New Zealand grapples with Delta – and Tucker Carlson

© Provided by Al Jazeera New Zealand’s Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Commissioner of Police Andrew Coster speak during a press conference in Wellington on September 4, 2021, after the country recorded its first COVID-related death in six months [Mark Mitchell/AFP]

On August 17, a 58-year-old man from Auckland became symptomatic and tested positive for COVID-19. It was New Zealand’s first community case of the coronavirus in almost six months.

Within hours, the nation of five million moved into alert level four, part of its “go hard, go early” approach. All travel outside of people’s homes was forbidden, except to fetch supplies, visit pharmacies or exercise.

The country largely ground to a halt.

“We have seen the dire consequences of taking too long to act in other countries, not least our neighbours,” said Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, while announcing the cabinet’s decision to impose a lockdown that evening.

Within a few days, one case had grown to 21 cases. After a week, to 148 cases. By August 31, the cluster contained 612 cases.

One month after imposing the snap lockdown, New Zealand has bent the curve and may be able to eliminate an outbreak of the potent Delta variant of COVID-19 – though it is no sure thing.

As of September 20, some 1,051 people in Auckland and 17 people in the capital city, Wellington, have been infected with the virus, of whom 694 have recovered. Contact tracers have methodically identified tens of thousands of contacts – and hundreds of locations of interest – part of an updated track-and-trace system repurposed to cast a much wider net around the far more transmissible Delta variant.

The outbreak, now spread across 20 subclusters, 10 of which have been epidemiologically linked, presents the most serious challenge to elimination that New Zealand has faced so far. With its fragmented public health system under intense strain from decades of under-funding, any unchecked spread of the Delta variant would see hospitals rapidly overwhelmed.

But New Zealanders rallied behind the restrictions, sticking to their “bubbles”, masking up and watching patiently as cases peaked, then began to decline – though the outbreak’s tail is proving persistent.

If the country does eliminate this outbreak, it would once again validate the “go hard, go early” approach that officials have taken over the past 18 months. With Auckland set to move to the more permissive alert level three at 11:59pm on September 21, case numbers over the coming weeks will be closely watched for any sign of uncontained spread.

Entitlement and denunciation

Yet, as with previous outbreaks, the clamour from critics of the government started almost immediately, a chorus of whinge.

Business special interests laundered their messaging through an uncritical media – “certainty” they chanted, while pressuring for a move down alert levels.

“We also know that in lockdown Treasury has forecast it to cost the country NZ$1.45 billion [$1.02bn] per week – and that’s just the economic impact,” Canterbury Employers’ Chamber of Commerce chief executive Leeann Watson told broadcaster Newstalk ZB.

Incredibly, less than a week into lockdown, Export New Zealand executive director Catherine Beard complained to Stuff, the country’s most popular news website, that the business environment was getting “tough” for exporters, while lobbying for more managed isolation spots for business travellers – or self-isolation. “Some of these are multimillion-dollar deals, so the situation is very stressful,” she said.

Some in the hospitality sector complained about limits on gatherings and threatened to withhold tax, while demanding “targeted” assistance from the government.

“Now it’s 100 per cent [Ministry of] Health running the show,” said Hospitality New Zealand chief executive Julie White, according to Stuff. “No one is advising them commercially.”

Most New Zealanders would, presumably, prefer that the Health Ministry – as opposed to hospitality interest groups – responds to the threat presented by a lethal, airborne pathogen.

The “glacial” pace of the country’s vaccine rollout was also riffed off in headline after headline.

Perhaps, as the political opposition and reporters contend, the rollout has been “sluggish”.

Perhaps the government could have instructed the medical regulator Medsafe to conduct a less rigorous assessment of the Pfizer vaccine, under emergency protocols.

“Another [possibility] is,” Craig McCulloch, Radio New Zealand’s deputy political editor speculated, “that the government’s negotiators came late to the party, did a poor job and got a raw deal.”

Or perhaps soaring global demand amid the pandemic, Pfizer’s finite ability to supply vaccines to a vast suite of countries and New Zealand’s limited purchasing power and largely COVID-free status explains the “delay”. Certainly, the World Health Organization has described vaccine hoarding by wealthy nations as approaching a “catastrophic moral failure”.

When Pfizer became able to deliver large shipments midway through July, New Zealand saw a dramatic scale-up in the vaccination programme, as officials had promised for months.

If anything, the nation’s rollout – a massive logistical undertaking – has largely been a success story, conducted in an environment of incredible uncertainty and reliant upon an already stretched workforce. It has additionally played a key role in supporting vaccination efforts in the Cook Islands.

As of September 20, some 4,711,410 doses of the vaccine have been administered, tracking close to supply, with 1,618,673 people now fully vaccinated.

Amid the rising racket, the entitlement and denunciation, even commentators from abroad got in on the act.

Fox News host Tucker Carlson – agitating anti-lockdown sentiment – suggested that New Zealand provided a model for how his viewers would be subjugated by Joe Biden’s administration.

“How far can they go? […] A single COVID case in New Zealand, not a death from COVID, but a case of COVID has shut down the entire country.”

Writing in Britain’s Daily Telegraph, one commentator called the outbreak “poetic justice” and claimed a “once-welcoming nation is turning into an isolated dystopia, where liberties are taken away in a heartbeat and outsiders are shunned”.

While these criticisms are couched in the language of defending civil liberties, they reduce to variants of the “learn to live with COVID” argument.

Or put another way: “the cure cannot be worse than the disease”.

The economy must reign supreme, after all.

Sound familiar?

‘Needles in my eyes’

New Zealand’s elimination strategy relies on public buy-in. Recent polling shows that some 84 percent of the public supports the latest lockdown.

As with previous outbreaks, Ardern has used clear, empathetic language to reassure and unify an often politically divided nation. These briefings are held in parliament’s theatrette and usually feature the Director-General of Health, Dr Ashley Bloomfield.

For many in New Zealand, the daily press briefings provide a detailed window into how authorities manage outbreaks and have been the most visible key to the elimination strategy’s success.

“To all Aucklanders, you have done an amazing job so far protecting yourselves, your family and your community,” Ardern said on September 13, while announcing that Auckland would stay in alert level four for another week. “We owe you a huge debt of gratitude … but the cases are telling us we have additional work to do.”

Voters rewarded Ardern’s Labour Party for this kind of humane approach and its exceptional management of the viral threat in the national elections last October, granting it an outright majority.

The political opposition judges these briefings a political threat, and routinely denigrates them as Ardern speaking from “The Podium of Truth”.

With the return of daily briefings on August 17, right-wing broadcasters and some journalists began to deride the briefings, at exactly the moment when trust in the authorities needed to be reinforced.

There is a difference between “holding power to account” and deliberately attempting, for purely partisan political reasons, to undermine public perceptions that the COVID-19 response is being well managed.

“I tried, I really did, but I wanted to stick needles in my eyes by about four minutes in,” said Newstalk ZB’s Kate Hawkesby, the day after the return of the 1pm press conferences. “I’d forgotten how soul-destroying it is to be spoken to like a three year old.”

On the same station, Hawkesby’s husband, Mike Hosking, overdubbed turkey “gobbles” and truck horn sound effects onto an interview recorded with Associate Health Minister Ayesha Verrall.

Newstalk ZB’s political editor, Barry Soper, in a report about an Auckland man whose kidney surgery was postponed due to staffing shortages, loaded his story’s preamble with phrases like “their altar” and “practise what they preach”.

He also issued a remarkable dog-whistle to New Zealand’s far-right, the kind of people who believe Ardern – a fairly mild political centrist – is turning the country into a communist dictatorship.

“If you have ever wondered what it must have been like to live in a totalitarian state, then perhaps wonder no more.”

This nonsense went on and on.

Some press gallery reporters began to complain about the length of Ardern’s introductions, while Jason Walls, a political reporter with Newstalk ZB, took to Twitter to moan about Bloomfield saying “finally” two times.

This speaks to how the media has fundamentally misunderstood what the briefings are: public service announcements.

They are for the public. Reporters are invited as a check and, as such, should resist the urge to demand a say in how these announcements are structured.

Even the New York Times managed to launder messaging that targeted the briefings, quoting former National Party staffer and political commentator Ben Thomas – who appears fixated on denigrating Bloomfield.

“He [Bloomfield] has … a cult-like following,” said Thomas. “The country has a huge kind of parasocial devotion to him, which is very new to New Zealand.”

Apparently, Thomas has not heard of Michael Joseph Savage, who founded New Zealand’s welfare state in the 1930s and whose framed photo hung in homes throughout the country for decades.

Regardless, all of this is a fairly obvious partisan political effort, driven by both ideology and market dynamics.

Many reporters and commentators at New Zealand Media and Entertainment (NZME), which owns the New Zealand Herald and Newstalk ZB, seem unable to accept that their preferred political tribe is no longer in power.

More critically, in an age where the news media increasingly attempts to attract subscribers by catering to their social and political values, NZME appears to be ring-fencing centre-to-far-right eyeballs.

It is, essentially, becoming New Zealand’s Fox News.

A brave new world

The sense in New Zealand is that this may be the last of the nation’s sledgehammer-style lockdowns, though one hopes officials do not retire lockdowns altogether.

The goal is to get as many people as possible vaccinated, assess the impact of opening up, and then tentatively start easing some border restrictions, if possible. No doubt, certain industries – tourism, hospitality, horticulture, media – will continue to apply relentless pressure.

Yet, when the nation reconnects more fully to the networks of global trade and travel, the super-highways of hyper-globalisation that have spread disease and death around the world, when the inevitable outbreaks come, there will be a toll.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


US, Brazil discuss ways to slow migration

Top U.S. and Brazil diplomats on Tuesday discussed the rise of regional migration between the two countries and ways to slow it. © Getty Images US, Brazil discuss ways to ... Read more »

Businesses nervously await fine print of vax-or-test rule

WASHINGTON (AP) — More than six weeks after promising a new vaccination-or-testing rule covering the millions of Americans at companies with 100 or more workers, President Joe Biden’s most aggressive ... Read more »

Blinken praises Ecuador democracy as leader declares state of emergency

© Cristina Vega RHOR The president of the Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador, Leonidas Iza (center), takes part in a protest march after meeting with Ecuador’s President Guillermo Lasso ... Read more »

Airports Company SA walloped by tourism malaise in pandemic — but ‘worst is over'

For more than two decades, the Airports Company SA (Acsa), a majority state-owned entity that manages the country’s nine biggest airports, has been profitable and successfully operated without taxpayer-funded bailouts.   ... Read more »

The changing nature of black swans in an economy built for a world that no longer exists

The list of potential black swan events feels depressingly endless right now. Just some of these range from runaway inflation, the lights going out across the world, a US sovereign ... Read more »

South Africa's youth largely dictate retail spending patterns, survey shows

Think the parents are in control of the household budget? Think again: young people might not be earning the big bucks yet, but often they determine how, when and on ... Read more »

Toronto Ultra adds Hicksy to 2022 Call of Duty League roster

© Provided by Dot Esports Charlie “Hicksy” Hicks has joined the Toronto Ultra for the 2022 Call of Duty League season, pending league approval, the franchise announced today. During the ... Read more »

UAE could excel in developing women coders, says Minister of State for AI

© Motivate Publishing His Excellency Omar Sultan Al Olama, Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence, Digital Economy and Remote Work Applications At the GITEX Global Leaders Vision, Omar Sultan Al ... Read more »

How much money does Quackity make streaming? – Twitch leaks 2021

© Provided by GamePur Following the major breach into streaming giant Twitch, the public is now familiar with the financials of some of the biggest creators on the site. As ... Read more »

VCT NA Last Chance Qualifier to Resume Matches Online on Oct. 27

The Valorant Champions Tour North American Last Chance Qualifier (LCQ) will resume play in an online-only format on Oct. 27, 2021, Riot Games announced Tuesday. As stated in an official ... Read more »

‘Unbelievable, speechless', ‘Absolute scenes' – These Nottingham Forest fans react to remarkable Bristol City win

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Barnsley v Nottingham Forest Nottingham Forest’s fine form under Steve Cooper continued as they recorded a dramatic 2-1 win over Bristol City ... Read more »

Mila Kunis Got Called Out by Ashton Kutcher for a Parenting Fail

© Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images Mila Kunis‘ latest parenting fail didn’t go unnoticed by her husband. In a new episode of The Ellen DeGeneres Show‘s digital series, Mom Confessions, the 38-year-old actress reveals ... Read more »

'Can win Connect Four in three moves' - Many Sunderland fans drool at star's 'masterclass'

© Provided by Transfer Tavern General view of Sunderland’s Stadium of Light Many Sunderland fans applauded Dan Neil during Tuesday night’s League One clash with Crewe Alexandra.  Sunderland were looking ... Read more »

Survivor: Fiji contestant Michelle Yi attacked in Santa Monica in suspected anti-Asian hate crime

© Michelle Yi says she was beaten over the head with a metal bar – A former contestant on the Survivor reality TV franchise has been left bloodied ... Read more »

Former top FBI official starts new job driving a school bus

© CBS Mike Mason has gone from running the FBI’s cyber criminal unit to driving a school bus – CBS The former No. 4 at the FBI who spurned retirement ... Read more »

Garda body requests urgent meeting with Commissioner Drew Harris over penalty points ‘discretion' comments

The Garda Representative Association (GRA) is requesting an urgent meeting with the Garda Commissioner following his comments regarding the ongoing issue of the right of a member of An Garda ... Read more »

Man slumped over in SUV shot to death in southeast Fort Worth neighborhood, police say

A man slumped over in a running sports utility vehicle which had been stopped by a large landscaping rock was found shot to death Monday afternoon in a southeast Fort ... Read more »

England's wind energy potential remains untapped

Photograph: Islandstock/Alamy The UK, being a windy island, has vast potential to produce more electricity from onshore windfarms. With urgent action required on the climate crises, the latest renewable prospectus ... Read more »

Cleo Smith disappearance: Police looking at the 'worst case scenario'

Western Australian police are now focusing on the “worst case scenario” in the hunt for Cleo Smith — as her shocked parents revealed the 4-year-old had been sleeping metres from ... Read more »

‘I'm doing this out of my heart': the fight for clean water in one remote WA Indigenous town

Kaitlyn Buaneye was eight months pregnant when she first learned she wasn’t supposed to drink the water, but it wasn’t until after her son was born she found out why. ... Read more »

Atletico Madrid vs Liverpool LIVE: Champions League result, final score and reaction from fixture tonight

LIVE – Updated at 21:56 © Reuters Champions League – Group B – Atletico Madrid v Liverpool Liverpool head into their third Champions League group stage match high on confidence ... Read more »

Kembla Grange train crash: driver trapped after train hits car and derails

A passenger train has partially derailed on a track near Wollongong, south of Sydney, with reports it hit a car before the front carriage overturned. Emergency services at the scene ... Read more »

Community approach can help fight against childhood obesity, international study finds

A study into childhood obesity rates in Australia has found a community-based approach to healthy choices can pay dividends for young people. According to the latest health data, almost 25 ... Read more »

FBI searches NYC, DC properties in probe of Russian oligarch with ties to Kremlin

The FBI on Tuesday searched properties in New York City and Washington, D.C., as part of an investigation into Oleg Deripaska, a Russian oligarch who had been previously sanctioned by ... Read more »

Boeing aims for unmanned Starliner test flight in first half of 2022

Boeing is aiming for a test flight of its unmanned CST-100 Starliner capsule in the first half of next year and a potential launch of its crewed spacecraft at the ... Read more »

Vice President Harris to visit NYC this week to plug Biden's infrastructure bills

Vice President Kamala Harris is heading to the Bronx this Friday to highlight how the Biden administration’s infrastructure agenda would “benefit working families” if approved by Congress, a White House ... Read more »

Top Republican senator demands US military suspend COVID-19 vaccine mandate, arguing it hurts morale and readiness

© Stefani Reynolds/Getty Images Sen. Jim Inhofe. Stefani Reynolds/Getty Images Sen. Jim Inhofe wrote to the defense secretary calling for the suspension of the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. The top Republican ... Read more »

Washington state sheriff faces false reporting charges after claiming that a Black newspaper carrier threatened to kill him

© KCPQ Pierce County Sheriff Ed Troyer. KCPQ A white sheriff in Washington state faces charges for claiming a Black newspaper carrier threatened to kill him. Pierce County Sheriff Ed ... Read more »

Cuba 'systematically' abused demonstrators, says human rights group

Various arms of Cuba’s government have “systematically” jailed and abused demonstrators that took part in July protests against the government, according to Human Rights Watch. © Getty Cuba ‘systematically’ abused ... Read more »

This is why bread bags have different color twist ties

Each color-coded tag shows when a loaf of bread was baked, according to Reader’s Digest. Getty Images/iStockphoto If you’ve ever noticed that bread bags in the grocery store have different ... Read more »

Inside the only lab infecting humans with COVID for pay

A London lab is preparing to be the first in the world to infect humans with Covid. Open Orphan A London hotel repurposed into a lab is preparing to be ... Read more »

Get your booster jab to save lives and keep our freedoms this winter

TODAY The Sun urges all readers to put rocket-boosters under the stuttering jabs rollout. Nothing is more vital to save lives and keep our freedoms this winter. Nothing is more ... Read more »

Get flu and Covid booster jab to protect yourselves and loved ones this winter

LAST winter the eyes of the world were on a Coventry hospital as Margaret Keenan, 91, received the world’s first  approved Covid-19 vaccine. Since then our vaccination programme has protected ... Read more »

Iowa Democratic Party leader says he was target of racist threats

FILE PHOTO: Iowa Democratic Party headquarters By Sharon Bernstein (Reuters) – The chair of the Iowa Democratic Party said on Tuesday he received racist messages and emails, including a threat ... Read more »

Molly-Mae Hague says she was a 'mess' as she undergoes endometriosis surgery

Molly-Mae Hague has opened up on her endometriosis surgery, after keeping the operation under wraps. Love Island beauty Molly-Mae, 22, decided to keep the exact surgery date a secret until ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo sends defiant message to Man Utd teammates ahead of crunch Atalanta tie

Cristiano Ronaldo has urged his Manchester United teammates to silence their critics and “prove themselves to the world” during their Champions League clash with Atalanta. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’ s side ... Read more »

Tickets on sale for Ireland-Portugal from later this week, with Aviva Stadium at 100% capacity

© Ryan Byrne INPHO A general view of September’s Ireland-Portugal clash at Estadio Algarve. THE FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION of Ireland [FAI] has announced that ticket sales for next month’s clash with ... Read more »

B.C. Interior town has the highest gas prices in the region and no one seems to know why

© Mike Blake/Reuters Regular gas costs $1.64 per litre in Revelstoke, B.C., as of Oct. 18, according to GasBuddy. Howard Lehman has been running a fairly successful taxi fleet in ... Read more »

S&P/TSX composite climbs past 21,000 for the first time, U.S. markets also up

TORONTO — Strong performances from tech and financials led Canada’s main stock index to a record close as it topped the 21,000 mark for the first time, while U.S. stock ... Read more »

Paramedic on stand at murder trial of stepmother in killing of 7-year-old Quebec girl

TROIS-RIVIÈRES, Que. — A paramedic who went to the home of a seven-year-old Granby, Que., girl who died in April 2019 told a trial Tuesday the girl was not breathing ... Read more »