NYT slammed for downplaying Steele dossier's impact on Trump-Russia probe

donald trump, dossier, new york times, russia

The New York Times was criticized for an explainer that claimed the Steele dossier was only tangential to the Trump-Russia investigation. Getty Images

Journalists, authors and ex-White House aides took to Twitter Thursday slamming the New York Times for an explainer that downplayed the impact of the since-discredited Steele dossier on the Russia investigation into former President Donald Trump

The story, headlined, “Why the Discredited Dossier Does Not Undercut the Russia Investigation” and written by Washington correspondent Charlie Savage, attempts to distance the dossier from the Russia investigation, saying the two are “tangential.”

“Mr. Trump and his allies have insinuated that the F.B.I. based the Russia investigation on the dossier. But when counterintelligence agents launched the effort on July 30, 2016, they did not yet know about the dossier. An inspector general report established that Mr. Steele’s reports reached that counterintelligence team on Sept. 19, 2016,” Savage wrote.

He later claimed that the dossier “did not create” an “atmosphere of suspicion” around Trump, pointing to previous reports of Trump’s connections with Russia that emerged prior to the dossier’s release.

donald trump, dossier, new york times, russia

The article’s author, Charlie Savage, had previously connected the Steele dossier to the Russia investigation and was criticized for hypocrisy.

Getty Images

Savage’s article was met with lots of criticism, with some accusing him of hypocrisy, having directly connected the dossier and the Russia investigation in 2018. 

“This you?” Historian Svetlana Lokhova tweeted, sharing a screenshot of an article authored by Savage in Feb. 2018.

This you? https://t.co/uadjYgBWRk pic.twitter.com/b6me5STD2J

— Svetlana Lokhova (@RealSLokhova) December 1, 2021

“An application to wiretap a former associate of President Trump’s campaign in fall 2016 “made only narrow use” of information provided by a former British spy who compiled a notorious dossier about Mr. Trump and Russia, according to a memo released by Democrats on the House Intelligence Committee on Saturday,” the screenshot read. 

Savage did note that the FBI took steps in its investigation based on claims made in the dossier, but emphasized that investigators and Special Counsel Robert Mueller did not rely on the allegations for their findings or criminal charges that came out of it. 

donald trump, dossier, new york times, russia

Former UK intelligence officer Christopher Steele authored the since discredited dossier.

AFP via Getty Images

In a tweet, the journalist promoted the explainer saying, “It’s become clear that the Steele Dossier was unreliable & unworthy of the attention it received. But it was also a largely tangential distraction from the actual Russia investigation, despite misleading attempts to conflate them.”

Others pointed out the New York Times’ reporting as a whole which — along with many other major media outlets such as the Washington Post and MSNBC — promoted the dossier as not entirely “disproven” for some time. 

“Sorry, Charlie. No. NYT dutifully reported as spun by a Clinton operation designed to undo free and fair election results and hobble a presidency. The only question is not who, but HOW MANY OF YOU knew full well you were part of the operation. You destroyed families. Children,” former Trump aide Michael Caputo wrote. 

donald trump, dossier, new york times, russia

The dossier alleged that former President Trump had paid Russian prostitutes to urinate on a hotel bed previously occupied by Barack and Michelle Obama.

Bloomberg via Getty Images

Mollie Hemmingway, senior editor for The Federalist, accused the paper of losing its credibility through downplaying the dossier’s role in the Russia investigation and the outlet’s reporting on it.

“Even moreso, it’s clear some of the dossier’s biggest peddlers aren’t just trying to downplay the role it played in their own ‘reporting’ but pretend that ONLY the dossier aspect of the Russia collusion hoax was problematic. Give it up, hoaxers. Your credibility: gone,” she said. 

Others completely disagreed with Savage’s reporting, arguing the dossier held a “central” role in the investigation.

donald trump, dossier, new york times, russia

Many accused the New York Times of having promoted the Steele dossier, and Mollie Hemingway, senior editor of The Federalist, claimed the New York Times had lost its credibility by now downplaying its role in the Russia investigation.

Getty Images

“The Steele Dossier wasn’t tangential to the Trump-Russia investigation — it was a central & essential part of it,” Washington Examiner reporter Jerry Dunleavy tweeted. 

The dossier was compiled and released in 2017 by former British spy Christopher Steele, who used several unreliable sources to allege several claims against Trump — including that Russian security services possessed a tape of Trump in a Moscow hotel room with prostitutes who were urinating on a bed where then-President Barack Obama and first lady Michelle Obama had previously stayed.

Many of the allegations have since been debunked and several media outlets have retracted some of their previous reporting that relied on sources who lied.

News Related


Republic Day Parade: India's first woman Rafale fighter jet pilot Shivangi Singh part of IAF tableau

© Provided by The Financial Express She is only the second woman fighter jet pilot to be part of the IAF tableau. (Photo source: ANI) The country’s first woman Rafale ... Read more »

'Many PPE firms registered only after lockdown'

© Provided by SowetanLive A number of companies that scored irregular awarded multi-million rand state PPE contracts were only registered after the national state of disaster was declared. The Special ... Read more »

Mayor did not crash car while ‘partying with female friends' — Municipality

© Provided by Times Live Municipal manager Sibusisiwe Ngiba confirmed that a crash took place on December 27 2021. Ngiba said a mayoral driver was travelling to Babanango to fetch Sibisi when ... Read more »

‘I suspect rats'- Here's who Malema believes is to blame for parliament blaze

© Provided by Times Live Addressing the media in Johannesburg on Tuesday, Malema shared his belief that negligence led to the blaze that ripped through the building earlier this month. He ... Read more »

Should handle COVID-19 third wave with 'total seriousness': Karnataka Guv

Cautioning about the third wave of COVID-19, Karnataka Governor Thaawar Chand Gehlot on Wednesday, called on the citizens to handle the situation with “total seriousness” and said there should be ... Read more »

From Virat Kohli to Neeraj Chopra, Indian sports stars wish fans on Republic Day 2022

© Provided by DNA As the nation celebrates its 73rd Republic Day today, not just Indian sportspersons, but international stars also took to social media to wish India on the ... Read more »

‘Immense', ‘Huge' – Many QPR fans react to recent announcement involving Wolves

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Queens Park Rangers v Birmingham City Many Queens Park Rangers have fans have taken to Twitter to react to the signing of ... Read more »

Is Ivory Coast vs Egypt on TV? Time, channel and how to watch all today's Africa Cup of Nations fixtures

© AFP via Getty Images GettyImages-1237836361.jpg One of the biggest match-ups at the 2021 Africa Cup of Nations so far takes place on Wednesday, with one of the pre-tournament favourites ... Read more »

Danielle Collins bounces back from surgery to set up Iga Swiatek semi-final at Australian Open

© AFP via Getty Images GettyImages-1237984056.jpg Former French Open champion Iga Swiatek will take on Danielle Collins in the semi-finals of the French Open after both won their last-eight encounters ... Read more »

Keith Downie teases late 'big-name loan signing' for NUFC; it's a former Ballon D'Or nominee

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Donny van de Beek gets past Emil Forsberg Sky Sports journalist Keith Downie has talked up the possibility of a late Newcastle United loan move ... Read more »

Virat Kohli quitting Test captaincy was a small setback for India before South Africa ODIs: Harbhajan Singh

Virat Kohli Former India off-spinner Harbhajan Singh said that Virat Kohli’s decision to quit Test captaincy midway during the South Africa tour did affect India a little bit ahead of ... Read more »

Afcon 2021: Mali vs Equatorial Guinea - Kick-off, TV channel, squad news and preview

Mali will face off with Equatorial Guinea in the 2021 Africa Cup of Nations Round of 16 match at the Limbe Stadium on Wednesday. The Eagles are hoping to reach ... Read more »

Man Utd may have already found Jesse Lingard replacement after Ralf Rangnick U-turn

The saga surrounding Jesse Lingard’s Manchester United future looks set to come to a head, with just days of the January window remaining. It’s been a tale of broken promises ... Read more »

Johor bukan Pantai Timur, parti komponen jangan bawa diri, Tok Mat ingatkan BN

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mohamad Hasan berkata BN akan melihat dan mengkaji dengan teliti sebelum memutuskan sama ada mahu bekerjasama dengan PAS atau sebaliknya pada PRN Johor. JOHOR ... Read more »

'Ironic Congress doesn't need his services': Kapil Sibal on Ghulam Nabi Azad's Padma Bhushan award

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: The factions in the Congress party continued to be on display this time over the Padma Bhushan award conferred ... Read more »

Masalah bekalan kentang goreng, McDonald's hanya tawar set saiz sederhana

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mcdonald’s Malaysia menerusi akaun Instagramnya sebelum ini memaklumkan bahawa hidangan kentang goreng bersaiz besar tidak ditawarkan bermula 24 Jan lalu kerana berdepan masalah kekurangan ... Read more »

Republic Day 2022: Meet India's first woman Rafale fighter jet pilot part of IAF tableau

© Provided by Zee News The Republic Day 2022 parade witnessed its grandest-ever flypast with 75 aircrafts being part of the celebrations. Not just the flypast, the Indian Air Force ... Read more »

From Centurions, PT-76 tanks to 75/24 Pack howitzers: Weapons used by Indian Army during '65 and '71 wars roll down Rajpath at Republic Day parade

© Provided by Firstpost From Centurions, PT-76 tanks to 75/24 Pack howitzers: Weapons used by Indian Army during ’65 and ’71 wars roll down Rajpath at Republic Day parade The ... Read more »

Great opportunity to get job in Google, company plans to open new India office later this year

© Provided by Zee News Mumbai: Google on Monday announced plans to open a new office in Pune this year, that will hire professionals for building advanced enterprise cloud technologies. ... Read more »

Norway's FHI official: The corona measures may place a greater burden on society than the disease itself

There is room to gradually ease the coronary measures, FHI official Frode Forland said on Tuesday. He believes that the measures may cause greater strain on society than the disease ... Read more »

Asian shares mixed ahead of Fed policy statements

The Associated PressA man wearing a face mask walks past a bank’s electronic board showing the Hong Kong share index in Hong Kong, Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2022. Asian shares were ... Read more »

Kolkata reports 219 drink-drive cases in last six days

Kolkata reports 219 drink-drive cases in last six days Kolkata has recorded 219 cases of drink-driving in just six days. On Monday and Tuesday, 88 cases were recorded in the ... Read more »

Ukraine's front line: Where lives turn on distant decisions

The Associated PressFILE – A Ukrainian serviceman patrols a street near the frontline with Russia-backed separatists in Verkhnotoretske village in Yasynuvata district, Donetsk region, eastern Ukraine, Jan. 22, 2022. Ukrainians ... Read more »

Lunch ideas: Dishes that will make you fall in love with mango

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Summer’s fruit harvest is so bountiful, it’s hard to choose a favourite. But juicy, sweet mangoes are our pick – maybe because they taste ... Read more »

Budget 2022 must align tax regime for NBFCs in line with banks' taxation

© Provided by The Financial Express NBFCs in India have played an important role over the years for business development. (File Photo: PTI) By Sunil Gidwani NBFCs play a crucial ... Read more »

How bitter PSG divorce and Roman Abramovich promise helped Thomas Tuchel fall in love at Chelsea

Thomas Tuchel had one question for the Chelsea board when first approached to replace Frank Lampard at Stamford Bridge. It consisted of just six words and needed an honest answer. ... Read more »

‘Now you're talking', ‘Be unreal' – These Sheffield Wednesday fans react as Owls target defender

© Provided by Football League World Harlee Dean Sheffield Wednesday are closing in on the signing of Harlee Dean on loan from Birmingham City for the rest of the season. ... Read more »

Over 21 million new Covid-19 cases reported globally last week, highest number of weekly cases recorded since beginning of pandemic: WHO

© Provided by The Financial Express The COVID-19 Weekly Epidemiological Update, released on Tuesday by the WHO, said that globally, the number of new COVID-19 cases increased by 5 per ... Read more »

Ukraine news – live: Biden says invasion would be ‘largest since WW2' as Moscow decries ‘Russophobia'

LIVE – Updated at 06:46 Joe Biden has said there would be “enormous consequences” globally if Russia invaded Ukraine. An estimated 100,000 or so Russian troops are amassed on the ... Read more »

Damian Lewis reads moving tribute to wife Helen McCrory at National Theatre: ‘Her thunder would not be stolen'

© AFP/Getty Damian Lewis and Helen McCrory at the Evening Standard Theatre Awards in 2014 – AFP/Getty Damian Lewis read an emotional tribute to his late wife Helen McCrory last ... Read more »

Teen ‘lucky to be alive' after knife attack in supermarket carpark in Finsbury Park

© Metropolitan Police Lights stock MND dimnesions.jpg A 15-year-old boy is “extremely lucky to be alive” after being stabbed in a supermarket carpark in Finsbury Park. Police were called to ... Read more »

Bradley Cooper nearly quit acting in 2020

© Bang Showbiz Bradley Cooper Bradley Cooper was ready to quit acting in 2020. The ‘A Star is Born’ actor has revealed he was going to give up his career ... Read more »

Kathryn Kates: Orange Is The New Black and Seinfield actress dies

© PA Archive Bed n Binge retreat Orange Is The New Black and Seinfeld actress Kathryn Kates has died, according to her representatives. The US actress was described as a ... Read more »

UK 'partygate': A timeline of Boris Johnson's lockdown scandals

© Daniel Leal, AFP The “partygate” scandal engulfing Boris Johnson has piqued public outrage that the prime minister was not playing by the rules he set for everyone else. Here ... Read more »

Roy Keane's reaction when Slaven Bilic touched his shoulder live on air was priceless

© GiveMeSport Roy Keane didn’t look overly happy… Slaven Bilic’s stint as a pundit for the 2018 World Cup is the stuff of legend. The charismatic Croatian was absolutely brilliant ... Read more »

Inside Thomas Tuchel's first year at Chelsea from Champions League glory to museum love

Thomas Tuchel arrived as the manager nervous about taking over from a Chelsea legend. And on the first anniversary of taking charge at Stamford Bridge, Tuchel has made himself at ... Read more »

San Jose, California, just voted to institute first-in-the-nation gun ownership requirements

The San Jose city council voted Tuesday night to adopt a first-in-the-nation ordinance requiring most gun owners to pay a fee and carry liability insurance. © Samuel Corum/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images ... Read more »

Erste Tennisspielerin mit Kopftuch: 17-jährige Iranerin schreibt in Australien Geschichte

© Bereitgestellt von Blick 17-jährige Iranerin schreibt in Australien Geschichte Die Sonne, sie brennt nur so vom australischen Himmel herunter. Über 33 Grad. Im Schatten sucht man Abkühlung vergeblich. Meshkatolzahra ... Read more »

Michael Schumachers Mercedes-Benz C 63 AMG steht zum Verkauf

Die Formel 1-Legende fuhr dieses schnelle T-Modelle rund sieben Monate lang als Dienstwagen … © Motor1.com Deutschland 2010 Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG for sale (lead image) Als Michael Schumacher Anfang 2010 ... Read more »

Raju Srivastava wants Bhagwant Mann to become Punjab CM

Raju Srivastava and Bhagwant Mann started their comedy career together. After their successful innings in comedy, both of them tried their hands at politics. Although their ideologies may be different ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic