No single best choice for currency in independent Scotland, think tank says

The Government in an independent Scotland could have to consider either tax rises or spending cuts “before too long” no matter which currency option was adopted after the leaving the UK, a think tank has warned.

The Institute for Government published new reports looking at the currency and borrowing options that could be available, should Scotland become independent.

But the paper on currency stated: “Whichever currency option an independent Scotland adopted, before too long it would probably have to run tighter fiscal policy than the position that Scotland would be likely to inherit on day one.”

This “tighter fiscal policy” could potentially mean spending cuts, tax rises, or both.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon wants Scots to have another independence referendum before the end of 2023 (Andy Buchanan/PA)

While the think-tank identified several potential options for currency in an independent Scotland, it ruled out a formal currency union with the UK – which the SNP had proposed in advance of the 2014 referendum – on the basis that the UK Government would not agree to it.

It also ruled out immediately joining the euro, adding that this would “only be possible only in the medium term – once Scotland had jumped through the necessary hoops” of re-entering the European Union and then meeting the necessary conditions for membership of the eurozone.

The think-tank concluded that “using sterling informally maybe the most attractive option at the very start”.

This fits with current SNP policy, which is that Scotland would retain the pound after independence, before seeking to establish its own currency.

The report added: “Once an independent Scotland had established its reputation for prudent fiscal policy and a commitment to low and stable inflation – and had time to build foreign exchange reserves – the attractions of issuing a new currency would probably increase.”

It went on to say that under such conditions a new currency “would be likely to be less volatile”.

The Institute for Government also claimed leaving the UK could “constrain Scotland’s fiscal policy because there would be limits on how much it could borrow year after year”.

And it warned that “Scottish debt interest costs would probably exceed rates that the UK could borrow at if Scotland remained in the union”.

Even in the the current low interest rate environment, the think tank estimated that “Scotland’s borrowing costs would be 0.4–0.9 percentage points higher than UK rates”.

Gemma Tetlow, chief economist at the Institute for Government and author of the report on Scotland’s currency options, said: “Scotland’s currency choice would have far wider implications than just the cash people use in their day-to-day lives – including implications for financial stability, what freedom the Government has to use monetary and fiscal policy, how easily businesses can trade with other countries, and the attractiveness of Scotland to foreign investors.

“There is no single best choice, all options would come with trade-offs.”

The papers have been published following confirmation from Nicola Sturgeon, the Scottish First Minister and SNP leader, that the Scottish Government is restarting work on a “detailed prospectus” for independence.

Ms Sturgeon has already said she wants to hold another vote on the future of the UK by the end of 2023, assuming it is safe to do so amidst the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

Pamela Nash, chief executive of the pro-UK campaign group, Scotland in Union, said the reports showed the “astonishing risk and recklessness of the SNP’s plan to scrap the pound”.

She stated: “Introducing a new Scottish currency would have devastating consequences for our economy, with a knock-on impact on how much we can spend on hospitals, schools and social care services.

“When our NHS is in crisis and people are waiting hours for ambulances, and we have years of recovery ahead of us following Covid, this proves just how irresponsible the SNP’s separation blueprint really is.”

A Scottish Government spokesman said: “As the First Minister set out last week, work on a detailed prospectus is now being taken forward in line with the democratic mandate which has been secured for a referendum.

“The evidence shows that many independent countries of Scotland’s size have higher national incomes per head than the UK.

“Given Scotland’s resources and advantages, there is no reason an independent Scotland would not also be a successful economy – free of the damage of Brexit.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Grape-sized electric balloon could make irregular heartbeats a thing of the past by resetting the organ's electrical activity in seconds

Operation is set to be introduced in heart clinics following widespread approval  Roughly 1.4million Britons suffer with an irregular heartbeat – or atrial fibrillationDuring new treatment, balloon fitted with ten electrodes is inserted in the groin Surgeons inflate it and fire up electrodes to give precise bursts of extreme heat Read more »

Glamorous AFL WAG and model, 26, reveals she's battling thyroid cancer just a week after her wedding - as she explains why she broke the news with a picture of herself in hospital

Liv Cripps, 26, took to Instagram on Friday to share tragic cancer newsAFL WAG and model revealed she was diagnosed with cancer a few weeks agoThe 26-year-old has received influx of well-wishes and support from her friendsThe model just married West Coast Eagles star Jamie Cripps last Saturday  Read more »

Problem solved! Hilarious snaps reveal the VERY bizarre ways people have overcome everyday issues - from using a burning wheelbarrow to heat a paddling pool to a seatbelt fastening as a gate latch

Doc Journals rounded up photos from around the world of solutions to problemsAmong the snaps is a doorbell that only works when the wires are connectedAnother image shows a hole in a shoe being disguised using spray paint   Read more »

HEALTH NOTES: A third of motorists say they drive more dangerously in the winter, shows survey

A third of motorists say they drive more dangerously in the winter, according to a survey, blaming the dark, difficult weather conditions and being blinded by headlights. A quarter admitted ... Read more »

Another Bay Area In-N-Out is fined for failing to enforce COVID rules after the only San Francisco branch of popular burger chain was temporary closed down

An In-N-Out Burger in the Bay Area has been hit with fines for not enforcing COVID-19 rules just a week after a different California branch was sanctionedThe Pleasant Hill branch was fined a total of $750 for not checking vaccination cards of indoor customers by Contra Costa Health Department officials The Fisherman's Wharf location was shut down last Thursday and fined hundreds of dollars for similarly refusing to abide by COVID-19 vaccine mandatesThe San Francisco Health Department said the restaurant refused to carry out spot checks of customers' vaccine passes to enforce vaccine mandatesHealth inspectors had visited the restaurant - the only location in San Francisco - three times and saw violations of the health ordinance On Wednesday, a sign posted to the location's doors read 'in compliance with the city and county of San Francisco, indoor dining is unavailable at this time' In-N-Out chief legal officer said the chain refused to become 'vaccination police'  Read more »

Obese mother-of-one who tipped the scales at 19st 7lbs and feared losing her life to Covid-19 is unrecognisable after dropping 9st in EIGHT months

Rachel Walkingshaw-McGuinness, 30, from Newport, tipped scales at 19st 7lbsMother-of-one was terrified she would die if she were to catch Covid-19Lost 9st in eight months thanks to a strict diet plan she started in December She is now learning to love her new sized ten figure at 10st and 10lbs  Read more »

Health chiefs bump up threat of even more transmissible Delta off-shoot and admit almost 150,000 people could have caught it since it first emerged in London in June

UK Health Security Agency — which took over from PHE — today labelled AY.4.2 a 'variant under investigation'This is reserved for variants that may be more transmissible or jab resistant than other strains of thevirusScientists said the threat level was was raised because of rising cases and evidence it is more transmissible Read more »

Vogue Paris is in danger of 'losing its soul' as Anna Wintour is pushing 'American woke values' onto magazine which 'crushes elitist French spirit', insiders claim

Insiders at Vogue Paris have claimed to a French newspaper the magazine is 'losing its soul' as Dame Anna Wintour is 'pushing a woke American agenda' on itAccused of 'crushing the elitist spirit' by streamlining editions of fashion bible French edition of Vogue is also in danger of having the 'Paris' title dropped from its cover for next month's edition for the first time in 70 years  Read more »

Lindt cafe at the centre of Sydney's deadly siege to CLOSE for good after it survived a terrorist attack only to fall victim to the pandemic

Sydney's Lindt Café was the venue for a terrorist attack in December of 2014Man  Haron Monis stormed the café, taking a number of hostages in the siege Monis was killed by police, with Tori Johnson & Katrina Dawson innocent victims Read more »

Crystal Palace 1-1 Newcastle: VAR denies Christian Benteke a late winner for the hosts as the Magpies hold on for a point thanks to Callum Wilson's overhead STUNNER in first game under caretaker boss Graeme Jones

VAR denied Crystal Palace a late winner against Newcastle at Selhurst ParkChristian Benteke opened the scoring for the hosts with a thumping headerCallum Wilson equalised with a stunning overhead kick against the run of playBenteke grabbed his second before VAR intervened to disallow his headerNewcastle held on for a point in their first game under caretaker Graeme Jones  Read more »

Unemployed fashion designer who used her house deposit to sell flowers from her CAR now owns a $14MILLION floral empire - and reveals the four trends set to bloom in 2022

Kellie Brown was made redundant from her high-flying fashion job in 2015She took $10k she had saved for a house to sell flowers from the boot of her car Ms Brown delivered 4,000 bouquets in her first year - she sold 93,000 in 2021Her business Fig and Bloom will turn over $14m this financial yearMs Brown has worked with Ferrari and decked out Elton John's green room Read more »

Tina Arena relists her lavish Toorak mansion and increases the price by $500,000 to $7.5 million - after pulling it off the market seven months ago because she 'changed her mind'

Tina Arena has relisted her lavish mansion in the affluent Melbourne suburb of Toorak. The $7 million property was taken off the market after seven months when the Chains singer, ... Read more »

Icing on the cake... Great British Bake off judge Paul Hollywood makes his lockdown bubble with pub landlady Melissa Spalding permanent

Pair began dating after Hollywood’s split from Summer Monteys-Fullam in 2019Friends say they are 'madly in love' and recently enjoyed sunshine break abroadThe baker, 55, met Ms Spalding, 37, at The Chequers Inn where he was a regular Read more »

Video: A gem of a find! Stunning 2,000-year-old lilac amethyst stone is discovered in Jerusalem featuring the first-ever known depiction of balsam - a plant prominently mentioned in the Bible

Read more »

Supermodel Elle Macpherson raises eyebrows after deleting 'Aborigine' ancestry remarks in Vogue makeup tutorial

Australian supermodel Elle Macpherson has raised eyebrows for making a surprising remark about her ancestry.  According to The Sydney Morning Herald, the 57-year-old stated in a new beauty video tutorial ... Read more »

Australia's Covid-19 vaccine booster program to start NEXT WEEK as fears grow of waning immunity ahead of the country reopening to the world - this is how to get your shot

Australia set to fast-track Covid-19 booster program to as early as next weekApproval for third dose of Pfizer is expected to be made by mid next week Aged-cared residents and frontline healthcare workers will be first in line  Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic