‘People want us to say something more ambitious’: Inside a Labour party desperate to win power

‘Keir said he wanted to paint his vision in primary colours, and then getting to policy detail closer to an election. But it doesn’t feel like we are even doing the primary colours’

‘People want us to say something more ambitious’: Inside a Labour party desperate to win power

Kier Starmer has been accused of going missing but he is pinning his hopes of victory on being less hated than the Tories (Photo: Lindsey Parnaby/Getty)

By Chloe Chaplain, Arj Singh, Hugo Gye

Labour is being “outflanked on the left by the Government” due to the leadership’s refusal to dominate the debate on the cost of living crisis, backbenchers have warned.

What has been perceived by some as the party’s failure to step up this week – allowing headlines over skyrocketing energy bills to be dominated by Lib Dem leader Sir Ed Davey and former PM Gordon Brown – must be changed if Labour is to inspire voters and win the next elections, MPs said.

The Labour leadership, under Sir Keir Starmer, has a forensic focus on deliverable policy. And it is preparing unveil a long-awaited cost of living package which will focus on support for the vulnerable and plans to reduce energy usage.

But, for some Labour activists and politicians, this is wasted if the leadership is not able to grab hold of the political debate when the country is being thrust into crisis.

“There is the thing Keir said ages ago about painting his vision in primary colours, and then getting to the policy detail closer to an election,” a Labour backbencher said.

“But it doesn’t feel like we’re even doing the primary colours. Our only real policy on it has been the VAT cut… well Liz Truss is offering more than that at the moment.

“Technically speaking, we are being outflanked from the left by the Government. Not really an ideal place for the Labour Party to be in.”

They said Labour-supporting constituents were crying out for more leadership from the party on cost of living issues.

“There’s clearly that appetite from people who want us to say something better and more ambitious,” they said.

Another backbencher said: “I think you’ve got a belief within the leadership’s office that you do not say too much, do not promise too much, watch the Tories fall into disarray, profit from that… and think that will be enough when it comes to an election.

“What that misses is that you actually need to give people a reason to leave their homes to go to the polling station and vote for you. That requires some ideas and a vision and a clear message.”

Some in the Labour movement have backed the “Enough is Enough” campaign, which is demanding urgent action to ensure fairer bills and wages. One of these is Labour MP Zarah Sultana.

She told i the Labour leadership is too focused on testing out policy ideas through polling and focus groups which, she said, is holding it back from being reactive.

“We are going through an unprecedented cost of living crisis, people are really scared and the Labour leadership has been completely missing in action. People need the party to be standing up for them and it simply hasn’t been doing that,” she said.

“Put bluntly the leadership just doesn’t have a clear vision or message. Not being Boris Johnson wasn’t enough. Now Boris is going, you can’t keep putting that framing of ‘we’re not Boris or we’re not the Tories’ – the country needs to see a real alternative.

“Every MP is getting emails, talking to constituents that are in really desperate situations. There is a real exasperation.”

Keir Starmer with shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves (Photo: Getty)

Sir Keir’s office is adamant that the decision to delay a full announcement on Labour’s energy policy was deliberate – claiming that allowing the Conservative leadership contenders to take the flack for their own plans would help discredit them in the eyes of voters.

“What’s that old saying about not interrupting your enemies when they are making a mistake?”, a source close to Sir Keir said.

“The longer the Tories, especially Liz Truss, dig their heels in the better that is for us.”

Labour sources also said it was always the party’s plan to wait for the latest energy predictions before announcing policy. It’s all part of the strategy of well-thought through and tested proposals to ensure any future manifesto is watertight. And it’s a deliberate step-change from former leader Jeremy Corbyn’s emphasis on vision and ideology – without the forensic detail.

But is it really working? After 12 years of Conservative power, dominated by crises, scandals and political misjudgement, you would be forgiven for thinking Labour would be skipping ahead in the polls now. Instead, less than two years out to the next election, it would seem the party’s tentative 10-point lead – against an essentially leaderless party – is actually falling.

The party is getting on an election footing by compiling dossiers against Government rivals, curating its image as financial sensible and getting ready to pounce on traditionally Tory policy areas where the Government has been failing, such a crime and immigration.

Sir Keir does not know yet who he will be up against – Rishi Sunak or Liz Truss. But ever since the Owen Paterson affair last year, when Mr Johnson’s premiership began to look pretty precarious, Labour has been burrowing away potentially negative information about his likely replacement.

And in the lead up to the election a team of Labour researchers will be scouring over the record of the newly formed Government in order to prepare attack lines. “That’s definitely what they do so I am sure they have got something up their sleeve,” one Labour source said. “There is a whole group of people who do that.”

If it sounds like Labour is gearing up for a dirty tricks campaign, it’s because the party knows these things end up being a game of who is disliked the least.

Dr Will Jennings, polling expert and professor at Southampton University explained that Sir Keir does not have to be popular, he just has to be the least unpopular – which, according to recent YouGov polling, he is.

“All you need to do is look back at the last election where disliking Jeremy Corbyn was a big factor. Keir Starmer has not got amazing ratings, but it’s all relative,” he said.

“Boris Johnson’s ratings in 2019 were worse in Theresa May in 2017. There is the myth he was deeply popular, but he was just more popular than Corbyn.”

But a Labour backbencher said they did not think these kind of tactics would be enough to cut through the political apathy, and encourage disheartened voters to back Labour.

“I think there is a very safe game being played but I don’t think it’s working,” they said. “People just identify you as boring as bland, don’t know what you stand for. And unless we actually have policies, I think just not being as unpopular, is just not going to cut it.”

One thing everyone does agree on is that this election is going to be dominated by the economy. The party that is perceived to have the best grip on the looming financial crisis will be the party that wins. This is why Labour has been carefully creating its new message around economic growth and stability. And the incoming PM will have little time for anything else.

“You’re going to have an NHS crisis and an economic crisis. Even if well-managed, they are going to take up a huge amount of focus,” Dr Jennings said.

“The scope for promises about tax cuts or other sorts of policies or any other sort of cultural politics are really going to go out the window. This belief that there’s going to be a kind of honeymoon period – I mean, they are in denial…”

By the time we get to the next election, the Tory PM may have run out of political capital responding to the recession alone. Then they would be faced with a tough contest on two fronts – fighting for both traditional Tory seats and newer Red wall areas.

A red wall Tory MP said it would be “difficult” for the Conservatives to win. “Everything depends on the economy,” they said. “If we get that right then we are okay, nothing else is going to matter really.”

A senior Labour MP added: “It’s going to be about living standards, getting people into work and fixing the NHS. It’s like when Bill Clinton took on George Bush after 12 years of the Republicans – ‘it’s the economy stupid but don’t forget health’.”

Healthcare is familiar stomping ground for Labour – but this election could also represent an opportunity for the party to encroach on traditionally Tory policy areas like crime and immigration.

Adam Hawksbee, deputy director and head of levelling up at influential Tory think-tank Onward said the Conservatives could fall flat on issues like crime and immigration – both top of Conservative voters’ priorities in both the Red wall and Southern heartlands.

“But the party doesn’t have a great story to tell on these issues,” he said. “The next PM needs to have a laser-like focus on addressing this, or it will be a vulnerable flank for Labour to exploit.”

“There has been a tendency in the past of immigration being a really tricky topic,” one Labour source said. “But the idea now is that we have a plan, we have a plan that will work.

“There is no slogan that is going to fix this. It’s about being realistic – if you sound tough without having the stuff to back it up, it comes across as hollow.”

In the meantime, can Sir Keir sell a strong enough vision whilst keeping a grip on the restless left-wing of the party?

As a Tory MP put it: “The leadership election is destroying us but I still think it’s amazing that despite us tearing chunks out of each other Labour still seems to be cocking things up for themselves. It is spectacular. Keir Starmer is such a gift, long may he reign.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Op-Ed: How juvenile white sharks in search of warmer waters disrupt life off the California coast

Since 2014, when a marine heat wave scientists dubbed “the blob” encroached on the Central Coast, juvenile white sharks have been following warmer currents to waters they didn’t usually inhabit. ... Read more »

Op-Ed: Here’s how companies can strong-arm their suppliers into cutting carbon emissions

The Inflation Reduction Act is both the most important federal climate legislation ever and sadly inadequate to protect the U.S. and the world from the effects of climate change. Where ... Read more »

Defiant Liz Truss vows to ‘win hearts and minds’ as she presses ahead with the rest of her mini-Budget after 45p u-turn

DEFIANT Liz Truss this morning vowed to “win hearts and minds” with her tax-cutting agenda in the face of a fresh Tory revolt. The PM said she will “press ahead” ... Read more »

Welcome to a billion-dollar art sale that will go down in history

Georges Seurat’s Les Poseuses (petite version) is part of Paul Allen’s collection and has a record-busting $100 million estimate If you thought Paris had taken centre stage in the European ... Read more »

NFL Power Rankings for Week 5: Eagles living in pure bliss

Do Philadelphia Eagles fans even remember how to boo these days? The notoriously sour fanbase first showered a standing ovation on former head coach Doug Pederson in his first game ... Read more »

'I feel like my immune system is attacking my face': Louise Thompson shares picture of 'horrendous' rash and reveals her son Leo is suffering from a perforated ear drum

Louise Thompson has shared pictures of a rash on her face as she admitted she feels like her immune system is ‘attacking her’. The former Made In Chelsea star, 32, ... Read more »

Jeremy Paxman documentary: Putting Up with Parkinson’s release date, who is University Challenge presenter?

Veteran broadcaster and television host Jeremy Paxman will share his experience of living with Parkinson’s disease for the first time in a new ITVdocumentary. Putting Up with Parkinson’s will explore ... Read more »

Meghan Markle releases delayed fourth episode of Archetypes podcast after it was postponed following death of the Queen

The Duchess of Sussex’s Archetypes podcast has resumed on Spotify after a four-week break following the death of the Queen. Meghan, in her latest episode released today, explores the ‘Dragon ... Read more »

Mortgage Mayhem Sparks Fears of a Housing Market Crash in Britain

There are growing fears of a housing market crash in the U.K., after a swathe of tax cuts announced by the government sent interest rate expectations soaring, driving up lending ... Read more »

California scientist, two others share Nobel physics prize for work on quantum mechanics

STOCKHOLM —  A California scientist and two European researchers won the Nobel Prize in physics Tuesday for their work on quantum mechanics. The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences in Stockholm announced ... Read more »

Wednesday's racing tips for Nottingham, Kempton and Sedgefield

Tough Enough sets a very tall standard for the others to aim at in the British Racing EBF Novice Stakes at Nottingham on Wednesday. Read more »

Video: Martin Lewis demands Government DELETES 'irresponsible' tweet suggesting first-time buyers in London on a £30,000 salary can buy a £600,000 terraced home 

Read more »

Chinese artist turns COVID-19 tests into art to represent the pandemic life in China

Artist Siyuan Zhuji’s artwork titled “Shengji” illustrates COVID-19 tests to bring awareness to the Coronavirus pandemic in China. VIA REUTERS For most of China’s 1.4 billion people, regular COVID-19 tests ... Read more »

$80,000 and 5 ER visits: An ectopic pregnancy takes a toll

A color-enhanced scan of an ectopic pregnancy, which develops outside the uterus — often inside a fallopian tube. Such pregnancies are never viable and, unless ended, can lead to rupture ... Read more »

I started a side-hustle aged 9 selling my pet hens’ eggs for pocket money – now I run a multi-million-pound business

A NIFTY nine-year-old who started selling his hens' eggs for pocket money is now running a multi-million-pound business empire. Josh Murray first realised his pets had profit potential back in ... Read more »

After years of waiting, rare turtles have bred 41 hatchlings at the San Diego Zoo

One of the Indian narrow-headed softshell turtle hatchlings bred at the San Diego Zoo. Ken Bohn/San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance hide caption toggle caption Ken Bohn/San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance ... Read more »

UK weather – Brits soaked by torrential rain TODAY – and it’s only going to get worse as ‘danger to life’ warning hits

BRITS will be soaked by torrential rain today – and it's going to get worse with a warning for fierce 'danger to life' winds tomorrow. Heavy downpours will drench parts ... Read more »

Water companies fined: which 11 firms have been fined by Ofwat - why are customers getting a refund on bills?

Eleven out of 17 in England and Wales have been and forced to give money off customers’ bills. The companies have been fined for missing their targets resulting in multi-million ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing leaderboard live: who tops the charts after Week 2, and who went from BBC show?

is now underway with a The judging panel including Shirley Ballas, Motsi Mabuse, Anton Du Beke and Craig Revel Horwood will expect to see further improvements from the contestants as ... Read more »

We wake up with bed bugs on our faces in horror infestation – but the council won’t move us in case we take them with us

A “DESPERATE” family are crying out for help after being stuck in a bed bug infested house for over a year. Mum Sharon Brookes, 52, says her family of four ... Read more »

Moeen Ali doubles down on decision to quit Test cricket after briefly considering a return

Moeen Ali has ruled out playing Test cricket for England in the future, despite briefly considering a return under Brendon McCullum in the summer. Read more »

The landmark Voting Rights Act faces further dismantling at the Supreme Court

Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images The U.S. Supreme Court hears arguments on Tuesday in a case that could put another nail in the coffin of the landmark Voting Rights Act, first passed ... Read more »

Christophe Soumillon has Aga Khan retainer ended with immediate effect

Christophe Soumillon has had his retainer with the Aga Khan ended with immediate effect following last week’s incident at Saint-Cloud. Read more »

Meghan Markle & Prince Harry think they’re ‘superheroes set to save the planet’ in new portraits, says body language pro

PRINCE Harry and wife Meghan give an aura of “dutiful superheroes” in their newly-released official portraits, according to body language expert Judi James. The pictures of the couple were taken ... Read more »

‘The Shrink Next Door’ Podcast Host & Writer Joe Nocera Forging Two Audible Shows

Joe Nocera Caitlyn Gaurano EXCLUSIVE: The Shrink Next Door podcast host and writer Joe Nocera is creating two Audible true-crime podcasts. Nocera will co-write and host the as-yet-untitled non-fiction shows ... Read more »

Congestion pricing? How about bulldozer blades on buses?

Traffic makes its way past Radio City along a cross-street in Manhattan, New York city on September 22, 2022. – NY state governor Kathy Hochul announced September 29, 2022 that ... Read more »

Beloved, besieged Social Security

Closeup detail of several Social Security Cards representing finances and retirement (Shutterstock) “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.” That famous phrase from Charles Dickens ... Read more »

'Emotionally, it's been the hardest period of my life': Molly-Mae Hague reveals she 'cries five times a day' as she details her pregnancy journey

Molly-Mae Hague has admitted she has ‘cried five times a day’ during her early pregnancy she updated her fans on Monday. The influencer, 23, said she has found the experience ... Read more »

Iran's president tries to appease public anger as protests spread to schools

Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi addresses the parliament in a vote of confidence session for his proposed labor minister in Tehran, Iran, Tuesday, Oct. 4, 2022. Vahid Salemi/AP hide caption toggle ... Read more »

'Don't try this at home!' Amanda Holden, 51, flashes her legs in a black miniskirt as she hilariously wears stilettos while using exercise machine

Amanda Holden joked with her fans as she hilariously wore stilettos while attempting to use a stepper exercise machine in a Tuesday Instagram post.  The TV personality, 51, flashed her ... Read more »

DeFi Tokens in Chainlink, Lido Finance, Maker DAO Jump 7%

New updates for Chainlink, post-merge improvements for Lido, and Maker’s impressive revenues have helped these DeFi tokens take flight. Read more »

The best hot water bottles to keep you warm and cosy this winter

Hot water bottles come in various sizes, from pocket-sized miniatures to extra-long styles. (Getty Images) Whether you're somebody who's permanently cold, you'll know how game-changing a hot water bottle can ... Read more »

Emily Ratajkowski: why model is criticising Netflix for Marilyn Monroe movie Blonde starring Ana de Armas

, 31, from New York took to TikTok to criticise the new Netflix film based on the life of Marilyn Monroe. The movie named Blonde is based off the fictional ... Read more »

The national park that reversed the destruction of civil war

safari holidays africa wildlife travel conservation pangolins – Simon Parker “You just missed the painted dogs,” said our guide, Richard Lusinga, as we signed the campsite’s indemnity forms and checked ... Read more »

Trial begins over alleged rape in Australia's parliament

Bruce Lehrmann is charged with raping fellow staffer Brittany Higgins in the then-defence industry minister Linda Reynolds' office in Parliament House in March 2019. Read more »

Stop Questioning People's Invisible Illnesses – It's None Of Your Business

Double Paralympic gold medallist Kadeena Cox. (Photo: JUSTIN TALLIS via Getty Images) Double Paralympic gold medallist Kadeena Cox. (Photo: JUSTIN TALLIS via Getty Images) Paralympian Kadeena Cox lives with multiple ... Read more »

'It scared the hell out of me': Strictly's Matt Goss reveals he was the victim of an attempted abduction as a child

The singer, 54, revealed a man tried to 'snatch' him into a car when he was seven Matt admitted it 'scared the hell out of me' and he still remembers the man's face Read more »

Payments Giant Mastercard Launches Cryptocurrency Anti-Fraud Tool for Card Issuers

Mastercard’s Crypto Secure product helps banks to determine the risk of crime associated with crypto exchanges on its payment network. Read more »

PICTURE EXCLUSIVE: Elizabeth Debicki is Diana's double as she films scenes for The Crown 'showing the princess's 1997 visit to Angola' where she toured landmine sites months before her death

Elizabeth Debicki donned a navy blazer as she transformed into Princess Diana for The Crown's sixth seriesThe Australian actress, 32, bore an uncanny resemblance to the late royal as she filmed scenes in SpainThe scenes portrayed the royal as she arrived at Luanda Airport Angola at the start of her Red Cross visit Read more »

Tower of Fantasy on Steam has a release date

The Steam page for Tower of Fantasy apparently has listed its release date, which is on October 20th this year. Tower of Fantasy was already available to add to your ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network