NPR Challenges Readers to Disregard Their Eyes and Common Sense on Trans Sports

npr challenges readers to disregard their eyes and common sense on trans sports

Lia Thomas

NPR is making a small ask of its readers: That they disregard both their sense of sight and common sense.

On Friday, NPR’s official Twitter account decried the World Athletics Council’s decision to prohibit male-to-female transgender athletes from competing in women’s track and field events, asserting that it was reached despite a dearth of evidence to support it.

“The international governing body for track and field will ban trans women athletes from elite women’s competitions, citing a priority for fairness over inclusion despite limited scientific evidence of physical advantage,” read the now deleted tweet, which linked to a story tying the decision to “dozens of more new and proposed laws that further curb transgender rights” in the United States.

It didn’t take long for Twitter to affix a contextual note to the tweet citing a British Journal of Sports Medicine study indicating that trans women remained significantly faster than their peers even after two years of hormone treatment.

Since then, NPR has issued a correction to its tweet, admitting that “existing research shows that higher levels of testosterone do impact athletic performance,” and instead submitting that the World Athletics Council reached its decision despite “limited research involving elite trans athletes in competition.”

But that too is misleading. The British Journal of Sports Medicine study was specifically geared toward evaluating the elite or Olympic level of competition and the accompanying article still holds that the Council has adopted its policy sans “strong evidence of an advantage.”

Even discounting the scientific evidence NPR is ignorant of, though, the underlying implication that transgender women boast no advantage in women’s sports strains credulity.

Hormone treatment certainly helps to level the playing field, but it can’t wipe out inherent advantages — in size, skeletal structure, and brain function — that those who are born as males, and especially those who undergo puberty, retain.

This is readily apparent to those who actually compete in and pay attention to women’s sports. It’s no accident that despite the small proportion of transgender athletes in the space, there’s no shortage of ones who have excelled in it.

Does anyone think it a coincidence that Lia Thomas, formerly a swimmer on the University of Pennsylvania’s men’s team, smashed records for the women’s team while towering over the competition? Sixteen of Thomas’s teammates, who wrote an open letter arguing that “biologically, Lia holds an unfair advantage over competition in the women’s category, as evidenced by her rankings that have bounced from #462 as a male to #1 as a female,” don’t.

Between 2017 and 2019, male-to-female transitioners ran away with 15 indoor track state championships in Connecticut alone, robbing numerous female competitors from numerous qualifying and podium finishes as along the way. Is it mere happenstance that former Connecticut high school indoor track star Chelsea Mitchell lost 4 state championships to transgender competitors, in some instances taking the bronze behind two such opponents?

Is it just a unhappy accident that transgender weightlifter Laurel Hubbard, a junior champion as a male, bumped fellow New Zealander Tracey Lambrechs into a lower weight class, forcing Lambrechs to lose 40 pounds in 3 months in order to carry on in the sport?

And is it just the luck of the draw that prevents female-to-male transitioners from enjoying similar success in men’s sports?

NPR has long been on a mission to convince its audience as much, insisting that restrictions on transgender participation have “no basis” in science and characterizing such restrictions as being rooted in opposition to “transgender rights.”

But unfortunately for the activists at the head of this deceptive effort, the truth of the matter is not just buried in lengthy, jargon-filled, academic inquiries. It’s discernable to the naked eye and intuitive to the human experience.

The post NPR Challenges Readers to Disregard Their Eyes and Common Sense on Trans Sports first appeared on Mediaite.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Gamblers are paying more money and winning less in Las Vegas casinos – here's why

Triple-zero roulette tables, which add another slot with three zeros, are becoming more common in Las Vegas Strip casinos. emreogan Casinos on the Las Vegas Strip are making changes to ... Read more »

Youth, community violence at forefront of Unity in the Community organizational team up

Ray Hall, Dream Tree Academy Director, standing from left, Julian Jackman, P.E.A.C.E. founder and director, Charles Stephenson, Powerhouse Community Development Corp. executive director and Lonnie Lockhart Bey, Destiny of Hope ... Read more »

Heat Book Team Flight to Denver Ahead of Game 7 vs. Celtics, per Report

Heat Book Team Flight to Denver Ahead of Game 7 vs. Celtics, per Report The Celtics and Heat will face each other in Game 7 of the Eastern Conference finals on Monday night to ... Read more »

Faces of volunteers: They provide more than donations and shelter to migrants in Chicago. They give love.

Susie Moya, right, a licensed clinical social worker and mental health therapist, speaks with a migrant woman about a support group for women she offers in a Pilsen shelter on ... Read more »

Fox Lake Police Fatally Shoot Man While Trying to Arrest Him, Injure Another Person

Police in suburban Fox Lake in fatally shot a man who lunged toward them with a knife when officers tried to arrest him, law enforcement officials said Monday. A woman ... Read more »

You’ve heard of an RV. Now, meet the $300K LV

(KTLA) – You’ve heard of an RV, but what about an LV? It stands for Living Vehicle, a company that makes luxury homes on wheels. “We’re nomadic, we aren’t … ... Read more »

Ruger SP101: The Perfect ‘Pocket Gun’ for Defending Your Home

Ruger SP101. Image Credit: Creative Commons. Ruger’s SP101 is a small, durable, and elegant-looking revolver that’s great for concealed carry, personal defense, or even home defense. It’s available in a ... Read more »

Some SacRT stations won’t be taking passengers during construction. Here’s where and when

One of Sacramento Regional Transit’s new low-floor trains is demonstrated to the media at SacRT’s heavy rail facility on Wednesday, May 3, 2023. SacRT has purchased 28 of the new ... Read more »

Summer is here, Chicago: Our guide to movies, music, TV, theater and more

Eugene and Linda Lamie, of Homerville, Ga., sit by the grave of their son U.S. Army Sgt. Gene Lamie in Section 60 at Arlington National Cemetery on Memorial Day, Monday, ... Read more »

The First Pokémon Movie's Dub Explained One Element The Original Didn't

The first Pokémon movie saw a lot of changes when it was dubbed, cutting out many things while simultaneously creating new scenes that didn’t previously exist. The film even saw ... Read more »

Bear trapped inside car freed by police in Nevada

The Washoe County Sheriff’s Office has warned people to be mindful of leaving food, food wrappers, and garbage inside cars. Read more »

Stephen King Endorses One Of The Greatest TV Shows Of All Time (15 Years After It Ended)

Stephen King takes to Twitter to endorse The Wire 15 years after it ended. King is one of the most prolific authors of all time whose works have been a ... Read more »

Johnny Depp Fractures Ankle, Delaying Hollywood Vampires US Tour Dates

Johnny Depp Fractures Ankle, Delaying Hollywood Vampires US Tour Dates Johnny Depp has suffered a “painful” ankle fracture, the actor and his band Hollywood Vampires revealed on Instagram Monday. In ... Read more »

How 'lack of competition' and 'the decline of independent grocers' jacked up food prices: columnist

Image via Creative Commons. MAGA Republicans and right-wing media outlets have had a lot to say about inflation, often claiming that President Joe Biden’s economic policies are to blame. But ... Read more »

Bread & Fred Is the Ultimate Divorce ‘Em Up – Frostbyte

Bread & Fred Is the Ultimate Divorce ‘Em Up – Frostbyte In his new Frostbyte video series, Sebastian Ruiz, aka Frost, talks about how Bread & Fred from Sand Castles ... Read more »

Xfinity Series race at Charlotte postponed by lingering rain

Xfinity Series race at Charlotte postponed by lingering rain CONCORD, N.C. — Persistent rain has forced the postponement of Monday’s NASCAR Xfinity Series race at Charlotte Motor Speedway. Ty Gibbs is ... Read more »

Weekly Horoscope: May 28 - June 3

Prepare yourselves for this weekly horoscope! This week’s cosmic energy is helping us move towards a more enlightened state of being. We can see things with an open mind and ... Read more »

'You are impossible to underestimate': 30+ Backhanded compliments and insults in disguise

These people shared their favorite “insults that don’t sound like insults,” and it’s giving us some great ideas! There’s no need to be mean when you can just be honest. ... Read more »

Gamers Are Divided Over Spider-Man 2's Symbiote Suit

Gamers Are Divided Over Spider-Man 2’s Symbiote Suit Spider-Man and controversial costumes go hand-in-hand. A couple of years ago, the comics unveiled a blue, white, and orange suit to a ... Read more »

Walmart employees are inundating the company's social-media site with memes making fun of management

One million Walmart workers, or more than half the retailer’s US employee base, have signed up for Workplace. Chris Hondros/Getty Images Walmart started using Workplace, a Meta-designed social-media app, in ... Read more »

How to keep your business moving forward: Tips from experts on managing inflation

How to keep your business moving forward: Tips from experts on managing inflation NEXT AVENUE This article is reprinted by permission from NextAvenue.org. A recent survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of New ... Read more »

Ukraine says it shot down 36 drones in overnight Russian attacks

Russian drone strike in Kyiv KYIV (Reuters) – Ukraine said on Thursday it had shot down all 36 Iranian-made drones launched by Russia in overnight attacks which it said probably ... Read more »

Nine (completely free) ways to save money on your energy bills

Nine (completely free) ways to save money on your energy bills You can hardly move these days for energy-saving hacks, regardless of how helpful they actually are. In the chaos ... Read more »

Apple could take its iPhone chips to the next level with huge 5G investment

null Future iPhones could get a big boost from Apple’s new investment into 5G components, which could see the tech giant make a single chip for cellular, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth ... Read more »

DJ Moore Finding Fit with Bears Easy to Make

Bears wide receiver DJ Moore might be planning a position switch. At least, he’s sort of fantasizing about one after seeing how he fits into the Halas Hall scene. It ... Read more »

Costco Is Offering $2,500 Off EVs Right Now

Prashanth Bala / Shutterstock.com Costco members shopping for an electric vehicle can save a little extra money on their purchase through July 31. Incentives of $2,500 now are available on ... Read more »

Arne Slot rules himself out of Tottenham job to stay at Feyenoord

Arne Slot will not be Tottenham’s next manager after confirming he will stay at Feyenoord. The Dutchman, who led the club to their first league title in five years this ... Read more »

Cubs Farm Report: Top Prospects Heating Up

The Chicago Cubs minor league system seems to be mirroring their Major League parent club.  Its farm system went 6-0  on Saturday, 0-4 on Sunday, and 4-0 on Tuesday. If ... Read more »

This Live Map Shows Exactly Where Sharks Are Roaming In The Ocean

This Live Map Shows Exactly Where Sharks Are Roaming In The Ocean In general, people have a lot of misunderstandings about sharks, and it makes sense. Most of us only ... Read more »

German economy minister's office receives envelope with white powder

FILE PHOTO: Plenum session of the lower house of parliament, Bundestag, in Berlin BERLIN (Reuters) -German Economy Minister Robert Habeck’s constituency office said on Thursday it had received an envelope ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự