Opinion: F1 is spoiling the show with post-race stewarding decisions

Opinion: F1 is spoiling the show with post-race stewarding decisions

It’s a theme that we’ve seen before and one that has generated indignation in the past – the outcome of a Formula 1 race result should not, if it can be avoided, be decided in the stewards’ room post-race.

Red Bull’s Sergio Perez masterfully drove to victory in difficult conditions on Sunday in Singapore, taking the fourth win of his F1 1 career.

However, the triumph was in doubt long before the Mexican driver reached the chequered flag, as he was placed under investigation for an alleged Safety Car infringement. 

Perez was indeed punished after being deemed to have been at fault on three occasions, but the five-second time penalty that he was dished didn’t abolish his race win, given the gap he built over Charles Leclerc before the finish.


Technical Insight: Budget cap controversy and big updates for McLaren

2 hours ago

Binotto hails ‘brave’ Ferrari for slick tyre call amid Red Bull fight

2 hours ago

Nevertheless, it led the sport back to the situation where fans sit and wait for the verdict, which takes away from the spectacle on the track. While the opening portion of the race was tedious, the close battle between Perez and Leclerc offered a strong show in the second half. 

But having the outcome sorted behind the scenes is distasteful, and creates an anti-climactic atmosphere that robs fans of being able to fully enjoy the experience.

There are some examples in which this is unavoidable. Last year’s Abu Dhabi Grand Prix saw Max Verstappen overtake Lewis Hamilton on the final lap, with Mercedes left unhappy with the way the Safety Car procedure was carried out.

It was an extreme case, as not only was the race win on the line, but so was the World Championship. Mercedes’ protest (against the FIA itself) was unsuccessful, and the result stood. Although the late nature of the incident gave the stewards no time to investigate during the race, the verdict came several hours after the chequered flag was waved, leaving fans and the teams in a state of limbo.

In Austria 2019, Verstappen was involved in a robust battle with Charles Leclerc for the race win. The two clashed wheels when Verstappen overtook the Monegasque driver. On that occasion, the verdict was delivered after the race, despite there being ample time to dissect the incident and ensure there’s a set-in-stone result when the chequered flag waves.

Perhaps the stewards feel that they want to hear directly from the driver before deciding their verdict. It’s a fair point, but teams have sporting directors and various team members that have a deep understanding of racing and are qualified to speak on behalf of the drivers.

At the 2019 Canadian Grand Prix, Sebastian Vettel was handed a five-second time penalty during the race after he was considered guilty of forcing Hamilton off the track following a mistake. The punishment was costly as it denied Vettel the win, dropping him to second place behind the Mercedes driver.

Whether or not you believe the penalty was justified, it was a refreshing scenario in the sense that there was no confusion over wait times after the grand prix had ended. The stewards had made their decision, displayed assertiveness and moved on.

In Singapore on Sunday, there appeared to be little need to postpone the verdict until after the race. The matter of Perez keeping within 10 car lengths of the Safety Car, which is required by the regulations, should be relatively simple to analyse and decipher.

Incidents that occur at the front of the field that require investigations should be a matter of great importance, and take priority over most other in-race dealings the stewards are forced to contend with.

At a time when the sport is giving attention to the show amid rocketing popularity, F1 risks frustrating fans if it wants to postpone such decisions to after the race, hours after they have diverted their attention away from the screens. 

Additional confusion is not welcomed – competent and assured stewarding decisions that don’t derail the momentum of a grand prix weekend are.

News Related


Ford Transit Electric Delivery Vans Added to DHL Fleets

Ford Pro and DHL are bringing more electric delivery vehicles to more places, including a new order for 2000 all-electric Ford E-Transit vans. DHL plans to use mostly zero-emission vans ... Read more »

New powersport LEDs from Lumileds

Lumileds is launching a new line of LED upgrade retrofits for fog light and powersports headlight applications. They produce a cool colour temperature of up to 6000K with a bright ... Read more »

New Wrangler tires from Goodyear

Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company announced the addition of the Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse HT. Engineered to deliver dependable all-season traction, the Wrangler Workhorse HT provides a smooth, confident ride and ... Read more »

KYB bringing JAOS suspension products to North America

KYB Americas announced a new partnership with Japan Offroad Service that will make KYB JAOS Suspension products available in North America through KYB distributors. JAOS designs and manufactures a complete ... Read more »

Elon Musk Tells President Biden Tesla Is Opening Supercharger Network

Tesla Supercharger 1 The vocal CEO also shares that Tesla has open-sourced its charge connector. Tesla’s outspoken CEO Elon Musk and President Joe Biden clearly haven’t seen eye to eye. ... Read more »

Top BMW Engineer Thinks Li-Ion Batteries Have "Peaked"

BMW Solid State Battery Info Solid-state batteries will likely be the next big thing. The next generation of BMW electric vehicles promises up to 620 miles of range, 30 percent ... Read more »

Australian vehicle sales for November 2022: VFACTS

It’s almost the end of the year which means the best-selling new vehicles for 2022 will soon be revealed. In the meantime though VFACTS new vehicle registration figures for November ... Read more »

Strange & sudden DPF jump on my Innova Crysta: Need Advice

Since the last tank fill, have driven 400 km on the highway and 200 km in city traffic. BHPian Innysta recently shared this with other enthusiasts. Had a strange experience ... Read more »

First Drive: 2024 Acura Integra Type S

Even before it arrived it was announcing its presence — the 2024 Acura Integra Type S, which is a prototype at this point, is the loudest Honda yet, and it is ... Read more »

Ford, SK on make significant construction progress at BlueOval SK Battery Park, on-plan to train 5,000 employees at on-site training center

Construction progress at BlueOval SK Battery Park on schedule, bringing Ford closer to its target of producing an annual run rate of 2 million electric vehicles globally by end of 2026 Read more »

Ford Pro and Deutsche Post DHL Group join forces to electrify last mile delivery worldwide

Ford Pro and Deutsche Post DHL Group signed a Memorandum of Understanding aiming to speed up electrification of vans around the globe Read more »

Acura Integra Type S Confirmed for Summer 2023 Arrival

With the recent launch of the revived Acura Integra, it seemed like it was only a matter of time before the Integra Type S would also debut. Now we know ... Read more »

BMW M2 Mixed Reality review: the best racing game ever created

Is that headset to prevent you from looking at the new BMW M2’s face? Indeed, on the surface there appears to be a plethora of easy targets to aim for ... Read more »

The Chevy Suburban Has 1 Long-Lasting Advantage

Give it up for the Chevrolet Suburban. It officially has one significant advantage over rivals such as the Ford Expedition, Dodge Durango, and Jeep Wagoneer. The Chevy Suburban serves as ... Read more »

Most Fuel-Efficient Midsize Pickup Trucks From 2021 for Light Towing

Looking for a truck that does it all? Here are three fuel-efficient midsize pickup trucks that are suitable for an everyday vehicle. Midsize trucks have the versatility of a sport ... Read more »

The Ford Transit Connect Slots Above the Chrysler Pacifica on This Best Minivans List

In a world dominated by crossovers and SUVs, minivans still have a place among families and small business owners. Comparing the Ford Transit Connect to the Chrysler Pacifica ends with ... Read more »

PCarmarket Is Selling 171-Mile A Ferrari Testarossa

This Ferrari is a 1990s superhero. Ferrari is a brand built off of the image of some of the most famous classic hand-built supercars in the world. The amazing engineering ... Read more »

Ultium Cells to expand battery factory in Spring Hill

Ultium Cells, the battery cell joint venture between General Motors and LG Energy Solution, is investing further money in its second plant in Spring Hill in the US state of ... Read more »

BayBatt opens new battery R&D laboratory

The Bavarian Centre for Battery Technology (BayBatt) at the University of Bayreuth has celebrated the inauguration of its new premises. Covering an area of around 7,000 square metres, the building ... Read more »

Toyota Innova Hycross Vs Tata Harrier Price, Engine Specs, Dimensions Comparison

Toyota Innova Hycross Vs Tata Harrier Price, Engine Specs, Dimensions Comparison In this Toyota Innova Hycross vs Tata Harrier comparison, we’ll look at the variant-wise prices, engine specs and dimensions ... Read more »

Lexus LFA Electric Successor To Have Manual Gearbox And Steer-By-Wire

It will have brake-by-wire and all-wheel drive, too. Read more »

An Acura Integra Type S Is Officially on the Way With Civic Type R Power

If you want a Civic Type R without the oversized wing, Acura's got something coming for you this summer. Read more »

Driven: The Acura Integra Type S Is Gonna Be Good

With only a brief session in a prototype, we can't draw final conclusions. But the 2024 Acura Integra Type S feels like it has that special Civic Type R magic. Read more »

Next-gen Santa Fe powertrains will be dictated by hybrid’s success; EV unlikely

An all-new Hyundai Santa Fe is expected to debut in late 2023 and Hyundai executives have told Wheels that sales results over the next 12 months will determine the forthcoming ... Read more »

Toyota C-HR to live on: New concept previews next-generation small SUV

Snapshot Next-generation 2024 Toyota C-HR confirmed; previewed by new concept Second-gen small SUV set to feature in Toyota’s local line-up Hybrid and plug-in hybrid powertrains announced A new concept has ... Read more »

Bentley Shows Off Custom Flying Spur Hybrid in Miami

This special Bentley Flying Spur is a collaboration between luxury automaker Bentley and custom shoemaker Dominic Ciambrone (a.k.a. “The Surgeon”), and comes directly after the pair released 10 sneakers, each ... Read more »

Newgarden, McLaughlin Team Up For Rolex 24

Tower Motorsports, the reigning LMP2 class champions in the IMSA WeatherTech Sportscar Championship has named their lineup for the Rolex 24 at Daytona (Fla.). NTT IndyCar Series drivers Josef Newgarden ... Read more »

Electric cars sales boom in November but 'big question marks' over how long it can last, says expert

Signs that private buyers are being turned off Read more »

Watch Kia EV6 GT Drag Race Lamborghini Aventador

kia ev6 versus lamborghini aventador drag race It’s not only gas versus electric, but also relatively budget-friendly versus ridiculously excessive. Did you ever think the day would come when we’d ... Read more »

Top 10 Gift Ideas for Petrolheads

It doesn’t have to be hard… Read more »

Redesigned Toyota C-HR previewed with plug-in hybrid concept

Toyota is working on a redesign for the C-HR subcompact crossover, and on Monday the automaker previewed the design with a thinly veiled concept vehicle. The fully electric bZ Compact ... Read more »

Rare And Desirable 2008 Porsche 911 GT3 RS Selling In Miami This Week

Cars like this were made for the track, now they’re worth a fortune. When you hear the name GT3, what exactly pops into your mind? For most people, they might ... Read more »

Had the privilege to drive the Maharaja of Mysore in my vintage Daimler

The Maharaja said that he was very happy to see the Mysore cars in person & he likes the Daimlers. BHPian KPS recently shared this with other enthusiasts. Bangalore Club ... Read more »

Bologna aims to deploy one of Europe’s largest H2 bus fleets

The Italian city of Bologna and public transit operators TPER and Srm are launching one of Europe’s largest fuel cell bus projects worth 90 million euros. The first 34 buses ... Read more »

Mercedes boss Toto Wolff states 'no team will run away with eight titles again’ in F1's new era

Mercedes boss Toto Wolff thinks the F1 cost cap regulations will prevent a run of one-team domination similar to the one his outfit enjoyed.  The German manufacturer went through an unprecedented streak ... Read more »

Tom Sykes ‘pleasantly surprised’ by WorldSBK return at Jerez

After a difficult 2022 season with Ducati in British Superbike, Tom Sykes was back in WorldSBK action during his first pre-season test with Puccetti Kawasaki, which he claimed went beyond expectations.  ... Read more »

C4 Corvette Crash and Fire Leaves Poor Car Nearly Unrecognizable

This C4 Corvette crash left little more than a molten pile of goo that’s barely recognizable at this point. We’ve certainly seen our fair share of Corvette-related crashes over the ... Read more »

2024 Acura Integra Type S Is More Like What We Were Hoping For

What’s the best way for Acura to improve upon its new Integra? Give it more power, better tires, and an upgraded chassis. So we’re pleased that the Integra’s upcoming performance ... Read more »

Acura Finally Confirms the 2024 Integra Type S with 300+ HP

Acura has shared the first info on the new Type S version of the Integra. This high-performance variant features the same components as the Honda Civic Type R: a 300-plus-hp ... Read more »

Button: Las Vegas GP in 2023 will be ‘bonkers’

Formula 1 Heineken Silver Las Vegas Grand Prix via Getty 2009 Formula 1 World Champion Jenson Button says that he expects the inaugural Las Vegas Grand Prix in 2023 to ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network