NYPD sergeant accused of shoplifting sues Macy’s for racial profiling, false arrest

An NYPD sergeant arrested for shoplifting in a Yonkers Macy’s is suing the department store giant, claiming security guards falsely arrested her and ruined her career.

In a lawsuit filed in Brooklyn Federal Court, Sgt. Eva Pena says she was a “loyal longtime customer” of Macy’s until Sept. 3, 2019, when store security and Yonkers police “falsely arrested her and is maliciously prosecuting her without having observed a crime committed in their presence.”

Pena was accused of stealing $359 worth of Guess and Tommy Hilfiger clothes from the Macy’s in the Cross County Shopping Center.

She claims in court papers she was targeted by store security guards because she is Dominican and that, although a store security guard followed her around the store and into both the changing rooms and bathrooms, no one ever saw her commit a crime.

Eva Pena

Eva Pena (Attorney Handout/Eric Sanders )

Macy’s Asset Protection Officer Samantha Newton-Henry said during Pena’s department trial in July that she never saw Pena take the clothing that was later found in the cop’s bag, court documents cite. Nor was the theft caught on video.

But Newton-Henry testified she followed Pena around the store after her colleagues suspected the mother of three of shoplifting. She claimed after following Pena into the ladies room she found clothing tags floating inside a toilet bowl when Pena walked out.

Newton-Henry also claimed Pena signed a confession.

Pena has accused the store’s asset protection staff of framing her, trying to shake her down and forging her signature on the confession.

“They said, ‘We’re going to count how many items there are and multiply it by five. You pay us that amount, we’ll open up the door and go home, no one would ever find out.’ I said, ‘Do yourself a favor and call the cops,’” Pena told the Daily News following her NYPD disciplinary proceeding.

The shakedown allegations are not mentioned in Pena’s lawsuit. The criminal case against her is still pending in Westchester Criminal Court.

As the result of her arrest, Pena, an NYPD public housing sergeant, was stripped of her gun and shield and the department “failed to promote her to the position of lieutenant,” the lawsuit noted. The NYPD’s Department Advocate’s office wants to fire Pena for shoplifting and lying to her bosses. The ruling of the judge in the departmental trial has not yet been released.

Pena’s departmental trial got off to a rocky start when prosecutors nixed plans for an NYPD analyst to testify the sergeant’s signature on the shoplifting confession provided by the department store was legit.

The planned testimony was canceled after a subordinate claimed in a lawsuit that she reviewed the handwriting analysis and came to the conclusion the signature was a “possible” match. Her boss tried to bully her into saying it was a definitive match, part of a pattern of bullying in the NYPD’s questioned documents unit, the suit claims.

Macy’s in the Cross County Shopping Center.

Macy’s in the Cross County Shopping Center. (Google Maps)

Sanders, who cited cases in which Macy’s was accused of racial profiling in the lawsuit, said that his client had a Macy’s credit card and about $1,000 in her wallet when she was arrested.

“Why would she steal something? It makes zero sense,” he said.

The New York State attorney general’s office accused Macy’s of racial profiling in 2005 after learning that more people of color were being stopped and accused of shoplifting than whites, the lawsuit states. Macy’s denied any wrongdoing but that same year singed a memorandum agreement “to resolve matters” stemming from the attorney general’s investigation.

In 2014, following another investigation into racial profiling by the attorney general’s office, this time involving Macy’s flagship store in Midtown, the retail company agreed to pay $650,000 to settle the AG’s lawsuit, although they again did not admit or deny the findings in the 37-page settlement.

Macy’s declined to comment on Pena’s suit.

News Related


Oregon linebacker punches fan after brutal loss to Oregon State

Oregon-Oregon State is one of the biggest in-state rivalries in college football. And Saturday in Corvallis, Ore., tensions heated over after the game when a Ducks player punched an Oregon ... Read more »

Jets know Mike White gives team better shot at playoffs than Zach Wilson

It was never a case of love at first sight for Mike White, never an infatuation with his magical right arm, never a dream that he could one day make ... Read more »

Protests of strict lockdown hit Shanghai, other China cities

Protests of strict lockdown hit Shanghai, other China cities A protest against China’s strict “zero-COVID” policies resurfaced in Shanghai on Sunday afternoon even after police cleared away hundreds of demonstrators ... Read more »

No dank bank: Congress should clear way for marijuana businesses to bank

If you ask any security consultant about one of the biggest physical security risks a business can take, high up on the list would be having huge piles of cash ... Read more »

Supreme accountability: SCOTUS justices are not immune from oversight

As the Supreme Court faces a crisis of credibility, another blow has landed in the form of former anti-abortion evangelical leader Rev. Rob Schenck’s allegations about the leak of a ... Read more »

Jonny Williams promises to document Wales' celebration if they manage to beat England

Wales winger Jonny Williams says he will not be the only cameraman inside the Wales squad should they produce a stunning World Cup win against England. Read more »

Writes of passage: More NYC high schools need student newspapers

New research reveals that just 27% of New York City’s public high schools have student newspapers. You don’t have to be a reporter or editorial writer or former student journalist ... Read more »

Cameron Smith crowned Australian PGA Championship winner for the third time

Hometown hero Cameron Smith continued his superlative 2022 with a third Australian PGA Championship victory at his birthplace in Brisbane on Sunday. Read more »

Chris Mepham claims Wales have another gear they can unlock when they take on England

Welsh defender Chris Mepham says Wales will “take the handbrake off” for their do-or-die World Cup clash with England. Read more »

Shevington death: Liam Smith named as man found dead with ‘potentially hazardous’ substances in Kilburn Drive

Grieving relatives have paid tribute to a man who was found dumped on a street with “potentially hazardous” substances on his body. Liam Smith was discovered on a residential street ... Read more »

Luke Shaw admits he is still haunted by Wales’ mocking England at Euro 2016

England fullback Luke Shaw believes the way Wales celebrated England’s elimination from Euro 2016 will add extra motivation to their World Cup clash. Read more »

Carlos Queiroz demands Jurgen Klinsmann’s resignation from FIFA post after criticism of Iran

Carlos Queiroz has called for Jurgen Klinsmann to resign from FIFA’s World Cup Technical Study Group and labelled comments he made about Iran “a disgrace to football”. Read more »

Red Wings host the Maple Leafs after shootout victory

Toronto Maple Leafs (9-5-3, second in the Atlantic Division) vs. Detroit Red Wings (7-5-4, third in the Atlantic Division) Detroit; Monday, 7 p.m. EST BOTTOM LINE: The Detroit Red Wings ... Read more »

AP PHOTOS: Bright shops enliven Congo's dark days

AP PHOTOS: Bright shops enliven Congo's dark days Jean Claude, 27, poses in front of his hairdressing salon in Goma, Democratic Republic of Congo, Saturday Nov. 26, 2022.At a time ... Read more »

Dillian Whyte punches his way to points victory over Jermaine Franklin

Dillian Whyte ended Jermaine Franklin's undefeated record with a majority decision win at Wembley Arena in London on Saturday night. Read more »

Shaghai protests: why are people protesting? Is it due to Covid-19 lockdown rules - here’s what we know

Protests against China’s restrictive Covid-19 measures appeared to have spread to a number of cities in displays of public defiance fanned by anger over a deadly fire in the western ... Read more »

Meet the US man on a mission to expose sneaky price increases

SOMERVILLE, Massachusetts – A few weeks ago, Edgar Dworsky got a promising tip by email. “Diluted cough syrup”, read the message, accompanied by a photo of two packages of syrup ... Read more »

Exploring a memory: Designer recreates a dress for Diana

Exploring a memory: Designer recreates a dress for Diana This is a dress with a story, and Elizabeth Emanuel wants to tell it British designer Elizabeth Emanuel stands beside a ... Read more »

Suspect killed 3 and torched house before being shot dead by cops

A person wanted for the killing of three people was fatally shot by sheriff deputies on Friday. (Will Lester/Inland Valley Daily Bulletin/SCNG via AP) A person suspected of killing three ... Read more »

Dear Abby: I can’t choose between my boyfriend and my best friend

Dear Abby advises a woman who has to choose between her boyfriend and her best friend. DEAR ABBY: I recently started talking to this guy from my past. I really ... Read more »

Kidnappings, looting cited in Ethiopia's Tigray after truce

Kidnappings, looting cited in Ethiopia's Tigray after truce Eyewitnesses and aid workers say that allies of Ethiopia’s federal military are looting property and carrying out mass detentions in Tigray FILE ... Read more »

Titans get first shot at revenge vs. Bengals since playoff loss

If having won seven of the past eight games and still being an underdog playing at home doesn’t have the Titans feeling disrespected, then how about a revenge angle? The ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic set to make Australia return in Adelaide

Novak Djokovic will not take part in the United Cup which has also nixed any chance of Serbian participation in the tournament. Read more »

Gareth Southgate: England need to want it more than Wales

Gareth Southgate is wary of a "wounded" Wales as his England side look to secure their progression to the World Cup group stages at the expense of their "desperate" neighbours. Read more »

Tesla recalls over 80,000 cars

Tesla is recalling almost 81,000 electric cars in China – more than it typically ships from its Shanghai factory in any given month- due to a software issue and seat ... Read more »

World Cup 2022 LIVE: Rooney URGES Southgate to rest Kane, Gary Neville SLAMS Messi despite VITAL Argentina win – latest

ENGLAND’S all-time top goal scorer Wayne Rooney has advised Gareth Southgate to rest Harry Kane for the Three Lions’ final group game against Wales. Kane, 29, played the whole 90 ... Read more »

WTA still concerned about Peng Shuai

The WTA have reiterated its desire to get answers regarding the safety and well-being of retired Chinese professional Peng Shuai. Read more »

US Soccer Posts Iran Flag Without Islamic Republic Emblem

The U.S. men's soccer team is scheduled to play the Iranian soccer team in a World Cup match on Tuesday Read more »

Ex-Islander Kieffer Bellows starting to find his game with Flyers

Kieffer Bellows is already seeing one benefit of playing away from Long Island: He’s grown out some facial hair. “I don’t know what you’d call it, I guess,” Bellows said ... Read more »

Lionel Messi relief as Argentina 'luckily' overcome Mexico

Lionel Messi admits Argentina faced a difficult World Cup opponent in Mexico on Saturday but was delighted to claim all three points after an opening day loss to Saudi Arabia. Read more »

Jets special team ace Justin Hardee not to blame for Patriots’ TD return

Special teams captain Justin Hardee took the blame after the Jets allowed an 84-yard punt return for a game-sealing touchdown in their 10-3 loss to the Patriots last Sunday. Hardee’s ... Read more »

Xi’s iron grip on his country is stopping the Covid U-turn it so desperately needs

Photograph: Kevin Frayer/Getty Last week, Covid-related images provoked outrage on Chinese social media: one showed a young woman kneeling on the ground with her hands tied behind her back after ... Read more »

Let it glow: 10 best Christmas light displays in Britain

Dunham Massey, Cheshire A pair of giant sparkling reindeer welcomes visitors to Dunham Massey’s illuminated trail, with both the grounds and the exterior of the house blazing with vivid, festive ... Read more »

Photos: Caleb Williams propels No. 6 USC past No. 15 Notre Dame

USC quarterback Caleb Williams accounted for four touchdowns during No. 6 USC’s 38-27 win over No. 15 Notre Dame on Saturday night at the Coliseum, inspiring fans and teammates to ... Read more »

Dane Dunn leads youthful Sierra Canyon to Southern Section Division 2 football title

They slumped, they stumbled, a traditionally dominant football program met with untraditionally scant levels of success. This was a fairly underclassmen-heavy Chatsworth Sierra Canyon High team, and they made underclassmen-type ... Read more »

US knows a win over Iran would erase past missed opportunities

If the World Cup-opening draw against Wales was the United States putting many of its worries on display, then the 0-0 draw against England on Friday was the reverse. The ... Read more »

Malaysia PM Anwar eyes targeted subsidies for low-income groups

KUALA LUMPUR – Malaysia is reviewing its government subsidies programme, aiming to direct money toward low-income groups, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said on Sunday, prioritising the rising cost of living ... Read more »

Online sales set Black Friday record

Cyber Week, the five days from Thanksgiving Day through Cyber Monday are expected to generate $34.8 billion in online sales Read more »

Video shows POV of terrifying moment truck smacks into motorcyclist

Here's video from a motorcyclist of that fatal crash that happened in Malibu on Nov 14. pic.twitter.com/Mf6bUNGZYL — Downtown LA Scanner (@DowntownLAScan) November 27, 2022 Shocking video captured what a ... Read more »

PAS gains prominence as Malaysian Malays reject corruption

KUALA LUMPUR – The fundamentalist Parti Islam SeMalaysia (PAS) emerged as one of the big winners in Malaysia’s general election, helped by a wave of Malay Muslim voters rejecting corruption ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network