OPINION - There’s a worrying subtext to these proposed cycling policies

opinion - there’s a worrying subtext to these proposed cycling policies

MarthaGillByline22NEW.jpg

Call it red-tape Britain. We’ve tied up businesses and borders, now the Government has suggested doing the same to cyclists.

Reports this week suggested that all bikes on the road should be fitted with number plates and require compulsory insurance, to hold them accountable for behaviour on the road, such as speeding.

To some, this may sound sensible. On the face of it the idea looks like it is addressing an inequality in the way different road users are treated. Cyclists, like motorists, can be irresponsible, and reckless ones can be a danger to others, but it is harder to punish erring cyclists because you can’t identify them as easily.

But look at the practicalities and the idea gets steadily sillier, partly because the problem at hand is relatively small. Twice as many people are killed by bees and wasps a year as by cyclists. Reckless cyclists are regularly caught and punished (their getaway is slower). Neither does identification solve all problems on the road. Take the number of uninsured motorists: the UK has an estimated one million of them.

Also silly is the idea of cyclists speeding as a huge problem: Transport Secretary Grant Shapps suggested in a recent interview that there is an issue with cyclists going over 20mph limits. But it’s the rare cyclist that is able to get to this speed in the first place (and enforcing it would mean more measures than simple identification. Would all bikes require compulsory speedometers?). Of course even a bike hitting a car at top speed would result in more damage to the cyclist than the car.

The idea is beset by impracticalities, too. How do you fit a big enough number-plate on a bike? How do you make sure the number plate identifies the cyclist, not just the bike? Do we really have the resources to register every cyclist on the road? Children get on bikes too. What about them? Little wonder that most places where this kind of thing has been tried have swiftly given up on it, with the exception of North Korea.

The most likely outcome of this idea, if the UK was ever able to get it off the ground, would be to put people off cycling. Registering number plates and buying insurance might be expensive and onerous enough to deter people but this would of course be a bad outcome. Cycling as an alternative to driving clears space on the road, promotes cleaner air in cities and is generally good for the environment. It is also vital for those who can’t afford a car. These are the people who would be most harmed from piling up the cost of cycling.

This is probably why the Department of Transport has repeatedly rejected proposals for registration schemes for cyclists, as recently as last November. Shapps himself admitted in another interview that he was not attracted to the bureaucracy of the idea. The chances of it ever happening are close to zero. So why is he proposing it?

The really interesting thing about this proposal is not that it will happen, but what it implies. Many government policy announcements in recent months have not been about what the Government intends to do but what it wants to signal about its position in various culture wars. Shapps thought it worth signalling that he was not on the side of cyclists but rather on the side of their natural enemies in the minor culture wars of the road: motorists.

Environmental matters were at least kept out of the culture war battles under Boris Johnson, himself a cyclist. If this announcement is a batsqueak signal that the Government is keen to ramp up a culture war in which it takes the side of motorists, that should trouble us.

Register now for one of the Evening Standard’s newsletters. From a daily news briefing to Homes & Property insights, plus lifestyle, going out, offers and more. For the best stories in your inbox, click here.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Chicago police shoot person who entered 10th District station lobby with gun

CHICAGO (CBS) — A person was shot by police inside the Chicago Police Department’s 10th District station lobby on Wednesday after he allegedly entered with a gun and waved it ... Read more »

Hilary Swank talks filming new series while expecting twins

Hilary Swank talks filming new series while expecting twins Hilary Swank has announced she’s pregnant with twins and says that revelation might explain some of her wardrobe alterations and other ... Read more »

You could be throwing away a third of your make-up without even realising it as our investigation reveals how poor packaging is costing us a fortune

An estimated 120 billion units of packaging are produced every year by the global cosmetics industry I decided to investigate, taking apart the packaging of several popular cosmeticsWhat I found after my investigation were some incredibly shocking results  Read more »

Fan Who Caught Aaron Judge's 62nd HR Offered $2M for Baseball

Link video: http://nbclim-download.edgesuite.net/Prod/NBCU_LM_VMS_-_KXAS/182/935/USE_THIS-Homerun_Ball_Cory_6P__524138.mp4 NBCUniversal, Inc. The owner of a sports memorabilia auction house says he has offered $2 million to the fan who caught Aaron Judge’s American League-record 62nd home run. JP ... Read more »

Atlas Air Takes The 3rd From Last Boeing 747 As The Final Aircraft Leaves The Production line

Atlas Air Takes The 3rd From Last Boeing 747 As The Final Aircraft Leaves The Production line On Wednesday, Atlas Air took delivery of a Boeing 747-8 Freighter. This unit ... Read more »

Ketanji Brown Jackson takes the Supreme Court's conservative majority to school

Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson outside the Supreme Court in Washington after her investiture on Friday. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson has made it clear in her first two days ... Read more »

Giants WR Sterling Shepard offers eye-opening explanation for non-contact ACL tear

10-5-22 New York Giants wide receiver Sterling Shepard went down with a torn ACL during the Week 3 loss vs. the Dallas Cowboys. Shepard’s injury was particularly worrisome given there ... Read more »

Man charged after juvenile girl discloses years of sexual abuse in Gilmer County

Man charged after juvenile girl discloses years of sexual abuse in Gilmer County GLENVILLE, W.Va. (WBOY) – A man has been charged after a female juvenile disclosed that he sexually ... Read more »

Harry Redknapp sends Phil Foden message after Man United hat-trick in Manchester derby

It was Foden’s first career hat-trick Harry Redknapp says Phil Foden proved doubters wrong with his treble against Manchester United on Sunday when selecting him and fellow hat-trick hero Erling ... Read more »

Here's How You Can Effectively Treat Tinnitus

man holding ear For many people worldwide, constant noise is part of everyday life. Internal sounds such as ringing, whistling, or roaring are heard almost 24 hours of the day. According to Cleveland ... Read more »

My Boyfriend Moved His Female Friend Into Our Home—What Should I Do?

An upset woman is asking for relationship advice. Here’s a stock image of an upset couple on the sofa. Dear Newsweek, I’m wondering if this is something that I should ... Read more »

Review: In 'Tár,' Cate Blanchett is a maestro at work

Review: In 'Tár,' Cate Blanchett is a maestro at work “Tár” is Todd Fields’ first film in 16 years, following 2006′s uneven “Little Children” and his assured Oscar-nominated 2001 debut, ... Read more »

How the MLB stopped Aaron Judge from being the true home run champ

New York Yankees slugger Aaron Judge entered baseball’s record books Tuesday by smashing his 62nd home run — the most long balls ever hit in a single season by an ... Read more »

DWP to offer 'budgeting' loans worth up to £812 for those on certain benefits

The DWP loan can be used to pay for essential products and services. A ‘budgeting’ loan is being offered by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) for those who ... Read more »

Laundry hacks to 'revive' knitwear and the one place you should 'never, ever' store it

Knitted jumpers and other clothing items are very delicate and can easily stretch or snag in the wash. Maintaining bold colours is also tricky using a standard wash cycle, but ... Read more »

Terence Corcoran: The all-new industrial dictatorship

Canada’s Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry François-Philippe Champagne . So here’s the latest from the Great Canadian Industrial Innovation Strategic Planning Development Science Infrastructure International Policy Trade Minister, François-Philippe ... Read more »

Qatar 2022: France's meticulous plan to boycott the next FIFA World Cup

Qatar 2022: France’s meticulous plan to boycott the next FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 is just around the corner, but not everything could go as planned. France has a meticulous ... Read more »

Cruz Beckham, 17, is 'working with Rita Ora's songwriter' as he follows in his mother Victoria's footsteps and prepares to launch music career

He is determined to follow in his mother Victoria’s footsteps after she achieved global fame as part of the Spice Girls. And Cruz Beckham’s singing career looks set to be on ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Gisele Bündchen met with a SPIRITUAL HEALER days - as the couple live apart following 'epic fight'

Supermodel Gisele Bündchen, 42, was spotted meeting with a spiritual healer for hours over the weekend amid reports she hired a divorce lawyer Bündchen reportedly hired a divorce lawyer this week ahead of her NFL star husband Tom Brady as the pair have allegedly been going through a rough patch The spiritual healer greeted Bündchen with Palo Santo, an incense known to remove negative energy, while the supermodel sat inside her car Bündchen was also seen outside a Miami gym without her luxurious diamond wedding ring amid rumors of her split from Brady Divorce rumors between Bündchen and Brady have been escalating since the NFL star decided to return to the field this year after announcing his retirement  Read more »

Voters say Boris Johnson would be better Tory leader as Liz Truss's popularity plummets, new poll shows

14 per cent of voters asked at weekend said they have favourable PM impressionThis is compared with 26 per cent who said so in SeptemberMore than seven in ten now see the PM in an unfavourable light Read more »

Woman ordered to remove Black Lives Matter sign inside her home or face fines

A resident at Washington State’s Lost Lake Resort community was told to remove a Black Lives Matter sign she had displayed inside her home or face fines. According to KIRO ... Read more »

NHS locum firms cash in on staff shortage and see incomes soar, data shows

Accounts reveal agencies supplying staff to NHS have seen their incomes rocketThe NHS has more than 100,000 vacancies, including one in ten nursing postsAgencies Acacium Group and Medacs Healthcare receive hundreds of millions Read more »

North Korea Continues Missile Launches as US Redeploys Carrier

Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida also confirmed the North Korean missile launches, saying the weapons firings are “absolutely intolerable" Read more »

Why young gym-goer, 24, was left in tears after being called 'brave' for working out in 'tight clothes' following 30kg weight loss

A fitness influencer has slammed those who call her 'brave' for going to the gymElloise, from Sydney, lost 30kg and has 'loose overhanging skin' around her torsoAn acquaintance said she was brave which Elloise said was 'hurtful'  She said she shouldn't be called brave for simply showing her body at the gym Elloise said the comment has 'absolutely destroyed' her self confidence  Read more »

Man files police report after Rams’ Bobby Wagner tackled him on 49ers’ field

Rams linebacker Bobby Wagner said he was just trying to help when he tackled a man who ran onto the field with a smoke bomb during a “Monday Night Football” ... Read more »

Trump cries 'hoax' as Biden and DeSantis survey hurricane damage

Trump cries ‘hoax’ as Biden and DeSantis survey hurricane damage Former President Donald Trump attacked the Biden administration Wednesday in Miami for “destroying the rule of law,” just hours after ... Read more »

Andrew Tate just had his 'misogyny’ called out by Piers Morgan

Andrew Tate has been confronted on ‘misogynistic’ comments by Piers Morgan during a fiery interview. The influencer was banned from TikTok, Meta, and YouTube earlier this year after they stated ... Read more »

Suella Braverman signals shake-up of how police log burglary cases after forces pledge to send officers to every break-in

Miss Braverman signals review  of how burglaries are reported so officers can be on streets, not pushing paper  All 43 police chiefs made pledge to send officers to every residential burglary  National Police Chiefs’ Council Martin Hewitt plans to tear up the bureaucratic process officers have to follow when a crime report comes in Read more »

Video: The secret language of 'supermarket dating': Brittany Hockley reveals the codes and special trolley items that signal you want to pick up on the grocery run

Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Hero dad who drowned trying to save his teenage sons at a popular tourist beach - even though he could not swim - is hailed for his bravery: 'Put kids before everything else'

Dr Ashwin Bhalsod, 55, drowned at Yallingup Beach, WA, on Saturday afternoonHe went into the ocean to help his sons, 13 and 15, thinking they were in dangerWA Police said Mr Bhalsod, a podiatrist, did not have any swimming experience The father has been hailed a 'hero'  for rushing to the aid of his two boys   Read more »

Baffled man who filmed his mate being busted by a sneaky cop posing as a roadside window washer reveals how the driver was 'surrounded and intimated' – as the underhand tactic is slammed as 'bloody trickery'

New Zealand man has exposed a sneaky police tactic to catch unaware motorists His video shows an undercover police officer disguised as a car window washer  The officer would try to catch drivers on their phone and radio it in to other cops  One man confronted the undercover cop and was swarmed by several officers Police then threatened to arrest the man for obstructing a police operation Radio host Duncan Garner called the move 'bloody trickery'  Read more »

‘If it was concealed, how did they know you had it?’: Sam’s Club customer argues with employees over concealed carry of gun, sparking debate

‘If it was concealed, how did they know you had it?’: Sam’s Club customer argues with employees over concealed carry of gun, sparking debate In a viral TikTok video, a ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: 'I should sue them!' James Jordan blasts 'pathetic' Steph's Packed Lunch bosses for 'stitching him up' on 's**t show' by 'misrepresenting' his tweet critiquing Strictly's Ellie Simmonds who has dwarfism

James Jordan has blasted ‘pathetic’ Steph’s Packed Lunch bosses for ‘stitching him up’ during his appearance on the ‘s**t’ Channel 4 programme last week. The former Strictly pro, 44, has ... Read more »

Price at the gas pumps could rise more as OPEC Plus cuts production

Price at the gas pumps could rise more as OPEC Plus cuts production Gasoline prices in Canada continue to creep higher ahead of the Thanksgiving long weekend. According to retail ... Read more »

Texas executes inmate who fought prayer, touch rules

John Henry Ramirez was convicted of killing 46-year-old Pablo Castro in 2004, as he took out the trash while working at a convenience store in Corpus Christi. Read more »

Black residents in 2 Florida neighborhoods say they have been left out of Hurricane Ian relief efforts

Latronia Latson said she feels like she has been neglected in the recovery efforts from Hurricane Ian. Latson, who lives in the Dunbar neighborhood in Fort Myers, Florida, said she ... Read more »

Azul Launches A New Airbus A320 Route From Recife To Montevideo

Azul Launches A New Airbus A320 Route From Recife To Montevideo Azul IATA/ICAO Code: AD/AZU Airline Type: Low-Cost Carrier Hub(s): Belo Horizonte International Airport, Sao Paulo Viracopos International Airport, Recife/Guararapes ... Read more »

‘Why am I doing 2 interviews for a part-time position at Planet Fitness?’: Job applicant calls out Planet Fitness’ hiring process

woman speaking in car (l) Planet Fitness building with sign and parking lot (c) woman speaking in car (r) A TikToker went viral after she shared her story about being ... Read more »

Video: Mother and her family lose their privacy and daylight after massive home build pops up next door - so how was the 'out-of-character' development approved?  

Read more »

I'm just potty about postboxes: As the first box marked with Charles III's cypher is being readied, HARRY WALLOP confesses to a rather nerdish midlife obsession

Some men, when they hit their mid-40s, buy themselves a sports car or start an affair. My midlife crisis is not as ruinous to my finances, but it could well ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network