Parliament has never given up power to imprison people – Jacob Rees-Mogg

Asia's Tech News Daily

Parliament could still have the power to imprison witnesses who refuse to appear in front of MPs, according to Jacob Rees-Mogg, as he said the “untested nature” of powers last used more than 140 years ago may compel people to give evidence.

Parliament has never given up power to imprison people – Jacob Rees-Mogg
© Victoria Jones Leader of the House of Commons Jacob Rees-Mogg has spoken about Parliament’s powers (Victoria Jones/PA)

The Leader of the House said that while he did not advocate its use, Parliament had never formally abandoned the power which could be used to imprison those who do not attend select committee sessions when told to.

But he said he would not be against issuing fines for those who do not appear to give evidence, and the power to imprison could be an incentive to show up “because people aren’t entirely sure whether it would be effective or not”.

The Commons Privileges Committee was hearing from Mr Rees-Mogg as part of its discussion into powers to summon witnesses and call for documents after high-profile cases where witnesses refused to attend hearings to examine specific issues.

These had included in the past – either temporarily or permanently – Rupert Murdoch, Mike Ashley and Sir Philip Green.

A report released in April recommended new legislation be introduced to confirm historic powers to compel witnesses to attend or be held in contempt of Parliament.

Mr Rees-Mogg said the power to detain those who refuse to attend “had not been abandoned by Parliament”, although he said they had fallen into “desuetude”.

He told the committee that “Parliament has never formally given up its ability to imprison during the session of Parliament”.

But he said: “I think the reality of our powers is that we don’t know whether they are there or not until they are used and then you might find that they are upheld by the courts or you might find that they are not and this is an argument where learned lawyers disagree.”

🔔 We’ve published our report into Select committees and contempts.

📄 We’ve set out new proposals to strengthen select committee scrutiny and ensure fair treatment of witnesses.

⤵️ See our key recommendations here: https://t.co/m3hk7KqjN8 pic.twitter.com/REYMjEbMWY

— Privileges Committee (@HoCPrivileges) May 3, 2021

The last time someone was fined by Parliament was in 1666 when Thomas White was told to pay £1,000, roughly £200,000 today, after he absconded.

Mr White had been ordered into the custody of Parliament’s Serjeant at Arms for causing MP for Horsham Henry Chowne to be arrested and prevented from attending Parliament.

The power to imprison was last used in 1880 with the committal of a member, Charles Bradlaugh, and the imprisonment of a non-member Charles Grissell in the same year.

But the committee’s report said it was “generally considered that the House of Commons does not nowadays have the power to fine non-members” and previous reports have said “the House no longer retains its right to imprison”.

Committee chairman and Labour MP Chris Bryant said he was sure lawyers would disagree with Mr Rees-Mogg’s view.

He said: “So you are saying that you think that if the House were to come to you as Leader of the House, you would table a motion which would say we are now going to imprison such and such for refusing to attend?”

Parliament has never given up power to imprison people – Jacob Rees-Mogg
© Provided by PA Media Labour MP Chris Bryant questioned Mr Rees-Mogg (Yui Mok/PA)

Mr Rees-Mogg said he could not predict whether the motion would pass and that the discussion was “theoretical” but added: “The power has not been formally abandoned by Parliament.”

Asked whether he thought it would be “morally OK” for Parliament to imprison somebody, he said: “I am not saying with any degree of confidence that I don’t think this power if used would be challenged. Is it an effective power? I don’t know. But has it been formally abandoned by Parliament? No.”

Mr Rees-Mogg said it was an “important part” of the committee’s report to consider whether to test the historic powers before creating new legislation.

He added: “You may think that the untested nature of it, actually in and of itself, provides an incentive to attend because people aren’t entirely sure whether it would be effective or not.”

However, Mr Bryant said he was “still in a bit of shock about your belief that we still… that Parliament has the power to arrest and imprison because I think that that certainly went with the Human Rights Act and arguably went with the European Convention on Human Rights”.

The Leader of the House responded: “I’m not advocating arrest, I think imprisonment for non-attendance would be an extreme procedure.”

Parliament has never given up power to imprison people – Jacob Rees-Mogg
© Provided by PA Media Leader of the House of Commons Jacob Rees-Mogg said people could be fined or even imprisoned (James Manning/PA)

But he added that instead of creating legislation and inviting the courts to become involved in parliamentary affairs, he said: “I think…it is not unreasonable for the House to fine people for failing to attend.”

And he said: “I think the high court of Parliament should exercise its powers as (a) general principle and we are a sovereign parliament. We are higher than any court in the land. We shouldn’t be mealy-mouthed about being a parliament.”

Mr Rees-Mogg said: “I may be less committed to the niceties of human rights law, I think the supreme sovereign parliament, the democratic mandate, is the greatest protection of human rights in this country.”

Mr Bryant replied: “Wow. That is pretty extraordinary.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Amazon Republic Day Sale: 8 Kettles under Rs 1500 to pair up with your toaster for a complete breakfast setup

Whether you are an avid coffee lover or a hosteller in love with light night noodles, electric kettles are your perfect companion. It also makes up for a style statement and adds ... Read more »

Chelsea 'target' Ivan Perisic with boss Thomas Tuchel eager to bolster his wing-back options amid injuries to Ben Chilwell and Reece James... and Inter Milan 'could be open to selling Croatia star in January'

Ivan Perisic has emerged as a candidate to bolster Chelsea's wing-back optionsCroatia international has only another six months left on his Inter Milan dealHe is open to stay at the San Siro but only on an improved three-year contractWhile Serie A champions want him to sign a two-year deal on lower wagesChelsea have lost Ben Chilwell for the season to an ACL injury  Read more »

Ashling Murphy murder cops close in on fresh suspect as house searches gather key DNA evidence in hunt for killer

POLICE investigating the murder of teacher Ashling Murphy are closing in on a fresh suspect. Cops are conducting house searches to gather key DNA evidence as they frantically hunt for ... Read more »

Anthony Martial hits back at Ralf Rangnick's claim he refused to play for Man United versus Aston Villa

Manchester United forward Anthony Martial has denied the assertion that he refused to travel with the squad for Saturday’s draw at Aston Villa. © AP Anthony Martial jan 22 Interim ... Read more »

Here's How Yoga is Key to Recovery From Mental and Physical Trauma

© Provided by News18 Here’s How Yoga is Key to Recovery From Mental and Physical Trauma Excerpt – Yoga, which ensures the proper working of a human body in various ... Read more »

‘What a guy', ‘Great performance!' – Many Derby fans heap praise on defender after 2-0 win over Sheffield United

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Derby County v Reading Richard Stearman has been receiving praise for his role in Derby County’s 2-0 win over Sheffield United on ... Read more »

Darren Moore explains eye-catching Sheffield Wednesday selection call in Plymouth win

Sheffield Wednesday manager Darren Moore says midfielder Lewis Wing was left out of his side’s 4-2 win over Plymouth Argyle on Saturday, purely for selection reasons. Having joined the Owls ... Read more »

Kamal Haasan wishes Vijay Sethupathi on birthday with a sweet note. See adorable pic

Kamal Haasan wished Vijay Sethupathi on his birthday. Vijay Sethupathi is celebrating his 44th birthday today, January 16. On this special day, Ulaganayagan Kamal Haasan took to Twitter to wish ... Read more »

WATCH: Celtics two way player Sam Hauser scores 31 points, 9 boards with Maine Celtics

You might not have been thinking very much about Boston Celtics two way forward Sam Hauser given how much he has been playing with the parent club in recent weeks, ... Read more »

Anushka Sharma remembers MS Dhoni's joke a day after Virat Kohli became Test captain

© Provided by Zee News Anushka Sharma penned a healtfelt note for husband Virat Kohli after he stepped down as Indian Test captain.  In her latest Instagram post, she posted ... Read more »

‘You, my love, are limitless': Anushka Sharma's emotional note for Virat Kohli redefines love beyond Cricket frontiers

© Provided by Jagran English Mumbai | Jagran Sports Desk: A day after Virat Kohli sent shockwave across India and rest of the world by announcing his departure from Test ... Read more »

Short-ball shortcomings exposed again as Australia leave door ajar

© Getty Images Steven Smith ended the series without a century © Getty Images Usman Khawaja had a wry smile as he was asked on the third morning whether he ... Read more »

'Amazing scenes', 'Wow', 'Yessss' - Lots of Aston Villa fans react as 'crazy' exit news emerges

Galatasaray have reportedly opened talks with Aston Villa over a move for winger Trezeguet. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Aston Villa winger Trezeguet That’s according to Fanatik, as relayed by ... Read more »

South Korean Actress Honey Lee Announces Her Pregnancy

© Provided by News18 South Korean actress Honey Lee surprised the world by marrying in a private ceremony to her boyfriend, who is not a public figure, in the last ... Read more »

2022 ICC Under-19 World Cup: There is Room for Further Improvement in my Batting, Says U-19 Skipper Yash Dhull

© Provided by News18 2022 ICC Under-19 World Cup: There is Room for Further Improvement in my Batting, Says U-19 Skipper Yash Dhull India U-19 skipper Yash Dhull, despite scoring ... Read more »

Coronavirus: UAE reports 3,067 new cases and three deaths

© Provided by The National Dubai, United Arab Emirates: A health worker showing a swap at a newly opened low cost PCR testing tent that has the capacity to do ... Read more »

Britney Spears claims her family treated her worse than a death row inmate

© Bang Showbiz Britney Spears writes another open letter to Jamie Lynn amid their feud Britney Spears has said that her family treated her worse than a “death row” inmate ... Read more »

Janka beim Rücktritt nur kurz mit wässrigen Augen

© KEYSTONE/PETER SCHNEIDER Was im Riesenslalom im Dezember 2005 in Kranjska Gora mit dem Ausscheiden im ersten Lauf beginnt, endet für Carlo Janka gut 16 Jahre später beim Abfahrts-Klassiker in ... Read more »

Covid tests to be SCRAPPED for fully vaccinated Brit travellers in boost for half-term holidays

COVID tests for fully-vaccinated Brits returning to the UK are set to be scrapped in a major boost for half-term holidays. Day two tests have already been downgraded from PCRs ... Read more »

Sky host Trevor Phillips breaks down over death of daughter during lockdown as he grills MP over No10 party

VETERAN broadcaster Trevor Phillips broke down this morning as he discussed his daughter's death while grilling a top politician over lockdown parties. Freelance journalist Sushila Phillips, 36, died in April 2021 ... Read more »

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer blamed for creating Manchester United problem under Ralf Rangnick

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has been blamed for the problems Ralf Rangnick has faced in keeping his Manchester United players happy so far. Despite the change in management this season, United’s ... Read more »

Tovino Thomas's 'Naradhan' cleared with U/A certificate, film release postponed

© IANS Naradhan cleared with U A certificate. Chennai, Jan 16 (IANS) Director Aashiq Abu’s Malayalam film ‘Naradan’, featuring Tovino Thomas and Anna Ben in the lead, has been cleared ... Read more »

State tableau rejected again for R-Day

© Provided by The Statesman State tableau rejected again for R-Day The Centre has yet again rejected West Bengal’s Republic Day tableau. This time, the theme of the tableau was ... Read more »

‘Faultless', ‘Wow' – Plenty of Blackburn fans rave about one man after win over Cardiff

Blackburn Rovers continued their push for Championship promotion on Saturday afternoon, with a 1-0 win away at Cardiff City. Joe Rothwell’s long range strike into the bottom corner 14 minutes ... Read more »

India daily COVID-19 case count reaches eight-month peak: Live

India has reported its highest daily count of new novel coronavirus infections, with more than 271,000 cases recorded in the last 24 hours. Meanwhile, in the United Kingdom, vaccinated travellers ... Read more »

‘New method of payment!': Tesco launches prepayment debit card with savings account

All of Tesco’s 20 million Clubcard customers will be able to apply for the bank’s new Clubcard+ product online. This follows an initial launch back in March 2021, which saw ... Read more »

Liverpool lineups as Takumi Minamino and Curtis Jones decisions made for Brentford

Ian Doyle – Takumi Minamino and Kostas Tsimikas start If it’s Sunday, it’s Liverpool playing. At least that’s how it feels at the moment, as Brentford prepare to visit in ... Read more »

Australia to deport Novak Djokovic after court defeat as tennis stars say row ‘not good' for tournament

Novak Djokovic has said he is “extremely disappointed” after an Australian court ruled it would uphold a decision to cancel his visa for the second time. Three judges reached a ... Read more »

Watch massive Emirates A380 fly near 'air hostess' standing on the top of Burj Khalifa

© Provided by Zee News Last year, social media went crazy when Emirates released a commercial featuring a “flight attendant” sitting atop the Burj Khalifa, the world’s tallest building. It was ... Read more »

'Ariyippu' unit wraps up shoot in India, to move abroad

© IANS Ariyippu wraps Indian schedule. Chennai, Jan 16 (IANS) The unit of director Mahesh Narayanan’s ‘Ariyippu’ (Declaration), which features actor Kunchacko Boban and Divya Prabha in the lead, has ... Read more »

Uttar Pradesh Covid-19 curbs: Schools, colleges to remain closed till January 23

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The Uttar Pradesh government on Sunday (January 16) said that all schools and colleges will remain shut till January 23, 2022, in the ... Read more »

No justification now for keeping schools closed in view of Covid-19, says World Bank Education Director

© Provided by The Financial Express Learning poverty means being unable to read and understand a simple text by the age of 10. (File) There is no justification now for ... Read more »

Former Israel PM Benjamin Netanyahu negotiating plea deal in corruption trial

© Provided by The Financial Express Netanyahu is charged in three separate cases. (File/Reuters) Former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is negotiating a plea deal in his corruption case, a ... Read more »

Goa polls: 'PM certified AAP as sincere and honest', says Arvind Kejriwal; lists 13-point agenda

© Provided by Firstpost Goa polls: ‘PM certified AAP as sincere and honest’, says Arvind Kejriwal; lists 13-point agenda Ahead of the Goa Assembly polls, Delhi chief minister and Aam ... Read more »

Pacific tsunami threat recedes, volcano ash hinders response

The Associated PressThis satellite image taken by Himawari-8, a Japanese weather satellite operated by Japan Meteorological Agency and released by National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT), shows an ... Read more »

Tamil Nadu shuts schools for classes 10, 12 too amid surging COVID-19 cases

© Provided by Zee News Chennai: The Tamil Nadu government on Sunday (January 16) declared holiday till January 31 for school students of standards 10-12 too in the wake of ... Read more »

“You look at the body language”: talkSPORT reporter drops worrying claim on Wolves ace

TalkSPORT journalist Alex Crook has questioned the relationship between Wolverhampton Wanderers manager Bruno Lage and winger Adama Traore.  It’s been a difficult first half of the season for the 25-year-old, ... Read more »

Oliver Dowden says Boris Johnson 'should of course remain as PM'

Oliver Dowden today insisted Boris Johnson should stay on as Prime Minister as he warned against a ‘divisive’ Tory leadership contest amid a growing backlash over the Number 10 party ... Read more »

Khairuddin dipecat atas faktor disiplin, bukan sebab isu PN, MN, kata Takiyuddin

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Takiyuddin Hassan berkata, tidak pernah ada orang digugurkan atau dipecat PAS akibat perbezaan pendapat, kecuali tindakan itu bercanggah perlembagaan parti kerana ia satu kesalahan ... Read more »

‘Cukup-cukuplah ‘bersandiwara' berhubung bantuan banjir, gesa Exco Johor kepada Syed Sadiq

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Onn Hafiz Ghazi mempersoalkan Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman mengapa tiba di Johor pada 7 Januari 2022, tujuh hari selepas Muar dilanda banjir. PETALING ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic