New views of autocracy emerge from historic archives

Political science PhD student Emilia Simison has found that despotic regimes vary, and the move to democracy doesn’t necessarily guarantee policy change.

Political science, Students, Graduate, postdoctoral, Democracy, Policy, Government, Research, Social sciences, Latin America, Spain, Profile, School of Humanities Arts and Social Sciences, Comparative Politics, Ben Ross Schneider

“I want to understand what makes autocracies different from democracies, by looking closely at the policymaking process inside dictatorships and determining if and how those policies change when a regime becomes democratic,” says political science graduate student Emilia Simison. Photo: Fiorella Sozzi

Political science, Students, Graduate, postdoctoral, Democracy, Policy, Government, Research, Social sciences, Latin America, Spain, Profile, School of Humanities Arts and Social Sciences, Comparative Politics, Ben Ross Schneider

Some of Simison's archive material at Centro de Pesquisa e Documentação de História Contemporânea do Brasil (CPDOC), Fundação Getulio Vargas, in Rio de Janeiro. Photo: Emilia Simison

“There’s a stereotype of dictatorship where one person decides everything, but that’s not always how politics works in an authoritarian regime,” says Emilia Simison, a sixth-year doctoral student in political science. Since 2015, Simison has been able to access and study documents that chronicle the lawmaking machinery of some of the past century’s most notorious dictatorships. Her analysis of these voluminous materials suggests that autocracies do not routinely follow a single “strongman” model, and that some even make room for opposition groups and legislatures.

“I want to understand what makes autocracies different from democracies, by looking closely at the policymaking process inside dictatorships and determining if and how those policies change when a regime becomes democratic,” says Simison.

Mining previously inaccessible, declassified archives as well as vast public databases, Simison is creating a new and perhaps controversial picture of how autocratic regimes functioned — ranging from Francisco Franco’s Spain to more recent dictatorships in Brazil and Argentina.

“We expect policies to be different under democracies because we have elections where people vote for those who offer the political economy they want,” says Simison. But Simison finds that when autocracy gives way to democracy, policy change does not automatically follow.

“There are real-life implications to my research,” she says. “If we know what things are going to be different, and what are not, we can build realistic expectations in our democratic governments, activating the right mechanisms to make policies we need, such as those that reduce inequality and improve the provision of public goods.”

Turbulent times in Argentina

A native Argentine, Simison grew up amidst political turmoil and witnessed the devastating consequences of both military rule and unstable democracies. One of her earliest memories is from 2001, when she was in grade school: “The country was experiencing a huge economic crisis, and in Buenos Aires there was panic and looting because store shelves were empty, and police were clubbing demonstrators in the streets,” she recalls. As a teenager, she participated in protests herself.

Compelled by her country’s traumatic history and ongoing struggles, Simison determined to study political science at the University of Buenos Aires. After helping one of her professors write a history book, Simison realized she had a gift and passion for research, and set out on a master’s program in political science at Torcuato Di Tella University directly after completing her bachelor’s degree.

Then a life-changing opportunity arrived: “My advisor told me that an insane number of documents from one of Argentina’s dictatorships had recently been discovered and he invited me to help study them,” says Simison. “We were among the very first to gain access to these records.”

Simison and this professor, Alejandro Bonvecchi, combed through detailed records documenting el Proceso, the military junta that ruled Argentina between 1976 and 1983, a cruel government infamous for torturing and murdering citizens. This regime had established a legislative body drawn from the different military branches, “but the history of this congress had been erased,” says Simison. “In school we learned only that the junta made all the decisions.” Yet the archives proved otherwise.

“The records showed that this congress was relevant in shaping public policy during the dictatorship, offering amendments to bills supported by the junta, and delivering some legislative defeats,” says Simison. A paper describing this legislative power-sharing was published in Comparative Politics in 2017.

Historical data could illuminate the political machinery of regimes that were shrouded in secrecy, Simison realized, and there was much more to investigate — in Argentina and elsewhere. She decided to deepen her scholarship in historical analysis, and headed to MIT, where she believed training in rigorous, quantitative methods would enable her “to ask really interesting questions.”

Despots and legislatures

Simison quickly found rich topics to tap as she began doctoral studies. She began examining media and other accounts of a Brazilian dictatorship that ruled from 1964 to 1985. “The military created a bipartisan system, with pro-government and opposition parties,” she says. Her research, which applied machine learning to classify bills into policy topics, revealed that the pro-government party confined itself to proposing legislation on local issues, and the “opposition party introduced bills on out-of-bound national topics that generally didn’t pass.”

Her dissertation emerged from a review of historical records of this Brazilian dictatorship, and those of the el Proceso Argentine autocracy. With guidance from thesis advisor Ben Ross Schneider, Ford International Professor of Political Science and a Latin America economics and politics expert, Simison is focusing on the evolution and impacts of policies produced during and after these two regimes.

One prominent policy area involves financing laws. Simison found that in both regimes, banking powers held the ears of junta leaders and legislators, influencing policies that stayed in place even after the regimes fell. There could sometimes be dissent: She found letters from Brazilian renters’ associations complaining about inequities in the banking system, for instance. Yet financial regulations remained untouched. “People representing banks are always there, whether in democracies or dictatorships,” she says.

In contrast, policies touching health care, education, and housing generated enormous interest after regime change — particularly in Argentina — and were subject to significant shifts. “In democracies where there is space for people to mobilize, where elections are competitive, people will demand improvements on issues they deeply care about, such as high rents, and receive better policies from their elected officials.”
As she completes her dissertation, Simison is collaborating with scholars from Argentina and other Latin American countries to uncover and detail the policymaking mechanisms of additional authoritarian governments, the fate of legislation they create, and whether these policies advance or frustrate the social and economic interests of their citizens.  

It is work, Simison believes, that will continue to yield essential insights for those concerned with strengthening democracies. Perhaps a better understanding of how authoritarian governments permit small openings for policymaking through legislation might shed light on “what can be done in authoritarian regimes to push for democratization,” she says. By the same token, it’s important to identify what is required in post-authoritarian democracies to achieve meaningful policy change. “At a time when some democracies are backsliding,” Simison says, “we must know what to expect from democracy, and to learn the mechanisms by which we can make those things happen that we want to happen.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


13 Types Of Online Daters Who Have Emerged During The Pandemic

(Photo: Dusan Stankovic via Getty Images) Dating app usage spiked last year, meaning the dating pool grew exponentially for singles looking for love (or something like it.) Yes, that means ... Read more »

Frank Sinatra's My Way loses top spot in funeral music request chart

Gerry and the Pacemakers’ emotional melody You’ll Never Walk Alone has hit the top spot in Co-op Funeralcare’s annual music chart of the most popular songs at funerals. The song ... Read more »

Sebi defers pension proposal, board nominee says government's call

Mumbai: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has deferred a proposal to give pension benefits to its employees after one of the government nominees to the regulator’s board ... Read more »

This hidden condition has left half of sufferers feeling 'unsupported' through pandemic

Model Lila Grace Moss Hack walks the runway at the Versace special event with her Type 1 diabetes insulin pump visible. (Getty Images ) Half of people living with type ... Read more »

The hottest new crypto trend: What is the Tungsten Cube?

Cubes of tungsten carbide. Photo: Thierry Zoccolan/AFP via Getty Images Over the last week crypto watchers have been abuzz about the new hottest commodity: the Tungsten Cube. No, it’s not ... Read more »

Senate directs NASA to choose another company to build a lunar lander: report

Read more »

First lunar samples in over 45 years key to moon's history

Last December, China's ambitious lunar sampling mission returned to Earth with the first lunar samples since NASA's Apollo and Russia's Luna missions, which ended in 1976. The first fresh samples ... Read more »

A police officer charged with murder, a secret hearing and a newspaper's pitch to Virginia's Supreme Court

1 / 2A police officer charged with murder, a secret hearing and a newspaper’s pitch to Virginia’s Supreme Court An attorney for the Daily Press and The Virginian-Pilot told a ... Read more »

Drug could help people with diabetes recover after heart attack, study suggests

Researchers have identified a drug that could help improve heart function in people with diabetes who have heart attacks. Currently in clinical trials as a potential treatment for a form ... Read more »

Almond drink ad banned over ‘good for the planet' claim

A poster for an almond drink has been banned for making the “misleading” environmental claim that the product is “good for the planet”. The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) announced last ... Read more »

Golden touch: Royal Mint to recycle precious metals from electronics waste

The Royal Mint is set to bring pioneering technology to the UK that will allow it to recycle discarded mobile phones and laptops to recover gold, silver and precious metals. ... Read more »

Texas plane crash - live: Aircraft owner identified as video shows shocking aftermath of Houston wreck

A plane carrying 21 passengers and crew crashed and burst into flames near Houston, Texas. Officials say that amazingly no-one was killed in the accident in Waller County, and two ... Read more »

After canceled lecture, free speech debate roils science academia

Some academics are pushing back against what they see as personal politics overshadowing scientific work. Others stress that actions have consequences. Read more »

Boeing zeros in on cause of Starliner launch scrub

Engineers are zeroing in on the “root cause” of a disappointing August launch scrub that grounded Boeing's Starliner astronaut ferry ship: humidity-triggered corrosion in key propulsion system valves, company managers ... Read more »

Targeted prostate cancer screening ‘could benefit men with inherited syndrome'

Men who inherit an increased risk of cancer through Lynch syndrome could benefit from regular specific testing to detect early signs of prostate cancer, researchers have said. Lynch syndrome increases ... Read more »

Astronaut Chris Hadfield found space for 'The Apollo Murders' in real history

© Provided by Space Chris Hadfield, former Canadian Space Agency astronaut, holds up a copy of his first novel, “The Apollo Murders.” Many writers have looked back at the events ... Read more »

A secret NASA moon mission launches in Chris Hadfield's alt-history novel 'The Apollo Murders' (book excerpt)

© Provided by Space Canadian astronaut Chris Hadfield’s new alternative history science fiction book “The Apollo Murders” recounts a Space Race to the moon very different from our own. New ... Read more »

Netflix is shifting the way it ranks its most popular titles

© Image: Netflix An image from Netflix’s popular title Squid Game. Netflix will change the public-facing metrics it uses to rank the most popular titles on its streaming service, the ... Read more »

Will we be advised to work from home again during the winter?

Employers will benefit from consulting with their workers about what they feel most comfortable doing if COVID-19 infections begin to rise this winter. Photo: Getty Since COVID-19 restrictions were eased ... Read more »

Six from MIT named American Physical Society Fellows for 2021

APS names Bourouiba, Grego, Liu, Peacock, Winslow, and Yildiz as MIT’s newest fellows for their contributions to physics. Read more »

Cynthia Breazeal named senior associate dean for open learning

Social robotics and artificial intelligence pioneer will oversee business units and help to guide innovative learning initiatives. Read more »

Inspiration4's Hayley Arceneaux Says Historic Space Mission 'Changed Me in Unexpected Ways'

inspiration 4 crew Inspiration4 The Inspiration4 crew in the Dragon's cupola It's been a month since Hayley Arceneaux returned from space, and now the Inspiration4 Medical Officer is opening up ... Read more »

‘Electric cars will not solve all our problems': Government's £26bn plan to cut greenhouse emissions

A new £620 million fund will continue to provide grants for electric vehicles as well as new on-street charging stations to help those without their own driveways – Jens Schlueter/AFP ... Read more »

Covid: Oxford scientists ‘working on new jab' to combat Delta variant

© PA Coronavirus – Fri Sep 17, 2021 Scientists at Oxford University are working on a modified version of the AstraZeneca Covid vaccine to target the Delta variant, according to ... Read more »

Canon 5D Mark IV review

© Provided by Space Canon 5D Mark IV review: image shows Canon 5D Mark IV For Canon shooters with older 5D models, the Canon 5D Mark IV is a pleasant ... Read more »

How serious is the government ‘ban' on new gas boilers from 2035?

© Getty Home heating systems are a major source of greenhouse gas emissions – Getty Thanks to the phase out of coal from the national grid – the most polluting ... Read more »

Government defeat as peers demand action to bolster future telecoms security

Peers have defeated the Government in backing a move aimed at strengthening the nation’s telecoms security by ensuring a diverse supply chain. The House of Lords supported by 180 votes ... Read more »

Fisher-Price Reinvents the Rotary Dial 'Chatter Telephone' for Adults — and It Has Bluetooth!

chatter telephone Mattel Inc. The Fisher-Price Chatter Telephone Ring, ring — your childhood is calling! On Tuesday, Fisher-Price unveiled its newest project: the relaunch of its Chatter Telephone. In honor ... Read more »

Will Smith shows off the results of his 'Dad Bod Challenge,' months after saying he was in the 'worst shape' of his life

HANNIBAL HANSCHKE/Reuters Will Smith posted an Instagram video showing his body transformation progress. Smith started the “Dad Bod Challenge” after saying he was in the worst shape of his life ... Read more »

Boiler upgrade scheme: When can you claim £5,000 to swap gas for a heat pump?

The government’s new grant will help 90,000 homes install heat pumps. (Getty Images) The government has announced a boiler upgrade scheme that will provide tens of thousands of households with ... Read more »

Government proposes £5,000 grant for households to swap boilers for heat pumps

The £5,000 grants will be available from next April (PA Wire) Government has set out plans to offer grants worth £5,000 for households willing to replace their gas boiler with ... Read more »

Adele says she still eats McDonald's once a week despite weight loss

Adele said thatr just because she has lost weight doesn’t mean she has stopped eating junk food. (Getty Images) Adele has confessed she still eats McDonald's once a week despite ... Read more »

Woman tries to drive over Insulate Britain protestors

An infuriated woman attempted to drive over Insulate Britain protesters as they blocked roads once again. Footage shared on Monday shows the driver pulling up behind the three blocking traffic, ... Read more »

A meteor that incinerated the residents of an ancient city inspired the biblical story of Sodom, research suggests

An artist’s depiction of a meteor in the sky above Tall el-Hammam, an ancient Middle Eastern city in present-day Jordan. Allen West and Jennifer Rice In the biblical story of ... Read more »

New cancer treatment may reawaken the immune system

By combining chemotherapy, tumor injury, and immunotherapy, researchers show that the immune system can be re-engaged to destroy tumors in mice. Read more »

Who knew you could get a top-rated laptop for only $240?

Yahoo Life is committed to finding you the best products at the best prices. We may receive a share from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability ... Read more »

Europe's veteran gamma-ray space telescope nearly killed by charged particle strike

© Provided by Space The European Space Agency’s longest serving space telescope Integrals looks for sources of the most energetic radiation in the universe. The European Space Agency (ESA) nearly ... Read more »