Out-of-zone girl, 5, wins right to attend school after enrolment offer unlawfully withdrawn

Out-of-zone girl, 5, wins right to attend school after enrolment offer unlawfully withdrawn

A new entrant student has won the right to attend an out-of-zone school with her big sister after her family took the school to court.

The girl’s big sister attended a primary school despite living out of zone. Last year her 4-year-old sister was offered a place when she turned 5 in July 2021, as the rules give priority to siblings of current students.

But several months later, after the school’s roll unexpectedly became overcrowded with kids from in zone, the school revoked the offer.

The family applied for a judicial review of the decision but were unsuccessful. However, the Court of Appeal has overturned the decision, giving her the right to attend.

Justices David Goddard and Clifford Brown today released their reasons for their July 15 decision. The names of the child and the school are permanently suppressed.

Under New Zealand law, all students living inside a school’s geographic enrolment zone are entitled to attend that school. If there is remaining space, students from out of zone can enter a ballot, with priority given to students with family links to the school.

As the roll was nearly full, the school decided not to hold a ballot last year, for the first time in two decades. But it wrote to five out-of-zone families who had children currently at the school, advising that their younger children would still be able to enrol in 2021 due to their sibling links.

Then came an “unprecedented” influx of home zone students between December and March. Court documents say the school found itself “stretched and struggling to accommodate existing students”. Facing pressure on staff, students and resources, including a high workload on the new entrant teacher, the school told the five families their offers had been withdrawn.

An adviser from the Ministry of Education told the school it had acted correctly.

Definition of 'entitled to enrol' called into question

Out-of-zone girl, 5, wins right to attend school after enrolment offer unlawfully withdrawn

Photo / File

The case hinged on whether it is lawful for a school to withdraw an unqualified offer to an out-of-zone student.

Section 74 of the Education and Training Act 2020 says that a person who lives in the home zone of a state school is “entitled to enrol” at that school.

An out-of-zone student is also “entitled to enrol” but only if they are offered a place at the school through correct enrolment scheme procedures.

The girl’s parents argued that since she had been unconditionally offered a place at the school, and they had accepted it, she was now “entitled to enrol” there in exactly the same way as a home zone student.

That meant her offer could not be revoked.

In the High Court in July Justice Simon France said while that explanation was “tenable” he preferred the Ministry and school’s explanation that there was a difference between the status of enrolment and the pre-enrolment process. The latter should not be viewed as creating a binding contract that would force a school to overload classes, he said.

But the Court of Appeal disagreed – concluding that “an unqualified offer of a place to an out-of-zone applicant may not be withdrawn even though the eventual number of in-zone enrolments is considered to cause overcrowding”.

The school’s decision to withdraw the girl’s offer was thus unlawful, and the Court had no choice but to direct the school to enrol her.

Ministry of Education officials had advised the school incorrectly, the Court said.

Once an unconditional offer had been communicated, a child and their family could be expected to act on the basis of that offer.

“It would not be fair or transparent, or consistent with the requirements of good administration, for such an offer to be withdrawn in the absence of an express power to do so.”

The Court said the girl’s school start date could be varied if the parents and school could come to an agreement.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

A-level results day: Record numbers of students get A grades or higher

(PA) Record numbers of students have achieved an A grade or higher in teacher-awarded A-level results this year, after exams were cancelled for a second year. Nearly half of students ... Read more »

Health boards to target schools to tackle low teen vaccination rate

Photo: DutchNews.nl Several of the Netherlands’ 25 regional health boards are hoping to provide information about the coronavirus vaccine directly in schools and in some cases to actually offer jabs, ... Read more »

COVID-era prayers

Parents of students who will take the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) pray for good luck for their children outside a building of Bongeun Temple in southern Seoul, Tuesday, 100 ... Read more »

‘Worst nightmare come true': Students on life since being caught up in the 2020 A-level fiasco

James, Lucas and Gwen were students during the 2020 A-level debacle (Supplied) Sixth-form students will find out their A-level results on Tuesday, which for the second year in a row ... Read more »

Macleans expulsion: School says it's had strong support from public after being ordered to apologise to an expelled student

An Auckland school that was told to apologise for expelling a student for what it considered gross misconduct has received support from people “dotted all over New Zealand”, the principal ... Read more »

Education ministry eases distancing rules to expand in-person learning in fall

Education Minister Yoo Eun-hae announces new relaxed social distancing guidelines in schools at the Seoul Government Complex, Aug. 9. Yonhap The Ministry of Education announced a set of new relaxed ... Read more »

Soaring numbers of pupils taught in ‘supersized' classes

Children at Manor Park School in Knutsford, Cheshire (PA) The number of school pupils in England packed into “supersized” classes has risen by 20 per cent under Tory rule, analysis ... Read more »

Ditch social distancing at university, VU chief says

Will students have to keep their distance? Photo: Depositphotos University chiefs have called on the government allow them to reopen completely in the coming academic year and to ditch the ... Read more »

Whangārei made children's e-book The Fun-tastic 7 is working its way to normalise disability

Glen McMillan and Ayla-Jane Ogle are on a mission to normalise disability with their creation of a children’s e-book series The Fun-tastic 7. McMillan came up with the idea and ... Read more »

Universities ‘are stopping actively recruiting foreign students': FD

A meeting for international students in Leiden. Photo: Brandon Hartley Most Dutch universities have stopped actively recruiting foreign students, the Financieele Dagblad reported on Friday after questioning officials at all ... Read more »

How to Text a Virgo Woman

If a Virgo has caught your eye, you might be wondering how to make your texts to her more meaningful. Virgos belong to the earth sign so they’re logical and ... Read more »

How to Text a Shy Person

Some people are naturally talkative, while others prefer solitude and quiet. There’s nothing wrong with being shy, but it can feel like a bit of a challenge if you’re trying ... Read more »

How to Text Someone You Just Met (Examples of Easy and Fun Conversation Starters)

You’ve just met someone awesome and you even got their phone number—score! But how on earth do you get a text conversation started with them if you hardly know them? ... Read more »

How to Ask a Girl to the Movies by Text

The movie date: it’s a staple for a reason. Watching a movie with the girl that you like is a fun way to get to know her and a great ... Read more »

90% of college students demand tuition refunds

Students hold a protest rally in Seoul, in this April 3 photo, calling on universities to refund tuition, as they have had to pay full tuition for low-quality online classes, ... Read more »

How to Socialize Without Being Awkward and Feel More Comfortable Talking to People

If you dread the occasional awkward silence or worry constantly about saying the wrong thing, you’re not alone. Socializing can be tricky, and everyone has awkward moments from time to ... Read more »

Thousands of students are on the waiting list for student housing in Bergen and Oslo

More than 6,200 students are waiting in line to get a place in student housing in Bergen and Oslo, with only two weeks left before the start of their studies. ... Read more »

How to Write an Argumentative Research Paper

An argumentative essay requires you to make an argument about something and support your point of view using evidence in the form of primary and secondary sources. The argumentative essay ... Read more »

How to Write a Test Plan

Test plans outline the process of testing the functionality of software. A test plan details each step taken to achieve a certain result and states the objective of each action. ... Read more »

How to Write a Progress Report

Progress reports are an important part of project management, whether it’s your dissertation or a project at work. You’ll need to use these to keep your supervisors, your colleagues, or ... Read more »

How to Write a Paper

Whether you’re in high school or university, writing papers is probably a big part of your grade for at least some of your classes. Writing an essay on any topic ... Read more »

How to Write a Critique in Five Paragraphs

A critique is usually written in response to a creative work, such as a novel, a film, poetry, or a painting. However, critiques are also sometimes assigned for research articles ... Read more »

How to Write a Conclusion

Writing the introduction and body of a paper is a big accomplishment, but you still need to write your conclusion. Writing a conclusion can feel difficult, but it’s easier if ... Read more »

How to Write a Case Study

There are many different kinds of case studies. There are also various uses for writing case studies, from academic research purposes to provision of corporate proof points. There are approximately ... Read more »

How to Write About Your Hobbies and Interests

The interests and hobbies section of a resume or college application provides a good opportunity to showcase your personality. A well-executed one can even compensate for a lack in experience ... Read more »

How to Use a Two Way Radio Policy to Protect School Students and Staff

Ensuring the safety of children and staff in America’s schools is the single most important issue school boards and administrators must address. Police departments and other law enforcement cannot be ... Read more »

How to Use Maths Pathway

Maths Pathway is a website that many schools use to teach maths without any physical textbooks. When doing schoolwork and homework, it’s helpful to know how to use it, so ... Read more »

How to Use Google Translate

There’s a whole world of information out there on the internet, but a vast majority of it is probably in a language you don’t understand. That’s where Google Translate comes ... Read more »

How to Use Bad Language Without Getting in Trouble

People have different ideas about using bad language. If you’re young, cursing can get you into a lot of trouble. Using bad language can make you feel more grown up, ... Read more »

How to Understand the Benefits of All Girls Schools

Single-sex education can have enormous benefits for its students, especially women. While you may initially balk at the idea of attending an all girls school or a women’s college, a ... Read more »

How to Transfer an IEP to Another School

Developing an individualized education program (IEP) for your child can be a challenging and time-consuming task. If you have to move, it would certainly be a lot easier if you ... Read more »

How to Teach Summary Writing

Summary writing is a really valuable skill, but it can be tricky to teach new students. If your pupils are young kids or ESL learners, they may not understand the ... Read more »

How to Teach Kids to Tell Time

Telling time is a tricky business, especially for kids. But as a parent or teacher, you can make learning how to tell time a fun activity by making clocks with ... Read more »

How to Teach Children Liberal Values

A liberal person believes that the government should take action to help improve the lives of its citizens. Although you may have your own specific opinions about certain politicized topics, ... Read more »

How to Teach Cause and Effect to Your Kids

The concept of cause and effect seems obvious and natural to adults, but for children, especially younger ones, the idea can be a bit more difficult to grasp. It’s important ... Read more »

How to Take Your Child to School for the First Time

Taking your child into kindergarten or preschool is a big step, and may cause some tension. This guide will help you know what to expect when you take your child ... Read more »

How to Take Steps to Protect Human Rights

Human rights are fundamental rights that all human beings possess regardless of their race, ethnicity, sex, national or ethnic origin, color, residence, religion, or any other status. These rights cannot ... Read more »

How to Take Advice

Even if you’re in a tough situation, taking advice can be really hard. Sometimes, though, an outside perspective can help you see things in a new light, making it easier ... Read more »

How to Stop Stammering

Stuttering, or stammering, refers to a speech disorder that results in speech being discontinuous or broken in its rhythm and pace. Words may be prolonged or repeated, sometimes accompanied by ... Read more »

How to Start a Revolution

To create a revolution, you need to unite people around a shared purpose. It’s possible to start a revolution, although it can take a lot of patience, organization, and passion. ... Read more »