Not Even Ariana Grande Can Save ‘The Voice'

On Monday night, The Voice welcomed its latest coach and one of the most high-profile artists the singing competition has managed to acquire in its 10-year run, Ariana Grande. Over the course of the two-hour premiere, the “Positions” singer was greeted with as much fanfare and lip service from the contestants and her fellow coaches as one would expect, first stealing the spotlight in a group performance of Aretha Franklin’s “Respect” and remaining the center of her colleagues’ stale comedic banter throughout the show. The pop superstar even received a “thank u, next” button on her rotating chair.

© Provided by The Daily Beast NBC

Since its inception, the NBC reality-competition program has always put its celebrities front and center, taking cues from American Idol in its later seasons and promoting its star power and coach dynamics above the amateur talent. But the announcement of Grande on The Voice felt slightly more urgent and tactical, particularly since the recent departure of one of the show’s inaugural coaches Adam Levine, who had more mainstream hits and relevancy amongst a younger, more female crowd as compared to artists like Blake Shelton, Jennifer Hudson, John Legend or even Gwen Stefani in the on-and-off years she’s coached. As with the addition of Miley Cyrus in 2016 and Nick Jonas last year, The Voice seems to be making another desperate bid for younger millennials’ and Gen Z’s attention, as the show’s viewership has increasingly skewed older like most network television in the streaming era. But while Grande and her legion of Arianators will most likely make some kind of impact in this department, the charismatic, astute coach still can’t save the show from itself.

It becomes clear thirty minutes into Season 21’s premiere that The Voice will always be a protracted celebrity meet-and-greet, first and foremost. While judges for more cutthroat competitions like American Idol and The X Factor have historically been less approachable and more daunting—they purposely hold the position of judges, not coaches after all—The Voice has always presented its stars as the most caring and good-natured people in the industry, suggesting that you actually should meet your heroes and even feel safe enough in their presence to be the most vulnerable version of yourself. During a time when cruelty on reality-competition shows is phasing out, this #positivevibes ethos has worked in the show’s favor and even inspired American Idol to eliminate “bad” auditions.

More insidiously though, The Voice has successfully cashed in on viewers’—including the fame-hungry musicians that audition for the show—naive presumptions about celebrities, their supposed magic and the overestimated power of our proximity to them in favor of tangible outcomes for these immensely gifted competitors who deserve better than hyperbolic compliments from Kelly Clarkson and promised Instagram exposure from Grande.

In the years that The Voice has become a broadcast television mainstay, much has been said of the competition’s glaring dilemma: its inability to produce successful or, at the very least, recognizable artists. Every once in a while on Twitter, usually around the time the show is gearing up for a new season, you’ll see a viral tweet pointing this out, challenging social media to name just one winner or comparing the show’s lack of care and attentiveness for its contestants to its Fox predecessor. That being said, measuring the achievements of these two shows and how they did or didn’t live up to their conceits solely on the basis that they’re both televised singing contests is a bit reductive and ignores how crucial social media and streaming have become in how stars are discovered and manufactured, where the public’s attention is drawn, and how fans mobilize (not to mention how oversaturated the music industry is compared to when American Idol premiered in 2002).

But according to The Voice contestants and even some of the judges, NBC has dropped the ball on its winners even before they have a real opportunity to see how they might fare against the Shawn Mendes’s and Billie Eilish’s of the world. In 2018, HuffPost reported on the post-competition careers of series’ winners. While Cassadee Pope, formerly of the already well-known pop punk band Hey Monday, stands out as someone who’s noticeably thrived after her experience and garnered several country hits, past winners such as Alisan Porter, Tessanne Chin, Craig Wayne Boyd, Javier Colon and Sawyer Fredericks were either dropped by the Universal Music Group (The Voice’s prizes are $100,000 and a record deal with Universal Music Group or its subsidiary Big Machine Records, which are both part of NBCUniversal) or left on their own because of neglect. Winners Jordan Smith and Danielle Bradbery have found niche fame in the genres of Christian and country, but their marginal popularity still pales in comparison to what we’ve seen reality TV alumni achieve, from Clarkson and Oscar winner Jennifer Hudson to the men of One Direction.

The judges have said as much. Levine previously voiced his frustration about the mismanagement of the show’s winners on Howard Stern’s radio show in 2015. And the following year, Blake Shelton echoed the same sentiment at a press conference after the season 11 finale, which a singer on his team, Sundance Head, won. Clarkson held the opinion in the aforementioned HuffPost article that the show doesn’t promise superstardom and underscored the value of seizing opportunities and “meet[ing] as many people as you can.” This is the response, although not sufficient in addressing NBC’s organizational issues, that’s probably the most in line with the show’s overall message of meritocracy despite the fact that the judges will often recklessly promise that they alone can transform the competitors into stars.

Which is why, during the premiere, when Grande mentioned her mammoth follower count on Instagram while convincing contestant Wendy Moten to join her team, it felt like the show inadvertently exposed the realities of modern fame that prevent a show of this format, on top of other structural issues, from ever truly working. Moten can sing her heart out before all of America week-to-week, fighting for her place in a competition that probably won’t reward her properly, or as easily as Grande can give her a shout-out on Instagram with a more guaranteed outcome. A new chart-topping star on the coach roster may bring the mega-watt star power and some occasionally funny moments, but The Voice can’t obscure its empty promises.

Read more at The Daily Beast.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness First Drive Review: An Off-Roadable Daily

The 2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness you see in the photo above is dusty and muddy after an afternoon of trawling through a national forest, as it should be. One of ... Read more »

Saudi crown prince boasted 'he could kill' King Abdullah: ex-official

A former senior Saudi security official has made a startling claim in an interview with “60 Minutes” that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman “boasted that he could kill” late ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian Announces SKIMs x Fendi Ready-to-Wear Collection

From the comfort of your bedroom to the runway — and back. © Provided by People Annemarieke van Drimmelen for WSJ. Magazine Kim Kardashian West and Kim Jones Kim Kardashian ... Read more »

Israel court rules cable car crash survivor be returned to family in Italy

An Israeli court ruled Monday that a boy whose parents died in an Italian cable car crash be returned to family in Italy, after his grandfather was accused of illegally ... Read more »

The future of world trade depends on US leadership

The fate of the world’s leading trade institution hangs in the balance. The World Trade Organization (WTO) has been in a state of sustained, low-burning crisis for nearly five years. ... Read more »

The Daily Sweat: Seahawks try to rally around Geno Smith vs. Saints

The Seattle Seahawks have never been bad the past 10 seasons. Starting in 2012, they’ve never posted a losing season.  They also had Russell Wilson that whole time.  Seattle is ... Read more »

Patrick Mahomes: It's been rainbows and flowers, but we have to go through times like these as well

© Provided by NBC Sports A humbling start to the 2021 season continued for the Chiefs on Sunday. Patrick Mahomes turned the ball over twice and the Chiefs failed to ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin was very careful with prop guns prior to 'Rust' accident according to camera operator

Alec Baldwin was reportedly very careful with firearms on the set of “Rust” prior to the accidental shooting incident that left cinematographer Halyna Hutchins dead and director Joel Souza wounded.  ... Read more »

These 6 bestselling fall solutions will help you make the most of the season

This article is sponsored by Amazon. Our editors independently selected these deals and items because we think you’ll enjoy them at these prices. If you purchase something through our links, ... Read more »

Abducted cable car crash boy to be returned to Italy

A six-year-old Israeli boy who was the sole survivor of an Italian cable car crash must be returned to family in Italy, a court has ruled. © Getty Images Eitan ... Read more »

Our Favorite Video Game Systems (And Games) to Play Right Now

© Joe Lingeman It’s all in the grip. Human society has progressed to the point of placing every aspect of modern life — friendship, finance, politics, health, sex, restaurant-quality cuisine, ... Read more »

Record-breaking "bomb cyclone" floods parts of Northern California

California woke up today to some of its worst weather in years. © CBS News rockslide-california.jpg Forecasters call it a “bomb cyclone” that’s already blasted the Pacific Northwest, killing two ... Read more »

Heisman Trophy watch: Updated odds, top candidates to win 2021 award

In 2019, Joe Burrow opened the season with 200-1 odds to win the Heisman Trophy. In 2020, Alabama’s DeVonta Smith became the first receiver to win the award since 1991. ... Read more »

Grizzlies' Ja Morant shares great message after missing clutch free throw

Ja Morant was the best player on the floor in Sunday night’s game between the Memphis Grizzlies and Los Angeles Lakers, but it was a shot he missed that generated ... Read more »

Giants defense wanted to put the team on its back against Panthers

© Provided by NBC Sports The Giants came into the 2021 season feeling more confident about their defense than their offense, but the unit was a disappointment through the first ... Read more »

Biden's, Grisham's energy policies impacting New Mexico political landscape

In the 2020 election, U.S. Rep. Xochitl Torres Small, D-New Mexico, lost to Republican Yvette Herrell in a district whose residents are reliant on oil and gas for survival. Despite ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin practiced on bench with weapon during fatal shooting incident

Souza was standing behind Hutchins when Baldwin fired. The actor sat on a bench in a church where filming was taking place at the time and practiced pulling the weapon ... Read more »

Everything you need to know about the WNBA offseason: Free agents, Sue Bird-Diana Taurasi decisions, more

The dust has settled on the Chicago Sky’s unprecedented run to the championship, and the 25th anniversary season of the WNBA has come to a close.  Now, it’s time to ... Read more »

African players in Europe: Salah's historic Old Trafford hat-trick

Prolific Liverpool scorer Mohamed Salah became the first away player to net a Premier League hat-trick at Old Trafford as he starred in a 5-0 humiliation of Manchester United. © ... Read more »

How to Hide Your Level in Valorant

Riot Games has added a feature to Valorant that lets players hide their account level. Here’s what you need to know. Valorant received a feature in Patch 3.0 which showcased ... Read more »

Thune endorses Herschel Walker in Georgia Senate race

Senate Minority Whip John Thune (R-S.D.) on Monday endorsed Herschel Walker’s bid to oust Sen. Raphael Warnock (D-Ga.) in the latest sign that GOP leaders are warming up to the ... Read more »

PHT Morning Skate: Golden Knights' struggles; Penguins' depth succeeding

Welcome to the PHT Morning Skate, a collection of links from the NHL and around the hockey world. Have a link you want to submit? Email us at phtblog@nbcsports. © Provided ... Read more »

Chaos in Sudan as ‘Deeply Alarming' Military Coup Jolts a Fragile Transition to Democracy

The tenuous peace that has kept Sudan on edge since a failed military coup attempt in September has been shattered. © Provided by The Daily Beast Mohamed Nureldin Abdallah via ... Read more »

Old West in a new light: Amon Carter Museum builds show around Thomas Moran watercolor

FORT WORTH — You can argue that the United States of myth was born not in 1776, but in the middle of the 19th century. It was the age of ... Read more »

How the Next Generation of Art Collectors Is Making Its Mark

From paintings and photographs to film and fashion, art is a fully sensory form of storytelling — and the best of it doesn’t just make us feel something; it says ... Read more »

You Can Always Get What You Want? Mick Jagger Has 2 Juicy (Jucy) Lucys Before Concert

MINNEAPOLIS (WCCO) — The Rolling Stones were live in concert downtown Minneapolis last night, after a year-long delay. The concert was not quite a sellout but it was still a ... Read more »

Midlake Announce First Album in 8 Years, Share Song: Listen

© Midlake (Photo by Barbara FG) Texas group Midlake are back with their first new music since 2013. They’ve shared a song titled “Meanwhile…,” the first track from their next ... Read more »

'Curb Your Enthusiasm' returns with Albert Brooks, Jon Hamm and Purell hoarding

Spoiler alert! The following contains details from the Season 11 premiere of “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” “The Five-Foot Fence.” The “spite store” has been replaced by the “plop” and the pandemic ... Read more »

'Most wanted man in country' coming to Rupp Arena in early December

Oct. 25—Country music’s newest superstar Morgan Wallen will be hosting a concert with HARDY and ERNEST at Rupp Arena on Dec. 4. Tickets for the show go on sale this ... Read more »

The FDA is weighing in on whether to authorize Pfizer's COVID-19 vaccine in younger kids

© ORLANDO SIERRA / AFP) (Photo by ORLANDO SIERRA/AFP/Getty Images The Food and Drug Administration is considering authorizing the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine for 5- to 11-year-olds. ORLANDO SIERRA / AFP) (Photo ... Read more »

Today's mortgage rates go up: Here's what that means

A few notable mortgage rates climbed today. The average interest rates for both 15-year fixed and 30-year fixed mortgages both grew. At the same time, average rates for 5/1 adjustable-rate ... Read more »

A man fraudulently received COVID relief funds. Then he spent $57,000 on a Pokémon card.

A Georgia man faces a charge of wire fraud after federal prosecutors say he spent over $57,000 he received from COVID-19 relief funds on something not for his business – a ... Read more »

Ranking the Braves' worst 21st-century postseason exits as they finally reach World Series

The Atlanta Braves exorcised a whole lot of 21st-century ghosts on Saturday night. The Braves had led the Los Angeles Dodgers three games to one in the 2021 National League ... Read more »

NHL Rink Wrap: Lucas Raymond shines for Red Wings; Another shutout for Sorokin

© Provided by NBC Sports Top player from Sunday in the NHL Lucas Raymond, Detroit Red Wings The Detroit Red Wings kept Chicago out of the win column on Sunday ... Read more »

Here are mortgage rates for Oct. 25, 2021: Rates move up

© Provided by CNET Jim Lane/Getty A few notable mortgage rates climbed higher today. The average interest rates for both 15-year fixed and 30-year fixed mortgages both grew. At the ... Read more »

To ensure equality for all, Senate must end filibuster

© Greg Nash The U.S. Capitol is seen from the East Front Plaza on Tuesday, October 12, 2021. On Nov. 3, 2020, Americans went to the polls in record numbers ... Read more »

Boris Johnson says chances of Cop26 success are ‘touch and go'

Boris Johnson has admitted Britain could fail to broker adequate enough deals to curb irreversible and devastating climate change at the global summit of world leaders beginning in Scotland later ... Read more »

Wave of Cyber Attacks Hitting American Companies, Microsoft Warns

Hundreds of companies and organizations have been hit by an attack on Microsoft’s computer systems. © Motortion/Getty Images Microsoft has accused the Russian group thought responsible for last year’s SolarWinds ... Read more »

Manchester United humiliated as Solskjaer nears end

© Provided by NBC Sports MANCHESTER — Certain wins and defeats are career defining and the embarrassing loss to bitter rivals Liverpool felt like this for Manchester United and Ole ... Read more »

Notes and stats from the Buccaneers 38-3 win over the Bears

– The Buccaneers defeated the Bears 38-3, moving to 6-1 on the season – the team’s best start through seven games in franchise history. © Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic