NSO blacklisting: It is time for the US to end its Cold War ways

NSO blacklisting: It is time for the US to end its Cold War ways
© Provided by Al Jazeera A man walks past the logo of Israeli cyber-firm NSO Group at one of its branches in the Arava Desert in Israel on July 22, 2021 [File: Reuters/Amir Cohen]

On November 3, the United States Department of Commerce announced it was blacklisting the Israeli technology firm, NSO Group. The decision to add the company to a list of entities engaging in activities contrary to US national security or foreign policy interests was momentous.

In its press release on the subject, the commerce department noted: “[there is] evidence that these entities developed and supplied spyware to foreign governments that used these tools to maliciously target government officials, journalists, businesspeople, activists, academics, and embassy workers.  These tools have also enabled foreign governments to conduct transnational repression, which is the practice of authoritarian governments targeting dissidents, journalists and activists outside of their sovereign borders to silence dissent. Such practices threaten the rules-based international order.”

Yet, the Israeli government and NSO decided to treat the matter as a public relations problem and not as a human rights crisis and tried to downplay it. The company first tried to look confident and published a statement that it “feels perplexed by the decision”. Then it sent a “secret” letter to the Israeli government, which got “leaked”, asking for assistance to get the US government to cancel the blacklisting and help save hundreds of Israeli jobs.

The Israeli government for its part also tried to engage in some damage control. On November 25, Israeli media widely reported on a supposed decision by the defence ministry to stop selling cybertechnology to some 65 countries, including the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, etc. Subsequent scrutiny of these reports, however, revealed that this is not the case; the ministry has simply added one more bureaucratic step – the need for permission to start export negotiations with these countries – to the otherwise unobstructed process.

None of these damage control attempts seemed to have helped. Moody’s downgraded NSO and warned it is at risk of default, while US tech giant Apple pushed forward with a lawsuit against the company for targeting iPhone users.

Indeed, the US blacklisting could be a game changer, the beginning of a strong US response to the challenge that the thriving surveillance systems industry poses to civil society and democracy movements around the world.

Organisations like Amnesty International, Citizen Lab, Forbidden Stories, Access Now, and many journalists and activists around the world, from India to Mexico and Hungary, to Israel, have long been ringing alarm bells about NSO and other spyware companies, hoping that officials in the US and elsewhere would listen when they make policy decisions.

For doing so, the critics have been accused by NSO and its supporters of being liars and even part of an anti-Israel and anti-Semitic campaign. There has also been an ever-present fear of being sued for defamation by a highly influential company with vast financial resources able to pay expensive lawyers.

For us, Israeli activists, there have been also the obstacle of convincing the Israeli public of the danger of surveillance systems, since many Israelis approve of 24/7 Israeli surveillance of the Palestinians living under a repressive military regime in the occupied territories.

While the US blacklisting of NSO is a victory for civil society, it is also a mark of disgrace for the Israeli parliament and judiciary which has refused to rein in surveillance companies or monitor the defence ministry’s dealings with them.

For decades the Knesset avoided having any real discussion about defence export licences to countries in conflict or under repressive regimes. It did little to respond to the refusal of the defence ministry to share details of surveillance technology exports.

In 2015, together with MK Tamar Zandberg (the current minister of environmental protection), I co-wrote a proposed amendment to the 2007 Law for Oversight of Defence Exports, which restricts defence exports only to countries under a United Nations embargo. We based the text on the US “Leahy law”, which prohibits the provision of US military assistance and exports to governments and security forces that violate human rights with impunity.

The Israeli defence and foreign affairs ministries opposed synchronising Israeli legislation with American law. Subsequently, the Knesset failed to pass the proposal.

The repeated attempts of a group of Israeli human rights activists, which I was part of, to expose the defence ministry’s complicity in crimes against humanity and genocide in other countries, and stop export licences to conflict zones and non-democratic regimes through the Israeli judicial system were also largely unsuccessful. In fact, we faced constant institutional gaslighting.

The judges and the state representative regularly tried to make us believe that we were crazy or naive, and that if we were not already part of an anti-Israeli movement, we were being manipulated into unknowingly becoming part of one. In one hearing about arms shipments to a bloody civil war, a Supreme Court judge asked who was financing us and who was truly behind the petition; in another, an administrative court judge wanted clarification that we are not part of the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement.

Despite the humiliating and frustrating court hearings, we kept pressing on with petitions because this was a way to express solidarity with the growing list of victims of Israeli surveillance technologies and arms, and because we still had a flicker of hope that we would eventually succeed. We had our rare victories, such as when the defence ministry decided to stop all defence exports to Myanmar in late 2017.

But we also had our demoralising defeats. For example, in June, the Supreme Court dismissed a petition that demanded to cancel the export licence of Cellebrite’s system to Russia, which was used to hack mobile phones of activists associated with opposition leader Alexey Navalny. The judges used this opportunity to block future petitions by ruling that the court system in Israel does not have jurisdiction to oversee defence exports policy.

Without cooperation from the Knesset and the courts, it has been very difficult or even impossible to push for domestic policy change within Israel. And this is why the decision by the US Department of Commerce is so important. It puts much needed external pressure on the Israeli authorities, which were probably quite shocked by the blacklisting.

After all, they have been quite used to non-interference by the US in their defence export policies. Probably the only major clash between the US and the Israeli governments on this subject took place in the late 1990s, when the latter wanted to supply a Phalcon surveillance aircraft to China. An agreement was eventually reached, which prohibited the supply of certain Israeli-made military equipment to Beijing and imposed a requirement for prior US approval for other defence exports.

For everything else, the US has been mostly turning a blind eye. This policy goes back to the Cold War, when successive US administrations were happy with Israel doing Washington’s dirty work and supplying military technology to murderous dictatorial regimes which faced US sanctions or aid cuts.

For example, the Israeli government and the Reagan administration famously collaborated in the Iran-Contra affair, which saw the secret Israeli sales of weapons to embargoed Iran. Documents declassified in recent years show that senior US officials knew about Israel providing training and arms shipments to dictatorial regimes, such as the military juntas in Argentina and Chile in the 1970s and 1980s, but did not really try to stop them.

After the Cold War was over, US inaction on problematic Israeli defence exports no longer made sense, especially in cases when they seemed to serve the interests of China and Russia or various dictators.

One has to wonder why the Clinton administration did not stop the arms shipments from Israel to Serb forces during the war in Bosnia. Why was Israel allowed to continue providing arms, surveillance systems and training to Myanmar’s military until after a full genocide started against the Rohingya people? Why was Israel able to sell the Cellebrite hacking system to Venezuela, Belarus, Russia and China? And why was Israel continuing to arm the illegal private security unit of Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni while his regime clashed with the US and accused its embassy of interfering in the local election?

The big question now is whether the US will stop at NSO or whether it will undertake a major policy change and move away from its Cold War methods and mentality. If NSO survives the blacklisting and Washington fails to expand its action against uncontrollable spyware exports, then this would only strengthen the feeling of impunity within the industry and the arrogance of the Israeli defence ministry, whose workers usually seek to integrate into the intelligence industry after retiring from public service.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

News Related


NATO sends reinforcements to Eastern Europe amid Russia tensions

© Provided by Al Jazeera Members of Ukraine’s Territorial Defence Forces, volunteer military units of the Armed Forces, train in a city park in Kyiv, Ukraine [Efrem Lukatsky/AP Photo] NATO ... Read more »

Mounties in Nova Scotia search for cremation urn stolen in recent break-in

UPPER RAWDON, N.S. — Police in Nova Scotia are asking for the public’s help as they investigate a break-in that resulted in the theft of several items, including an urn ... Read more »

'Last Cuentista,' 'Unspeakable' win children's book awards

NEW YORK (AP) — Donna Barba Higuera’s “The Last Cuentista,” a post-apocalyptic tale of a young girl who must preserve the memory of Earth’s history, has won the John Newbery ... Read more »

Unheimliche Kreatur - TikToker flehen Wissenschaftler an

© YouTube / pangeaprogressblog Unheimlicher Meeresbewohner TikToker richten eine Bitte an Wissenschaftler, die Erforschung des Ozeans einzustellen, nachdem diese das Filmmaterial eines Tiefsee-“Aliens” veröffentlichten.. Eine ungewöhnliche Bitte mehrerer TikToker sorgt ... Read more »

Burkina Faso military says it has seized power in statement on state TV

Burkina Faso’s army announced it took control of the country on Monday, deposing President Roch Kabore, dissolving the government and parliament, suspending the constitution and shuttering its borders. © ISSOUF ... Read more »

Congress' mission is to improve school education in rural areas: Mohali MLA

© Provided by Hindustan Times Mohali MLA called upon residents to shun the negative election campaign of his rivals and vote and support the development of the district. (HT) Congress ... Read more »

US puts 8,500 troops on heightened alert amid Russia tension

BRUSSELS (AP) — The Pentagon said Monday that Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin has put up to 8,500 troops on heightened alert, so they will be prepared to deploy if needed ... Read more »

Canadian dollar falls to 2-week low on wave of risk aversion

By Fergal Smith © Reuters/Mark Blinch FILE PHOTO: A Canadian dollar coin, commonly known as the “Loonie”, is pictured in this illustration picture taken in Toronto TORONTO (Reuters) – The ... Read more »

'Free passes got lion's share of R-Day seats in 2019 and 2020'

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Nearly 80% of visitors to the Republic Day celebrations in New Delhi in 2019 got free passes issued by the government. ... Read more »

New York mayor unveils blueprint to combat gun violence

[Breaking news update, posted at 3:18 p.m. ET] © Provided by CNN New York City Mayor Eric Adams on Monday announced details of his administration’s wide-ranging blueprint to combat gun ... Read more »

The workplace of the future is here. Experts explain how to remove friction from remote work and enable productivity.

© Insider Senior reporter Jennifer Ortakales Dawkins (left), and panelists Tsedal Neeley and Todd Gerber. Insider Remote work for companies of all sizes requires connection, empathy, and innovation.  Experts advised ... Read more »

Emmerdale fans spot 'terrible' blunders as police confirm Liv will remain in prison

Emmerdale fans were not impressed on Monday evening as it was confirmed that Liv Flaherty will remain in jail. Poor Liv (Isobel Steele) was arrested on suspicion of murdering Ben ... Read more »

US puts 8,500 troops on alert as Biden ‘refining plans for all scenarios'

© Getty Images GettyImages-1366605004.jpg The Pentagon announced that it placed 8,500 troops on “heightened preparedness ” as the White House said it is refining any plans to find a solution ... Read more »

Soha Ali Khan shares throwback video of her putting daughter Inaaya in crib; Fans say, “Can't stop laughing”

© Provided by Pinkvilla Soha Ali Khan is enjoying her motherhood to its fullest. She gave birth to her daughter Inaaya in the year 2017 and ever since then she ... Read more »

New Transport Minister as Scottish Government makes changes

The First Minister of Scotland has announced two changes to her government, including the appointment of new Transport Minister Jenny Gilruth. The appointment comes after Graeme Dey, who formerly held ... Read more »

Super Bowl 2022: When, who is playing and how can I watch it?

© Getty Images This year will see the 56th edition of the Super Bowl – Getty Images This year’s edition of the Super Bowl will be the 56th in the ... Read more »

Wolves dealt transfer blow as Ornstein reveals Europa League competition for Molineux target

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Wolves, Molineux, Premier League, Duje Caleta-Car Wolves have suffered a potential blow in their quest to sign Marseille centre-back Duje Caleta-Car, with West Ham eyeing ... Read more »

TikTok is feeling emotional damage over the market crash

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge My TikTok For You page is generally a wonderland of soothing cooking videos, lesbian carpentry, dieticians frothing at the mouth at fitness ... Read more »

Newcastle may have big advantage to secure deal for Tottenham outcast Dele Alli

Newcastle United could have a huge advantage amid reports that they are interested in a move for Tottenham Hotspur midfielder Dele Alli. The England international reportedly shares the same agent ... Read more »

Boris Johnson under pressure over Islamophobia as he orders inquiry into MP's sacking

© PA Media Tory MP Nusrat Ghani has welcomed the announcement of an inquiry – PA Boris Johnson is coming under growing pressure over alleged Islamophobia within his government, after ... Read more »

‘They don't compare' – Goldson told to snub WBA, Forest by Gers icon

© PA Images Connor Goldson during a warm-up Rangers legend Barry Ferguson has urged Connor Goldson to snub a move to West Brom and Nottingham Forest in the summer. Goldson ... Read more »

US puts 8,500 troops on heightened alert amid fears over Ukraine

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Facundo Arrizabalaga/EPA The US has placed 8,500 troops on heightened alert to deploy to Europe as Nato reinforced its eastern borders with warships and ... Read more »

Minister quits Government with blast over ‘schoolboy' handling of Covid fraud

A minister quit the Government at the despatch box and marched out the chamber over the “schoolboy” handling of fraudulent Covid business loans. Lord Agnew of Oulton’s resignation from his ... Read more »

Americans in Ukraine ‘should leave now,' no evacuation in works: White House

White House press secretary Jen Psaki said Monday that US citizens in Ukraine “should leave now” and reiterated that no organized evacuation effort is planned should Russia invade the eastern ... Read more »

Facebook parent Meta creates powerful AI supercomputer

MENLO PARK, Calif. — Facebook’s parent company Meta on Monday said it has created what it believes is among the fastest artificial intelligence supercomputers running today. The social media giant ... Read more »

Feds launch website for claiming part 2 of child tax credit

The Associated PressThe government website childtaxcredit.gov is photographed on a computer screen Monday, Jan. 24, 2022, in Annapolis, Md. The IRS has launched a revamped Child Tax Credit website meant ... Read more »

LOT plane makes emergency landing after cabin pressure loss

WARSAW, Poland — A Polish LOT airlines whose passengers included four Polish members of the European Parliament made an emergency landing at a German airport Monday after suffering cabin pressure ... Read more »

Dad spends year camping, building log cabin ‘survival shelter' with young sons

A Virginia father went on an adventure of a lifetime with his three young sons. Luke Nichols, a criminal defense attorney and host of the Outdoor Boys YouTube Channel, built ... Read more »

5 teams who make sense for Aaron Rodgers if he parts ways with Packers

Aaron Rodgers and the Green Bay Packers may or may not be headed for a divorce this offseason. Rodgers, 38, was non-committal when asked directly about the possibility after a ... Read more »

Sean McVay's fiancée celebrates his birthday after thrilling Rams playoff win

Best birthday weekend ever? One day before celebrating his 36th birthday, Rams coach Sean McVay watched his team defeat the Buccaneers in thrilling fashion, with Los Angeles sealing the Divisional ... Read more »

Cars crash into same New Jersey home two weekends in a row

The family has an online fundraiser to help repair the damages with nearly $21,000. Wanamassa Fire Company A New Jersey house has been hit by cars two weekends in a ... Read more »

Danger signals as SABC victimises head of news division, Phathiswa Magopeni

A scandal is unfolding in the SABC, apparently aimed at reversing significant steps to have the corporation fulfil its mandate as a public broadcaster – and not simply a mouthpiece ... Read more »

COVID-19 in Europe: Germany maintains restrictions as Omicron infections rise

Several countries in Europe are still registering a record number of COVID-19 infections this week — here is our summary of the situation across the continent. The World Health Organization ... Read more »

Celebrating Dolly Rathebe, South Africa's original black woman superstar

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved Together with Miriam Makeba, Letta Mbulu and Dorothy Masuku, Rathebe’s name represents a golden era of local blues and jazz music ... Read more »

Taliban demand release of $10B frozen by US, Europe

​The Taliban kicked off their first meeting with Western officials since taking over Afghanistan last August by demanding the release of $10 billion in assets frozen by the United States ... Read more »

Webb telescope reaches destination, 1 mn miles from Earth: NASA

The James Webb Space Telescope has fired its thrusters and reached its orbital destination around a million miles (1.5 million kilometers) away from our planet, NASA said Monday, a key milestone ... Read more »

Heidi Klum (And Her Toned AF Legs) Filmed A Music Video With Her Besties—And It's Epic

Heidi Klum just dropped three epic videos on Instagram. In the clips, the 48-year-old supermodel is wearing a pair of sweat shorts and rocking out to her latest musical release, ... Read more »

Mitten im Lockdown!: Johnson feierte Geburtstagsparty mit 30 Gästen

Der britische Premierminister Boris Johnson kämpft im Skandal um Partys am Regierungssitz mit allen Mitteln um einen Verbleib im Amt. Nun gestand er per Regierungssprecherin ein, dass er seinen Geburtstag ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic