Pakistani statements and Indian reactions post T20 match show nothing has changed in past 1,000 years

Asia's Tech News Daily

Pakistani statements and Indian reactions post T20 match show nothing has changed in past 1,000 years
© Provided by Firstpost Pakistani statements and Indian reactions post T20 match show nothing has changed in past 1,000 years

Remember Leon Trotsky’s famous adage, “You may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.” It has taken a set of events surrounding the India-Pakistan T20 World Cup match to remind us: That even though Hindus may believe in banalities like “Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam”, our Muslim neighbours across the border certainly don’t.

The surprising thing is that this is not new. Far from it, this has been a repeated historical pattern over the last thousand years of Muslim colonisation where Hindus did not particularly see the Muslims as different, but Muslims always saw Hindus are different. This goes back to how one defines identity.

Also read: How India’s T20 loss to Pakistan lets our social media ‘liberals’ take off their masks

Harvard professor Samuel Huntington hypothesised that one’s identity comprises two parts: Substance (what binds us together) and salience (what separates us from others). Now historically, if you look at this, you will see that Indians have neither had substance nor have they had salience.

In fact, it is safe to say that all religions founded in the Bronze Age or early antiquity never emphasised either. However, the second axial age that heralded religions like Christianity and Islam place this unique invention at the centre of everything they did. The aim was to create a strong bond between coreligionists and at the same time create a strong division with others who did not follow the religion.

A simple example of this is how the Greek, Roman and Egyptian religions all co-existed and syncreticized with each other. When revolts happened in the Roman world, it was not because of religion, but everything else. The notable exceptions were the Abrahamic religions — Judaism and Christianity. Christianity ultimately absorbed the Roman Empire; the last remaining Roman pagans never understood till the end why the Christians didn’t accept their Gods while they were happy to accept Christianity as one more stream within the Roman whole.

The same scene played out in India when the Muslim Turkic invasions began. Rajendra Chola, for example, in 1094, setting out for the conquest of what was there in Indonesia and Malaysia never spared a thought for Mahmud Ghazni destroying the Jyotirlinga at Somnath, this despite being an alleged “Shiva Bhakta”.

Similarly, the previous pre-Islamic Turks who had invaded India, like the Turk Shahi dynasty, integrated completely into the Indian fold. Their cousins — the Mongols — similarly integrated into every society they conquered. Yet, the same ethnic stock post religious conversion not just refused to integrate, but viewed everything from a religious viewpoint.

After all, if the Turk Shahis integrated, why didn’t the Mamluks, Khiljis and Tughlaqs? If the Mongols were equal opportunity destroyers, why did Berke (khan of the Golden Horde) take his cousin Hulagu’s destruction of Baghdad and killing of the Caliph so seriously that he declared war? What toxicity is this that turns cousin against cousin for the sake of beliefs?

This is the mindset we face today and have faced for the last 1,000 years. We may very well have seen the invaders merely as an ethnicity “Turks” (Turushkas), not as a religion. But they saw us not as an ethnicity, but as a religion (Hindu). This is what we have seen with the Pakistan cricket team this week — from praying on the field, to referring to the victory as “kufr to toot gaya” (the infidel was destroyed) by an official ICC commentator, to Pakistan captain Babar Azam responding to it positively, saying “Allah ka shukr hai” (all thanks to Allah), to Shoaib Akhtar, Waqar Younis and a Pakistani minister claiming this was a “victory for Islam”, to the wild celebrations among a section of Indian Muslims.

What is gobsmacking though is that the Hindu response to all of this has remained the exact same as Rajendra Chola in 1094 AD. Some tried explaining away “kufr” as “jinx”, ignoring the fact that the root of it still lay in the three Arabic consonants K F R, denoting a pejorative. Others claimed that it was simply normal usage used even by Hindu poets writing in Urdu.

That’s a bit like saying that inflections and variations of the N-word are perfectly acceptable because they come from the Portuguese for black. Captain Virat Kohli, who loves sermonising Hindus on how to celebrate Diwali, meanwhile, had nothing to say about this. Worse still the management of the team run by the BCCI comes under the son of a home minister who gives lectures across India on protecting Hindus and their “civilisational heritage”.

Yet, apparently, he never taught his son any of those virtues, because the management was happy to get the team to “take the knee” supporting a violent, rioting, arsonist movement in the United States a year back, but had nothing to say about the slaughter of Hindus in Kashmir and Bangladesh just a week ago.

Mind you, the BCCI didn’t even take cognisance of the religious slur and has to date refused to even acknowledge it.

While we know the “liberal secular” media would completely ignore it, the real shocker was some right-wing outlets dismissing it in a blasé fashion in a few lines, merely asking Team India and its management to introspect. Had a major politician’s son not been involved, these publications would’ve gone hammer and tongs on the subject.

To sum up, in 1,000 years, nothing has changed.


The ceaseless civilisational assault on Hindus continues unabated and Hindus, especially their much vaunted champions and gonfalonieres, prize their access and financial benefits over their identity. Clearly, you can take the Jaichand out of India, but you can’t take the Jaichand out of the Hindu. Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose (the more things change, the more they stay the same).

The writer is Senior Fellow at the Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Panthers fire offensive coordinator Joe Brady with offense in tatters

The Panthers are making yet another offensive change. The team announced Sunday that it had fired offensive coordinator Joe Brady during the Carolina’s bye week. With Brady out, senior offensive ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing's Dan Walker axed from the contest as he pays emotional tribute to ‘amazing' Nadiya Bychkova

STRICTLY Come Dancing star Dan Walker and Nadiya Bychkova were dramatically axed from the show tonight after losing the dance-off. The BBC Breakfast star, 44, had defied the odds to make it ... Read more »

'Affordable' London borough where you can buy a house for less than £323,000

As any Londoner will attest to, property is notoriously expensive in the capital, with prices continuing to rise despite the effects of the pandemic. As lockdown restrictions began to ease ... Read more »

Miles Teller looks dapper with wife Keleigh at a party in Brentwood

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo They certainly know how to have a good time. And Miles Teller looked dapper as he stepped out with stylish wife Keleigh as ... Read more »

CNN fires Chris Cuomo after law firm probes involvement in brother's harassment scandal

Outside investigators have found that onetime CNN anchor Chris Cuomo, right, crossed the line in helping his brother Andrew, left, navigate the sexual harassment scandal that forced him to resign ... Read more »

Rand Paul: Chris Cuomo firing 'a small step toward CNN regaining any credibility'

Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) asks questions about FISA and Crossfire Hurricane during a Senate Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs Committee hearing to discuss security threats 20 years after the 9/11 ... Read more »

Doctor Who festive special sees return of an old enemy - the Daleks

It’s nearly time for the Doctor Who festive special which can only mean one thing – Daleks. The metal monsters will make a return on New Year’s Day in a ... Read more »

Congress trying to win MLC polls with money power: Karnataka CM Bommai

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Congress had accused the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) of using — or misusing — state machinery to win support. (ANI) Karnataka chief minister Basavaraj ... Read more »

Shopkeeper held for selling LPG illegally in Ludhiana

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Ludhiana police received information that the accused shopkeeper refilled small LPG cylinders from regular ones and sold them to labourers at a higher price. ... Read more »

Germany: Free Democrats back coalition agreement

© Provided by WION Germany’s pro-business Free Democrats (FDP) on Sunday voted on Sunday to back coalition agreement with the Social Democrats and the Greens. This has paved way for ... Read more »

Air India pilots to meet Aviation Secretary before taking call on ‘industrial action'

© Provided by Hindustan Times Air India pilots have been writing to the airline since October but they haven’t received any reply. (HT PHOTO.) Air India pilots, who had warned the ... Read more »

Erste Details zur Impfpflicht in Österreich geleakt: 600 Euro Busse alle drei Monate – oder Knast!

Ab dem 1. Februar gilt in Österreich die Impfpflicht. Nun ist auch klar, wie der Staat diese Pandemie-Massnahme durchsetzen will. Verweigerern drohen immer wieder saftige Bussen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick ... Read more »

Doctor Who recap: Flux chapter six – The Vanquishers

“What an awfully big adventure,” said Kevin McNally’s Prof Jericho as he faced certain death at the hands of either a Sontaran or the Flux, or possibly both simultaneously. And ... Read more »

Belarus summons Ukraine attache over alleged airspace violations

© Provided by Tensions have soared in recent months on Belarusian borders Ukrainian defense attache had been summoned to the country’s Ministry of Defense over allegations that a Ukrainian ... Read more »

Police: Buckeye man fatally shot by neighbor who was harassing family

Shooting Alfonso Gastelum, a 27-year-old man from Buckeye, is dead after he was shot during a dispute by a suspect who had been harassing members of his family. At roughly ... Read more »

Michigan Quarterback Has Brutally Honest Admission On Ohio State

© Provided by The Spun Michigan Wolverines quarterback Cade McNamara. Michigan quarterback Cade McNamara threw a little bit of shade at Ohio State on Sunday afternoon. McNamara was asked if ... Read more »

Former Tennessee analyst hired as ACC offensive coordinator

© Provided by Vols Wire Chip Long served as Tulane’s offensive coordinator during the 2021 season. He will serve in the same capacity at Georgia Tech in 2022 under head ... Read more »

Where to discover The Device in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1

© Provided by GamePur One of the Season Quests in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1 is to discover The Device. This is a piece of tech that The Seven will ... Read more »

ShahZaM vs. Berlin: Sentinels' IGL seeks to conquer the city that burned him twice

© Provided by Dot Esports Mere minutes after his NA CS:GO roster had been eliminated in the Challengers Stage of the StarLadder Berlin Major, Complexity’s CEO Jason Lake went public ... Read more »

Urgent warning for millions of Android users about hack that can access your money if you answer the phone

ANDROID users have been identified as potential victims to a malware scam that seeks to obtain personal information, through their phone. By answering a simple phone call, users become at ... Read more »

Valorant Invalid Access to Memory Location: How to Fix

Valorant’s invalid access to memory location has been a pop-up error message for some players. This error is not as simple as exiting and reentering the game. Instead, this is ... Read more »

Gambia: President Barrow set for victory but rivals cry foul

© Provided by Gambian president Adama Barrow looks set for a landslide win at the country’s elections Gambian President Adama Barrow on Sunday looked set for an emphatic win ... Read more »

Chiefs OL Kyle Long built chemistry with teammates during time on Reserve/PUP list

© Provided by Chiefs Wire The Kansas City Chiefs officially activated offensive lineman Kyle Long this week after a knee injury in OTAs kept him on the Reserve/PUP list following ... Read more »

Tottenham sweep Norwich aside after Lucas Moura's wonder strike

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Daniel Leal/AFP/Getty Images It might not have been the day that Harry Kane scored his first Premier League goal of the Antonio Conte era, ... Read more »

Gambian opposition parties reject preliminary election results

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: John Wessels/AFP/Getty Images Gambian opposition candidates have rejected the preliminary results of Saturday’s historic vote in the West African nation which suggest the incumbent ... Read more »

Premier League 2021-22 Manchester United vs Crystal Palace LIVE Streaming: When and Where to Watch Online, TV Telecast, Team News

© Provided by News18 Ralf Rangnick will take the mantle of Manchester United for the first time as an interim manager on Sunday when the Red Devils host Crystal Palace ... Read more »

Travel bans will do nothing to stop spread of omicron in UK, scientist warns

© AP Professor Willem Hanekom said controls on travel should not be the priority for UK authorities in dealing with the new variant – AP Cases of the new omicron ... Read more »

Falcons' Marlon Davidson gets a THICC SIX touchdown against Tom Brady

© Provided by Touchdown Wire Is there anything better in football than a big dude rumbling into the end zone with a ball he’s procured from the opposing offense? We ... Read more »

Chris Cuomo was accused of harassment days before CNN firing

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – Chris Cuomo attends The Hollywood Reporter’s annual Most Powerful People in Media cocktail reception on April 11, 2019, in New York. CNN fired ... Read more »

Will Buccaneers consider cutting Antonio Brown after fake COVID card?

© Provided by Fansided With the news of Antonio Brown being suspended for his fake COVID card, his future with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers really feels up in the air.  ... Read more »

Gerrard hails ‘brilliant' Villa after ‘sloppy' start vs Leicester

© PA Images Steven Gerrard watches from the touchline Steven Gerrard has praised his Aston Villa side for overcoming their “sloppy” start to defeat Leicester 2-1 at Villa Park. The ... Read more »

Panthers part ways with OC Joe Brady

© Reuters/Bob Donnan NFL: Washington Football Team at Carolina Panthers The Carolina Panthers fired offensive coordinator Joe Brady on Sunday with five games remaining in his second season with the ... Read more »

Watch: Rangnick admits double-take at Fred's right-footed winner

© PA Images Manchester United manager Ralf Rangnick Ralf Rangnick got off to a winning start at Manchester United after overseeing their 1-0 win over Crystal Palace – and the ... Read more »

Watch: Former Notre Dame tight end scores first NFL touchdown

© Provided by Fighting Irish Wire Brock Wright went undrafted this past spring but was ultimately signed by the Detroit Lions.  After bouncing between the practice squad and active roster ... Read more »

Our hopes for a mayo bath might be coming true at this year's Duke's Mayo Bowl

© Provided by For The Win Before the 2020 college football season, the Belk Bowl — a bowl game based in Charlotte that features an ACC team against either a ... Read more »

Gardner Minshew Is Off To An Incredible Start On Sunday

© Provided by The Spun Eagles quarterback Gardner Minshew smiles while holding his jersey. The Philadelphia Eagles were forced to swap quarterbacks on Sunday as usual starter Jalen Hurts nurses ... Read more »

Bills CB Dane Jackson: 'It's a huge opportunity'

© Provided by Bills Wire Buffalo Bills CB Dane Jackson spent most of his rookie season on the practice squad though he shined when he had opportunities in limited gameplay ... Read more »

How to get Endwalker Tomestone Gear in Final Fantasy XIV

© Provided by GamePur Once you’ve defeated Zenos, watched the end credits roll, and turned in your final quest, you are officially done with the story content of Endwalker. However, ... Read more »

TFT Patch 11.24 slated to buff Frozen Heart and Blue Buff, rework Spellblade Hextech Augment

© Provided by Dot Esports Game designer Kent “Riot Kent” Wu and game design director Stephen “Mortdog” Mortimer revealed a massive amount of changes to Set Six Teamfight Tactics within ... Read more »

Quinn Ewers Reportedly Visiting Major Program On Sunday

© Provided by The Spun Quinn Ewers throws a ball. On Friday night, reports emerged that five-star quarterback Quinn Ewers would be transferring from Ohio State. Today, Ewers is reportedly ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic