arsenal assessing Bukayo Saka injury ahead of Man Utd clash

© Provided by 90min Bukayo Saka suffered a thigh problem against Newcastle | Richard Heathcote/GettyImages Arsenal are sweating on the fitness of winger Bukayo Saka ahead of facing Manchester United ... Read more »

Messi n'avait pas imaginé gagner un septième Ballon d'Or

Lionel Messi est heureux d’être le Ballon d’Or 2021. © Fournis par 90min Messi, Ballon d’Or 2021 | FRANCK FIFE/GettyImages Lionel Messi a remporté le Ballon d’Or 2021 ce lundi, ... Read more »

Ballon d'Or: Un scandale dénoncé

© Fournis par Lionel Messi et Didier Drogba Rarement l’attribution du Ballon d’Or n’aura suscité autant de réactions. Pas même en 2010 lorsque Lionel Messi, déjà lui, l’avait emporté ... Read more »

ASSE : changement de stratégie pour Lomakin, deux autres milliardaires dans la balance ?

Après la visite de Sergueï Lomakin dans le Forez, la vente de l’ASSE pourrait s’accélérer, mais les présidents du club gardent encore des atouts en cas de revirement de situation. ... Read more »

Xavi et Emery en seraient venus aux mains après Villarreal-FC Barcelone

Après la victoire du FC Barcelone contre Villarreal, le ton serait monté entre les entraîneurs Xavi et Unai Emery, séparés puis finalement revenus au calme. © Fournis par 90min Cela ... Read more »

Ballon d'Or 2021 : soirée poker, message à Messi... La soirée parallèle de Neymar loin de la cérémonie

Si ses deux partenaires du PSG, Lionel Messi et Kylian Mbappé, étaient présents pour la cérémonie du Ballon d’Or, Neymar n’a pas fait le déplacement. © Icon Sport Neymar Si ... Read more »

Ballon d'or 2021 : comme Benzema, Cristiano Ronaldo n'ira pas à Paris !

A l’image de son ancien coéquipier Karim Benzema, Cristiano Ronaldo ne sera pas présent à la cérémonie du Ballon d’or ce soir au Théâtre du Châtelet. © Icon Sport Cristiano ... Read more »

Incidents OL – OM : Aulas et sa garde rapprochée s'insurgent contre les sanctions, le CNOSF va trancher !

Jean-Michel Aulas, le président de l’OL, et sa garde rapprochée ont donné une interview à l’Equipe pour s’insurger de la sanction prise par la LFP après les incidents contre l’OM. ... Read more »

Ballon d'Or 2021 : grosse déception pour Benzema, plombé par l'affaire de la sextape ?

L’une des surprises de la cérémonie du Ballon d’Or 2021 est l’absence de Karim Benzema sur le podium final. Une vraie déception pour l’attaquant madrilène. © Icon Sport Karim Benzema ... Read more »

Ballon d'or 2021 : Messi crée la folie à son arrivée, les barrières de sécurité sont tombées !

Comme il y a deux ans, Lionel Messi a créé la folie à son arrivée au théâtre du Châtelet à Paris. © Icon Sport Lionel Messi Comme il y a ... Read more »

Valerien Ismael delivers verdict on Sam Johnstone's West Brom situation amid Newcastle, Spurs and West Ham links

© Provided by Football League World Championship – West Bromwich Albion v Queens Park Rangers West Bromwich Albion boss Valerien Ismael believes goalkeeper Sam Johnstone is still ‘fully committed’ to ... Read more »

John Sillett, FA Cup-winning manager with Coventry, dies aged 85

Photograph: Action Images John Sillett has died at the age of 85, his family have announced. Sillett managed Coventry between 1986 and 1990 and led the club to FA Cup ... Read more »

Formula E | Ecco il teaser della Gen3 per il 2022

Agli AD dei Costruttori e ai capi delle squadre sono stati mostrati in gran segreto design completo e specifiche nel primo giorno di test pre-stagionali 2022 a Valencia. © Fornito ... Read more »

Genesis G90 (2022): Luxus-Limo debütiert mit zwei Radständen

Die Langversion hat die Maybach S-Klasse im Visier 2022 Genesis G90 2022 Genesis G90 2022 Genesis G90 2022 Genesis G90 2022 Genesis G90 2022 Genesis G90 2022 Genesis G90 © ... Read more »

Abid Ali steers Pakistan to convincing victory

© PA Images Abid-Ali-1024 Pakistan opener Abid Ali missed out on twin centuries in the first Test against Bangladesh, but nevertheless steered the side to a comfortable eight-wicket win in ... Read more »

Bafana Bafana star BLAMED for Portuguese club's Omicron outbreak!

© Provided by The South African The 13 reported cases of Covid-19 at Portuguese club Belenenses, whose league match against Benfica was called off at the weekend when their team was ... Read more »

You love amagwinya/puff puff/bofrot? Here's a healthier version of Africa's favourite snack

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved The ability to predict and regulate blood glucose absorption after consumption of starchy food is vital in the fight against diabesity. ... Read more »

Shares in Macau's Suncity collapse after boss detained

© Anthony WALLACE Macau’s casinos are facing heightened scruitiny from mainland officials Shares in Macau’s largest junket operator Suncity plummeted more than 48 percent on Tuesday after boss Alvin Chau ... Read more »

China to host 2022 Olympics smoothly despite challenges posed by Omicron, says diplomat

The 2022 Winter Olympic Games in Beijing are scheduled to be held between February 4 and 20 Read more »

Khamzat Chimaev calls out THREE retired UFC legends, with the rising star taking aim at Brock Lesnar and Georges St-Pierre... before asking Daniel Cormier for wrestling match

Khamzat Chimaev is searching for his next big fight after incredible start in UFCCechen-born Swede is not afraid to call-out some of the biggest names in MMAHe wants to take on Georges St-Pierre, Brock Lesnar and Daniel Cormier  Read more »

Basket – Qualifs Mondial 2023 (H) : Les Etats-Unis battus

© USA basketball isaiah thomas etats-unis Privés de tous leurs joueurs de NBA, les Etats-Unis se sont inclinés face au Mexique (97-88), lundi soir à Chihuahua lors de leur deuxième ... Read more »

Basket : Alexis Ajinça annonce sa retraite

© Panoramic alexis ajinca Agé de 33 ans et sans club depuis deux ans et demi, le pivot international français Alexis Ajinça a annoncé ce vendredi qu’il prenait sa retraite, ... Read more »

Quiz: 30 questions about some of Coventry City's best ever goalkeepers – Can you score 100% correct?

© Provided by Football League World Football – FA Carling Premier League , Aston Villa v Coventry City – 5/5/01 Coventry City produced a shrewd bit of business to bring ... Read more »

Max Verstappen has ‘polished up' his aggression, says Daniel Ricciardo

© Getty Images Max Verstappen Max Verstappen’s former teammate, Daniel Ricciardo, believes the Red Bull driver has “polished up” his aggression and is benefitting from a more mature approach to ... Read more »

Former Coventry manager Sillett dies aged 85

Former Coventry manager John Sillett has died at the age of 85, his family have announced in a statement. Sillett managed Coventry between 1986 and 1990 and led the Sky ... Read more »

Washington into NFC playoff picture with Seattle Seahawks win

A last-minute interception by Kendall Fuller ensured the Washington Football Team beat the Seattle Seahawks 17-15 to register their third consecutive victory. © AP Washington cornerback Kendall Fuller (29) intercepts ... Read more »

Van der Kraan keert na drie maanden terug als algemeen directeur bij FC Twente

Paul van der Kraan keert na drie maanden terug als algemeen directeur van FC Twente. De ervaren bestuurder vervangt Jan-Willem Brüggenwirth, die twee weken geleden moest vertrekken bij de Eredivisie-club omdat er geen match was. Read more »

Prince Charles brands slavery 'a dark stain' in Barbados speech as the Queen is removed as their Head of State

Prince Charles arrived in Barbados yesterday (November 29) to mark the country’s official break with the crown after nearly 400 years. The Caribbean country became a republic at midnight on ... Read more »

Kaizer Chiefs make contract decision on Daniel Akpeyi ahead of January transfer window

© Provided by The South African Kaizer Chiefs have made a decision regarding Daniel Akpeyi’s contract at the club, ahead of the January transfer window. READ | KAIZER CHIEFS MAKE ... Read more »

Rachel Furness Becomes Northern Ireland's International Top Scorer

© Photo by Charles McQuillan/Getty Images Liverpool Women star Rachel Furness makes history by becoming the highest scoring international player in Northern Ireland. Furness and Northern Ireland played against North ... Read more »

Talisman Andy Carroll Has Galvanised Reading On And Off The Pitch

Some players just feel special, don’t they? For whatever reason, whether you can put your finger on it or not, a few of those to pull on the blue and ... Read more »

“I imagine”: Journo drops update over £7.2m-rated flop, Palace fans will be delighted - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Crystal-Palace-Jean-Philippe-Mateta-Premier-League Crystal Palace are not expected to make Jean-Philippe Mateta’s stay at the club permanent after a disappointing loan spell from Mainz 05. What’s the ... Read more »

Steven Gerrard's response to Gary Lineker's brilliant Aston Villa quip

Aston Villa are flying under Steven Gerrard. Since Gerrard replaced Dean Smith earlier this month Villa have won both of their games and would have kept two clean sheets but ... Read more »

Sky Sports have posted a teaser clip of Amir Khan & Kell Brook's The Gloves Are Off episode

After years of trash-talking, speculation and more trash-talking, Amir Khan vs  is finally happening. © GiveMeSport p1flo0nd0odv81apc17mu2f39euf.jpg It is one of the biggest rivalries in boxing and based on their ... Read more »

Wayne Rooney delivers message over Chris Kirchner's presence at Derby County during QPR clash

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Derby County v Luton Town Derby County manager Wayne Rooney has suggested that the Rams administrators need to do all they can ... Read more »

Red Bull confront F1 chiefs over Mercedes battle and ‘one-sided' decisions

© Getty Images Helmut Marko is said to have raised concerns of favouritism – Getty Images Red Bull boss Helmut Marko discussed “one-sided” decisions in favour of Mercedes with Formula ... Read more »

Simon Kjaer says he must 'move on' from Christian Erisken incident

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Simon Kjaer has said it is time for him to ‘move on’ from the incident that defined his and Denmark’s summer at the ... Read more »

Kylian Mbappe's reaction to learning final place in 2021 Ballon d'Or vote speaks volumes

Kylian Mbappe was left visibly unimpressed by finishing ninth in the vote for the 2021 Ballon d’Or. While Paris Saint-Germain team-mate Lionel Messi took home the grand prize for a ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic