Op-Ed: The first prisoners arrived at Guantanamo Bay 20 years ago. Will it ever close?

Op-Ed: The first prisoners arrived at Guantanamo Bay 20 years ago. Will it ever close?

On Jan. 11, 2002, a U.S. military plane landed at our base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and the first men deemed “the worst of the worst” by then-Vice President Dick Cheney were brought into the now-infamous detention center. Jumah Al-Dossari, a citizen of both Bahrain and Saudi Arabia whom I would eventually represent, arrived a few days later. He was held as an “enemy combatant” based on the accusation that he was a member of Al Qaeda, a claim made without substantiation or allegation that he had done anything to harm the U.S., its citizens or its allies.

Similarly, most detainees at Guantanamo were not said to have committed any hostile acts against the U.S. or its allies. Yet 20 years after the first prisoners were brought there, Guantanamo remains open largely because of congressional intransigence.

The U.S. chose Guantanamo to detain people captured in the “war on terror” after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, primarily because it was not on American soil. The government’s theory was that holding foreigners outside the U.S. would prevent our courts from exercising jurisdiction over claims by the detainees, effectively ensuring that those held would have no enforceable rights.

But in 2004, the Supreme Court ruled in Rasul vs. Bush that detainees could file habeas corpus petitions, which allowed them to meet with lawyers. By then, the government’s assumption that those held in Guantanamo would be revealed as high-value terrorists had unraveled. Even the facility’s commanders admitted many detainees had just been in the wrong place at the wrong time.

When I first met Jumah in October 2004, I didn’t believe that all Guantanamo detainees were, as Donald Rumsfeld had described them, the “best-trained vicious killers.” Still, I was nervous. My anxiety quickly dissolved. Jumah looked too gaunt to be a physical threat and his smile was disarming. And we were quickly chatting about American movies (“Jumanji” was his favorite), his daughter and Egyptian cuisine. At one point, he asked if I was Jewish, based on my first name. When I told him no, he looked disappointed. “I heard the best lawyers were Jewish,” he said, before adding, “I’m sure you’re good too.”

During our visits over the next year, Jumah and I talked about family and romantic relationships. Over time, he had learned a lot of English from the guards, particularly slang. He said that once an interrogator threatened him, saying, “You can’t punk me, motherf—, I’m from Brooklyn.” We co-opted the line to express mock indignation with each other. Jumah also gained a command of racial epithets from the guards, but he made me promise not to tell his mother he knew those bad words.

However, it was not all gallows humor and easy conversation. Jumah described abuses such as being beaten unconscious and having an interrogator smear what she said was menstrual blood on him, accounts corroborated by reports from U.S. personnel. But he said his most painful experience was being held in long-term solitary confinement.

In October 2004, on my fourth visit to Guantanamo, Jumah was despondent. After being released from the hospital following a hunger strike, he had been returned to isolation, contrary to what a doctor had promised. An hour into our meeting, he asked me to leave the room so he could use the bathroom. Soon after leaving, I started feeling anxious and cracked the door to the cell open. I saw Jumah hanging by his neck, unconscious, with blood flowing from a gash in his arm. He had emergency surgery and survived.

After this suicide attempt, I asked that Jumah be moved out of isolation.

When the military denied the request, our legal team sought intervention from the courts. The U.S. government argued that Jumah wasn’t isolated because guards gave him food through a slot in his door and he played checkers and ate pizza with interrogators. The court ruled it did not have authority to order modifications.

That decision underscored our team’s belief that there was no chance the court would ever order our clients’ release. Being released seemed to be a political exercise. All detainees who were citizens of Western European countries had gone home through diplomatic deals. We argued for such arrangements for our clients who were citizens of Bahrain, a U.S. ally, and I hoped this strategy would work before Jumah succeeded in killing himself.

In July 2007, and after several more suicide attempts, Jumah was released from Guantanamo and sent to Saudi Arabia through a diplomatic agreement. When I eventually visited him at his home there in 2009, I held his newborn daughter and ate dinner with his family. I wondered what the U.S. had gained from holding him for over five years.

Twenty years after Guantanamo opened, that question applies to the entire operation. Seven hundred and thirty-two detainees, most held for years, have been released. Of the 39 people still imprisoned, most are detained as “combatants.” Thirteen have been cleared for release yet remain jailed. And, of course, the war in Afghanistan is over. The five that have been charged with helping plot the 9/11 attacks have yet to be tried.

Keeping Guantanamo open costs about $13 million annually per detainee and the facility is a symbol of human rights abuses by the U.S. But it remains open almost entirely because Congress has barred transferring detainees to prisons in the U.S. and has restricted transfers to other countries.

There is little reason to believe that things will change in the near future, though President Biden, like Presidents Obama and George W. Bush before him, has said he wants to close Guantanamo.

If a solution to closing Guantanamo isn’t found, the U.S. will end up perpetually imprisoning an aging population of men who should be tried in federal courts, or should have been set free long ago.

Joshua Colangelo-Bryan is a lawyer at Dorsey & Whitney and a consultant to Human Rights Watch. He was part of a group of firms and nonprofits that represented Guantanamo detainees pro bono.

News Related


How to watch SpaceX’s Starlink launch tomorrow

How to watch SpaceX’s Starlink launch tomorrow Tomorrow, Sunday, January 29, SpaceX will launch a further batch of Starlink satellites. The launch will use one of the company’s Falcon 9 ... Read more »

National Signing Day 2023: Predicting where Top 10 unsigned recruits land

National Signing Day 2023: Predicting where Top 10 unsigned recruits land Predicting where the top 10 unsigned recruits will end up signing on National Signing Day. While most of the ... Read more »

This Is Ford's Most Reliable F-150 Engine Ever

This Is Ford’s Most Reliable F-150 Engine Ever Even supply chain issues and chip shortages cannot stop the Ford F-150 from dominating the market in the United States. Recently, Ford ... Read more »

San Francisco 49ers Elevate RB For NFC Championship Game After Injuries To Christian McCaffrey, Elijah Mitchell

San Francisco 49ers Elevate RB For NFC Championship Game After Injuries To Christian McCaffrey, Elijah Mitchell The San Francisco 49ers elevate two for Sunday The San Francisco 49ers elevated two ... Read more »

Leslie Jones Should Be the New Host of The Daily Show

Leslie Jones Should Be the New Host of The Daily Show When Trevor Noah said goodbye to The Daily Show last December, it marked the second time in eight years ... Read more »

Bodycam Footage of Tyre Nichols Beating Draws Horror, Condemnation

Flanked by Rodney Wells, center, and RowVaughn Wells, the stepfather and mother of Tyre Nichols, civil rights attorney Ben Crump speaks next to a photo of Tyre Nichols during a ... Read more »

At least 25 die in Peru when bus plunges off cliff

At least 25 people died Saturday when a bus carrying 60 passengers plunged over a cliff in northwestern Peru, police said. The bus, belonging to the Qorianka Tours company, had ... Read more »

Stepan the Gooberish Grizzly Bear Celebrates His 30th Birthday Alongside His Adoptive Pawrents, a Pair of Risky Russians Who Found Him Orphaned in the Woods as a Cub

When you think of outrageously enormous, exotic pets (like lions, tigers and bears), your knee jerk reaction might be to think of Russia. Well, there’s a reason for that. The ... Read more »

Israel to ‘Strengthen' Settlements After Shooting Attacks

AP Photo/Maya Alleruzzo Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has announced a a series of punitive steps against the Palestinians in response to a pair of shootings in Jerusalem that killed ... Read more »

Memphis police disband unit that beat Tyre Nichols

MEMPHIS, Tenn. —  The Memphis police chief on Saturday disbanded the city’s so-called Scorpion unit after some of its officers beat to death Tyre Nichols, reversing an earlier statement that she ... Read more »

When Dogs Go Snooping: The Art of Sticking Your Nose in People's Business (30 Pictures)

We’re all guilty of doing it – secretly listening in on someone’s conversation. Sometimes the gossip is too juicy and you just have to. Well, these adorable puppers know all ... Read more »

Phil Mickelson Not Happy With PGA Tour Today - Here's Why

BROOKLINE, MASSACHUSETTS – JUNE 17: Phil Mickelson of the United States watches his shot from the sixth tee during the second round of the 122nd U.S. Open Championship at The ... Read more »

Rosanna Arquette Fears Backlash to Andrea Riseborough Oscar Nom Could Damage 'Small Films Made Outside the Corporate Machine'

rosanna arquette andrea riseborough Rosanna Arquette is the latest to voice support for Andrea Riseborough’s “To Leslie” performance after her surprise Oscar nomination sparked an inquiry into possible campaign violations. ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo could complete shock Premier League return as Al Nassr boss names forward’s transfer wish

Cristiano Ronaldo represents Portugal at Qatar World Cup Portuguese striker Cristiano Ronaldo may end up coming back to the Premier League in the future after his Al Nassr coach spoke ... Read more »

Among millennials, this is the most popular grocery chain

Woman at the grocery store standing in front of productsGetty Images/d3sign Step back Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods and Costco — it’s Aldi’s time to shine! The German multinational discount supermarket ... Read more »

Trump appears to take aim at potential 2024 GOP rivals, says he doesn't have much 'competition'

Former President Donald Trump took aim at his potential rivals for the Republican presidential nomination as he kicked off a new phase of this 2024 White House campaign with a ... Read more »

Kaivon Washington, who is accused in Madison Brooks rape, arrested for sexual assault of 12-year-old: cops

One of the men accused of raping LSU student Madison Brooks before she was hit and killed by a car has been arrested on charges that he sexually assaulted a ... Read more »

Kate Middleton May Be Dabbling in the Entertainment World As She Shares a Sneak Peek of Her Newest Project

Kate Middleton May Be Dabbling in the Entertainment World As She Shares a Sneak Peek of Her Newest Project It seems Kate Middleton is not only doubling down on ensuring ... Read more »

The Viral Dishwasher Hack That Can Cut Down Drying Time

dishwasher One household task most people disdain on their never-ending weekly to-do list is doing the dishes. According to Cision, Americans spend nearly 30 minutes each day performing this unexciting ... Read more »

Distrust of police: Black parents, children have 'the talk'

Rodney Wells, stepfather of Tyre Nichols, who died after being beaten by Memphis police officers, speaks at a news conference with civil rights Attorney Ben Crump, seen comforting Tyre’s mother ... Read more »

Kevin Durant Reveals The Young NBA Players He Enjoys Watching

Kevin Durant is an avid basketball lover, and he knows a couple of young guys are doing interesting things in the league. Credit: Fadeaway World Kevin Durant has never hesitated ... Read more »

Alabama's Nick Saban rejected 2 players who were searching for $1.3 million combined in NIL money: report

If you want to play for Alabama, you might not get your way when it comes to NIL money. According to OutKick, Nick Saban had no problems letting a top ... Read more »

10 Easy Ways to Make Money from Home

Earn fun spending money, create a supplemental income for your family, or even develop a full-time job with these 10 ways to make money from home. Earn fun spending money, ... Read more »

The Best Valentine's Candy Deals This Week!

Best Valentine’s Candy Deals! Best Valentine’s Candy Deals! See Our List of the Best Valentine’s Candy Deals This Week! 💘 Valentine’s Day is less than a month away so don’t ... Read more »

Memphis Police permanently disbands SCORPION unit in wake of Tyre Nichols' death

Memphis Police announced the deactivation Saturday, saying the officers assigned to the unit agreed with the move. Read more »

Dallas Schools Remove Access to TikTok on District Wi-Fi

Dallas students, teachers and visitors can no longer access TikTok from school district devices and networks. In a Friday letter to families, chief of school leadership Tiffany Huitt said the ... Read more »

Teen Found Fatally Shot Inside Suburban Oak Forest Building, Police Say

Police in south suburban Oak Forest are investigating after a 17-year-old boy was found shot to death Saturday, authorities said. At an unknown time, officers responded to the 15500 block ... Read more »

The American 2024 Ford Ranger Is Different From the Global Model

Ford makes some of world’s the best-selling trucks. The F-Series models outsold every other pickup stateside in 2022, with more than 650,000 units delivered. Two other Ford trucks made the ... Read more »

Will Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson make his WWE return at tonight’s Royal Rumble?

When it comes to the Royal Rumble, it’s quite clear that anything can happen. This electrifying pay-per-view brawl is one of the WWE’s most iconic events, and for better or ... Read more »

Insider suggests Broncos made last-ditch attempt to lure Jim Harbaugh

Michigan head coach Jim Harbaugh. The Denver Broncos’ coaching search appears to be in an uncertain spot, and it may have led them back to a candidate who was seemingly ... Read more »

Why Yankees won’t trade Aaron Hicks, Josh Donaldson

1/28/23 If you ask any New York Yankees fan which players they wouldn’t want to see penciled into the 2023 Opening Day lineup, the answers would very likely be Aaron ... Read more »

MPD decides to permanently deactivate SCORPION Unit

Chief CJ Davis MEMPHIS, Tenn. (WMC) – Memphis police officers assigned to the SCORPION Unit (Street Crimes Operations to Restore Peace in Our Neighborhoods) met with Chief C.J Davis on ... Read more »

Virginia lawmakers unanimously reject anti-trans bill

While the decision is a victory for trans rights in the state, another anti-trans bill aimed at students remains on the table. This week, the House Early Childhood/Innovation subcommittee in ... Read more »

Chiefs Make Noteworthy Roster Move Following Travis Kelce Injury

Despite practicing in full capacity all week, Chiefs’ tight end Travis Kelce was a surprise listing on Kansas City’s injury report this Friday. According to CBS broadcaster Jim Nantz, Kelce ... Read more »

LeBron James is accused of blaming Black people for Tyree Nichols’ murder by five Black Memphis police officers, after tweeting “we are our own worst enemy”

LeBron James blames Black people for Tyree Nichols’ murder LeBron James blames Black people for Tyree Nichols’ murder LeBron James always charted his own path and he’s been successful doing ... Read more »

No. 1 Purdue Basketball Prepared for Rematch With Michigan State

Purdue basketball hosts Michigan State on Sunday at Mackey Arena, the second matchup of the season between the two teams. The Boilermakers escaped the Breslin Center in East Lansing, Mich., ... Read more »

Chock and Bates defend title, win 4th U.S. ice dance gold

US Championships Figure Skating SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) — Madison Chock and Evan Bates successfully defended their ice dancing title Saturday at the U.S. Figure Skating Championships, scoring 137.85 in ... Read more »

Beneath M&M's candy-coated image switcheroo is a dark chocolatey, ethically broke business

Maya Rudolf and M&MsPhoto illustration by Salon/Getty Images/Mars Inc. In a future where drastic climate change has made the cultivation of cocoa trees impossible, and ragged elders make their children ... Read more »

Body found on North Shore identified as missing Mass. man

Michael Gray, 31, whom authorities said had ties to Peabody, Massachusetts, and Maine, was reported missing on Dec. 11, 2022. Authorities say Gray’s body was found in Marblehead, Massachusetts, on ... Read more »

Chiefs make 5 roster moves before Sunday’s AFC Championship

Chiefs make 5 roster moves before Sunday’s AFC Championship On Saturday, the Kansas City Chiefs made five roster moves in advance of Sunday’s AFC Championship against the Cincinnati Bengals on ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự