Picture Cave in Missouri sold at auction for $2.2 million. The Osage Nation says it belongs to them

More than 1,000 years ago, Indigenous people journeyed into a dark cave on the land now called Missouri and painted nearly 300 detailed images on its walls.

© Alan Cressler/AP A Missouri cave containing artwork created by the Osage Nation about a thousand years ago was sold at auction earlier this week.

The cave was a sacred space, where tribes performed ceremonies, made sense of the universe and buried their dead. A millennium later, the paintings contained within it continue to offer clues about how those civilizations lived and what they believed.

On Tuesday, Picture Cave — as it’s commonly known — sold at auction for $2.2 million. And for the Osage Nation, whose ancestors created much of the artwork in the cave, the sale came as a huge blow.

“It is our ancestors who are buried there in that cave,” Andrea Hunter, tribal historic preservation officer for the Osage Nation, told CNN. “It is our ancestors that created the images that are on the walls and conducted the rituals that took place. It is absolutely the most sacred site that we have. And it rightfully should be in our ownership.”

© Alan Cressler/AP The images on the walls of Picture Cave in Missouri depict humans, animals and mythical creatures, painted about 1,000 years ago.

For decades, a private family owned the site

Since 1953, Picture Cave and the 43 acres of land on which it sits had been owned by a St. Louis family who used it mainly for hunting. But in recent years, the family began to discuss the possibility of selling the site, according to Bryan Laughlin, executive director of Selkirk Auctioneers & Appraisers, the company that managed the auction.

Once the Osage Nation learned their sacred site might soon be up for sale, the tribe knew they wanted to reclaim it, Hunter said.

Over a period of several months, the Osage Nation, in conjunction with the Conservation Fund and the US Fish and Wildlife Service, discussed an arrangement with the family that would have allowed the tribe to purchase the site directly. Ultimately, however, the parties were unable to agree on a price, Hunter added.

During this time, the family had the site valued by real estate appraisers, whose estimates ranged from $420,000 to $450,000, Laughlin said. Unhappy with that valuation, the family presented their situation to the auction house, which estimated the site would sell for anywhere between $1 million and $3 million at auction.

“To me, it was just mindboggling how they wouldn’t be able to realize that the significance and the historical intrinsic value would make it so much greater than just the acreage times a certain number,” he added.

Earlier this year, it was announced that Picture Cave would be coming up for auction. For some, however, the notion of putting a price on a site with such historical and cultural significance to Indigenous people was alarming.

Carol Diaz-Granados, an anthropologist who along with her husband James Duncan spent more than two decades researching the cave and wrote a book on its mysteries, called the sale “both wrong and unethical.”

“It really sends the wrong message — that ancient sacred American Indian sites can be purchased for the ‘right’ amount of money, irregardless of their patrimony,” she wrote in an email to CNN.

The new buyer hasn’t been identified

Though Hunter said the Osage Nation, represented by the Conservation Fund, were among the bidders on Picture Cave, an anonymous buyer ended up winning out on the sale earlier this week — much to the heartbreak of the tribe.

“It’s hard to put into words,” Hunter said, of her feelings after the sale.

In recent years, tribes in the US have reclaimed ancestral lands through various methods: Some have raised funds to buy back the lands themselves, while others have had their lands repatriated by previous owners. It’s unclear, though, whether the Osage Nation will eventually be able to reclaim Picture Cave.

The new buyer has not been publicly identified, but Laughlin described the entity as cave conservationists who have worked to preserve other caves in the Midwest and around North America. He said he’s optimistic that the site will continue to be taken care of, both because the auction house had limited who could bid and because a Missouri law makes it a crime to damage a human burial site or profit off of cultural items from there.

“Regarding time and unforeseen occurrence, I cannot say, but all indications thus far would be that the cave is going to be preserved very well,” Laughlin added.

As for now, the Osage Nation is attempting to connect with the buyer to ensure that the tribe’s sacred site remains preserved and protected, according to Hunter. But the point remains, she said: Picture Cave was theirs to begin with, and to them it should have been returned.

“That’s good that they have an interest in preserving it,” she added. “But why should it be some cave conservationist in control?”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Bucs DT Vita Vea's high school RB highlight video is a must-watch

Vita Vea is among the best interior defensive linemen in the NFL. But did you know that he was a stud as a running back in high school too? © ... Read more »

Ministers to ramp up Covid vaccine rollout as hospitalisations rise

Photograph: Karwai Tang/Getty Images Two million people who are eligible for a Covid booster vaccine in England will receive their invitation this week as ministers seek to intensify the rollout. ... Read more »

Six big off-year elections you might be missing

A pitched battle between former Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe (D) and businessman Glenn Youngkin (R) promises to steal the headlines in November’s off-year elections, while a less competitive race between ... Read more »

Budget 2021: Business urge chancellor to go green

The UK currently stands in sixth place out of the G7 nations for investment in climate infrastructure, according to a report by the Trades Union Congress (TUC). Above, Rishi Sunak, ... Read more »

UK government ‘waging secret war against transparency'

Photograph: Joe Giddens/PA The UK government has been accused of waging a secret war against transparency, using an array of tactics to block the release of information to the public. ... Read more »

Starmer demands fast-track exclusion orders to protect schools from anti-vaxxers

Councils should be able to use exclusion orders to keep anti-vaxxers from protesting outside schools, Sir Keir Starmer has said. The Labour leader said it was “sickening” that those against ... Read more »

Biden's Cabinet: President still hasn't nominated an OMB director. Here's why that matters.

Nine months after taking office, President Joe Biden still doesn’t have a permanent director of a critical agency in his administration. © Provided by CNN The last Cabinet-level position that ... Read more »

The 10 Best Appetite Suppressants To Curb Cravings and Stop Weight Gain (Including Dark Chocolate!)

© Image Licensed from Adobe Choosing the best appetite suppressants to curb and control cravings is no easy task. And with so many on the market, it’s hard to know ... Read more »

Atlanta Prepares to Host World Series After Losing MLB All-Star Game for State Voting Laws

Months after the MLB All-Star Game was moved out of their ballpark over a slate of restrictive voting laws in Georgia, the Atlanta Braves will now play in baseball’s crown ... Read more »

Autumn budget 2021: Rishi Sunak unveils new spending pledges including £5bn for health research and innovation and £3bn for skills education

The chancellor has announced a series of spending pledges ahead of the autumn budget this week, which include £5bn for health research and innovation and £3bn for education. Rishi Sunak ... Read more »

Police shoot suspect who 'literally kidnapped' officer, tried to drive away in DC

A man reportedly tried to escape a scuffle with police Friday by driving away from the scene while an officer was inside his vehicle, police say. Police responded to the ... Read more »

Disney Plus: Everything coming in November 2021

There was a period there, in the opening months of 2021, where you literally couldn’t move for premium Disney Plus TV shows set in its most high profile universes. There ... Read more »

Riley Keough Thanks Dakota Johnson After Chris Martin Dedicates Song to Her Late Brother at Coldplay Show

Riley Keough is sharing her heartfelt appreciation to Chris Martin and Dakota Johnson after the musician dedicated a song to her late brother. The 32-year-old Zola actress posted footage to ... Read more »

Fans Choose Swedish House Mafia & The Weeknd's ‘Moth to a Flame' as This Week's Favorite New Music

Swedish House Mafia & the Weeknd “Moth to a Flame,” Swedish House Mafia and The Weeknd’s new collab, has topped this week’s fan-voted new music poll. Music fans voted in a poll that ... Read more »

Day of the Dead event returns to Figge Museum

DAVENPORT, Iowa (KWQC) – Music, dancing, food, and remembrance. A rainy day couldn’t put a stop to the Figge Art Museum’s Day of the Dead event. Organizers were eager to ... Read more »

Julianne Hough Cozies Up in Chunky Sweater, Patchwork Jeans and Sleek Mules for Mother Denim Party

© Courtesy of Net-A-Porter JHough-2 Julianne Hough gave summery sandals a fall upgrade for the Net-A-Porter x Mother denim launch event with supermodel Carolyn Murphy this weekend. The “Footloose” star ... Read more »

B8 starts another Dota 2 rebuild, benches Limitless, watson, and TSA

B8 Esports’ Dota 2 roster is once again back down to just Danil “Dendi” Ishutin. The organization moved Alimzhan “watson” Islambekov, Yaroslav “Limitless” Parshin, and Sergey “[T]SA” Timchenko to the ... Read more »

NASCAR at Kansas results from Hollywood Casino 400: Kyle Larson wins third straight race and ninth of the year, locked into Championship 4

With just one race left in the NASCAR Round of 8 playoffs and three Championship 4 spots up for grabs, all eyes have descended upon Kansas Speedway. Kyle Larson was the ... Read more »

Review: After cancellations in Europe, tenor Jonas Kaufmann brings his 'poison' to the Broad Stage

Jonas Kaufmann is in many ways the model modern tenor. © (Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times) Stellar tenor Jonas Kaufmann appears in a rare recital at the Broad ... Read more »

Adrien Brody: I like being hard to define

© Bang Showbiz Adrien Brody Adrien Brody enjoys the sense of mystery that surrounds his acting career. The 48-year-old actor explained that he likes being seen as a puzzle to ... Read more »

How Celtic science and manager's faith is paying off for resurgent winger Mikey Johnston, ready to prove naysayers wrong

Celtic supporters want to see their club moving forward off the pitch as well as on it. The bright cameos provided by winger Mikey Johnston in the weekend 2-0 success ... Read more »

Josh Jacobs injury update: Raiders RB ruled out after suffering chest injury vs. Eagles

The Raiders will have to finish their game Sunday against the Eagles without running back Josh Jacobs. Jacobs went to the Las Vegas locker room before the end of the first ... Read more »

Week 8 Overreaction: Pitt races past Clemson, Illinois at PSU OT... thriller?

Dan Wetzel, Pete Thamel and SI’s Pat Forde go around the nation to recap the week 8 college football slate. The trio begins in the ACC where the Pitt Panthers ... Read more »

Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa on Miami's Deshaun Watson rumors: 'I do hear it'

Rumors of a potential Deshaun Watson trade have intensified this week, with the Miami Dolphins named as the most likely suitor. It’s easy to imagine those rumors are taking a ... Read more »

Highlights, box score and MVP from Cincinnati destroying the Ravens

What. A. Game. © Sam Greene/The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK No, this wasn’t the back-and-forth affair that many thought would happen as the 4-2 Bengals and Ravens faced off ... Read more »

Tom Brady establishes NFL's 600 TD pass club — and Mike Evans gives ball away

In the history of the NHL, 20 players have scored 600 goals. In the history of MLB, nine players have hit 600 home runs. On Sunday, Tom Brady created the ... Read more »

Zach Ertz scores first touchdown with his new team as Arizona takes 24-5 lead

© Provided by NBC Sports Zach Ertz caught four passes for 29 yards and a touchdown in his final game with the Eagles. He was traded to the Cardinals after ... Read more »

LeBron James takes aim at trolls dissing Dwyane Wade's son

LeBron James and Dwyane Wade are family, having won two NBA titles in addition to posing on a banana boat together. Now James is going after the trolls targeting Wade’s ... Read more »

Nets lose to Hornets in ugly home opener after pro-Kyrie Irving protests

The Nets’ home opener was a wreck, from the testy pro-Kyrie Irving protests outside that forced Barclays Center to briefly close its doors, to getting their doors blown off in ... Read more »

Plan to regenerate brownfield sites to deliver hundreds of thousands of homes

Brownfield sites covering the equivalent of 2,000 football pitches could be turned into plots for new homes with a £1.8 billion injection set to be announced in the Budget. It ... Read more »

James Michael Tyler, who played Gunther on 'Friends,' dies

NEW YORK (AP) — James Michael Tyler, the actor known widely for his recurring role as Gunther on “Friends,” has died. He was 59. Tyler died Sunday at home in ... Read more »

Man arrested in connection with more vandalism at Monument Square businesses

Oct. 24—A man was arrested Saturday after he allegedly smashed four windows at businesses in Portland's Monument Square. Michael Hale, 51, who was identified as homeless by Portland police, has ... Read more »

Kobe Bryant's widow reveals she learned of his death via online tributes after helicopter crash

Vanessa Bryant is suing the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department for negligence and invasion of privacy, claiming officers shared graphic photos of the crash scene - including images of Kobe and Gianni's bodies. Read more »

Ahead of launch of Capt's party, Sodhi raises farm laws, tells Modi withdrawal won't make BJP look weak

© Provided by The Indian Express AHEAD OF former chief minister Capt Amarinder Singh floating his own political outfit, his closest aide and former Cabinet minister Rana Gurmit Singh Sodhi ... Read more »

Woman gives birth on moving bus in Maharashtra's Pune district

A woman gave birth to a child in Maharashtra’s Baramati on a moving bus during her journey from Devdur in Karnataka to Pune. After delivery, the woman, identified as 20-year-old ... Read more »

Buccaneers hooking up fan who gave Tom Brady milestone ball back

A Buccaneers fan briefly found himself in possession of an incredibly valuable piece of memorabilia on Sunday, and Tampa Bay has promised to reward him for giving it back. © ... Read more »

Bengals thrash Ravens in 41-17 win, take hold of AFC North lead

The Cincinnati Bengals stunned the Baltimore Ravens at M&T Bank Stadium, winning by a whopping 41-17. Not only did the Bengals defeat the Ravens, but they won by their largest ... Read more »

Who plays on 'Sunday Night Football' tonight? Time, TV channel, schedule for NFL Week 7

“Sunday Night Football” went into overtime last week in a matchup between an NFC West team and one of last year’s AFC playoff teams. NBC will hope to get a similarly ... Read more »

Trey Flowers questionable to return with knee injury

© Provided by NBC Sports The Lions are staying tricky, executing a second fake punt of the game in the second half. But it didn’t lead to points and now ... Read more »

Philadelphia students 'scared to go to school' as gun violence escalates

Joshua Corneilius, 17, should be enjoying his senior year of high school, but instead, he is constantly worried about the violence occurring both inside and outside of his North Philadelphia ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic