Opinion: As GOP governors obscure Black history, let’s finally tell the truth about Marcus Garvey

Earlier this month, President Joe Biden called out the GOP for “trying to hide the truth” about Black history. While politicians like Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin have described their efforts to reform education as bans on teaching critical race theory, in reality, these bans have been invoked to prohibit teaching elements of American history, especially Black history.

opinion: as gop governors obscure black history, let’s finally tell the truth about marcus garvey

Opinion: As GOP governors obscure Black history, let’s finally tell the truth about Marcus Garvey

Justin Hansford – Courtesy Justin Hansford

opinion: as gop governors obscure black history, let’s finally tell the truth about marcus garvey
Shaq Al-Hijaz – Courtesy Shaq Al-Hijaz

The suppression of stories integral to the American narrative not only robs us of important historical lessons, but also warps our vision of ourselves and our future — and makes all of our lives less rich.

With some of this country’s most powerful political figures trying to obscure the story of Black history, now is a good time to tell the true stories of Black leaders in America — particularly ones like Marcus Garvey, who was the subject of injustice and distortion. Known superficially as a “Back to Africa” advocate (as in, repatriating Black people to the African continent), Garvey actually founded what might well have been the largest human rights campaign in the history of the African Diaspora. At its zenith, Garvey’s organization boasted a membership of at least 6 million people with chapters registered in more than 40 nations. It provided inspiration for the life’s work of many important Black leaders, including Nelson Mandela, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr.

The Jamaican-born Garvey energized millions by calling for an end to colonialism in Africa, for economic justice for the entire African Diaspora and for cultural and political recognition and independence 100 years ago — a time when such declarations were just about unheard of.

As part of his push to provide economic opportunity and autonomy for Black people, Garvey started the Black-owned and -operated Black Star Line shipping company, stylized after the White Star Line, which owned the Titanic. Garvey’s ships, in theory, could have helped transport Black people back to Africa, facilitated trade throughout the diaspora and instilled pride while providing a vision of economic empowerment.

Instead, Garvey’s movement splintered in the summer of 1923, when a federal judge in the southern district of New York convicted him of mail fraud for sending out advertisements for the purchase of stock in the Black Star Line, even though the shipping company was failing economically. The government not only accused Garvey of seeking to sell stock for too high of a price, but it insinuated that Garvey’s entire career was nothing more than a Ponzi scheme designed to make a quick buck.

To the contrary, historians have for decades believed that Garvey was framed for political reasons. Indeed, as one of us has documented, the entire legal process dripped with injustice and animosity toward Garvey. For example, both the trial judge and an appellate judge were conspicuously friendly with Garvey’s political opponents.

In fact, even the initial charges can be traced directly to espionage and efforts to infiltrate the Black Star Line by J. Edgar Hoover, who hired some of the first-ever Black Bureau of Investigation agents in order to stop any “Black Moses” figures like Garvey from succeeding. Hoover wrote about his search to find a charge that would allow the government to deport Garvey, settling on mail fraud when other grounds for charges were unsuccessful.

After thousands of Garvey’s followers (the supposed victims of the fraud) petitioned for his release, his sentence was commuted in 1927. Ultimately, after Garvey’s political vision had been silenced, advocates for racial justice in the United States and abroad began to focus less on economic justice and more on civil and political rights for most of the 20th century. Today, the widening wealth gap and other indicators of inequality suggest that this shift in focus was costly.

Now Democratic Rep. Yvette D. Clarke of New York, first vice-chair of the Congressional Black Caucus, and Democratic Rep. Hank Johnson of Georgia are trying to set the historical record straight, recognizing the weight of evidence supporting Garvey’s innocence and identifying him as a champion for the liberation of people of African descent.

“The world deserves to know the truth about Marcus Mosiah Garvey and the truth about Black history,” Clarke declared in introducing the resolution to exonerate the civil rights leader. Johnson added that “it’s time to right this fundamental wrong” given the “utter lack of merit to the charges on which he was originally convicted, combined with his profound legacy and contributions to Black history in our country.”

To be sure, Garvey’s record involves some controversial decisions. This includes meeting with the KKK, asserting correctly that, during the 1920s, they had a strong voice in the US government. But this cannot stand in the way of learning about Garvey’s true history and exonerating him. This is more than simply an exercise in historical truth telling and providing justice for his family, although both are immensely important.

Garvey’s legacy is also relevant today because we see the same tactics — espionage and politically motivated charges — being deployed against Black leaders attempting to organize against the status quo. For example, Black Lives Matter protesters were designated as Black Identity Extremists by the FBI, and informants were inserted into their movement spaces in 2020 after the George Floyd uprisings.

As a society, we have failed to learn from Garvey’s story. That’s largely because mainstream narratives rarely teach about his legacy, and when they do, they usually fail to correct the historical inaccuracies promulgated by his wrongful conviction. By failing to learn the lessons from Garvey’s case, and by underestimating the harm of politically motivated infiltration and prosecution, we open the door to continuing these policies and practices. And this will result in shame for years to come.

Posthumous vindication for Garvey would begin the process of acknowledging that political sabotage from the government is antidemocratic and inherently wrong. And at a time when a battle is being waged against teachers and schools that dare discuss the African American experience, including threatening the banning of AP African American Studies in Florida, exonerating Garvey would be an important response. It would be a clear sign of resistance to revisionist history and the urge to promote versions of the past that fail to look critically at our path to the present.

For more CNN news and newsletters create an account at CNN.com

News Related


STAMPEDERS NOTES: Mike Rose set to go even bigger

Calgary Stampeders Mike Rose takes part in team practice at McMahon Stadium on Tuesday, June 6, 2023. Sure, the sack title would be nice, but it’s not really what Mike ... Read more »

Wildfire smoke hangs over Toronto, poor air quality prompts cancellations, warnings

Wildfire smoke hangs over Toronto, poor air quality prompts cancellations, warnings TORONTO — Canada’s most populous city experienced hazy skies and poor air quality Thursday as smoke from wildfires in ... Read more »

Could Less Be More for McDavid and Draisaitl? Part Two

Could Less Be More for McDavid and Draisaitl? Part Two In part one we focused on 5×5 ice time and production for Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl the past two ... Read more »

N.L. looking for proposals to build more than 850 new affordable rental units

Newfoundland and Labrador has put out a call for proposals to build more affordable housing units across the province. The move is part of a new, three-year affordable housing program ... Read more »

Toronto mayoral candidate Mark Saunders warns voters to 'Stop Chow'

Toronto mayoral candidate Mark Saunders speaks about the decline of the downtown core on Thursday, April 20, 2023. Toronto mayoral candidate Mark Saunders wants to stop Olivia Chow, who’s been ... Read more »

Maple Leafs can strengthen core with these two free agents

Maple Leafs can strengthen core with these two free agents It has been a week since the Toronto Maple Leafs named their new general manager (GM), Brad Treliving. He becomes ... Read more »

Three trade targets for the Golden State Warriors

O.G. Anunoby. The 2023 NBA playoffs proved that the Golden State Warriors weren’t good enough. If the franchise is going to win another championship in the Stephen Curry era, it ... Read more »

Carter Hart's future clouded after Flyers' blockbuster trade

The Flyers’ blockbuster three-way trade with the Columbus Blue Jackets and Los Angeles Kings marks the first significant transaction of the club’s eagerly-awaited rebuild. And by all accounts, it was ... Read more »

Florida player Brandon Montour streaks home for birth of child between Stanley Cup Final games

SUNRISE, Fla. (AP) — Brandon Montour took a baby break between the first two games of the Stanley Cup Final. With wife Ryian going into labor earlier than expected, the ... Read more »

Mills Announces End To National Team Career

Alena Mills, the captain of Czechia’s national women’s hockey team has announced she will step back from the program, although she will continue to play hockey. “It’s been delightful, but ... Read more »

Alex DeBrincat Submits Preferred Trade List to Senators

Alex DeBrincat Submits Preferred Trade List to Senators Following speculation that the Ottawa Senators were willing to work with the forward at nearly any level to get a deal done ... Read more »

Toyota Could Bring the Land Cruiser Prado to the U.S.

A report claims Toyota is planning to badge the upcoming, redesigned Prado as a Land Cruiser for the U.S. market. Toyota could be reviving the Land Cruiser for the U.S., ... Read more »

AP Exclusive: Drone footage of collapsed dam shows devastation, no evidence to back Russian claims

AP Exclusive: Drone footage of collapsed dam shows devastation, no evidence to back Russian claims KHERSON, Ukraine (AP) — Exclusive drone footage of the collapsed Ukrainian dam and surrounding villages ... Read more »

‘The amount of times I’ve seen perishable items on a random shelf…’: Customer bought Panera soups on clearance at Kroger. He got food poisoning

Man showing reduced Panera soup with expiration date A user on TikTok has sparked discussion after claiming that a Panera prepackaged soup he bought on clearance from Kroger gave him ... Read more »

David Johnston no longer working with crisis communications firm Navigator

David Johnston, independent special rapporteur on foreign interference, appears as a witness at the procedure and House affairs committee on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Tuesday, June 6, 2023. David ... Read more »

Here's why the interest rate on your high-yield savings account may be going up

Find a Qualified Financial Advisor Finding a qualified financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with up to 3 fiduciary financial advisors in your area ... Read more »

Delta Opens New Delta One Check-In at LAX

Delta One Check-In at LAX Delta and Los Angeles International Airport (LAX) have wrapped-up another phase in the Delta Sky Way at LAX project with the completion of a new ... Read more »

CITY ISSUES: The latest from some of Toronto’s top mayoral candidates

Josh Matlow, left, applauds a comment from Mitzie Hunter, centre left, as they are joined on stage by Olivia Chow, second left, Brad Bradford, centre right, Mark Saunders, second right, ... Read more »

Calgary Flames prospect Cade Littler has swapped college commitments

Calgary Flames prospect Cade Littler has swapped college commitments In the seventh round of the 2022 NHL Draft, the Calgary Flames selected centre Cade Littler of the BCHL’s Wenatchee Wild. ... Read more »

Hands-on with the new 15-inch MacBook Air

Hands-on with the new 15-inch MacBook Air Apple just announced the new MacBook Air 15, a 15-inch version of the most popular laptop in the world. I just saw it ... Read more »

Cowboy country in British Columbia: a taste of pioneer days with a ranch stay

In British Columbia, the area around the Cariboo Chilcotin Coast is home to large numbers of guest ranches such as Echo Valley, where wrangler Mike Christensen leads horse experiences between ... Read more »

Louisiana Senate passes bill banning gender-affirming car for transgender youths

Louisiana Senate passes bill banning gender-affirming car for transgender youths BATON ROUGE, La. (AP) — A controversial bill — that at one point had been presumed dead — banning gender-affirming ... Read more »

Ukrainian offensive is ‘taking place in several directions,’ says official

A Ukrainian offensive is “taking place in several directions,” Deputy Defense Minister Hanna Maliar told Ukrainian television on Monday, as speculation mounted that Kyiv would soon launch a summer counteroffensive ... Read more »

New teams emerge as potential buyers for DeAndre Hopkins

DeAndre Hopkins As teams around the league begin minicamp, the DeAndre Hopkins free agency watch continues. The list of potential suitors for the veteran wideout has fluctuated in recent days, ... Read more »

'It was tough': World War II veterans return to Utah Beach to mark D-Day's 79th anniversary

‘It was tough’: World War II veterans return to Utah Beach to mark D-Day’s 79th anniversary ON UTAH BEACH, France (AP) — World War II veterans shared vivid memories of ... Read more »

Hovland goes from winning Memorial to caddying in US Open qualifier

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — Viktor Hovland didn’t have much time to celebrate the biggest win of his career. One day after winning the Memorial, he went 36 holes as a ... Read more »

Apple announces new VR headset Vision Pro, to launch next year

“It’s the first Apple product you look through, not at,” Apple CEO Tim Cook said while introducing the Apple Vision Pro, the company’s new virtual reality headset that will allow users ... Read more »

Northeast wildfire now the third largest in B.C's history: BC Wildfire Service

The BC Wildfire Service says the Donnie Creek wildfire has grown into one of the largest blazes over the last century in the province. The fire, which is burning north ... Read more »

STELTER: Is Winnipeg hot enough for you?

A boy dips his foot at a spray pad at Provencher Park on a hot day in Winnipeg, Monday, June 5, 2023. Is anyone else not a fan of the ... Read more »

Prayers Are Pouring In For Jimmy Butler's Family During NBA Finals

DENVER, COLORADO – JUNE 04: Jimmy Butler #22 of the Miami Heat warms up prior to Game Two of the 2023 NBA Finals against the Denver Nuggets at Ball Arena ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự