Opinion: The Minneapolis 'Defund the Police' ballot question should alarm Democrats nationwide

Asia's Tech News Daily

On November 2, voters across the nation will head to the polls for an array of state and local elections. Although 2021 is considered to be an “off-year election,” there is no shortage of high-profile political positions up for grabs.

© Apu Gomes/Getty Images Janne Lennox participates in a Black Lives Matter protest near City Hall on the first anniversary of George Floyd’s murder, May 25, 2021 in Los Angeles, California.

In addition to New Yorkers deciding who will take over managing America’s largest city, the races for governor in New Jersey and Virginia will likely dominate the election night media coverage. Pundits will be in overdrive, dicing and dissecting exit polls and voting data in search of clues that might give some indication about what this all means for the pivotal 2022 midterm elections, as well as the 2024 presidential race.

Yet, there may be one issue looming larger than any one of these high-profile races this November: Question 2 on the Minneapolis ballot, perhaps better known as the referendum on “Defunding the Police.”

This controversial ballot measure, sparked by last year’s killing of George Floyd at the hands of former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, asks voters to decide whether to essentially dismantle and defund the city’s current police department, replacing it with a “Department of Public Safety” which would exert “public safety functions through a comprehensive public health approach to be determined by the Mayor and Council.”

The measure, supported by a progressive coalition which has branded itself as “Yes on Question 2” explains in “the majority of situations where people need help, a police officer is not the appropriate response,” and the ballot measure will empower the mayor and city council to “remove a requirement for the city to maintain an armed police-only model of safety.”

The City of Minneapolis is a progressive, Democratic stronghold, yet the question will finally bring some clarity to how much mojo the “defund the police” movement really has against the backdrop of a city where gun violence is careening out of control.

For years, long before the death of George Floyd, in many large US cities including Minneapolis, there had been a small, but vocal contingent of racial-justice activists that argued a good chunk of the annual $100 billion in taxpayer dollars used to prop up police departments across the country could be better deployed to reimagine what public safety might look like.

These advocates for reform, led by groups such as Black Lives Matter, believe a reapportionment of the funds — which tend to be the lion’s share of city budgets — could deliver better net outcomes in urban environments if all or a significant portion of funds were directed towards an array of smart community initiatives, after-school programs for students and public housing efforts.

Activists have argued police departments are largely failing in their mission to make communities safer by addressing only the symptoms, namely crime, and not its underlying root causes. Some go as far as arguing police departments are really civilian-led paramilitaries that have exacerbated inner-city problems, especially among communities of color, and the time to curtail or even eliminate the role they play in society is long overdue.

A poll by PBS’ Frontline with other local news organizations last month suggests Minneapolis voters are split fairly evenly on the issue of defunding the police, with a plurality indicating they would just as soon do away with the MPD. Yet how much of this rhetoric translates into actual yes votes on election day is still very much an open question. The ballot effort has even struggled to gain overwhelming support from the majority of Black voters in Minneapolis, according to the same poll.

In the immediate aftermath of George Floyd’s death, I, like so many other Americans of all different racial and ethnic backgrounds, was outraged by the full display of police brutality. In my case, it really hit home as I have two small mixed-race children, and Floyd’s death served as a wake-up call about the need for police reform. However, as a liberal but somewhat moderate Democrat, I see practical and political peril in going too far too quickly to address police abuse. And I am not alone.

Politically, the ‘defund the police’ ballot question debate is driving a wedge between Minnesota Democrats. The state’s best-known progressives, Rep. Ilhan Omar and Attorney General Keith Ellison defend the ballot measure, while other top Democrats, including Sen. Amy Klobuchar and Gov. Tim Walz, strongly oppose it. On a national scale, the Minneapolis ballot question will provide the first test of how much legs the big-city police department restructuring movement really has ahead of the 2022 midterm elections. And for Democrats all along the ideological continuum, the stakes could not be bigger.

© Tunheim Arick Wierson

The split between the moderate and progressive wings among Minneapolis Democrats reflects a broader gap evident nationwide, as the Democratic centrist establishment faces increasing pressure from a highly energized and insurgent progressive wing. Should Minneapolis voters decide to vote out their police department and replace it with an ill-defined public safety organization, the result could have national repercussions for Democrats already facing an uphill battle in the 2022 midterms.

Republican operatives are already salivating at the thought of shooting TV ads for competitive 2022 House and Senate races that paint Democrats — even when faced with record crime rates — as being a party out of touch when it comes to the basic issues of keeping order and maintaining public safety.

The national political blowback, should the “yes” option to Question 2 on the Minneapolis ballot prevail, could be significant. Fortunately, this is not lost on some Democrats, especially those in purple swing districts targeted by the National Republican Congressional Committee for takeback.

Democratic Rep. Angie Craig, from Minnesota’s 2nd District, which includes suburbs of the Twin Cities, understands even though her district doesn’t include Minneapolis, the political runoff from the defund ballot measure into her own election could be significant. Craig has denounced the police defunding referendum as “shortsighted, misguided and likely to harm the very communities that it seeks to protect.”

This much is clear: Although they are extremely vocal, Democrats who support the “defund the police” movement hold views that are frankly frightening to the majority of Americans across the ideological spectrum. If a progressive stronghold like Minneapolis effectively votes to dismantle its police department, it will send shockwaves across the political ecosystem and deliver Republicans a powerful talking point.

Minneapolis will be seen as a city of lawlessness, and Democrats will be blamed. This is a narrative arc that will feed perfectly into the Republicans’ framing that Democrats just aren’t that good at governing anyway.

Need more proof? Republicans will just point to Congress. Despite controlling both the executive and legislative branches of government, Democrats’ internecine dysfunction has already stalled President Joe Biden’s domestic agenda. Coupled with the Biden Administration’s disastrous handling of the military withdrawal from Afghanistan on the foreign policy front, we can see an entire party already bracing for severe voter backlash in 2022.

It’s going to be tough enough already for Democrats in 2022. And “Question 2” on the Minneapolis ballot could make things a whole lot worse.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

BSF DG concedes threat of Pak pushing in Taliban fighters, abandoned US military equipment into Kashmir

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: BSF DG Pankaj Kumar Singh on Tuesday warned about the possibility of Pakistan using Taliban fighters and arms and war equipment ... Read more »

Return military land under commercial use to government: Pakistan SC

© Provided by The Times of India ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s Supreme Court on Tuesday said the country’s law does not allow land meant for defence purposes to be used for commercial ... Read more »

New daily infection record in Oslo: 831 new corona cases registered in the last 24 hours

A total of 831 new corona infection cases have been registered in Oslo in the last 24 hours. That is 201 more than the same day last week and a ... Read more »

Takeover of Gurugram colonies: MCG to meet RWAs, builders this week

© Provided by Hindustan Times The civic body will prepare a detailed project report for each colony, officials said. (HT archive) The Municipal Corporation of Gurugram (MCG) has decided to ... Read more »

A private jet charter firm says it's seen more than 600 searches for flights out of South Africa since Omicron was identified

© Provided by Business Insider Wealthy travelers are searching for private jet flights out of South Africa. Shutterstock.com The newly-discovered Omicron variant of COVID-19 has the wealthy looking to leave ... Read more »

TISS campus to reopen in phased manner

© Provided by Hindustan Times This move to reopen TISS campus comes after a report was submitted by a special committee to assess the situation and make recommendations. (HT PHOTO) ... Read more »

Civilian fatalities in J&K highest in 4 years: MHA in Lok Sabha

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Civilian fatalities in Jammu and Kashmir till November 15 this year were higher than the annual figure for the past four ... Read more »

Central scheme to upskill 2,500 street food vendors in east Delhi

© Provided by Hindustan Times According to EDMC officials, registered street food vendors will go through four-five days of counselling sessions where they will get clarity on their competencies, aptitude, ... Read more »

Walmart turned an empty lot into a pop-up container yard as retailers scramble to combat the supply-chain crisis

© Provided by Business Insider Associated Press Walmart is using an empty lot to process over 500 shipping container per day, according to its VP of Supply Chain Operations. The ... Read more »

Demographic shift in Assam, Bengal may have led Centre to extend BSF jurisdiction: BSF DG

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: BSF director general (DG) Pankaj Kumar Singh on Tuesday said that the “demographic balance has been upset to a great degree” ... Read more »

Desmond inquiry: official says review needed on how N.S. serves African Nova Scotians

PORT HAWKESBURY, N.S. — A Nova Scotia government official says the province’s Health Department could do a better job serving African Nova Scotians. © Provided by The Canadian Press Wayne ... Read more »

‘If there's a breach, we go from zero to 100': Abbotsford, B.C. on high flood alert Tuesday

The Fraser Valley is bracing for more flooding Tuesday as the third atmospheric river hits B.C. © THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward People watch the rising flood waters crossing the Canada/United ... Read more »

Apply for citizenship under CAA once rules come, govt says but mum on timeline

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Discounting speculation about a rethink on the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) a day after the three farm laws were repealed ... Read more »

Ben Raymond: The neo-Nazi terrorist who thought he had got away with it

Months before Ben Raymond was convicted of being a member of the terrorist group National Action, he created a guide to evading prosecution. © Bitchute Ben Raymond, centre, speaking at ... Read more »

Covid: Further 159 deaths and 39,716 new coronavirus cases recorded in latest UK daily figures

A further 159 deaths and 39,716 new coronavirus cases have been recorded in the UK in the latest daily Covid figures. © PA Archive Coronavirus – Mon Mar 29, 2021 ... Read more »

Experts Settle the Debate: Is It Better to Work Out in the Morning or at Night?

I don’t know what’s worse: the alarm blaring at 5 a.m., filling me with workout dread, or the anxiety that tends to creep in at the end of the day ... Read more »

BBC Celebrity Antiques Road Trip: Trisha Goddard's three marriages and surviving breast cancer

In tonight’s episode of Celebrity Antiques Road Trip, TV doctor and GP Amir Khan will be taking on TV talk show icon Trisha Goddard. Experts Tim Medhurst and Izzie Balmer ... Read more »

Johnson verspricht: Booster für alle Erwachsene bis Ende Januar

Der britische Premierminister Boris Johnson hat allen Erwachsenen in seinem Land bis Ende Januar eine Booster-Impfung gegen das Coronavirus in Aussicht gestellt. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Boris Johnson, Premierminister von ... Read more »

Wegen russischer Truppenbewegungen: Nato aktiviert Krisenmechanismus

Die Nato wird nach Angaben des geschäftsführenden Bundesaussenministers Heiko Maas wegen der russischen Truppenbewegungen unweit der ukrainischen Grenze einen Krisenmechanismus auslösen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Jens Stoltenberg (3.v.r), Nato-Generalsekretär, Edgars ... Read more »

NHL COVID-19 updates: Boston Bruins coach Bruce Cassidy enters protocol with mild symptoms

BOSTON — Boston Bruins coach Bruce Cassidy has been placed in the NHL’s COVID-19 protocol. Cassidy is the first Bruins player or coach to be added to the protocol this ... Read more »

Boris Johnson announcement – 4 Covid booster jabs vital for vulnerable says NHS boss as Brits face fines under new rules

THE most vulnerable in the country are set to get four coronavirus jabs in a race to stop the spread of the Omicron variant, an NHS chief has revealed. NHS ... Read more »

States: Sackler family members abusing bankruptcy process

The Associated PressFILE – In this Aug. 9, 2021, file photo, fake pill bottles with messages about OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma are displayed during a protest outside the courthouse where ... Read more »

The best present this Xmas is getting boosters to protect loved ones from Omicron

On this day, a year ago, we lacked the one thing we needed most of all in our fight against COVID: an approved vaccine to deploy to the people of ... Read more »

The hidden Disney World spot where you can avoid the crowds

DISNEY World can draw huge crowds all year round, as families flock to the happiest place on earth. But if you are planning on going and want to avoid the ... Read more »

Man with Tesla face tattoo busted for DUI after crashing minivan

Jordan Lindsey, above, was driving of a 1992 GMC Safari when he crashed on a highway outside Chicago last Thursday. A man with Tesla face tattoo has been busted on ... Read more »

NJ cop Louis Santiago had reportedly been drinking before fatally striking nurse with car

Louis Santiago was slapped with reckless vehicular homicide, desecrating human remains, DWI and other charges after he allegedly struck and killed nurse Damian Dymka. Essex County, N.J. jail A Newark ... Read more »

Camden County Acting Prosecutor announces departure

CAMDEN – Jill S. Mayer, Camden County's acting prosecutor since October 2019, has announced her abrupt departure from the law enforcement agency. Mayer on Tuesday said she will retire Wednesday, ... Read more »

Shocking images show what diabetes really looks like for millions of people

Diabetics’ vision can get wavy, as illustrated using a very fragile-looking Tower Bridge. Lenstore These shocking images give an idea of what millions of people with diabetes have struggled with. ... Read more »

Tiger Woods Reveals Amputating His Leg Was Considered After Car Accident

© Ben Jared/PGA TOUR via Getty Image Tiger Woods faced the possibility of having his leg amputated after his car accident. In a Tuesday press conference at the Hero World Challenge, his ... Read more »

Prosecutors begin calling witnesses on second day of actor Jussie Smollett's trial for reporting allegedly bogus hate crime

CHICAGO — One of the lead Chicago police detectives assigned to investigate the alleged hate-crime attack on Jussie Smollett took the stand Tuesday morning in Smollett’s trial, walking jurors step ... Read more »

Beyoncé Features Daughters Rumi and Blue Ivy in New Fashion Campaign

© Tiffany & Co. Beyoncé’s keeping it in the family when it comes to her hype crew. Bey enlisted her 9-year-old daughter, Blue Ivy, and 4-year-old daughter, Rumi, for her new ... Read more »

Britney Spears is now on 'the right medication' after conservatorship termination

Britney Spears is basking in the glow of her new unrestrained life.  On Nov. 29, the pop star posted a photo of a fireplace decorated for the holidays. In her ... Read more »

Michael K. Williams' Docuseries 'Black Market' Gets Emotional Season 2 Trailer

© et Michael K. Williams‘ final documentary project is making its debut. On Monday, Vice dropped a first look at season 2 of the late actor‘s TV docuseries, Black Market With Michael K. ... Read more »

People over-60 should postpone travel amid Omicron variant, WHO warns

(Evening Standard) Vulnerable people – including over-60s – should postpone travel, the World Health Organization (WHO) has advised. New advice was issued to people in the wake of the new ... Read more »

For Boris everything will always turn out for the best — until it doesn't

Well, who would you trust with the nation’s health? On the Radio 4 Today programme, Jenny Harries, chief executive of the Health Security Agency and frequent celebrity guest at Downing ... Read more »

Father of 8-week-old baby wanted in connection to infant's death: Court documents

The father of an 8-week-old baby who died over the weekend in Sioux Falls is charged with one count of murder and one count of manslaughter, according to court documents ... Read more »

Covid rules could be tightened, minister says

© PA Media Mask wearing is now expected in shops and schools The Isle of Man government is “prepared to go further and harder” with Covid restrictions if new rules ... Read more »

Boosters ‘huge logistical challenge' for the NHS, experts say

The expansion of the Covid-19 vaccine booster programme poses a “huge logistical challenge” for the NHS, experts have said. Health leaders said the campaign was already at its “most complex ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial: Prince Andrew travelled in Jeffrey Epstein's private jet, pilot tells court

Jeffrey Epstein‘s former pilot, Lawrence Visoski, arrives for Ghislaine Maxwell‘s sex trafficking trial in New York Jeffrey Epstein’s private pilot has described Ghislaine Maxwell as the “number two” in the ... Read more »

Face masks now exempt for dancing on some forms of public transport

© Getty Images The exemption is intended to cover party buses and boats – Getty Images Areas of public transport “used mainly for dancing” have been exempted from new Covid ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic