Not job of court to declare Hindus minority, says Supreme Court

not job of court to declare hindus minority, says supreme court

It is not the job of a court to declare Hindus a minority in states where they are outnumbered by other communities, the Supreme Court observed on Monday (HT File)

It is not the job of a court to declare Hindus a minority in states where they are outnumbered by other communities, the Supreme Court observed on Monday, pointing out that the determination of minority status depends on several empirical factors and statistics because of which the exercise is outside the judicial domain.

According to a bench of justices Uday U Lalit and S Ravindra Bhat, the top court cannot issue a generic directive declaring Hindus a minority in states without authentic materials on record.

“It is not the job of the court to declare minorities…This has to be on a case-by-case basis. There cannot be a general declaration to declare Hindus as minority unless you show us something concrete about denial of rights,” the bench told advocate Ashwini Upadhyay, who was appearing for petitioner Devkinandan Thakur Ji.

The public interest litigation, filed in June, has challenged the provision of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) Act, 1992 and NCM Educational Institutions (NCMEI) Act, 2004 that restrict certain benefits and rights available for minorities, including the right to establish and administer institutions, to six notified communities – Christians, Muslims, Sikhs, Buddhists, Parsis and Jains.

On Monday, the bench told Upadhyay that there have been judgments by the top court since 1957 that laid down that minority status for religious and linguistic minorities has to be ascertained by state.

“The issue has gone by since 1957 (Re: Kerala Education Bill Case) when the Supreme Court said it has to be done state-wise. Why should we say or clarify anything now? The problem is that you want to make out a case when there is none,” it told Upadhyay. In the 1957 verdict, the top court held that the minority must be determined with regard to the whole population of the state.

The court added: “If you give us examples where Hindus are in minority and some directions are required, we may perhaps look at that. But you are asking for a general direction to declare Hindus as minority in some states. Why should we do that? We cannot declare any community as a minority because we don’t have the statistics of different states or other facts.”

Regarding a prayer in the PIL on declaration of minority status on a district level, the bench made it clear that such a plea is not proper. “…It can’t be on a district level. This will be contrary to the law and the 11-judge bench decision (in TMA Pai case),” it said. In the 2002 TMA Pai case, the top court, while dealing with the right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice, held that the unit for determining status of both linguistic and religious minorities would be the state.

At this point, Upadhyay requested the bench to tag Thakur Ji’s PIL with another case already pending before a different bench of the Supreme Court. In that case, Upadhyay himself is the petitioner. As Upadhyay submitted that the matter before the other bench is expected to come up on August 30, the bench listed Thakur Ji’s plea in the first week of September along with the other PIL.

The petition filed by Upadhyay is currently pending before a bench headed by justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul. In that plea, Upadhyay has challenged the validity of Section 2(f) of the NCMEI Act on grounds that it gives unbridled powers to the Centre to restrict minority benefits to the notified six religious communities.

It stated that Hindus are merely 1% in Ladakh, 2.75% in Mizoram, 2.77% in Lakshadweep, 4% in Jammu and Kashmir, 8.74% in Nagaland, 11.52% in Meghalaya, 29% in Arunachal Pradesh, 38.49% in Punjab, and 41.29% in Manipur. Upadhyay’s plea has also questioned the creation of the NMC (National Minorities Commission) and the Minority Education Commission, arguing that the Centre created these institutions to “divide and rule”.

By an order in May, justice Kaul’s bench allowed the Centre time till August 30 to consult stakeholders and submit a report on whether minority status could be given to Hindus based on their population within a state.

The court order on May 10 came after the Union government said it would initiate a “wide consultation” with states and other stakeholders to examine whether Hindus can be granted minority status in states where their numbers are less than those of other communities.

The government sought time for deliberation while withdrawing its previous stand in March when the Centre sought dismissal of Upadhyay’s writ petition and defended the 1992 NCM Act and the 2004 NCMEI Act.

In its first affidavit filed in March, the central government put the onus on states and Union territories (UTs) to take a call on whether or not to grant minority status to Hindus where they are numerically less, adding that both the Centre and states have the legislative competence to enact laws on the protection of minorities.

However, withdrawing its previous affidavit in May, the government conceded that the question involved in the petition has far-reaching ramifications throughout the country and, therefore, any stand taken without detailed deliberations with the stakeholders may result in an unintended complication for the country.

The May affidavit underlined that although the power is vested with the central government to notify minorities, the stand to be formulated by the Centre with regard to issues raised in the batch of petitions on the issue will be finalised after having a wide consultation with the state governments and other stakeholders.

Sign on to read the HT ePaper epaper.hindustantimes.com

News Related

OTHER NEWS

All inside photos and videos from Richa Chadha and Ali Fazal's wedding reception

All inside photos and videos from Richa Chadha and Ali Fazal's wedding reception Bollywood stars Richa Chadha and Ali Fazal made their relationship official as they exchanged rings and got ... Read more »

Hat-trick of assists for Di Maria as inspired Juventus beat Maccabi to kick-start Champions League campaign

hat-trick of assists for di maria as inspired juventus beat maccabi to kick-start champions league campaign Juventus got off the mark in the Champions League with Wednesday’s 3-1 win over ... Read more »

Sailana: Student kills self after alleged torture by teacher

Sailana (Madhya Pradesh): Reportedly depressed due to continuous harassment and alleged torture by a school teacher, a class 7 student who was studying at a private school in Sailana tehsil ... Read more »

ISL all set to kick off with more excitement than ever

ISL all set to kick off with more excitement than ever All set to return this Friday, Indian Super League (ISL) is poised to be bigger and more exciting than ... Read more »

Donald Trump asks Supreme Court to intervene in Mar-a-Lago dispute

Former President Donald Trump listens to applause from the crowd as he steps up to the podium at a rally Friday, Sept. 23, 2022, in Wilmington. (File photo: AP) Lawyers ... Read more »

Vikram Vedha box office collection day 5: Hrithik Roshan, Saif Ali Khan starrer holding very well on weekdays; crosses a half century

Vikram Vedha box office collection day 5: Hrithik Roshan, Saif Ali Khan starrer holding very well on weekdays; crosses a half century Finally, Vikram Vedha looks to be putting on ... Read more »

‘Giving me gyaan but came begging after 2014 Lok Sabha polls loss’: Prashant Kishor’s fresh jibe on Nitish Kumar

‘Giving me gyaan but came begging after 2014 Lok Sabha polls loss’: Prashant Kishor’s fresh jibe on Nitish Kumar Just a few days after launching his own padyatra in Bihar ... Read more »

Joe Biden surveys Hurricane Ian damage in Florida, pledges federal aid

Joe Biden surveys Hurricane Ian damage in Florida, pledges federal aid United States President Joe Biden travelled to Florida on Wednesday to take account of the situation in the aftermath ... Read more »

'Not fitted into any role': Ajay Jadeja reveals the reason behind Rishabh Pant's inability to deliver in T20Is

‘not fitted into any role’: ajay jadeja reveals the reason behind rishabh pant’s inability to deliver in t20is Star Indian wicketkeeper-batter Rishabh Pant has played a total of 62 T20Is ... Read more »

Saif Ali Khan reveals his dream role would be in Mahabharata: ‘If it’s made like Lord of The Rings…’

Saif Ali Khan reveals his dream role would be in Mahabharata: ‘If it’s made like Lord of The Rings…’ Actor Saif Ali Khan has revealed that while he doesn’t quite ... Read more »

Mandana Karimi decides to quit Bollywood after Sajid Khan joins Bigg Boss 16: There is no respect for women

mandana karimi decides to quit bollywood after sajid khan joins bigg boss 16: there is no respect for women Sajid Khan’s participation in Salman Khan-hosted Bigg Boss 16 has raised ... Read more »

Search for new Earths should look for ‘pale yellow dots,’ not blue: Research

Search for new Earths should look for ‘pale yellow dots,’ not blue: Research New research suggests that the search for Earth-like worlds should look for dry, cold “pale yellow dots” ... Read more »

Dawood Ibrahim aide Riyaz Bhati taken into custody for extorting ‘Badshah Khan’, approver in 1993 Mumbai blasts case

Dawood Ibrahim aide Riyaz Bhati taken into custody for extorting ‘Badshah Khan’, approver in 1993 Mumbai blasts case One the two approvers in the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts case, popularly ... Read more »

NASA-hit asteroid leaves 10,000 kilometre-long trail of debris

NASA-hit asteroid leaves 10,000 kilometre-long trail of debris An asteroid Dimorphos was hit by NASA’s DART (Double Asteroid Redirection Test) spacecraft on September 27. A huge trail of dust and ... Read more »

'Sar tan se juda' themed Ravan effigy burned in Lucknow Ramlila

An effigy of Ravan on the theme of ‘sar tan se juda’ Aishbagh Ram Leela Committee, the oldest Ramlila organisers in Lucknow, have built an effigy of Ravan this year ... Read more »

Real Madrid's samba stars see them past Shakhtar despite Benzema's finishing woes

Rodrygo Vinicius Junior Real Madrid 2022-23 Rodrygo struck from outside the box to open scoring Vinicius Jr finished off brilliant team move Zubkov halved the deficit with acrobatic effort WHAT ... Read more »

California: Four of Indian family missing, kidnapper in custody

California: Four of Indian family missing, kidnapper in custody A suspect in California was taken into custody for allegedly kidnapping four of a Sikh family, including an eight-month-baby, who are ... Read more »

Sonu Sood takes a ride on a Mumbai local train, shares stories from his struggling days

Sonu Sood takes a ride on a Mumbai local train, shares stories from his struggling days Words fall short while describing the philanthropic activities of Sonu Sood. And behind that ... Read more »

India registers decline in female infant mortality rate: Smriti Irani

India registers decline in female infant mortality rate: Smriti Irani India’s Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani has said that the nation has registered a decline in the female ... Read more »

UK ends standoff with EU as Northern Ireland Brexit deal nears resolution

UK ends standoff with EU as Northern Ireland Brexit deal nears resolution The dispute over the Northern Ireland Brexit arrangements seems to be coming to an end finally as the ... Read more »

TRS is now Bharat Rashtra Samithi: Will KCR's name-change gamble pay off?

TRS is now Bharat Rashtra Samithi: Will KCR’s name-change gamble pay off? New Delhi: Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrashekar Rao’s attempt to catapult his party TRS to the centre stage ... Read more »

Honda City, Amaze, Jazz, WR-V: Offers up to Rs 39,300 in October

Honda City Amid strong festive demand, Honda Cars India saw its wholesale despatches rising 29% year-on-year to 8,714 units in September from 6,765 units in the year-ago month. However, the ... Read more »

Zontes 350T: What else can you buy

Zontes India recently launched the 350T in India. It’s priced at Rs 3.37 lakh (ex-showroom Delhi) and is one of the two ADV offerings from the entrant. That said, there ... Read more »

Threat call to Ambanis: Mumbai police begin probe

Threat call to Ambanis: Mumbai police begin probe THE MUMBAI police have initiated an investigation to locate an unknown person who allegedly dialled the landline number of Sir H N ... Read more »

Dussehra 2022: 7 facts about Dussehra you did not know

Dussehra 2022: 7 facts about Dussehra you did not know Dussehra 2022: Dussehra, also known as Vijayadashami, is a Hindu festival celebrated on the tenth day of the Ashvin month. ... Read more »

Tamil actor Lokesh Rajendran dies by suicide

Trigger Warning Content Warning: This article contains references to suicide. Tamil television actor Lokesh Rajendran, best known for his work as a child artist in the popular serial Marmadesam or ... Read more »

Princess Anne rides the Staten Island Ferry during a visit to the states following Queen Elizabeth's death

Princess Anne rides the Staten Island Ferry during a visit to the states following Queen Elizabeth’s death On Tuesday, Princess Anne rode the iconic Staten Island Ferry during her trip ... Read more »

Carlos Alcaraz loses incredible 62-match streak as he fails to win first match as No 1

Carlos Alcaraz crashed out of the Astana Open Carlos Alcaraz suffered his first straight-sets defeat in 11 months as he crashed out in the first round of the Astana Open. ... Read more »

Nikhil Siddhartha Shines In Karthikeya 2 As The Plot Ties Dwapar Yug To The Contemporary World

Nikhil Siddhartha Shines In Karthikeya 2 As The Plot Ties Dwapar Yug To The Contemporary World Poster Are you someone who enjoys watching fantasy films? If the answer is yes ... Read more »

'He is my favourite': Uddhav Thackeray's brother extends support to Eknath Shinde at Dussehra rally

‘He is my favourite’: Uddhav Thackeray’s brother extends support to Eknath Shinde at Dussehra rally Jaidev Thackeray, the elder brother of Shiv Sena chief Uddhav Thackeray, shared the stage with ... Read more »

Why Bhagwat brought up East Timor, South Sudan & Kosovo in speech about ‘population imbalance’

Why Bhagwat brought up East Timor, South Sudan & Kosovo in speech about ‘population imbalance’ New Delhi: In his annual Vijayadashmi speech in Nagpur, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh chief Mohan Bhagwat ... Read more »

A Definitive Guide to the 13 Most Haunted Hotels in the US

Story Inn Fall is in the air, trees are dying a beautiful death, decorative gourds have descended on doorsteps en masse and pumpkin spice has clenched its vice grip on ... Read more »

Nothing ear (stick) earbuds to be revealed on October 26, 2nd product of 2022 after Nothing Phone (1)

Nothing ear (stick) earbuds to be revealed on October 26, 2nd product of 2022 after Nothing Phone (1) Nothing has been one of the most talked-about smartphone manufacturers of 2022. ... Read more »

CBSE Board Exams 2023: All you need to know about datesheet, sample papers, exam pattern

CBSE Board Exams 2023: All you need to know about datesheet, sample papers, exam pattern CBSE Board Exam 2023 Class 10th 12th Updates:  The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) ... Read more »

Union home minister Amit Shah gets bulletproof shield removed at Baramulla rally, meets slain cop’s family in Uri

Union home minister Amit Shah gets bulletproof shield removed at Baramulla rally, meets slain cop’s family in Uri SRINAGAR: Union home minister Amit Shah got the bulletproof shield removed before ... Read more »

IND vs SA: After India's 49-run Loss, 'A Dash of Laughter' Between Rohit Sharma, Dinesh Karthik | WATCH

IND vs SA: After India’s 49-run Loss, ‘A Dash of Laughter’ Between Rohit Sharma, Dinesh Karthik | WATCH The camaraderie between Rohit Sharma and Dinesh Karthik is known to all. ... Read more »

Jose Mourinho vindicates Edu's decisive £45m Arsenal decision that elevated Mikel Arteta rebuild

Jose Mourinho vindicates Arsenal’s decision to sign Gabriel Jesus. Edu has been heavily criticised in the past for his transfer market activity as Arsenal’s technical director since taking over in ... Read more »

Watch LIVE | SpaceX launches Crew-5 mission with Russian cosmonaut to space

SpaceX Falcon 9 SpaceX is set to launch four astronauts to the International Space Station as part of the Crew-5 mission. This is the first time that the Elon Musk-led ... Read more »

Airtel plans wireless broadband services with 5G technology

“Today, if you are in a remote area, the only access you have is to use a dongle with 4G. We will make a significant amount of shift in making ... Read more »

World Teachers’ Day 2022: Over 4,500 faculty posts vacant across IITs, Kharagpur tops the list

The Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) — country’s premier technology schools — together have over 4,500 faculty positions vacant, according to government data. Of the 23 IITs, IIT Kharagpur has ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network