Opinion: How to solve the problem posed by Rep. Boebert

Asia's Tech News Daily

After video surfaced of Colorado Rep. Lauren Boebert making anti-Muslim comments about Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar in mid-November, Congress must again contend with a major question: how to handle members who step out of line, offending and potentially endangering the wellbeing of their colleagues.

Opinion: How to solve the problem posed by Rep. Boebert
© Joe Raedle/Getty Images ORLANDO, FLORIDA – FEBRUARY 27: Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) attends the Conservative Political Action Conference held in the Hyatt Regency on February 27, 2021 in Orlando, Florida. Begun in 1974, CPAC brings together conservative organizations, activists, and world leaders to discuss issues important to them. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

In a video posted on Facebook before Thanksgiving, Boebert implied Omar had been mistaken for a terrorist — or member of the “jihad squad” — in a Capitol Hill elevator. On Friday, Boebert offered a weak apology on Twitter, saying she was sorry “to anyone in the Muslim community” she offended with her comment.

This comes on the heels of Arizona Rep. Paul Gosar being censured and stripped of committees for tweeting a photoshopped anime video in which he attacks New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and President Joe Biden with swords. Now, some think Boebert should face a similar fate and, at the very least, censure.

There is no question that Boebert’s comments were deeply bigoted, that Gosar’s violent fantasies are disturbing and that neither are conducting themselves the way most of us would like to see members of Congress — regardless of party — behave.

But it is not at all obvious that censure, and a corresponding stripping of committee assignments, is the right, or even useful, solution to this problem. Though it may have worked in the past, notably when Wisconsin Sen. Joe McCarthy was censured by his colleagues in 1954 and faded into irrelevance, the US Senate — and Congress at large — is a very different institution today, increasing plagued by partisan politics.

And while censure and stripping of committees may make Boebert and Gosar’s political opponents feel like some form of justice has been served, they inevitably lead down a slippery slope. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy has already made it clear that Republicans like Gosar, who have been stripped of committee assignments, will be reinstated if and when the Republicans regain control of the US House of Representatives.

More troublingly, censuring Boebert and Gosar for their extreme and dangerous comments raises the possibility — or more accurately ensures — that similar methods will be used against Democratic members of the House the next time the Republicans are the majority party, which could happen as early as January 2023. Once again, McCarthy has said as much — arguing that Democrats have not taken similar action against their own members when they have stepped out of line, but that a Republican majority most certainly would.

Some may say if the GOP is going to censure Democrats in the future, that the Democrats in the House should not hesitate to censure members like Boebert and Gosar who say and post offensive material. There is some truth to that, but that argument is weakened by the reality that this kind of censure does not reform members of Congress who chose to traffic in bigotry or violence.

Despite facing potential punishment, Boebert has — even after issuing a weak apology — again attacked Omar. After a call between the two members, Boebert said, “I will fearlessly continue to put America first, never sympathizing with terrorists. Unfortunately Ilhan can’t say the same thing and our country is worse off for it.”

Boebert appears more interested in generating headlines than delivering for the district she represents. Censure — and particularly stripping of committee assignments — makes it much more difficult for members of Congress to deliver for their district, work on legislation that is particularly important to them or otherwise function as effective legislators.

The failure of the censure process and the likelihood that it will become a common partisan tool in the coming years leaves Congress with few choices for policing its own members. While it would be ideal if Congress could agree — in a bipartisan way — on a clear set of rules of decorum, which are more specific than the current code of conduct, as well consequences for members who broke those rules, that is unlikely.

Given the extremely partisan nature of Congress today — in which only two Republican members of the House voted to censure Gosar — Democrats and Republicans will not reach a necessary consensus to institutionalize new rules.

As much as the bigoted comments from Boebert and violent threats from Gosar may be troubling and repugnant, it may be best that Congress get out of the business of trying to police its members and leave that to the voters.

If the voters of Colorado’s 3rd district or Arizona’s 4th district want vulgar and racist representation, that is also their right. And, at least this approach — which gives the voters ultimate say — also means that Omar, Ocasio-Cortez and other prominent Democrats, who are widely disliked by the right, will likely not have to worry about censure if the GOP regains control of the House.

Opinion: How to solve the problem posed by Rep. Boebert
© Courtesy Lincoln Mitchell Lincoln Mitchell

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Elective surgeries and procedures postponed at SMH

Stevenson Memorial Hospital has  ramped down elective and non-urgent surgeries procedures.  The hospital was directed to make  the change by the Province. Effective January 5, 2022, began  ramping down elective ... Read more »

Lawyers for N.B. doctor file lawsuit against province, RCMP and Facebook

© Provided by The Canadian Press FREDERICTON — A doctor who says he faced a barrage of hate and racism after being accused of breaking COVID-19 rules in New Brunswick ... Read more »

Hearthstone Patch 22.2 arrives on live servers next week

© Provided by Dot Esports Hearthstone players have taken on the game’s latest expansion, Fractured in Alterac Valley, for over a month now. Patch 22.2 will hit live servers next ... Read more »

Confirmed: Cadillac Is Building an Escalade V and It Sounds Like It'll Have a V-8

Despite being one of Cadillac’s most popular models, the Escalade has never been offered in a high-performance V variant. But with competitors from BMW M and Mercedes-AMG raking up sales, ... Read more »

Charlie Puth Breaks A Sweat In ‘Light Switch' Music Video

Charlie Puth is flicking a switch in the new music video for “Light Switch”. Puth, 30, made the transition from Fat Thor (“Avengers: Endgame”) to Fit Thor in his latest ... Read more »

Apprentice star Shama Amin discusses decision to QUIT

Shama Amin has discussed the difficult decision to quit The Apprentice after struggling with her rheumatoid arthritis, which made it too hard for her to carry on. The nursery-owner from Bradford, 41, ... Read more »

What does ‘nocebo effect' mean - and how does it relate to placebos?

A “placebo effect’’ occurs when a medical patient is given a treatment that has no pharmacological therapeutic benefit as part of a trial programme, such as a saline injection or ... Read more »

Tiny two-bed cottage goes on the market for £300,000 – but just wait until you see the view

A REMOTE two-bed cottage has gone on the market for £300,000 – and there's a very good reason for the cost. The home is a little short on space inside, ... Read more »

The Best Massage Oils for Every Purpose and Occasion

There’s nothing better than a relaxing massage to help take you away from all of life’s turbulent moments. Sometimes a little rubdown can ease all of your tensions, get rid ... Read more »

Rocket League’s Neon Nights event will feature a collaboration with artist GRIMES

© Provided by GamePur Psyonix has announced a new event for its ever-popular vehicular soccer game Rocket League. It’s called Neon Nights and will feature the artist GRIMES, making it ... Read more »

Pokémon Legends: Arceus leak shows time-space distortions, new overworld encounter method

© Provided by Dot Esports More mechanics from Pokémon Legends: Arceus are continuing to leak as more players get their hands on the game ahead of its official launch on ... Read more »

A Man Led Police On A Chase Just So He Could Finish His Hamburger

© Image: Bridget Bennett (Getty Images) Image: Bridget Bennett (Getty Images) Have you ever been so hungry that satisfying your burger craving meant more to you than a stint in ... Read more »

Stephen Harper — activist investor? Why the former PM's path after politics shouldn't surprise anyone

© Provided by Financial Post Former Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks at a conference in Washington in 2017. In contrast with many of other former prime ministers, Harper has ... Read more »

Graeme Swann and Matt Prior slam English cricket counties for 'pricing out' emerging talent

Former England cricketers Graeme Swann and Matt Prior have attacked counties for “pricing out young talent” as calls mount for grass-roots reform following the Ashes humiliation. Prior, 39, hit out ... Read more »

Peloton’s woes continue as it temporarily halts bike, treadmill production

© Photo by Amelia Holowaty Krales / The Verge Peloton is pausing production of its connected bikes and treadmills. Peloton’s pandemic fortunes began waning in 2021, and it appears that ... Read more »

The International Space Station could soon have a FILM STUDIO

The International Space Station could have a new dedicated film studio and sports arena by the middle of the decade, if a British firm gets its way. Space Entertainment Enterprise ... Read more »

House GOP chair slams Biden for questioning what Republicans 'are for'

Republican Conference Chair Rep. Elise Stefanik hammered President Joe Biden Thursday morning for questioning at his press conference what Republicans stand for.  ‘Let me tell you what we are for,’ ... Read more »

Apple warns ALL Android users to install its new app – tell your friends and family

ANDROID smartphone owners have been urged to install an app by rival Apple after a string of stalking incidents. The tech giant has made the rare decision to release an ... Read more »

Canada's Ontario to start lifting COVID-related curbs, Quebec more cautious

© Reuters/PATRICK DOYLE FILE PHOTO: People queue to collect coronavirus disease (COVID-19) antigen test kits at the Hazeldean Mall in Ottawa (Reuters) – Canada’s most populous province of Ontario has ... Read more »

Saturday morning UK news briefing: Today's top headlines from The Telegraph

© Provided by The Telegraph boris johnson latest news downing street party prince andrew china russia Welcome to your early morning news briefing from The Telegraph – a round-up of ... Read more »

Ranieri and Smith try to shrug off the pressure ahead of survival showdown

How big is the Friday night fixture between Watford and Norwich? “It’s very big,” says Claudio Ranieri. “We all know how important it is,” says Dean Smith. The two managers ... Read more »

Red Bull Salzburg rule out sale of Leeds target Brenden Aaronson

Brenden Aaronson will not be leaving Red Bull Salzburg this January, a club spokesperson has told 90min. © Provided by 90min Aaronson has enjoyed a great start to life in Europe. ... Read more »

Papst Benedikt soll Missbrauch verharmlost haben

In seiner Zeit als Münchner Erzbischof unternahm Joseph Ratzinger laut einem Gutachten nichts oder zu wenig, um Kinder und Jugendliche vor Übergriffen durch Amtsträger zu schützen. Die Studie geht von ... Read more »

Americans out sick because of COVID-19 surges to record 8.8 million

© Jane Barlow – WPA Pool/Getty Images Americans out sick because of COVID-19 surges to record 8.8 million A record of nine million Americans are out sick due to the ... Read more »

My fiancé took me to Dubai and proposed… then ghosted me a few weeks before the wedding – I still don't know why

GETTING ghosted is never fun, but getting ghosted by your fiancé is a whole other ball game. A beautician from Dallas, Texas has taken to TikTok to share her story ... Read more »

The Good News (and Less Good News) for Democrats in 2022 Governors Races

© (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA – OCTOBER 13: A view of voting booths at the Santa Clara County registrar of voters office on October 13, 2020 in San ... Read more »

Is Sharing a COVID Test a Bad Idea, or Just a Gross One?

© Adam Maida / The Atlantic “It started as a joke, actually,” Elena Korngold told me. But late last month, the 40-something radiologist from Portland and her family decided that ... Read more »

New EU rules will help farmers prevent costly disease outbreaks | View

For animals as much as people, prevention is not only better than cure: it is also more cost-effective. But for livestock farmers already operating on tight margins, it can be ... Read more »

London Charing Cross incident: Trains delayed after trespasser at station

Trains from the busy Charing Cross station in Central London have been delayed this evening after trespassers got onto the line. The incident has now been cleared, but later services ... Read more »

Boris Johnson news - live: No 10 accused of blackmail against rebels as MP says defection ‘calmed nerves'

LIVE – Updated at 11:35 A senior Conservative MP has accused ministers of breaching the ministerial code by making threats to rebel colleagues who are considering trying to topple Boris ... Read more »

Hunt for 'serial killer' on the loose after animals found with their heads cut off in South London 'lake of horror'

Fears are growing over a suspected “serial killer” that is responsible for several animal decapitations and drownings taking place at a “lake of horror” in southeast London. Wildlife rescuer Carly ... Read more »

How to watch Netflix's epic Kanye West film trilogy before it's on Netflix

© Provided by CNET Netflix’s Kanye West docuseries followed the rapper, with his permission, for more than 20 years from his very beginnings as a hiphop artist. Getty Images Netflix’s ... Read more »

Georgia prosecutor requests special grand jury in Trump probe

The Georgia prosecutor investigating possible interference in the 2020 presidential election by former President Donald Trump has asked a judge to appoint a special grand jury for her investigation. In ... Read more »

Armed man shot and killed at San Francisco airport

© Getty Images Armed man shot and killed at San Francisco airport An armed man was shot and killed by police at the San Francisco International Airport Thursday morning. The ... Read more »

How to watch Carabao Cup: Draws, fixtures for Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool in 2021-2022 League Cup

© Provided by Sporting News The Carabao Cup, also known as the League Cup or EFL Cup, is the first major trophy awarded in the English football season and one of ... Read more »

Trump insists his phone call with Georgia's secretary of state was 'perfect' after Fulton County DA requests a grand jury in criminal probe

© White House Trump. White House Trump released a statement insisting his phone call with Georgia’s secretary of state after the 2020 election was “perfect.” The statement followed a report ... Read more »

Raiders Player Explains Why Team Improved After Jon Gruden's Exit

© Provided by Sports Illustrated Rich Bisaccia appeared to be a welcome replacement for Jon Gruden in Las Vegas. View the original article to see embedded media. The Raiders went ... Read more »

Mike Vrabel: Derrick Henry progressing well, decision coming Friday

Titans running back Derrick Henry completed the practice week without any issues involving his foot and all signs point to him playing against the Bengals on Saturday, but final word ... Read more »

Gov. Hochul announces ‘next phase' of Brooklyn-Queens transit link

Gov. Kathy Hochul’s plan to build a public transit link between Brooklyn and Queens picked up steam Thursday as she released an initial MTA study into the project. Under the framework, an ... Read more »

Cheers! NY moviegoers can now grab beer or wine with their popcorn

The New York State Liquor Authority ruled that movie theaters can now sell wine and beer at concession stands and the drinks can be taken into the theaters. Getty Images/iStockphoto ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic