Penn president responds to backlash over testimony on antisemitism

penn president responds to backlash over testimony on antisemitism

Penn president responds to backlash over testimony on antisemitism

The president of the University of Pennsylvania released a video late Wednesday walking back some of her testimony at a congressional hearing this week about antisemitism on campus after calls for her resignation followed her remarks.

In the video, Liz Magill said she should have responded differently to questions Tuesday from Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) about whether calls for the genocide of Jewish people would violate university policies.

“I was not focused on, but I should have been, the irrefutable fact that a call for genocide of Jewish people is a call for some of the most terrible violence human beings can perpetrate,” Magill said Wednesday. “It’s evil, plain and simple.”

On Thursday, some Penn trustees met virtually for an informal gathering, a university spokesman said.

Magill has led Penn since July 2022 after previously serving as executive vice president and provost of the University of Virginia and a professor and dean at Stanford Law School.

She became the focus of forceful condemnations on and off campus after her remarks Tuesday before a House committee that summoned Magill, Harvard University President Claudine Gay and Massachusetts Institute of Technology president Sally Kornbluth to testify about efforts to stop antisemitism on their campuses since the war in Israel and Gaza.

White House, lawmakers criticize university leaders’ answers on antisemitism

The presidents were pressed by Stefanik to answer whether calls for the genocide of Jews would violate university code of conduct or rules on bullying and harassment.

Magill said such speech would violate the school’s code of conduct “if the speech turns into conduct, it can be harassment. Yes.” Pressed further by Stefanik, Magill said: “It is a context-dependent decision, congresswoman.”

Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro (D), said Magill’s comments were “absolutely shameful.”

“It should not be hard to condemn genocide,” he said Wednesday in Philadelphia while visiting a Jewish-owned restaurant that was the site of a recent pro-Palestinian protest.

Shapiro, who is a nonvoting trustee of Penn, told reporters the university’s board needed to make a “serious decision” on whether Magill should represent the institution.

Pressure to act mounted quickly on and off campus. A petition calling for Magill’s resignation had more than 15,000 signatures as of Thursday afternoon. The rabbi and co-presidents of Penn Hillel said Wednesday in a statement: “President Magill’s refusal to draw a line around any antisemitic speech — no matter how vitriolic and hateful — as a violation of Penn’s policies, is extremely disappointing. If there is any ambiguity with respect to the Code’s application to this type of threat, it should be immediately amended.”

The New York Times also reported that Marc Rowan, the chief executive of Apollo Global Management and chair of the board at Penn’s Wharton School of Business, sent a letter to trustees asking: “How much damage to our reputation are we willing to accept?”

College leaders have faced intense scrutiny over statements and other actions made in recent months as they seek to balance free-speech traditions and protections while also trying to prevent bias and hate.

Magill’s video message Wednesday acknowledged she had not found the right balance in her congressional testimony. She stopped short of apologizing.

“In that moment I was focused on our university’s long-standing policies aligned with the U.S. Constitution which say that speech alone is not punishable,” Magill said.

Magill also said the university would review its policies, which she said had been long guided by the constitution and law. “In today’s world where we are seeing signs of hate proliferating across our campus and our world in a way not seen in years, these policies need to be clarified and evaluated.”

In recent weeks, Magill had issued statements condemning antisemitic emails to Penn staff and “vile” messages projected on several campus buildings. “Our Jewish community is afraid. Our Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian communities feel unseen and unheard. I condemn the death threats and doxing that many at Penn are experiencing based only on their identity, their affiliations, or their views of the suffering in this war,” Magill told trustees in early November.

Free speech advocates said tightening policies on self-expression is not the solution.

“Were Penn to retreat from the robust protection of expressive rights, university administrators would make inevitably political decisions about who may speak and what may be said on campus,” the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression said in a statement. “Such a result would undoubtedly compromise the knowledge-generating process free expression enables and for which universities exist.

Facing criticism, Harvard’s president on Wednesday also sought to clarify the congressional testimony. “There are some who have confused a right to free expression with the idea that Harvard will condone calls for violence against Jewish students,” Gay said. “Let me be clear: Calls for violence or genocide against the Jewish community, or any religious or ethnic group are vile, they have no place at Harvard, and those who threaten our Jewish students will be held to account.”

Palestinian Americans face fear, violence amid Israel’s war in Gaza

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has long been a source of debate on college campuses, and tensions were reignited since the surprise Oct. 7 attack by Hamas that killed at least 1,200 people in Israel. About 80 percent of Gaza’s population of more than 2 million has been displaced during Israeli military actions in the aftermath, according to the United Nations.

In addition to concerns about antisemitism, campuses also are trying to protect against Islamophobia and other bias. The Education Department has opened investigations into several colleges and K-12 institutions, including Harvard, over allegations of antisemitism or Islamophobia.

While there had been a rise in hate crimes in the United States even before the war, federal officials reported in late October that they were responding to more threats against Arab, Jewish and Muslim communities as the conflict intensified.

News Related


Lawsuit seeks $16 million against Maryland county over death of pet dog shot by police

A department investigator accused two of the officers of “conduct unbecoming an officer” for entering the apartment without a warrant, but the third officer was cleared of wrongdoing, the suit says. Read more »

Heidi Klum shares rare photo of all 4 of her and Seal's kids

Heidi Klum posted a rare picture with husband Tom Kaulitz and her four kids: Leni, 19, Henry, 18, Johan, 17, and Lou, 14, having some quality family time. Read more »

European stocks head for flat open as markets struggle to find momentum

This is CNBC’s live blog covering European markets. European markets are heading for a flat open Tuesday, continuing lackluster sentiment seen at the start of the week in the region ... Read more »

Linda C. Black Horoscopes: November 28

Nancy Black Today’s Birthday (11/28/23). This year energizes your work and health. Faithful domestic routines provide central support. Shift directions to balance your work and health, before adapting around team ... Read more »

Michigan Democrats poised to test ambitious environmental goals in the industrial Midwest

FILE – One of more than 4,000 solar panels constructed by DTE Energy lines a 9.37-acre swath of land in Ann Arbor Township, Mich., Sept. 15, 2015. Michigan will join ... Read more »

Gaza Is Falling Into ‘Absolute Chaos,’ Aid Groups Say

A shaky cease-fire between Israel and Hamas has allowed a surge of aid to reach Palestinians in Gaza, but humanitarian groups and civilians in the enclave say the convoys aren’t ... Read more »

Bereaved Israeli and Palestinian families to march together in anti-hate vigil

Demonstrators march against the rise of antisemitism in the UK on Sunday – SUSANNAH IRELAND/REUTERS Bereaved Israeli and Palestinian families will march together as part of an anti-hate vigil on ... Read more »
Top List in the World