No more apologies: Inside Facebook's push to defend its image

No more apologies: Inside Facebook's push to defend its image

LOS ANGELES (NYTIMES) – Facebook chief executive Mark Zuckerberg signed off last month on a new initiative code-named Project Amplify. The effort, which was hatched at an internal meeting in January, had a specific purpose: to use Facebook’s News Feed, the site’s most important digital real estate, to show people positive stories about the social network.

The idea was that pushing pro-Facebook news items – some of them written by the company – would improve its image in the eyes of its users, three people with knowledge of the effort said. But the move was sensitive because Facebook had not previously positioned the News Feed as a place where it burnished its own reputation. Several executives at the meeting were shocked by the proposal, one attendee said.

Project Amplify punctuated a series of decisions that Facebook has made this year to aggressively reshape its image. Since that January meeting, the company has begun a multipronged effort to change its narrative by distancing Mr Zuckerberg from scandals, reducing outsiders’ access to internal data, burying a potentially negative report about its content and increasing its own advertising to showcase its brand.

The moves amount to a broad shift in strategy. For years, Facebook confronted crisis after crisis over privacy, misinformation and hate speech on its platform by publicly apologising. Mr Zuckerberg personally took responsibility for Russian interference on the site during the 2016 presidential election and has loudly stood up for free speech online. Facebook also promised transparency into the way that it operated.

But the drumbeat of criticism on issues as varied as racist speech and vaccine misinformation has not relented. Disgruntled Facebook employees have added to the furor by speaking out against their employer and leaking internal documents. Facebook executives, concluding that their methods had done little to quell criticism or win supporters, decided early this year to go on the offensive, said six current and former employees, who declined to be identified for fear of reprisal.

“They’re realising that no one else is going to come to their defense, so they need to do it and say it themselves,” said Ms Katie Harbath, a former Facebook public policy director.

The changes have involved Facebook executives from its marketing, communications, policy and integrity teams. Mr Alex Schultz, a 14-year company veteran who was named chief marketing officer last year, has also been influential in the image reshaping effort, said five people who worked with him. But at least one of the decisions was driven by Mr Zuckerberg, and all were approved by him.

Mr Joe Osborne, a Facebook spokesperson, denied that the company had changed its approach. “People deserve to know the steps we’re taking to address the different issues facing our company – and we’re going to share those steps widely,” he said in a statement.

For years, Facebook executives have chafed at how their company appeared to receive more scrutiny than Google and Twitter, said current and former employees. They attributed that attention to Facebook’s leaving itself more exposed with its apologies and providing access to internal data, the people said.

So in January, executives held a virtual meeting and broached the idea of a more aggressive defense, one attendee said. The group discussed using the News Feed to promote positive news about the company, as well as running ads that linked to favorable articles about Facebook. They also debated how to define a pro-Facebook story, two participants said.

That same month, the communications team discussed ways for executives to be less conciliatory when responding to crises and decided there would be less apologizing, said two people with knowledge of the plan.

Mr Zuckerberg, who had become intertwined with policy issues including the 2020 election, also wanted to recast himself as an innovator, the people said. In January, the communications team circulated a document with a strategy for distancing Mr Zuckerberg from scandals, partly by focusing his Facebook posts and media appearances on new products, they said.

The impact was immediate. On Jan 11, Ms Sheryl Sandberg, Facebook’s chief operating officer – and not Mr Zuckerberg – told Reuters that the storming of the US Capitol a week earlier had little to do with Facebook. In July, when President Joe Biden said the social network was “killing people” by spreading COVID-19 misinformation, Mr Guy Rosen, Facebook’s vice president for integrity, disputed the characterization in a blog post and pointed out that the White House had missed its coronavirus vaccination goals. “Facebook is not the reason this goal was missed,” he wrote.

Mr Zuckerberg’s personal Facebook and Instagram accounts soon changed. Rather than addressing corporate controversies, Mr Zuckerberg’s posts have recently featured a video of himself riding across a lake carrying an American flag, with messages about new virtual reality and hardware devices.

Facebook also started cutting back the availability of data that allowed academics and journalists to study how the platform worked. In April, the company told its team behind CrowdTangle, a tool that provides data on the engagement and popularity of Facebook posts, that it was being broken up. While the tool still exists, the people who worked on it were moved to other teams.

For academics who relied on CrowdTangle, it was a blow. Mr Cameron Hickey, a misinformation researcher at the National Conference on Citizenship, a nonprofit focused on civic engagement, said he was “particularly angry” because he felt the CrowdTangle team was being punished for giving an unfiltered view of engagement on Facebook.

Mr Schultz argued that Facebook should publish its own information about the site’s most popular content rather than supply access to tools like CrowdTangle, two people said. So in June, the company compiled a report on Facebook’s most-viewed posts for the first three months of 2021.

But Facebook did not release the report. After the policy communications team discovered that the top-viewed link for the period was a news story with a headline that suggested a doctor had died after receiving the COVID-19 vaccine, they feared the company would be chastised for contributing to vaccine hesitancy, according to internal emails reviewed by The New York Times.

A day before the report was supposed to be published, Mr Schultz was part of a group that voted to shelve the document, according to the emails. He later posted an internal message about his role at Facebook, which was reviewed by The Times, saying, “I do care about protecting the company’s reputation, but I also care deeply about rigour and transparency.”

In August, after Mr Zuckerberg approved Project Amplify, the company tested the change in three US cities, two people with knowledge of the effort said. While the company had previously used the News Feed to promote its own products and social causes, it had not turned to it to openly push positive press about itself, they said.

Once the tests began, Facebook used a system known as Quick Promotes to place stories about people and organizations that used the social network into users’ News Feeds, they said. People essentially see posts with a Facebook logo that link to stories and websites published by the company and from third-party local news sites. One story pushed “Facebook’s Latest Innovations for 2021” and discussed how it was achieving “100 percent renewable energy for our global operations.”

“This is a test for an informational unit clearly marked as coming from Facebook,” Mr Osborne said, adding that Project Amplify was “similar to corporate responsibility initiatives people see in other technology and consumer products.”

News Related


Hainan's foreign trade volume grew 57.7% in 2021

The province's foreign trade turnover reached $23.16 billion last year Read more »

As Tesla puts off new launches, Chinese trio NIO, Xpeng and Li Auto get a chance to close gap with US rival

Chinese smart electric vehicle makers have a chance to catch up with Tesla on the mainland with their ramped up car development plans, after the US carmaker said it does ... Read more »

Police started arresting activists in forest near Nedcar

Activists have been occupying a forest next to the car factory near Born (Limburg) since Friday morning. They climbed trees with ropes and settled there with hammocks, the action group ... Read more »

Hong Kong's best-known travel agency folds after 50 years Industry leader expects woes to continue for rest of 2022

Mong Kok branch of Morning Star Travel Service in Hong Kong. (South China Morning Post photo) HONG KONG: One of Hong Kong's best-known tour operators has decided to wind up ... Read more »

Budget 2022 | What are the tourism industry's expectations of Budget 2022?

A massive order placed in India’s pink city Jaipur was worth Rs 1,84,760 and it was delivered in 415 boxes. (Image: Reuters) India’s travel and tourism industry, among the worst ... Read more »

Oil prices on track for sixth consecutive week of gains

Photo: ANP Oil prices are on track for a sixth consecutive week of gains, fueled by strong demand, limited supply and tensions around Ukraine. That would be the longest period ... Read more »

Chevron shares retreat from a record after fourth-quarter profit falls short of expectations

Journalists are reflected in the sunglasses of drilling site manager Greg Murphy during a media day at Chevron's site in Pungesti, Romania, April 8, 2014.Bogdan Cristel | Reuters Chevron shares ... Read more »

Cinemas reopening in Delhi will set the ball rolling for new releases, say exhibitors

Representative image. Delhi’s announcement of cinema closures on December 28 had resulted in the postponement of many upcoming releases, leaving theatres with limited new content. With Delhi now allowing theatres to reopen from January ... Read more »

Century Plyboards India's net profit jumps 42.7% to Rs 93.9 crore in December quarter

Century Plyboards (India) Ltd on Friday reported a 42.7 per cent jump in its consolidated net profit to Rs 93.89 crore for the third quarter ended December 2021. The company ... Read more »

Budget 2022 unlikely to provide capital infusion for banks for the first time in over a decade

With capital infusion of Rs 3.36 trillion during the last six years from the Government of India, public banks have significantly cleaned up their balance sheets with the net non-performing ... Read more »

Kremlin unaware of gas reverse from Germany to Ukraine

However, such purchases do indeed take place, Dmitry Peskov noted Read more »

Taking Stock | Market ends a volatile day on a flat note; Sensex down 76 points, Nifty holds 17,100

The Indian benchmark indices witnessed high volatility and ended the day with marginal losses on January 28. The markets carried the positive tone from yesterday and had a strong gap-up ... Read more »

COVID-19: Work from home tax break set to end after costs 'spiral to £500m' during pandemic

Rishi Sunak is said to be planning to close the loophole that allows people to claim up to £125 a year for working even a single day from home, as a result of the bill soaring over the coronavirus crisis with millions told to stay away from the office. Read more »

Kumar Mangalam Birla's Annual Reflections: Capex fest is coming, resilience and unit-economics will be back in vogue

Kumar Mangalam Birla wrote that “real success lies in the quiet acceptance of both (highs and lows of life)” in his Annnual Reflections. The coming decade will be one of ... Read more »

Funeralcare provider's husband-and-wife team eye £400m windfall

Pure Cremation’s parent company, Cognicent, has hired bankers to explore a sale or listing that would catapult Bryan and Catherine Powell into the ranks of Britain’s super-rich, Sky News learns. Read more »

De Hypotheekshop: mortgage interest continues to rise

Photo: ANP Mortgage interest rates are continuing to rise after a period of standstill, mortgage broker De Hypotheekshop notes. It counted 103 rate hikes in January against 17 rate cuts. ... Read more »

Marico Q3 results | Revenue grows 13.4% YoY to Rs 2,407 crore, PAT up 1.6% to Rs 317 crore

An array of consumer products is marketed by Marico (Representative image) FMCG major Marico on January 28 announced its results for the third quarter of financial year 2022-23, with the ... Read more »

15 NPA accounts worth Rs 50,000 crore to be transferred to NARCL by Mar-end: SBI chairman Dinesh Khara

SBI Chairman Dinesh Kumar Khara. (Photo Credit: PTI) State Bank of India Chairman Dinesh Khara on Friday said the National Asset Reconstruction Company (NARCL) or bad bank and India Debt ... Read more »

Mike Lynch loses $5bn fraud case over sale of Autonomy to HP in 2011

UK entrepreneur Mike Lynch has lost a multi-billion pound fraud action brought over the sale of software company Autonomy to Hewlett Packard (HP) in 2011. The High Court judge found ... Read more »

Neglected after PV Narasimha Rao, Modi puts spotlight back on India-Central Asia ties

File Photo| India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrives for a roundtable meeting during the G20 summit in Rome, Italy (REUTERS/Remo Casilli) If the cliché ‘timely’ was ever appropriate in the ... Read more »

Technical View | Nifty forms Shooting Star pattern, volatility to remain high ahead of Budget

The Nifty rebounded sharply in the early trade but erased gains to end lower on January 28, the first day of the February series, as investors get cautious ahead of ... Read more »

Beijing's new measures supporting ‘insurance connect' scheme may boost Hong Kong insurers' expansion into bay area

Hong Kong insurance companies are expected to expand more aggressively into the Greater Bay Area as a result of new measures announced by Beijing to make it easier for mainland ... Read more »

Hold Rallis India; target of Rs 280: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on Rallis India Rallis India’s (RALI) 3QFY22 results were broadly in line with ours as well as consensus estimates. Key highlights are: 1) domestic revenue grew ... Read more »

Buy Asian Paints; target of Rs 3762: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on Asian Paints We increase our FY22/FY23/FY24 EPS by 13.6%/7%/3.2% given 1) strong pent-up demand 2) long runway for growth in Rurban India 3) bounce back ... Read more »

Buy Hindustan Unilever; target of Rs 2900: Prabhudas Lilladher

The research firm ICICI Securities believes earnings of apparel brands and retail companies under their coverage may surprise positively from Q3FY22E as the likely demand recovery may result in better than expected ... Read more »

Buy Bajaj Auto; target of Rs 3911: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on Bajaj Auto Bajaj Auto’s 3QFY22 performance came in-line with our estimates, with realization growing 12% YoY on the back of price hikes and higher exports ... Read more »

Spartan Poker launches India's first-ever gaming NFTs

Globally today, online gaming is no more about just entertainment or a hobby that a select few indulge in to kill time; it is a booming, serious business. India’s online ... Read more »

Buy PVR; target of Rs 1891: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on PVR PVR’s operational performance was broadly in-line with our estimates with pre Ind-AS EBITDA margin of 6.2% (PLe 7.4%) aided by strong content (5 movies ... Read more »

Buy Sharda Cropchem; target of Rs 570: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on Sharda Cropchem Sharda Cropchem (SHCR) reported strong operational performance in 3QFY22, primarily led by healthy revenue growth across regions. Key highlights are: (1) Volume/Price/FX growth ... Read more »

'High raw material prices, lower sales volume to dent operating profit of tractor makers in FY22'

Representative image Operating profitability of tractor makers is set to shrink by 300-400 basis points in the ongoing fiscal year owing to a sharp increase in raw material prices, primarily ... Read more »

Hold CEAT; target of Rs 1174: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on CEAT CEAT’s 3QFY22 consol. revenue came missed our estimates at Rs 24.1B (9% YoY/ -1% QoQ, PLe 26.5B) led by volume decline of 5.5% YoY/ ... Read more »

Hold Polycab India; target of Rs 2387: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on Polycab India We cut our FY22/FY23/FY24 earnings by 4.1%/ 5.1%/ 4.5% largely on account of 1) inflationary input cost environment led margin pressure and 2) ... Read more »

Accumulate JSW Steel; target of Rs 760: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on JSW Steel Steel (JSTL) reported Q3FY22 Adj. EBITDA in-line with our estimates. While, it came above consensus estimates (CE) by 8%. On reported basis, EBITDA ... Read more »

Hold The Ramco Cements; target of Rs 925: Prabhudas Lilladher

Prabhudas Lilladher’s research report on The Ramco Cements The Ramco Cements (TRCL) reported disappointing earnings for Q3FY22. EBITDA declined 42% YoY to Rs2.3bn, below our/consensus estimates (CE) by 30%/35%. The ... Read more »

Does Lynch case highlight US-UK extradition imbalance?

Read more »

Moglix valuation doubles to $2.6 billion in less than a year

Rahul Garg, Founder and CEO, Moglix. Industrial goods marketplace Moglix said January 28 that it has raised $250 million, valuing it at $2.6 billion, more than double its valuation from ... Read more »

3 resilient stocks to help you weather market crashes: Chipotle, Domino's, Texas Roadhouse

Portfolio construction is an often-neglected aspect of investing that not many people discuss. However, this skill is vitally important in ensuring that your portfolio can withstand crises and weather economic ... Read more »

Upping 2022 comedy slate, Netflix adds Kapil Sharma stand-up, but will it drive subscriptions?

Kapil Sharma Streaming platform Netflix is focusing on comedy and its first offering under the category this year is headlined by Kapil Sharma, a stand-up comedy talent and host of ... Read more »

Race for Apollo Global's BPO arm IGT Solutions: Who is in the shortlist?

Technology A clutch of strategic suitors and bulge bracket private equity funds have been shortlisted for the ongoing sale process of InterGlobe Technologies ( now IGT Solutions) owned by private ... Read more »

German economy shrinks in the closing quarter of 2021

Photo: ANP The German economy shrank by 0.7 percent in the fourth quarter of 2021 compared to the previous period. This was reported by the German Federal Statistical Office. The ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic