Opinion: Time for mandatory vaccinations

Opinion: Time for mandatory vaccinations
© Provided by dw.com Surveys show a majority of people in Germany now support mandatory vaccinations against COVID-19

German Health Minister Jens Spahn has said he fears a general vaccine mandate would widen divisions in society and entrench people in their positions. Other politicians have expressed similar views in recent weeks and months. My impression is that people always tend to fall back on the threat of division when they don’t want to make unpleasant decisions.

And it’s nonsense. A homogeneous society is, and always has been, a theoretical construct. Real society is heterogeneous, and has many fault lines — it is, you could say, divided. As long as no decisions are made — especially not about COVID measures, or mandatory vaccinations — politicians are able to keep all the citizens onside. By putting off the decisions, we’re not making any headway at all — and squandering valuable time.

Incidentally: If social harmony is what’s at stake, there’s more to be said in favor of a COVID vaccine mandate than against it. Although not everyone supports mandatory vaccinations, the majority of the population now does, as surveys have shown. This is probably one of the reasons why we’re beginning to see politicians, among them State Premiers Markus Söder and Winfried Kretschmann, starting to change their minds. The incoming German government also announced a few days ago that it would at least consider making vaccinations mandatory.

Where there’s no will, there’s no way

This leaves the second argument decision-makers like to use against a general vaccination requirement: that it’s incompatible with the Basic Law, Germany’s constitution, and that courts could quash it. On the one hand, it’s striking that concerns like these were apparently no such deterrent when other legislative projects were under consideration: the climate protection act, for example, which was rejected by the Federal Constitutional Court, or the toll on private motor vehicles, which was overturned by the European Court of Justice.

On the other hand, renowned constitutional lawyers like Ulrich Battis have recently indicated that they consider mandatory vaccinations very much in line with the constitution. Battis’ colleague, Christoph Möllers, has said he is unsure which experts in his field politicians are relying on for their negative assessments.

So it makes sense, not only to me but also to these lawyers, that in an exceptional situation like the COVID-19 pandemic, the fundamental right to physical integrity can come second to the need to protect the lives of others.

And yes — because this is something else that people like to invoke — it’s true that a vaccine mandate on its own will not end the pandemic, and that it would in any case come too late to help stem the current fourth wave of COVID-19. But how about looking ahead, for a change? Namely to the fifth wave that’s still in store for us, if everything stays as it is. Together with measures such as social distancing, mask-wearing and so on, a significant increase in vaccination coverage could make an enormous difference. Among experts, this fact is undisputed.

Vaccine mandate ‘lite’ is coming anyway

In any case, the outrage is exaggerated. With the new “2G rules” [under which only those who have either been vaccinated or have recently recovered from a COVID infection are allowed to access certain spaces and activities — Editor’s note] and the likely introduction of mandatory vaccination for certain occupational groups, vaccine mandate “lite” has already got in through the back door. It’s just that there are no actual penalties yet for those who don’t get vaccinated. Wouldn’t that be a strong inducement, one that could still be used? We don’t have many others left.

By contrast, the scenario of unwilling people being dragged into the vaccination center and forcibly vaccinated is utterly unrealistic. Public discussion of such notions of extreme compulsory vaccination simply fans people’s fears, and is irresponsible.

Dilemma of its own making

Of course, I realize that no one wants to be the bad guy and incur the wrath of the vaccine skeptics. The situation is not made any easier by the fact that, for so long, the prospect of a general vaccine mandate has vociferously been denied by politicians. If it changes course now, the government will appear even less trustworthy to those already disenchanted with politics.

But continuing to categorically rule out mandatory vaccinations is even more problematic. In times like these, we don’t need politicians who dodge responsibility, but those who dare to make a decision that won’t make them universally popular.

This commentary has been translated from German

Author: Ines Eisele

News Related

OTHER NEWS

St Mirren recall MacPherson from St Johnstone as he agrees deal with Perth club

© PA Archive Cammy Macpherson has been recalled from St Mirren (Jeff Holmes/PA) – PA Archive St Mirren have recalled Cammy MacPherson from his loan spell at St Johnstone after ... Read more »

Tottenham predicted team vs Chelsea: Injuries mean Antonio Conte must name very different team

Conte On Injuries See more videos What to watch next Thomas Tuchel On Whether Chelsea Are Out Of The Title Race Thomas Tuchel On Whether Chelsea Are Out Of The ... Read more »

The biggest property trends for 2022 revealed

The ‘race for space’ that’s dominated the property market for the past 20 months will carry on throughout 2022, according to experts. Kickstarted by the pandemic, it’s seen prospective buyers ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel told why to make 'quality' Armando Broja transfer decision amid Chelsea's woes

Thomas Tuchel Discusses Armando Broja's Future Amid Exit Talk See more videos What to watch next Thomas Tuchel On Whether Chelsea Are Out Of The Title Race Thomas Tuchel On ... Read more »

"Out of their reach": Journalist dismisses "interesting" Leeds transfer link to 25 y/o "animal"

© GiveMeSport Leeds manager Marcelo Bielsa on the touchline Journalist Pete O’Rourke does not think that signing Torino full-back Ola Aina is a priority for Leeds this month. Aina has ... Read more »

'I'm not ready for this', 'Yesss' - Many Liverpool fans erupt as James Pearce drops update

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Premier League – Liverpool v Brighton & Hove Albion Some Liverpool supporters are delighted after Jurgen Klopp provided a positive injury update on the progress ... Read more »

Mkhanyiseli Siwahla on the demise of Ajax Cape Town

© Provided by Times Live The club was renamed Cape Town Spurs towards the end of 2020 after Dutch giants Ajax Amsterdam sold their 51% share of Ajax CT bringing ... Read more »

Maha: Court orders MNS functionary to pull down party office set up illegally on temple trust land

A court in Thane has ordered a functionary of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) to pull down within a month his party’s public relations office set up “illegally” on a ... Read more »

Potter should avoid Allardyce trap – his chance will come

A decade on from Sam Allardyce joking about the perception of British managers, Graham Potter voiced similar beliefs. But times have changed.   It is 12 years since Sam Allardyce, ... Read more »

Rajasthan Governer's Twitter account hacked

The Twitter account of Rajasthan Governor Kalraj Mishra was hacked on Sunday, sources in the Raj Bhawan said. The hacker also posted a tweet in the Arabic language from the ... Read more »

Spurs could take advantage to turn Chelsea slump into crisis

Chelsea should be the favourites as hosts, European champions and the highest team in the table, but Tottenham seem well-placed to beat them.   Manchester United awkwardly stumble on under ... Read more »

India got political independence 75yrs ago but economic independence still elusive for millions: Manik Sarkar

Former Tripura Chief Minister Manik Sarkar said on Sunday that India got political independence 75 years ago but <a href="/tag/economic-independence“>economic independence still remains elusive for millions of Indians. Speaking at ... Read more »

Devin Singletary Player Prop Bets for the NFL Playoffs - Buffalo vs. Kansas City

Discover player props odds, plays, and insights for Devin Singletary in his NFL Playoffs contest with the Buffalo Bills against the Kansas City Chiefs. © Provided by Sports Illustrated Dec ... Read more »

Inside the Secure Community Network, the organization training Jewish communities to protect themselves

© courtesy Secure Community Network When the survivors of last weekend’s attack on a Texas synagogue talk about why they’re alive today, they point to two factors. One is the ... Read more »

US detains smuggling ship, UK seizes drugs in Mideast waters

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — The U.S. Navy announced Sunday it seized a boat in the Gulf of Oman carrying fertilizer used to make explosives that was caught last year ... Read more »

Europa-Resolution von ETH, Unis und Pharma: Die Forschung entlarvt die Politik

Wo sind eigentlich all die Meinungsführer, die vor dem Abschuss des Rahmenabkommens einen Plan B ankündigten? © Bereitgestellt von Blick Foto: Thomas Meier. Zürich, 09.06.21. Portraits der Blick Redaktion Zürich. ... Read more »

Vatican fraud trial to resume with boost for prosecution

1 / 2Vatican fraud trial to resume with boost for prosecutionView of 60 Sloane Avenue in London By Philip Pullella VATICAN CITY (Reuters) – The Vatican's landmark fraud and embezzlement ... Read more »

Jasmin Savoy Brown: 'Scream 5' monologue was 'exciting and terrifying'

© IANS Jasmin Savoy Brown.(Photo:IMDB.com) Los Angeles, Jan 23 (IANS) Actress Jasmin Savoy Brown says performing her ‘Scream 5’ monologue was “exciting and terrifying”, and she has expressed her love ... Read more »

Vicky Kaushal and Sara Ali Khan wrap up Laxman Utekar's film, Sharib Hashmi shares photos: ‘Dream team…'

© Provided by Firstpost Vicky Kaushal and Sara Ali Khan wrap up Laxman Utekar’s film, Sharib Hashmi shares photos: ‘Dream team…’ Director Laxman Utekar has been filming his next untitled ... Read more »

New parents Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas cosy up in unseen photo with friends

© Provided by Pinkvilla Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas collectively sent the Internet into a meltdown when they announced that they had welcomed their first child via surrogacy. The couple, ... Read more »

Kristen Wiig and Willem Dafoe make SURPRISE appearances in Will Forte's opening monologue on SNL

© Provided by Pinkvilla Will Forte finally got a chance to host Saturday Night Live, nearly 12 years after he starred as a cast member on the show. In his ... Read more »

Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin's Yash Pandit marries girlfriend Mahima Mishra

Yash Pandit and Mahima Mishra got married on January 22. Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin actor Yash Pandit got married to his girlfriend Mahima Mishra on Saturday, January 22, at ... Read more »

The BBC: A People's History by David Hendy review – inside the nation's ‘moral improver'

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Mirrorpix/Getty Images With the culture secretary Nadine Dorries’s announcement last week that the licence fee will be frozen for two years, the BBC’s future ... Read more »

Transfer news LIVE: Aston Villa open talks for Rodrigo Bentancur

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The January transfer window is now open and active for Premier League sides  Clubs will have until 11pm on Monday, January 31 to ... Read more »

Hyundai retires unwell Solberg at WRC Monte Carlo due to fume issue

The Swede, who started Sunday’s action in 48th place overall, managed to complete the first stage of the final day before Hyundai confirmed they would retire the entry, with both ... Read more »

Africa's health boss seeks to tempt expat medics to come back home

During the pandemic, the UK and other rich nations have relied on African doctors and nurses to shore up their health services. © Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Kim Ludbrook/EPA ... Read more »

India vs South Africa, 3rd ODI Live Score: India Claim Two Wickets in the Powerplay Overs

© Provided by News18 India vs South Africa, 3rd ODI Live Score: India Claim Two Wickets in the Powerplay Overs India vs South Africa, 3rd ODI Live Score: Indian captain KL ... Read more »

PH logs 29,828 new Covid-19 cases

© Provided by The Manila Times THE Department of Health logged 29,828 new Covid-19 cases on Sunday, pushing the total number of infections to 3,417,216. Of the 273,580 active cases, ... Read more »

UK accuses Russia of trying to install pro-Kremlin gov’t in Kyiv

© Provided by Al Jazeera Thirty-two percent of Ukrainians are willing to enlist in ‘popular resistance units’ as tensions with Russia mount [File: Anna Kudriavtseva/Reuters] The UK has accused the ... Read more »

Dreaming about spending March Break abroad? Here are some risks to consider

If the call of beaches or European cafés is becoming too much to resist, one travel expert suggests planning ahead is key to preventing your trip from becoming a logistical nightmare. ... Read more »

The exotic plants that love life in the UK

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Getty Images One of the most wonderful (and peculiar) things about gardening is the seemingly universal desire to defy climate to create landscapes that ... Read more »

The glowing praise for 'excellent' Man City loanee Tommy Doyle proves only positive for Cardiff City as substitution explained

There were very few positives in that disappointing Severnside derby loss for Cardiff City, but Tommy Doyle was undoubtedly one of them. The Manchester City loanee was thrown straight into ... Read more »

Inside Anne Frank's final days as ‘sunny, smiley' girl was turned into ‘walking skeleton' wrapped in lice-infested rags

STANDING pale as a ghost, Anne Frank shivered as she hauled stones in the blistering cold – while Nazi guards hurled insults around her. Forced to sleep in a freezing, ... Read more »

UK lawmaker Nusrat Ghani claims she was fired from ministerial job for her 'Muslimness'

© Provided by Zee News LONDON: A British lawmaker has said she was fired from a ministerial job in Prime Minister Boris Johnson`s Conservative government partly because her Muslim faith ... Read more »

'You don't play on reputations': Gambhir warns India in his brutal assessment of SA tour; 'Look beyond fear of losing'

Team India will be aiming to end the series against South Africa on a positive note as they take on the Proteas in the third and final ODI of the ... Read more »

UFC 270 results, takeaways: Francis Ngannou shows the heart of a champion and UFC needs to reward him

© Provided by CBS Sports Although it was far from a shocker that the pair of title bouts headlining Saturday’s UFC 270 card from Anaheim, California, turned out to be ... Read more »

Russia rejects UK claim of trying to replace Ukraine leader

© Provided by Associated Press Members of Ukraine’s Territorial Defense Forces, volunteer military units of the Armed Forces, train in a city park in Kyiv, Ukraine, Saturday, Jan. 22, 2022. ... Read more »

Massive Ford Collection Includes Rare Mustangs And Shelby Cobras

© Motor1.com This Massive Ford Collection Includes Rare Mustangs And Shelby Cobras It’s one of the most extensive private Ford collections in the world. If you had the chance to ... Read more »

ICC Awards: Mohammad Rizwan Named Men's T20 Cricketer of the Year

© Provided by News18 ICC Awards: Mohammad Rizwan Named Men’s T20 Cricketer of the Year Pakistan wicketkeeper-batter Mohammad Rizwan was on Sunday named the ICC Men’s T20 Player of the ... Read more »

Revellers took to the streets in style as ‘curfew' is lifted for the nation

Buoyed by the lifting of restrictions, revellers took to the streets in style on Saturday night to celebrate the end of the dreaded 8pm ‘curfew’. Dublin city centre was thronged ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic