Patrick Stewart Vs. James McAvoy: Here's Who Played The Best Professor X

Asia's Tech News Daily

Patrick Stewart Vs. James McAvoy: Here's Who Played The Best Professor X
Albert L. Ortega/Getty

Though the franchise is now effectively finished, at least for now, thanks to the purchase of Fox by Disney, the “X-Men” films were perhaps vital in launching the blockbuster comic book movies that fans are all too used to today. In fact, some have argued that the original “X-Men” from 2000 is the most important superhero film ever made (per Nerdist). Not only were they important for comic book films, but they also helped bring to life several fan-favorite comic book characters. While Hugh Jackman’s interpretation of Wolverine may have garnered the most popularity, with a trilogy of solo films dedicated to the character, it was also a net positive for others.

One of those characters was Charles Xavier, the de facto leader of the X-Men and a powerful mutant in his own right. Patrick Stewart portrayed the older, wiser version of the character through the first three “X-Men” films. In the 2010s, James McAvoy stepped into the role of a younger Xavier in the spin-off prequel “X-Men: First Class” and then again in subsequent installments, some of which blurred both the past and present timelines. Both actors brought their own unique twist on the character, but who best inhabited the traits that make Professor X such a legendary character? Well, it’s not exactly an easy answer, and it’ll largely depend on what one expects from their Professor X.

Patrick Stewart as older, comic accurate Professor X

Patrick Stewart Vs. James McAvoy: Here's Who Played The Best Professor X
Fox

There are specific roles that seem tailor-made for certain actors, especially when it comes to comic book adaptations. Over the on r/movies subreddit, u/jadamsmash created a post in 2016 stating that they believed Patrick Stewart was the quintessential Professor X. “Patrick Stewart IS professor X. He looks exactly like him,” they said. “He has that stoic look, the wisdom, the accent, the class, the commanding presence, and everything. I can’t think of a character/actor match as good in nearly any medium.”

The post has over 20 thousand upvotes on Reddit, so it’s clear that this isn’t an isolated opinion. Stewart played the role several times throughout Fox’s “X-Men” franchise, culminating in “Logan.” In fact, his portrayal of the character was so spot-on that, according to an interview that the actor did in 2020 with Digital Spy, Stewart had conversations with Disney Studios president Kevin Feige about potentially returning as the character. Of course, he also said it wouldn’t happen because he was happy with how “Logan” wrapped the story up, but even having discussions with Feige is a testament to how beloved Stewart’s Professor X is.

James McAvoy as a younger, more egocentric Professor X

Patrick Stewart Vs. James McAvoy: Here's Who Played The Best Professor X
Fox

James McAvoy brought an entirely different kind of performance to the role of Professor X during his time as the character, which started in “X-Men: First Class.” Over on the r/Marvel subreddit, u/Regime-leader asked users what their opinion was on McAvoy’s portrayal of Professor X. Mostly, the comments were positive, with the top comment being from u/DaveyBoyblue. “Think he played it very well,” they said. “Prof X is an extremely flawed character, his ego driving so many decisions and self-justification for his actions that lead to so much harm and that was captured well.”

So while McAvoy’s performance may not have been entirely comic accurate like Stewart’s, McAvoy brought a lot of the ego that comic fans would frequently see from the character in the source material. Professor X was also more of a central character during McAvoy’s tenure, which meant that it was something more of a meatier role for the actor. This certainly allowed him more time to develop a more three-dimensional character.

Stewart slightly edges McAvoy out as the better Professor X

Patrick Stewart Vs. James McAvoy: Here's Who Played The Best Professor X
Fox

It’s clear that both James McAvoy and Patrick Stewart brought a lot of their own considerable talent to the role of Professor X. It’s almost nearly impossible to decide with any level of certainty who did a better job. Still, there’s one film that could edge Stewart just slightly ahead. “Logan” saw Stewart step into the role of a much older Professor X, who’s dealing with dementia, which has made his telepathic powers dangerous and unstable. It’s an entirely new take on the character, and “Logan” was praised for Stewart’s performance and the film’s other leading performances. In fact, the film has one of the highest Rotten Tomatoes scores of the whole franchise, sitting at 94%.

It’s perhaps for this performance alone that Stewart narrowly edges out McAvoy’s, though that’s by no means a statement of fact. Still, there was even speculation that Stewart would receive a nomination for Best Supporting Actor at the Oscars (per The Hollywood Reporter), though that ultimately did not happen. Awards or not, it’s a brilliant and heartbreaking interpretation of the character that, while not comic accurate, will likely stand as one of the best performances in a comic book film.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

The Matrix Scene That Went Too Far

Warner Bros. To say that 1999’s “The Matrix” was a game changer in the cinematic landscape is a massive understatement. The film follows Neo (Keanu Reeves), a mild-mannered cog in ... Read more »

Javier Bardem Confirms What We All Suspected About Johnny Depp's On-Set Behavior

Rich Fury/Getty As he has risen to the absolute highest level of his profession, Javier Bardem has worked with some of the biggest names in the acting game. One of ... Read more »

The Character Everyone Forgot Ashley Tisdale Played In Donnie Darko

Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images 2001’s “Donnie Darko” can be a confusing movie upon first watch. The film plays on elements of both sci-fi and psychological thrillers, so it can leave viewers ... Read more »

The Studio Ghibli Character Everyone Forgets Christian Bale Played

Denis Makarenko/Shutterstock Legendary Japanese animation company Studio Ghibli, behind such classics as “Spirited Away,” “Princess Mononoke,” and “My Neighbor Totoro,” was founded by Hayao Miyazaki, Isao Takahata, and Toshio Suzuki. ... Read more »

Why Future Sophie From How I Met Your Father Looks So Familiar

Ovidiu Hrubaru/Shutterstock “How I Met Your Father” has landed on Hulu, serving as a spinoff of the very successful “How I Met Your Mother,” which went off the air in ... Read more »

Most Memorable Iron Man Quotes In The MCU

Marvel Studios/Disney The current era of the MCU is without Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr.). His legacy lives on, though as he’s still mentioned in the newest films, and the ... Read more »

Here's How Much Iron Man's House Would Actually Cost

Paramount Pictures/Marvel Studios As anyone who’s seen “Iron Man 3” knows, Tony Starks’ massive modern mansion was completely destroyed at the hands of a man who called himself The Mandarin ... Read more »

Movies Like Menace II Society That Crime Fans Need To See

New Line Cinema It’s easy to assume that the people making the films you watch are a great deal older than you, but sometimes a tremendous young talent emerges to ... Read more »

(Yonhap Interview) Kang Ha-neul creates own clumsy pirate character through hairstyle in 'The Pirates'

By Kim Boram SEOUL, Jan. 18 (Yonhap) — In the upcoming action adventure movie “The Pirates: The Last Royal Treasure,” actor Kang Ha-neul takes the role of Muchi, an offhand, ... Read more »

The X-Men: Days Of Future Past Scene Michael Fassbender Regrets Filming

Featureflash Photo Agency Shutterstock Michael Fassbender has been working non-stop since he kicked off his acting career in 2001 with a supporting role in the Emmy-winning HBO mini-series “Band of ... Read more »

Why Constantine From Law & Order: Organized Crime Looks So Familiar

Virginia Sherwood/NBC Fans of “Law & Order: Organized Crime” have been thrilled by the character of Sebastian McClane, a master hacker whose storyline contains echoes of real-life cases like the ... Read more »

How Daniel Radcliffe Really Felt About Quidditch In The Harry Potter Movies

Noam Galai/Getty Some of the most unique elements of the “Harry Potter” franchise are the visually stimulating Quidditch matches. Invented by “Harry Potter” author J.K. Rowling, Quidditch is a sport which places ... Read more »

The Untold Truth Of Maggie Smith

landmarkmedia/Shutterstock There are certain actors whom you don’t know a great deal about but are always glad to see on screen. Dame Margaret “Maggie” Natalie Smith is one such actress who ... Read more »

The DC Comics Easter Egg In The Accountant Isn't What You'd Think

Kathy Hutchins/Shutterstock Director Gavin O’Connor’s “The Accountant” is a film that has received more attention since its theatrical release in 2016. Despite the film getting a 52% on Rotten Tomatoes, ... Read more »

The Most Bizarre Horror And Sci-Fi Movies About Insects From Around The World

Grosso-Jacobson Productions When it comes to insects in horror and science fiction, we all know the king-sized variety: the oversized ants in “Them!”, the monster-god Mothra in Toho’s Godzilla series, ... Read more »

The Cheesy Horror Classic You Forgot Starred Jennifer Aniston

Amy Sussman/Getty Images Jennifer Aniston became a household name during her 10-year stint playing Rachel Green on “Friends,” one of the most famous sitcoms of all time. Not only did ... Read more »

[INTERVIEW] Han Hyo-joo stars as treasure-seeking hero in 'Pirates 2'

Actress Han Hyo-joo / Courtesy of BH Entertainment By Kwak Yeon-soo Actress Han Hyo-joo has taken on a new challenge by starring in the stunt-heavy, adventure fantasy film “The Pirates: ... Read more »

Best Movies And TV Shows About People Surviving In The Wilderness

20th Century Fox Showtime’s buzzy series “Yellowjackets” is the latest in a long line of movies and TV shows focused upon humans surviving in the wilderness. Whether on a tropic ... Read more »

The Cheesy '80s Comedy You Forgot Starred Jason Bateman

Frazer Harrison/Getty Images Actor Jason Bateman has been working in Hollywood since the early 1980s when he appeared on the TV series, “Little House on the Prairie,” as the character ... Read more »

The Real Reason Jack Nicholson Turned Down This Iconic Mafia Movie

360b/Shutterstock With multiple Oscars and a career stretching back to the 1950s, few actors are as famous or esteemed in Hollywood as Jack Nicholson. He’s been in countless iconic movies, ... Read more »

The Real Reason There Was A Doctor On Set While Shooting After We Fell

Voltage Pictures/YouTube The latest installment of the “After” film series is releasing this week and it’s taking the steaminess to a whole new level. The series that famously started off ... Read more »

The Timeline Mistake You Missed In Black Widow

Film Frame/Marvel Studios The 2021 Marvel Studios film “Black Widow” begins with a shot of the sunlight streaming through the trees, and then a young Natasha Romanoff (Ever Anderson), blue ... Read more »

The Entire Madrigal Family Tree In Encanto Explained

Walt Disney Studios “Encanto” is a charming addition to the Disney canon. The 60th film from the Disney Animation studio catalog is full of magic and whimsy. It achieves a ... Read more »

Why The Oranges In The Godfather Mean More Than You Think

Paramount Pictures You may have heard of a little film called “The Godfather.” Nowadays, as we near the 50th anniversary of Francis Ford Coppola’s seminal crime epic, it’s sometimes easier ... Read more »

The Top 10 Sports Movies According To The AFI

United Artists Starting in 1998 and ending in 2008, the American Film Institute published a series of lists of the greatest movies of all time, voted on by over 1500 ... Read more »

Against The Ice Release Date, Cast And Plot - What We Know So Far

Netflix/YouTube The 2010s, as a decade in film, was marked by a lot of conspicuous trends that got extensively pored over, analyzed, and discussed. But one genre that really took ... Read more »

The Character Everyone Forgets Tony Hawk Played In Police Academy 4

Doug Pensinger/Getty The “Police Academy” movies are often considered classics in the eyes of comedy fans. The basic premise of the first installment, released in 1984, involves a new mayor ... Read more »

Why Zook From 22 Jump Street Looks So Familiar

Columbia Pictures It’s safe to say that 2014’s “22 Jump Street” is one of the best comedy sequels of all time. Granted, the competition isn’t that tough, but even so, ... Read more »

23rd Jeonju film festival to open in April, host offline screenings

The 23rd Jeonju International Film Festival logo / Courtesy of the Jeonju International Film Festival organizing committee By Kwak Yeon-soo This year’s Jeonju International Film Festival, scheduled from April 28 ... Read more »

The Fantastic Four Easter Egg We Never Saw In Black Widow

Marvel Studios/Disney After some unexpected time away, Marvel Studios returned to the movies in full force in 2021. Though fans are still buzzing about the cameo-filled “Spider-Man: No Way Home” ... Read more »

NZ travel for movie buffs: The Power of the Dog set locations

As the Power of the Dog movie continues to enjoy box office and Golden Globes success, writer Alexia Santamaria reveals its Central Otago set locations. It’s no secret that many ... Read more »

Scream returns in a self-referential reboot

Scream was ahead of the game when its fourth installment in 2011 made fun of the idea of reboots within its very own reboot. So 11 years later what could ... Read more »

The Major Deadpool 2 Role John Cena Auditioned For

lev radin/Shutterstock For a certain set of fans, John Cena was, is, and ever will be one of the most memorable figures to ever grace the pro wrestling ranks of ... Read more »

The Reason J.J. Abrams Said Leia Didn't Use The Force In The Force Awakens

Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures/YouTube The “Star Wars” films first hit screens in 1977 with “Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope” and quickly exploded with an overwhelming amount ... Read more »

The Studio Ghibli Character Everyone Forgets Tina Fey Played

Ovidiu Hrubaru/Shutterstock It’s no secret to anyone what a versatile, sharp-minded, and hilarious writer and entertainer Tina Fey is. From her galvanizing early-2000s tenure on “Saturday Night Live” to her ... Read more »

The Studio Ghibli Character Everyone Forgets Matt Damon Played

Jamie Mccarthy/Getty Images Matt Damon could be considered a multilevel success when it comes to his résumé in Hollywood. His body of work as an actor speaks for itself. The ... Read more »

Marvel's Most Underrated Female Superheroes

Marvel Entertainment For 14 years, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has dominated the box office, creating millions of new comic book fans and breathing new life into hundreds of characters. In ... Read more »

Most Memorable Quotes From Movies

Orion Pictures Much like iconic song lyrics, movie quotes are something that just sticks with you, launching to the front of your brain whenever a certain circumstance triggers it — ... Read more »

X-Men: Apocalypse's Oscar Isaac Opens Up About His Nightmare On-Set Experience

Marvel/20th Century Fox In 2016, the “X-Men” franchise film “X-Men: Apocalypse” premiered, following up 2014’s time-traveling adventure “X-Men: Days of Future Past.” While the earlier film wowed critics and audiences, ... Read more »

Kristen Stewart finds common ground with the People's Princess in researching for Spencer

When Kristen Stewart was approached to play Princess Diana in Pablo Larrain’s impressionistic biopic, Spencer, she couldn’t quite believe what she was hearing. “When I first spoke to Pablo, he ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic