Pipeline: Cascade of white owners has slowed NFL change

Asia's Tech News Daily

Over the past 100 years, around 110 people have owned controlling portions of NFL teams. Of that select group, all but two have been white.

This basic head count might offer the simplest explanation for how, even with rules in place for nearly two decades that are designed to improve diversity, the league has struggled to build a pipeline for bringing Blacks and other minorities into coaching and front-office positions.

The lead investigator for the latest NFL Inclusion and Diversity Report gives a nod to the less-than-satisfying nature of the numbers in that report by leading off his opening message with the reminder: “Progress is a process.”

In 2021, the process produced these statistics: Black players make up about 70% of team rosters but the league has only three Black head coaches, while it had eight in 2011; Black coaches who fail in their first try in the jobs get inordinately fewer second and third chances than their white counterparts; the NFL this year recalibrated its much-celebrated Rooney Rule, which ensures minority candidates for front-office positions are identified and interviewed, to make sure teams talk to at least two such candidates for front-office positions and coordinator roles.

Academics who study the subject say the latest set of underwhelming numbers, along with the latest set of changes implemented in an attempt to improve them, are in line with the century-long history of a league that has been controlled by rich white men.

“To understand this problem, you have to look at it from a broader macro-historical lens,” said John Singer, who teaches courses on diversity and social justice in sports at Texas A&M. “It goes back to an old-boys network. It’s an informal system in which wealthy men, particularly wealthy white men with social and economic backgrounds, help each other out.”

In many ways, the academics say, the arc of diversity and inclusion in the NFL mirrors that in America itself. It’s more complex than simply saying owners have long been more comfortable hiring people who looked and talked like them, though that certainly could be one element in play in a league that didn’t hire a single Black head coach between Fritz Pollard in the 1920s and Art Shell in 1989.

“There’s also a matter of who they think is most marketable, who resonates with their fan base,” said Anthony Weems, an a ssistant professor at Florida International University who wrote a dissertation on NFL owners and the social structure they created over a century.

“Over time, a lot of these owners are the same people, or the teams got passed down in the family. So it’s almost like, ‘Why would things have changed if the actual players in those positions haven’t changed?’” Weems said.

The professors agree that it was no surprise earlier this year to see the racist emails that surfaced between Jon Grude n and former Washington executive Bruce Allen. Also not shocking, but far less spotlighted, was the scenario that played out in 2017 when Texans owner Bob McNair said “We can’t have the inmates running the prison.”

McNair apologized and said he hadn’t been speaking about the players. When he died in 2018, ownership of the team passed to his wife.

“There was backlash for sure, but why are they running Gruden out of a job when they allowed McNair to operate just fine and he passed the team down?” Weems said. “It’s indicative of a larger culture.”

Jaguars owner Shad Khan, one of the league’s two minority owners, said he was taken aback when he tried to buy a controlling stake in the Rams in 2010.

“I had met some people at that time and the apology that went around, the conjecture was, ‘You will never get approved because you’re not white,’” he said.

But he said those thoughts didn’t match up with the reality. He moved on from the Rams and ended up buying the Jaguars in 2011, and paints a much more optimistic picture about NFL ownerships’ relation to race.

“I think the league is at the forefront and they’re going to be doing more,” Khan said. “And my being in the middle, yes, I’ve seen a change.”

In a short essay that accompanied the latest diversity and inclusion report, lead investigator C. Keith Harrison writes about the academic topic of attribution bias, which, he explains, are errors made when trying to explain why people make decisions they make. It undercuts the idea that, for instance, all decisions made by a largely white group of owners might be based solely on race.

Still, the results remain the same, and Harrison points to other academic studies that conclude the impact of biased behavior does add up over time.

“In the context of the NFL, African Americans and other human beings of color pay their dues, and when it appears to be their turn it is often a white coach hired again. And again. And again,” he writes.

He used the example of Urban Meyer’s attempt to hire Chris Doyle as an assistant for the Jaguars as a prime example.

Doyle’s hiring was squelched after accusations surfaced about his racist remarks and bullying of players during his 22 years at the University of Iowa.

That episode illustrated what many people see as one core problem in the NFL’s diversity issue: A century’s worth of white owners have built a system in which white coaches and leaders get far more second and third chances, while Black coaches are harder to find and don’t have as many chances to fail. For instance, since 1963, 15 white coaches have been given a third head-coaching job, compared to zero coaches of color. (The report says Tom Flores was the lone coach to be afforded a third chance, but authors did not respond to The Associated Press when it asked what the third job was. Flores coached the Raiders and Seahawks.)

Cyrus Mehri, who co-founded the Fritz Pollard Alliance, which, according to its website, “exists to champion diversity in the National Football League,” said the league office is not to blame for the systemic diversity issues in the NFL.

“It’s the owners,” Mehri said, in a quote embedded in the diversity and inclusion report. “We have spectacular candidates, and we still have decision making (among owners) that’s irrational.”

John Solow, an Iowa professor who co-wrote a paper on the Rooney Rule in 2011, said that in the universe the owners have created, it can be argued that it’s hard to tell if Black assistant coaches are being discriminated against because, compared to whites in the same positions, there haven’t been enough of them over the years to do a truly scientific study on the issue.

For instance, between 2012-2021, whites were hired for 168 of the 219 (76%) open coordinator positions, which are considered the top launching pads for head-coaching jobs. That almost mirrors the hiring pattern for head coaches: Whites have been tabbed for 51 of the 62 openings (82%) since 2012.

“But then, you have to go back a step and say ‘Why aren’t there (more) Black assistant coaches?’” Solow said. “And then you ask ‘Was there discrimination?’ And we couldn’t really find any. But we also couldn’t really find any evidence that the Rooney Rule was working.”


AP Pro Football Writer Mark Long contributed to this report.


More AP NFL coverage: https://apnews.com/hub/nfl and https://twitter.com/AP_NFL

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Union Pacific Q4 profit up 24% despite weak rail volume

The Associated PressFILE – In this Sept. 13, 2019, file photo the logo for Union Pacific appears above a trading post on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. ... Read more »

Review: 'Yinka, Where is Your Huzband' funny and big-hearted

The Associated PressThis cover image released by Pamela Dorman Books shows “Yinka, Where is Your Huzband” by Lizzie Damilola Blackburn. (Pamela Dorman Books via AP) NEW YORK — “Yinka, Where ... Read more »

Raducanu reveals team wanted her to pull out of second round match

Emma Raducanu has revealed that there were people in her team who didn’t want the British number one to play as she crashed out of the Australian Open. The US ... Read more »

Tennessee ranked No. 1 in ITA rankings

© Provided by Vols Wire Tennessee men’s tennis team is ranked No. 1 by the International Tennis Association. The Vols were ranked No. 4 in the ITA’s spring preseason poll. ... Read more »

Why Titans will be a different team vs. Bengals if Derrick Henry plays, plus Troy Aikman isn't wrong

© Provided by CBS Sports Happy Thursday morning, all. I hope this newsletter finds you well. Let’s get right to it. This is the article version of the CBS Sports ... Read more »

Supreme Court skeptical of campaign finance law challenged by Ted Cruz

© Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call/Bloomberg via Getty Images Senator Ted Cruz Holds Get Out The Vote Bus Stops Ahead Of Midterm Election Washington — The Supreme Court on Wednesday grappled ... Read more »

Saga is back, and I'm ready to be hurt again

© Provided by CNET Saga was first published in 2012. Image Comics When was the last time you cried over the death of a fictional character? A secondary character? Scratch ... Read more »

NIH says Pfizer's Paxloid should be first treatment option for certain COVID-19 patients

© Marketwatch MARKET PULSE The National Institutes of Health on Wednesday updated its COVID-19 treatment guidelines for patients with mild to moderate forms of COVID-19 who are at high risk ... Read more »

Will Derrick Henry be back to boost AFC No. 1 seed Titans? Plus, a hypothetical blockbuster Yankees trade

Happy Thursday morning, all. I hope this newsletter finds you well. Let’s get right to it. Good morning to everyone but especially to… DERRICK HENRY AND THE TENNESSEE TITANS Derrick ... Read more »


Overview Syringomyelia (sih-ring-go-my-E-lee-uh) is the development of a fluid-filled cyst (syrinx) within your spinal cord. Over time, the cyst can enlarge, damaging your spinal cord and causing pain, weakness and ... Read more »

Sperm donation is largely unregulated, but that could soon change as lawsuits multiply

© Provided by Salon Pregnant Woman Getty/NataliaDeriabina When Wendy and Janet Norman decided to have a baby, they went sperm shopping through Xytex Corp., a sperm bank. The couple chose ... Read more »

Photojournalist Steve Schapiro, who died last week, left images that reach into the soul of history

In the hours after the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in Memphis, Tenn., in 1968, Steve Schapiro walked into a room — not the one at the Lorraine ... Read more »

Watch New York Giants' Daniel Jones gift high school football player Super Bowl tickets in heartfelt surprise

New York Giants quarterback Daniel Jones gifted high school student Alex Brown with tickets to the Super Bowl in a heartfelt surprise. Brown is a quarterback at Red Bank Catholic ... Read more »

Get a Sleepingo Camping Sleeping Pad for $34 if You’re the Type of Person Who Would Use That

© Image: Sophy Ziss Sleepingo Camping Sleeping Pad | $34 | Amazon | Promo Code 15RHS84W Sleepingo Camping Sleeping Pad | $34 | Amazon | Promo Code 15RHS84W I’ve recently ... Read more »

Ousmane Dembélé dropped by Barcelona's Xavi, told to find a new club by the end of the January transfer window

Barcelona dropped Ousmane Dembélé from Xavi’s 22-man squad hours before their Copa del Rey round of 16 tie against Athletic Bilbao. Club director Mateu Alemany, in an interview with Barça ... Read more »

A Christian Eriksen move to Brentford would be more than just a heart-warming story – it could really work

Where Christian Eriksen is concerned, events have already gone from the life-threatening to the life-affirming once in the last year. It is to be hoped they do again. © Provided ... Read more »

Want to Keep Your Liver Healthy? Your Favorite Activity—Running!—May Help

Running and strength training are two activities that may prevent a condition known as non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD), new research shows. This may be due to the fact that ... Read more »

Bantering Points: 1/20/22

© Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images Here are today’s news and links: Rangers News: Highlights: NYR 6, TOR 3 (5:06 video via NHL.com) Game Recap: Multi-goal efforts from Adam Fox ... Read more »

Watch Dozens of Fighters Punch Francis Ngannou in the Chest as Hard as They Can

You don’t get to be the reigning UFC Heavyweight champion without knowing how to take a punch—but not many mixed martial artists make it look quite as easy as Francis ... Read more »

Watch Tom Stoltman and Eddie Hall Literally Destroy a Gym During a Workout

Tom Stoltman, the reigning World’s Strongest Man, is less than two weeks out from the imminent Britain’s Strongest Man competition. As part of his preparation, he and his equally giant ... Read more »

PHT Morning Skate: Hughes on Habs; What Sharks could get for Hertl

© Provided by NBC Sports Welcome to the PHT Morning Skate, a collection of links from the NHL and around the hockey world. Have a link you want to submit? ... Read more »

Travel Deals to Book Now: Wave Season Cruise Discounts and NYC's Inaugural Hotel Week

The new year is here—which means 12 new months to plan for. Not sure where to start? Follow the deals on hotels, airlines, and cruise lines, which provide plenty of ... Read more »

Lakers HC Frank Vogel reportedly had go-ahead to bench Russell Westbrook late vs. Pacers

© Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports Los Angeles Lakers guard Russell Westbrook Things are going from bad to worse for the Los Angeles Lakers. Not only is the team a disappointing ... Read more »

Track profile: Tucson Speedway

Short-track racing is alive and well in the Arizona desert. This thanks in part to the existence and excellence of Tucson Speedway, a 0.375-mile paved oval located on the Pima ... Read more »

Suns vs. Mavericks prediction, odds, line: 2022 NBA picks, Jan. 20 best bets from model on 56-30 run

© Provided by CBS Sports The Phoenix Suns visit the Dallas Mavericks in a Western Conference tilt on Thursday. Phoenix is 34-9, leading the NBA, and the Suns are 17-4 ... Read more »

This Tiny Alabama Town Of 1,200 Has Been Overrun By Policing

© Image: Chris Carlson (AP) Image: Chris Carlson (AP) Brookside, Alabama’s population barely crests a population size 1,200 people, but officials decided that what the town really needed was even ... Read more »

The Great Divide: Who are the best and worst UFC commentary trios?

The Great Divide is a recurring feature here at MMA Fighting in which two of our staff debate a topic in the world of MMA — news, a fight, a ... Read more »

Starbucks Drops COVID Vaccine and Testing Requirements for Employees After Supreme Court Ruling

© Provided by People Ronald Martinez/Getty Images Coronavirus vaccines and weekly testing are no longer on the menu of requirements for Starbucks employees in the U.S. On Tuesday, the coffee ... Read more »

2022 Australian Open men’s singles draw, scores

© Provided by NBC Sports Novak Djokovic losing his deportation appeal on Sunday, the day before main draw action begins, shook up the Australian Open men’s draw. Djokovic, the record ... Read more »

How to watch Murray State vs. Eastern Illinois: NCAAB live stream info, TV channel, time, game odds

© Provided by CBS Sports Mar 20, 2019; Salt Lake City, UT, USA; General overall view of a basketball approaching the rim and net before the first round of the ... Read more »

Law books and feminist classics in Ruth Bader Ginsburg library up for auction

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Jessica Hill/AP The personal library of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the late US supreme court judge who became a liberal and feminist icon for championing ... Read more »

Toyota GR Corolla details further leak ahead of production

The Drive’s source inside Toyota’s dealer network has been spilling secrets again. Last time, the source told the outlet that a Toyota Supra with a manual transmission is “confirmed” and ... Read more »

Signs of life in Bidenland: President seizes the pulpit at last — will it change anything?

© Provided by Salon Joe Biden U.S. President Joe Biden answers questions during a news conference in the East Room of the White House on January 19, 2022 in Washington, ... Read more »

11-month-old baby girl shot in face, hospitalized in critical condition

On Location: January 20, 2022 See more videos What to watch next UP NEXT An 11-month-old girl has been shot in the face in the Bronx, prompting a search for ... Read more »

Bob Saget's widow Kelly Rizzo grieves him in interview: 'He was just so kind and so wonderful'

© Leon Bennett/Getty Images Bob Saget and Kelly Rizzo attend the red carpet premiere and party for Peacock’s new comedy series “MacGruber” at the California Science Center on December 8, ... Read more »

Producer prices soared by 9.7% in December, biggest gain on record

Producer price index measures inflation at the wholesale level before it reaches consumers Read more »

FIA must lay out ‘what was right, what was wrong'

The FIA’s report into the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix not only needs to state what was “right, and what was wrong” but also what action will be taken. © PA ... Read more »

Knicks vs. Pelicans prediction, odds, line: 2022 NBA picks, Jan. 20 best bets from model on 56-30 run

© Provided by CBS Sports The New Orleans Pelicans will try to end a five-game losing streak on the road when they take on the New York Knicks on Thursday ... Read more »

'Called every hospital within 75 miles': Man with COVID dies while waiting for hospital bed

WORCESTER, Mass. — A Massachusetts man and pizza shop owner died while waiting for a hospital bed to open up after contracting COVID-19 Antonios “Tony” Tsantinis, 68, of East Brookfield ... Read more »

Newgarden: No smoking gun to explain Penske’s Indy 500 struggles

© Barry Cantrell / Motorsport Images Josef Newgarden Team Penske Chevrolet, Simon Pagenaud, Team Penske Chevrolet, Scott McLaughlin, Team Penske Chevrolet, Will Power, Team Penske Chevrolet Penske has 18 wins ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic