One Very Big Problem With the Democrats' Billionaires Tax

Asia's Tech News Daily

This article is part of the The DC Brief, TIME’s politics newsletter. Sign up here to get stories like this sent to your inbox every weekday.

One Very Big Problem With the Democrats' Billionaires Tax
© Drew Angerer—Getty Images Sen. Ron Wyden speaks to reporters about a corporate minimum tax plan at the Capitol on Oct. 26, 2021.

Some of the darkest instincts in politics have been given permission with the simple act of dehumanizing someone or someones. It’s surprisingly easy to lash a political rival when you forget they’re someone’s son or daughter, a parent or spouse. If you want to discount a candidacy, you can reduce its supporters to ignorant fools who, in the words of one candidate, cling to guns and religion as a refuge from a modernizing world, or from the mouth of another are characterized as nothing but takers. When the other side is treated as The Other, it demands zero respect and makes it easy to persecute them for political gain. So much of human history is animated by this exploitation.

Well, as Washington is hurtling toward fast-approaching deadlines and scrambling to solve a riddle over infrastructure spending, Democratic lawmakers seem to have found the latest incarnation of The Other. This time, they are roughly 700 uber-rich Americans and the assets that grow in value every year and make their largess even more obscene. Today, Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon released details of his plan to target the nation’s very richest billionaires and tax their investment gains as a way to pay for some of the spending in Biden’s Build Back Better agenda.

Americans have long held a simultaneous fascination and a contempt for this class of billionaires. From Daddy Warbucks to Donald Trump, the mystery of vast wealth has sparked the imagination of the public. They’re a cut above, a cohort of some who have risen to the top of their professions and others who inherited their position through birth. The haves are easy targets for the have-nots or even the have-enoughs. And, in that, Democrats might have found a way out of the trap they’ve laid for themselves in chasing trillions of dollars for social safety spending that they insist will be completely paid-for without adding red ink.

Under Wyden’s plan, anyone worth $1 billion or more would face a one-time tax on wealth they’ve accrued. For instance, if someone bought $1 billion in stocks and those shares are now worth $5 billion, that person would be assessed as having made $4 billion and face a tax bill on those shares, even if they were never sold. Then, going forward, the IRS would send a tax bill annually for further gains. That $5 billion investment going to $6 billion would show as $1 billion in income. Losses could be carried over for a while, but the proposal clearly assumes accumulating wealth and not a massive crash like 2008 or even big dents resulting from threats of a government shutdown.

But there’s one fairly big problem here: it’s potentially illegal. The Constitution has a pretty narrow tolerance for taxes, even after the Sixteenth Amendment remedied an 1895 case that declared income taxes unconstitutional. For one, wealth isn’t income. When something gains value but isn’t sold, it’s a theoretical increase in an individual’s buying power. The argument behind Wyden’s plan is that you could be buying that yacht, so you should pay taxes on that ability even if you’re still sitting on the mountain of cash. It’s not clear the Supreme Court would agree.

In practice, of course, the super-rich have found ways to use that theoretical wealth to fund their lifestyles. They can park their money in an account that keeps growing and then borrow against it to pay for their day-to-day costs, like private jets and islands. It’s how PayPal founder Peter Thiel has a Roth IRA reportedly valued at $5 billion. So the latent asset could be seen as taxable in this scenario. And that’s what Democrats are—if you’ll pardon the pun—banking on.

To be clear, billionaires aren’t a class of victims. But they are an easy target to pay for Democrats’ ambitious—and as yet amorphous—plans for a new social safety net. Billionaires already pay a far lower share of their wealth annually than the rest of us. The bottom 99% of Americans turn about 7% of their net worth to governments. The top 0.1% send less than half of that to Uncle Sam. It’s the exact opposite of a progressive tax system and a rub on populists in both parties.

But the idea remains one set for debate, not passage. “There’s a patriotic duty that you should be paying something to this great country that gave you the protection and the support and the opportunities,” Manchin told reporters on Capitol Hill today. But, like a lot of Democrats, Manchin said the so-called Billionaires’ Tax seems to be more of an idea than an actual policy at this point. “I don’t like the connotation that we’re targeting different people,” said Manchin, who in a 50-50 Senate can single-handedly veto any part of this infrastructure deal.

But they are targeting a specific class, at least in the plan’s current iteration. On top of the questions about the constitutionality of taxing wealth, the proposal triggers a second constitutional question: Can a law legally target a specific person or group of people? The Constitution explicitly bans laws passed targeting a specific person. For instance, Congress cannot pass a law declaring Citizen Z guilty of a crime in the absence of a trial. That, courts have agreed, is very British in its bill of attainder origins. The Supreme Court has largely agreed, especially if such laws are seen as punitive, as was the case of Communists being banned from labor unions’ leadership during the Cold War.

Yet there is a window whereby the Supreme Court might allow for Wyden’s plan, and it dates to Congress passing a law during Watergate demanding the federal caretakers seize Richard Nixon’s presidential papers so they couldn’t be destroyed. In that case, the Supreme Court ruled that Nixon was not being punished and his compensation for the records negated any perceived penalty.

The likes of Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk aren’t much more sympathetic than Nixon right now. But that doesn’t mean Congress has a blank check to confiscate their wealth to pay for new social programs without risking some political price. And that’s what Congress is considering right now: Is paid family leave worth risking the ire of billionaires who can unleash a torrent of retribution? After all, declarations of hostility aren’t a one-way road.

You could hear Musk hinting at as much in a series of tweets in recent days. In response to one tweet criticizing the billionaire bashing, the world’s richest man replied with a warning: “Eventually, they run out of other people’s money and then they come for you.” And, in that, Musk turned the tables on Congress. Lawmakers, in his telling, are now The Other—and thus just as contemptible as his billionaire pals.

Make sense of what matters in Washington. Sign up for the daily D.C. Brief newsletter.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Individu terlibat kes seleweng geran MITRA didakwa awal tahun depan, kata SPRM

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today SPRM berkata, siasatan membabitkan kes rasuah membabitkan MITRA rumit dan memakan masa panjang, justeru siasatan secara berfasa perlu dilaksanakan. PETALING JAYA: Lebih sembilan individu ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic in biggest Australian Open hint yet as ATP Cup spot in Sydney confirmed

Novak Djokovic has been named in Serbia’s squad for January’s ATP Cup, taking place in Sydney. The world No 1 has been a big doubt to compete in Australia after ... Read more »

Yemen chooses new Central Bank governor amid economic crisis

© LUCAS JACKSON Yemeni President Abdrabu Mansur Hadi issued a decree on Monday to confirm the changes after talks with the leadership of the Southern Transitional Council. Reuters Yemen’s President ... Read more »

Here's why the Middle East region is a lucrative market for startups

© Motivate Publishing Jida Itani_COO_Hub71_2021 How does Hub71 see the growth of startups in the Middle East region? Why do you think Middle East is a lucrative market for startups? ... Read more »

Omicron cases in UK soon expected to exceed those in red list nations – expert

Cases of the Omicron variant in the UK are soon expected to be higher than in some African countries placed on the travel red list, a scientist has warned. Professor ... Read more »

Raab insists animals were not prioritised over people in Afghanistan evacuation

Dominic Raab insisted the Government did not prioritise evacuating dogs over people in the chaos as Afghanistan fell after a whistleblower claimed limited airlift capacity was used to transport animals. ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: Rakhi Sawant gets violent as Abhijit Bichukale comments about her hiring Ritesh

© Provided by Pinkvilla The upcoming episode of the reality show Bigg Boss will have oodles of drama as it will be seen that Rakhi Sawant will be breaking the ... Read more »

Santhwanam, December 7, 2021, Written Update; Anjali confronts Shathru

© Provided by Pinkvilla As the episode starts, Aparna begs Hari to cooperate with her family for just one more day as they will be gone by tomorrow. She pleads ... Read more »

Watch: Fawad Khan sings Kishore Kumar's Dilbar Mere Kab Tak Mujhe during his 40th birthday celebrations

© Provided by Firstpost Watch: Fawad Khan sings Kishore Kumar’s Dilbar Mere Kab Tak Mujhe during his 40th birthday celebrations Pakistani actor Fawad Khan, recently celebrated his 40th birthday on ... Read more »

Ed Sheeran 'nearly killed' Sir Elton John

Ed Sheeran “almost killed” Sir Elton John while shooting their festive music video. © Bang Showbiz Ed Sheeran has teamed up with Sir Elton John for a Christmas single The ... Read more »

Strong earnings forecasts, miners lift FTSE 100 to near 3-week highs

By Bansari Mayur Kamdar © Reuters/Neil Hall FILE PHOTO: Pedestrians leave and enter the London Stock Exchange in London (Reuters) -UK’s FTSE 100 rose to near three-week highs on Tuesday, ... Read more »

Rafa Benitez signing given remarkable send off in final match as ex-Liverpool star retires at 40

Former Liverpool star Maxi Rodriguez was given a special send-off in his final match as a professional footballer. The 40-year-old announced last month that he would be retiring from a ... Read more »

Video shows a cruise ship being pulled VERY carefully along a river

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Full steam ahead was never going to be on the agenda. Amazing video footage shows the mammoth Odyssey of the Seas cruise ship ... Read more »

Ask me anything: Simon Calder answers your questions as new testing restrictions come into play

This week feels somewhat like going back in time when it comes to travel testing in the UK; not only have post-arrival “day two” tests been swapped from lateral flows ... Read more »

H.E.R will pay tribute to Marvin Gaye at People's Choice Awards

H.E.R. will pay tribute to Marvin Gaye at the 2021 People’s Choice Awards. © Bang Showbiz H.E.R will perform a tribute to Marvin Gaye at the People’s Choice Awards The ... Read more »

Little Mix: Jade Thirlwall hints at behind-the-scenes drama while sharing band's biggest regret

© Provided by The Independent Little Mix are collectively agreed on what their biggest regret as a girl band is. The group, who recently announced they would go on hiatus ... Read more »

Mit dieser Ausgangslage ging die Formel 1 erst einmal in den letzten GP

Die Formel 1 erlebt am Sonntag zum zweiten Mal in ihrer Geschichte ein Finale mit zwei punktgleichen Titelanwärtern. Vor 47 Jahren zog der Schweizer Clay Regazzoni gegen den Brasilianer Emerson ... Read more »

‘Race for space' over as flat prices rise more than houses

Britain’s race for space and homeowners upgrading to larger, rural properties has turned, with flat prices rising significantly quicker than houses.  © Provided by The Telegraph A house and money ... Read more »

'Succession', 'You Don't Know Me', 'The Richard Dimbleby Lecture': The 5 best things to watch on TV, Monday 6 December

Monday’s TV highlights. (HBO/BBC) The second last episode in this series of Succession airs on Sky Atlantic as the Roys take a trip to Italy for a wedding, while crime ... Read more »

Tommy Fury shares x-ray of broken rib that's forcing him out of the Jake Paul fight

© GiveMeSport p1fma2cfi71g731ms9166h1rler3tf.jpg Tommy Fury was due to take on Jake Paul in Florida on December 18, but the former has pulled out of the fight with a little under ... Read more »

Police Officers Who Took Photos Of Dead Sisters' Bodies Receive Prison Sentence

© Getty Images Two Metropolitan police officers who photographed the bodies of Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman after their murder last year have been fired from the force. Article updated ... Read more »

Susanna Reid breaks down in tears speaking to tragic Arthur Labinjo-Hughes' gran

Susanna Reid broke down in tears today while speaking to tragic Arthur Labinjo-Hughes’ gran on Good Morning Britain today. Madeleine Halcrow said that her grandson’s evil stepmum and dad will ... Read more »

Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, Sonia Gandhi, Priyanka Chopra among those tested, jabbed for COVID in Bihar!

Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, Sonia Gandhi, Priyanka Chopra and Akshay Kumar – these are the names of residents of a non-descript rural area of an impoverished south Bihar district. If ... Read more »

Never Forget That Trump Purged the Pentagon Leadership Between the Election and January 6

© brent stirton – Getty Images And that the new leadership he installed seized direct control over deploying the National Guard that day. And that deployment was delayed for hours. ... Read more »

New Hampshire Is Trying to Protect Itself From 'Subversive Doctrines.' Can You Guess Which Ones?

© GraphicaArtis – Getty Images It’s almost scientifically impossible to be so wrong about so many things in such a short amount of time. I thank the Great Whoever that ... Read more »

Stacey Solomon shows sons the exact moment she met Joe Swash on I'm A Celeb

Stacey Solomon showed her sons the exact moment she met her soon to be husband Joe Swash on I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! eleven years earlier. Back ... Read more »

Levelling up must begin with better policies for children in the North of England, report warns

Widening inequalities for children in the North of England are increasing poverty, costing childrens’ lives and billions of pounds, a landmark report on outcomes for young people in the region ... Read more »

Jose Mourinho's blunt dig at Arsenal appointing Mikel Arteta as manager in rant

Jose Mourinho isn’t one to mince his words. And back when Arsenal were in the process of hiring Mikel Arteta as their new manager in December 2019, the current Roma ... Read more »

Viewers are saying the same thing about Martin Lewis presenting Good Morning Britain

© Provided by Hello! martin-lewis-minutes Good Morning Britain presenter Martin Lewis has taken over presenting duties opposite Susannah Reid on the hit breakfast show – but how are viewers finding ... Read more »

Veteran Labour MP Harriet Harman to stand down at next election

© PA ‘Mother of the House’ Harman will stand down after over 40 years in parliament – PA Labour MP and former minister Harriet Harman has announced that she will ... Read more »

How to get the Skies of Friendship Commendation in Sea of Thieves

© Provided by GamePur The Skies of Friendship Commendation in Sea of Thieves requires you to set off Fireworks while in an Alliance. Check whether you’ve already done this or ... Read more »

LBC's Steve Allen cleared by Ofcom after calling Strictly's Tilly Ramsay ‘chubby'

© Provided by The Independent LBC presenter Steve Allen has been cleared by Ofcom following complaints over derogatory comments he made about Strictly Come Dancing star Tilly Ramsay. The radio ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett says 'there was no hoax' as he testifies in court

© Bang Showbiz Jussie Smollett testified in court this week Jussie Smollett has insisted “there was no hoax” as he testified in court over claims he staged a racist and ... Read more »

Beijing Winter Olympics: China threatens US with retaliation over diplomatic boycott

China has threatened the Biden administration with retaliation over its decision to impose a diplomatic boycott of the 2022 Winter Olympics in Beijing, warning the move could harm bilateral relations. ... Read more »

Harsher Covid restrictions like working from home still aren't required despite spread of Omicron, insists deputy PM

HARSHER Covid restrictions aren't required despite the rapid spread of the Omicron variant across Britain, Dominic Raab declared today. The deputy PM said there's still no need to introduce tougher ... Read more »

Chilling moment road rage killer calmly heads off on holiday moments after stabbing dad to death in front of his son, 4

A MONSTER who stabbed a dad to death in front of his four-year-old son was caught on camera minutes after the brutal attack – calmly setting off on holiday. Chilling ... Read more »

Facebook to simplify online payments via Messenger

With the holiday season fast approaching, Facebook wants to give its users the ability to handle finances and easily divide funds and get back payments online from other users all ... Read more »

‘Invisible, worthless, disempowered!' WASPI women outline state pension age plight

State pension age previously stood at 60 for women in the UK but the Pensions Acts of 1995 and 2011, respectively, changed this. The state pension age for women increased ... Read more »

'His performance is better than Kumble, Laker': Ex-NZ bowler explains why Ajaz Patel's 10-wicket haul was 'amazing'

© Provided by Hindustan Times New Zealand’s Ajaz Patel celebrates the dismissal of India’s Mohammed Siraj on the second day of the 2nd Test match between India and New Zealand, ... Read more »

Elon Musk says there are "not enough people" and that the falling birthrate could threaten human civilization

Tesla CEO Elon Musk.REUTERS/Michele Tantussi/File Photo “If people don't have more children, civilization is going to crumble, mark my words,” said Elon Musk. Musk was responding to a question about ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic