‘Only two pages' of Luxembourg PM's university thesis was not plagiarised

Asia's Tech News Daily

Photograph: Johanna Geron/EPA

Luxembourg’s prime minister, Xavier Bettel, has admitted his university thesis “should have been done differently” after a media investigation concluded that only two of the work’s 56 pages had not been plagiarised.

A local news outlet, reporter.lu, said on Wednesday that Bettel had lifted three-quarters of the text, describing it as “an impressive hodgepodge of copied passages that does not meet the customary requirements of academia”.

Related: German politicians suffer higher degree of embarrassment from plagiarism than from sex scandals

Bettel, 48, who has been prime minister since 2013, said the thesis was more than 20 years old and written with a clear conscience. But “from today’s standpoint, it could have – yes, maybe should have – been done differently”, he said.

Bettel said he had full confidence in the University of Lorraine in eastern France to assess whether the work met its standards at the time, and that he would “naturally accept” its decision, even if it meant his qualification was withdrawn.

The thesis was written as part of an advanced diploma – roughly the equivalent of a master’s degree – in public law and political science that Bettel completed at what was then known as the University of Nancy in the same year he entered parliament.

Reporter.lu said the theis, called Toward a Possible Reform of Voting Systems in the European Parliament, contained lengthy passages of text that had been lifted unattributed from two books, four websites and a press article.

It said only “a few paragraphs in the introduction” and “an equally short conclusion” had not been copied wholesale, amounting to an exercise in plagiarism “unparalleled in its scope” – a verdict that it said had been confirmed by independent experts.

Fully 20 pages of the thesis were lifted straight from the website of the European parliament in defiance of a clear copyright warning, it said, with nine more taken from a 1998 report by a Greek MEP and further passages copied from a standard introductory textbook on the EU’s institutions.

“The plagiarism I found is very problematic because long passages were transferred almost word for word,” Anna-Lena Högenauer, a political science professor at the University of Luxembourg, told the outlet. “You can’t accidentally copy several pages.”

Nicolas Sauger, a political scientist at Sciences Po in Paris, said Bettel’s thesis was unoriginal and poorly researched, and the plagiarism “too extensive to be reasonable”. But the prime minister’s former supervisor, Etienne Criqui, said standards were different before the invention of plagiarism-detecting software.

The scandal is the latest plagiarism row to hit a high-profile European politician in recent years, with Germany the worst affected. Germany’s family minister Franziska Giffey was forced to step down in May over claims she plagiarised her doctoral thesis.

In 2013 Annette Schavan, then the education minister, had to step down after the University of Düsseldorf stripped her of her doctorate, while two years earlier defence minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg resigned for the same reason.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


NYC transit advocates call on city to scrap ‘gridlock alert days'

Traffic on the Trans-Manhattan Expressway in Manhattan. Transportation advocate group Riders Alliance is calling for an end to “gridlock alert days.” Christopher Sadowski The end of gridlock? Not so fast. ... Read more »

Nasser Hussain delivers verdict on Joe Root's decision to bat in first Ashes Test

Former England captain Nasser Hussain infamously chose to bowl after winning the toss in the first Ashes Test at the Gabba in 2002. Hussain’s decision backfired spectacularly during that Test, ... Read more »

PHOTO: Kareena Kapoor Khan is proud of her ‘beta' as Jehangir tries to stand on his own

© Provided by Pinkvilla Kareena Kapoor Khan is quite active on her social media. She often keeps posting beautiful pictures of her on Instagram. But ever since she has stepped ... Read more »

Globe says subscribers may experience service disruption

© Globe Globe Telecom cell tower for cell site. FOR USE ONLY FOR GLOBE (NOT SMART). Photo courtesy: Globe Globe Telecom on Thursday said its subscribers may experience service disruption ... Read more »

Profit booking drives Sensex 100 points lower; banks, metal suffer

NEW DELHI: Indian bluechip indices wiped off early gains to trade lower on Thursday as market participants preferred to book profits rather than continue their buying spree even as Omicron ... Read more »

Hasina ranked 43rd on Forbes' 100 Most Powerful Women list

© IANS Sheikh Hasina, Prime Minister of Bangladesh. Dhaka, Dec 9 (IANS) Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has been ranked 43rd in the Forbes magazine’s list of 100 Most Powerful ... Read more »

SWAT team arrests suspect in case involving body found in storage unit near Sonora

A Jamestown man faces murder and other charges in the death of a Twain Harte resident whose body was found in a storage unit in October. The Tuolumne County Sheriff’s ... Read more »

SBI CBO 2021 recruitment: Check eligibility, vacancy; know how to apply

The State Bank of India (SBI) has invited applications for recruitment to circle based officers or the CBOs. The application forms are available on the official website of the Bank, ... Read more »

Harry Potter reunion FIRST LOOK: Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint are all grown up in upcoming HBO Max special Return To Hogwarts

Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint were seen in a first-look image from the upcoming Harry Potter reunion special, Return to Hogwarts. In the shots, the stars of the ... Read more »

Australia's most powerful banker issues a chilling warning on cryptocurrency

Reserve Bank of Australia Governor Philip Lowe has warning on cryptocurrencyHe said the volatility was a cause for concern urging investors to 'take care' Treasurer Josh Frydenberg is embarking on regulation of decentralised finance  Read more »

7 Long-Lasting Cream Blushes That Will Give You a Natural Flush

© Provided by Preview.ph After lipstick, many of us can attest that blush fades the fastest. In a humid country like the Philippines, we are prone to getting oily and ... Read more »

Mother of two boys, 6 and 7, hit and killed while walking to the local pool 'threatened a woman with a kitchen knife and tried to steal $700' - but is granted bail because she is 'suffering PTSD and depression over the crash'

Shayleen Frail is accused of threatening a woman with a knife for $717 in OctoberCourt heard she is suffering PTSD and depression after deaths of her two sonsSheldon and Shane, 6 and 7, were killed when they were hit by a car in JanuaryThey were visiting their mum in central west NSW from QLD in school holidays Man accused of manslaughter and 28 other charges is in court on December 23  Read more »

Katrina Kaif once revealed all she wants is to get married and have kids. Vicky Kaushal, thoughts?

The day of Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal’s union is finally here. They are to tie the knot today, December 9, at Hotel Six Senses Barwara Fort in Sawai Madhopur, ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif- Vicky Kaushal's WHOPPING net worth in crores will leave your jaw dropped

© Provided by DNA Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal are getting married at the Six Senses Fort Barwara on December 9 (today). Several celebs are expected to attend the celebration, ... Read more »

Warum die Pandemie so ungerecht ist

Wie prägt der europäische Blick unseren Zugang zur Pandemie? Und wie ungerecht verhalten sich die Länder des Nordens gegenüber den Ländern des Südens? Antworten in «Apropos». © Bild: Keystone Südafrika ... Read more »

Inside Poh Ling Yeow's unique love square: MasterChef star reveals how she coped after learning her ex-husband Matt Phipps had found love with her best friend Sarah Rich

Poh Ling Yeow has lifted the lid on her very unusual relationship with ex-husband Matt Phipps and his new wife Sarah Rich.    The MasterChef star, 48, divorced filmmaker Matt in ... Read more »

VIDEOS: Ram Charan, Jr NTR fans go berserk and kickstart celebrations ahead of the trailer launch of RRR

© Provided by Pinkvilla After Baahubali, SS Rajamouli has geared up for the release of another mega project titled, RRR. Starring Ram Charan and Jr NTR in the lead roles, ... Read more »

Grünes Licht für Medikament in den USA: Diese künstlichen Corona-Antikörper sind jetzt zugelassen

Die USA lassen ein Medikament zu, in dem künstliche Corona-Antikörper stecken. Das sei keine generelle Alternative zur Impfung, aber nützlich für Allergiker und Menschen mit einem geschwächten Immunsystem. © Bereitgestellt ... Read more »

'Pathetic Officiating': Former AUS Captain Slams TV Umpire After Ben Stokes's Overstepping Goes Unnoticed

© Provided by News18 ‘Pathetic Officiating’: Former AUS Captain Slams TV Umpire After Ben Stokes’s Overstepping Goes Unnoticed Ben Stokes overstepping the bowling crease multiple times on Thursday became one ... Read more »

Jennifer Aniston explains why she walked out of 'Friends' reunion

© IANS Jennifer Aniston.(photo:IMDB.com) Los Angeles, Dec 9 (IANS) Actress Jennifer Aniston recalled walking out of the reunion special for ‘Friends’. In a new interview with the Hollywood Reporter, the ... Read more »

Obi Toppin's impressive dunk couldn't even inspire woeful Knicks

The breakaway slam should have sparked a raging fire inside the Knicks, because it came straight from the heart of the city game. Obi Toppin grew up on the famous ... Read more »

This Seahawks-Saints trade for Russell Wilson could actually work

With the news that Russell Wilson might be interested in a move to the New Orleans Saints, the Seattle Seahawks may look to make a trade happen. © Provided by ... Read more »

Cricket-Warner burns England but late wickets leave Australia on 193-3

FILE PHOTO: Ashes 2019 – Fifth Test – England v Australia By Ian Ransom MELBOURNE (Reuters) –David Warner marched to the brink of a century after being reprieved three times ... Read more »

CEO of Apotheca Beauty Nora Al Ramadhan talks us through her skincare routine

© Motivate Publishing Nora Al Ramadhan December’s – ‘The Winter Escape Issue’ – Download Now Nora Al Ramadhan, CEO and Co-Founder of Apoethca Beauty, talks us through her beauty routines. Talk ... Read more »

'Game-changing' new Covid drugs will be sent to patients at home

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Thousands of lives will be saved this winter by two ‘game-changing’ new Covid treatments being rolled out on the NHS today, ministers announced ... Read more »

Two teenagers shot in parking lot of Kansas City's Kauffman school Wednesday night

Two teenagers were injured in a shooting that unfolded in the Ewing Marion Kauffman School parking lot during a high school basketball game on Wednesday night. Off-duty Kansas City police ... Read more »

Glenwood High School goes to soft lockdown; Springfield police arrest 3 in separate threats

A Chatham Police K9 unit is parked outside Glenwood High School as the school goes on soft lockdown after a threat was made via the Yik Yak messaging platform to ... Read more »

Aston Villa coach exits as Steven Gerrard strikes key deal before January

Welcome to all the Aston Villa news from BirminghamLive on Wednesday, December 8. Coach exit confirmed Steven Gerrard‘s Aston Villa backroom staff shake-up has continued with first-team sport scientist Jack ... Read more »

Cricket-Ashes equipment malfunction sparks Stokes no-ball controversy

SYDNEY (Reuters) – The no-ball call that denied England’s Ben Stokes a wicket in his first over of the opening Ashes test on Thursday led to the revelation that the ... Read more »

Traces of Omicron super variant found at Melbourne Airport

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Melbourne Airport has been put on alert after traces of the Omicron super variant were found in the wastewater – as Victoria records ... Read more »

Video: The Project's Carrie Bickmore suffers another major wardrobe malfunction just moments before walking the AACTA awards red carpet where she accidentally flashed her bottom 

Read more »

COMMENT | Will Pekan Nanas become Pineappolis?

© Malaysiakini (English) COMMENT | I don’t usually agree with Rais Yatim’s political views but his swipe at local authorities for adopting English names over Malaysian names is well taken. ... Read more »

Canada to join diplomatic boycott of Olympics to send China human rights message -PM

1 / 4Canada to join diplomatic boycott of Olympics to send China human rights message -PMCanada’s Minister of Sport Pascale St-Onge, with Minister of Foreign Affairs Melanie Joly and Parliamentary ... Read more »

Pfizer says its vaccine booster provides protection against the Omicron variant

Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine DANIEL LEAL/AFP via Getty Images Early data suggests three doses of Pfizer and BioNTech's COVID-19 vaccine provides protection against the new Omicron variant, the companies say. Pfizer ... Read more »

A Chinese government spokesperson said the US committed 'evil crimes' against Native Americans in a bid to counter reports of genocide in Xinjiang

Chinese spokesperson Zhao Lijian speaks at a daily media briefing in 2020.Greg Baker/AFP via Getty Images A Chinese spokesperson railed against the US' diplomatic boycott of the Winter Olympics. The ... Read more »

Texas gunman who mistook cop for home intruder acquitted of murder

David Wilson, found not guilty, was acquitted of the murder of Midland Police Officer Nathan Heidelberg. Midland County Sheriff’s Office A Texas man who opened fire on a cop who ... Read more »

Don't Ask Me Any Cliché Questions: General Bipin Rawat's Last Words to Me That Best Honour the Jolly Officer Bold

© Provided by News18 Don’t Ask Me Any Cliché Questions: General Bipin Rawat’s Last Words to Me That Best Honour the Jolly Officer Bold “Don’t ask me any cliché questions. ... Read more »

Group Captain Varun Singh, Lone survivor of Chopper Crash Had Dodged Death in 2020 As Well | A Look Into What Had Happened

© Surabhi Shaurya | India.com News Desk Group Captain Varun Singh is the sole survivor of the crash. IAF Chopper Crash: Indian Air Force‘s Group Captain Varun Singh, the lone ... Read more »

Manchin kills Biden's private vaccine mandate: Senator and fellow Democrat Jon Tester join 50 Republicans to vote down plan that would force COVID shot on 31 million

Wednesday's vote overturned Biden's mandate ordering businesses with 100 workers or more to demand vaccination from workers by Jan 4Workers who refused were to be subjected to regular COVID testing The 52-48 vote sends the legislation to the Democratic-led House of Representatives, where it faces strong headwindsManchin and Tester argued on Wednesday that the consequences of implementing the mandate would be largely felt on the country's economyThe chamber's top Republican, Mitch McConnell, branded the Biden mandate as an 'illegal' and 'absurd' government effort to micromanage the lives of citizens Read more »

Jimmy Lai among three Hong Kong pro-democracy activists convicted over Tiananmen vigil

© AP File: Founder of Apple Daily Jimmy Lai is one of the three activists that a Hong Kong court found guilty of unauthorised assembly on 4 June last year ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic