Pfizer and Moderna have revealed the way they're tracking how long vaccine protection lasts

A woman receives a COVID-19 booster shot in Netanya, Israel, on January 19, 2021. Ronen Zvulun/REUTERS

  • New data show how Pfizer and Moderna measure the duration of their vaccines' protection.

  • Protection offered by both mRNA vaccines wanes significantly over time.

  • Many health experts don't think young, healthy people need boosters yet.

A Friday meeting in Washington got a little messy: An expert panel said the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) shouldn't green-light Pfizer's COVID-19 booster shot for the general public – but not without some dissent.

Pfizer executive Dr. William Gruber argued that without booster shots the US could face a wave of infections among the vaccinated. But committee members questioned whether it was too soon to tell if boosters offer any more protection to healthy Americans who've already received two doses. Members voted 16 to 3 against recommending Pfizer boosters for people ages 16 and up – but unanimously recommended the shots for adults ages 65 and up or those at high risk of severe disease.

Their debate hinged on a key question: When do the first two shots stop offering enough protection?

This week, Pfizer published its most robust data yet about how long its vaccine protection lasts, with results from at least eight studies. The data showed that the vaccine's effectiveness fell significantly over time – to 47% efficacy after five months, down from 88% in the month following dose two.

Though Friday's meeting didn't evaluate Moderna's booster, the company released data in a press release on Wednesday that also makes a case for boosters.

Both datasets give a look under the hood at how each company is measuring the duration of vaccine protection. Pfizer and Moderna have been tracking participants from their clinical trials, who are divided into two groups: Those who got vaccines as part of the trials (which began in 2020) and those who got a placebo, then the real vaccine once it was authorized.

Pfizer and Moderna each compared the incidences of breakthrough infections between the two groups. Pfizer's results showed that the risk of breakthrough infections was 26% lower for trial participants who were fully vaccinated roughly five months prior, compared to those who had gotten their second shot approximately 10 months earlier.

Moderna, similarly, said breakthrough infections were more common among trial participants who got vaccinated between July and October 2020 than among those vaccinated between December and March. The company identified 162 breakthrough infections among those who were fully vaccinated 13 months prior, compared to 88 breakthrough infections among those who had gotten their second shot eight months before.

Stéphane Bancel, Moderna's CEO, cited those numbers as support for booster shots.

Vaccine protection seems to wane over time

A 12-year-old receives their first Pfizer vaccine dose at a Los Angeles County mobile vaccination clinic on May 14, 2021. Patrick Fallon/AFP/Getty Images

Several recent studies have similarly found that Pfizer's vaccine effectiveness diminishes over time.

The vaccine's protection against infection fell from 88% in the month following the second dose to 47% five months after that second shot, according to a study from Kaiser Permanente. And real-world data from Israel suggests that the risk of breakthrough infections is significantly higher for people who were vaccinated with Pfizer earlier in the pandemic than for those who received vaccines later.

The Delta variant may pose a particular challenge. Pfizer's protection against breakthrough infections fell to 53% four months after it was administered, based on data collected from June to July, when Delta was becoming more prevalent in the US. The company thinks these results are due to waning protection, though – not the variant's ability to evade vaccines.

Moderna's data showed a smaller dropoff in efficacy against Delta infections. Another Kaiser Permanente study that's still awaiting peer review found that Moderna's vaccine was 87% effective in preventing COVID-19 infections after three months – down from 94% prior to the rise of Delta.

While the Pfizer vaccine remains highly effective against hospitalization and death from COVID-19, a new report released by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) suggests that Moderna may offer better protection against hospitalization. Being fully vaccinated with Moderna lowered recipients' risk of hospitalization by 93% from March to August, according to the report, compared to an 88% reduced risk of hospitalization among Pfizer recipients.

The report's findings may “guide individual choices and policy recommendations regarding vaccine boosters,” the CDC authors wrote.

Is it time for boosters yet?

President Joe Biden wants to roll out COVID-19 booster shots to most Americans on September 20. Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Before the FDA advisory panel made its decision on Friday, the Biden administration had already announced a booster shot campaign for those who'd gotten Pfizer or Moderna. The administration pinpointed September 20 as the date on which most Americans would be eligible for third shots. (The FDA has already authorized boosters for immunocompromised people.)

Dr. William Schaffner, a professor of infectious diseases at Vanderbilt University, questioned whether the White House got ahead of itself.

“This is the sort of internal, behind-closed-doors argument – inside baseball – that goes on in science being translated into public policy all the time,” Schaffner said. “The reason it's out in the open is because the White House made that pronouncement.”

Protection wanes over times for all vaccinations, he said, and COVID-19 shots were not designed to prevent mild infections, but rather to prevent hospitalization and death – which they do very well after six or eight months.

“Will we need a booster someday?” Schaffner asked. “Sure. Do we need it today? No!”

Schaffner doesn't begrudge the scientists at Pfizer and Moderna for pushing boosters, though.

“I don't think this comes out of marketing division of the company,” he said. “I think the scientists really believe it.”

But he noted that many other concerns are at play. For one, two departing FDA regulators, as well as the World Health Organization, have cautioned against offering third shots to the general population while much of the world remains unvaccinated, and without compelling evidence showing the need for extra shots.

Schaffner doesn't think that global equity argument holds up. He noted that regulatory and distribution challenges would make it difficult for the US's vaccine surplus to go directly to poorer countries with low vaccine access.

“It's a false notion that if you don't give the boosters, those doses will be delivered to Indonesia,” he said, adding, “The problem is that we haven't gotten a first dose into people. That's where we ought to put our energy, time, and resources.”

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Best Budget Soundbar

When you’re watching a huge blockbuster with a carefully designed sound mix, you want to be able to get the best out of it, even if you’re viewing it in ... Read more »

15 sustainable gifts from brands that give back

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. As the holiday season nears, you may be on the hunt ... Read more »

Customer-favorite Madewell jeans, purses and jewelry are up to 30% off now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Need a new bag to take you through the fall or ... Read more »

THE ROAD TO HOME: Our comprehensive guide to buying your first house

© Kazi Awal/Insider Kazi Awal/Insider © Provided by Business Insider Alyssa Powell/Insider The pandemic caused a housing frenzy. Buying a home right now is daunting – but exhilarating. A new ... Read more »

Rudy Giuliani associate Lev Parnas convicted for funneling foreign money into US campaigns

© Eduardo Munoz Alvarez/Getty Images NEW YORK, NY – FEBRUARY 03: Lev Parnas (C) arrives to federal court with his wife Svetlana Parnas (R) for a hearing on February 3, ... Read more »

The Worst Side Effect of Not Getting Enough Vitamin D

© Provided by Eat This, Not That! vitamin D Vitamin D was likely the most talked-about vitamin of 2020. In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, vitamin D was the ... Read more »

Get ready for 'Battlefield 2042'—here's where you can pre-order it right now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Battlefield 2042 is the newest entry to the Battlefield franchise, bringing ... Read more »

Walmart Black Friday: Shop early deals on LEGO, Shark and Keurig now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Ready to shop Black Friday? Good news: Walmart’s early Black Friday ... Read more »

Rudy Giuliani associate Lev Parnas convicted for funneling foreign money into US campaigns and making straw donations

© Eduardo Munoz Alvarez/Getty Images NEW YORK, NY – FEBRUARY 03: Lev Parnas (C) arrives to federal court with his wife Svetlana Parnas (R) for a hearing on February 3, ... Read more »

Backcountry is having a massive sale on socks right now—get up to 55% off top styles

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Not only are premium pairs of socks essential to surviving the ... Read more »

Vikings beat Columbus across the Atlantic by 470 years. Astrophysics and tree rings helped scientists nail down the timeline.

© Gail Shotlander/Getty Images L’Anse aux Meadows was a North American landing point for the Vikings and is now part of Canada’s National Park system. The indentations in the earth ... Read more »

Donald Trump's social media platform hacked just hours after it was announced, reports say

Hackers gained access to a private version of former President Donald Trump’s recently announced social media platform and posted images of defecating pigs, expletives and more, according to multiple reports ... Read more »

Digital World Acquisition stock surges another 285% as Trump SPAC rally continues for a second day

© Associated Press/Charlie Neibergall Donald Trump. Associated Press/Charlie Neibergall Digital World Acquisition stock surged as much as 285% on Friday. The SPAC’s shares closed 357% higher on Thursday after it ... Read more »

The rose gold Apple AirPods Max just dropped to an all-time low ahead of Black Friday

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Looking for a good holiday gift for your techie friend or ... Read more »

The US is running out of cardboard and packaging materials as the supply chain crisis drags on, making it harder for retailers to ship online orders

© Justin Sullivan/Getty Images A FedEx worker sorts packages being unloaded from a truck on a conveyor belt at the FedEx Oakland Airport sort facility. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images Cardboard boxes ... Read more »

15 gifts from QVC that show mom how much you love her

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Finding the best gift for the one woman always in your ... Read more »

Priscilla Chan joins executive board of Reform Alliance alongside Jay-Z, Meek Mill, Michael Rubin, Van Jones, and others

© Steve Jennings/Getty Images Priscilla Chan. Steve Jennings/Getty Images Priscilla Chan has joined the executive board of the Reform Alliance, the criminal-justice reform organization told Insider ahead of an announcement. ... Read more »

17 mini brands your kids will go crazy for

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. For the past few years, mini brands have been one of ... Read more »

The 26 best toys and gifts for 8-year-olds

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Buying for 8-year-olds can be tough. They aren’t quite tween, they ... Read more »

Remember 3G? It's going away as AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile shift to 5G. What to know about 3G shutdown

The 3G network shutdown is coming and mainly will affect older phones like iPhones before iPhone 6. As AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile usher in the 5G era, they’re also about ... Read more »

The CDC continues to recommend mask-wearing in schools—here are the best masks

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. As federal regulators work to authorize the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine for ... Read more »

Hide your clutter like a pro with these ideas

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. This past spring, Gallup revealed that the majority of white-collar workers ... Read more »

Chipotle is switching up the model that made it famous as it embraces changing consumer habits

© Hollis Johnson/Business Insider Hollis Johnson/Business Insider Chipotle is growing its digital business, which makes up nearly half of all orders. The chain is also pivoting to rely more on ... Read more »

Tesla's surge to record highs catapults Elon Musk's net worth to $250 billion

© REUTERS/Aly Song/File Photo/File Photo Tesla Inc CEO Elon Musk dances onstage during a delivery event for Tesla China-made Model 3 cars in Shanghai, China January 7, 2020. REUTERS/Aly Song/File ... Read more »

Here's why you should be using an air purifier—stat

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Air quality is a serious issue. It has made headlines over ... Read more »

Phunware extends 2-day gain to 2,189% as Trump campaign app developer rides Digital World hype

© EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP via Getty Images A stock trader claps at the end of trade at the New York Stock Exchange. EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP via Getty Images Phunware stock extended its ... Read more »

An analyst estimates the labor shortage is keeping McDonald's sales down by 3 to 4% from where they would be if stores had enough workers

© Hollis Johnson/Business Insider Hollis Johnson/Business Insider A lack of workers is keeping McDonald’s sales down, one analyst says. The restaurant industry is in crisis as some businesses close dining ... Read more »

Matt Gaetz tried to give himself, Lauren Boebert and MTG a nickname - and it backfired badly

© Getty Images GettyImages-1236029850.jpg On Thursday, Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) gave himself and two other Trump-supporting conservatives a nickname, implying that they would form a right-wing version to “The Squad,” ... Read more »

Cozy up with huge discounts on sweatshirts, joggers and more at Athleta

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Looking for cute and cozy holiday gifts? Athleta has you covered ... Read more »

Get up to 40% off Nike shoes, sweatshirts and more at this markdown sale

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Looking for some eye-catching athletic wear at savings worthy of Black ... Read more »

Delta, Alaska, United, and American flights were impacted after regional carrier SkyWest canceled hundreds of flights due to a system outage

© Heather Dunbar / Shutterstock.com A SkyWest Airlines Bombardier CRJ200 aircraft. Heather Dunbar / Shutterstock.com Regional carrier SkyWest Airlines canceled more than 1,000 flights over two days due to a ... Read more »

Squid Game sparks high-stakes battle for the internet

In the South Korean Netflix hit Squid Game, 456 heavily indebted characters are plunged into murderous children’s games for a chance to win £28m. The likes of “grandma’s footsteps” and tug ... Read more »

Anthony Scaramucci says the Trump media SPAC is 'garbage propaganda,' but if it does well enough it could keep the former president out of politics

© AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais, File Former Trump White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci surprised many in endorsing Biden last year. AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais, File AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais, ... Read more »

Apple's latest sci-fi drama Invasion starts out too dang slow

© Image: Apple For a show about an alien invasion, Invasion is decidedly lacking in aliens thus far. The latest sci-fi drama on Apple TV Plus, the series debuts with ... Read more »

12 of the best things to buy from the new Netflix store at Walmart

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re someone who spends most of their free time perusing—or ... Read more »

The supply-chain crisis is causing retailers to offer fewer sales and deals

© Provided by Business Insider KENA BETANCUR/AFP via Getty Images Global supply-chain issues are causing retailers to slash sales and deals. Traffic jams at ports and severe labor shortages are ... Read more »

Razer Wolverine V2 review: Razer's Xbox controller almost feels illegal

© Windows Central Razer Wolverine V2 Review 2021 Building a better mousetrap. Razer’s Wolverine controller for Xbox proved itself to be a capable alternative to the Xbox Elite Controller and ... Read more »

NHS waiting list may not be cleared until 2030 without ‘deeper and faster' reforms, Tony Blair Institute warn

The NHS waiting list backlog caused by the pandemic may not be cleared until the end of this decade unless the government carries out “deeper and faster” reforms than it ... Read more »

Trump's social network has 30 days to stop breaking the rules of its software license

The Software Freedom Conservancy (SFC) says former President Donald Trump’s new social network violated a free and open-source software licensing agreement by ripping off decentralized social network Mastodon. The Trump ... Read more »

Best Buy's early Black Friday sale ends today: here are the 10 best deals

Black Friday deals are dropping earlier than ever, and so far, they don’t disappoint. Best Buy’s early Black Friday sale launched earlier this week with record-low prices on 4K TVs, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic