Neuralink and Tesla have an AI problem that Elon's money can't solve

Asia's Tech News Daily

Tesla Motors, Artificial intelligence, Google, artificial general intelligence, Elon Musk, solve autism, fill the night sky with satellites, 10, 20, or 100 years away, or not, Follow @neural

Elon Musk’s problems are bigger and more important than yours. While most of us are consumed with our day-to-day activities, Musk has been anointed by a higher power to save us all from ourselves.

He’s here to ensure we , make , solve autism (his words, not mine), , fill the night sky with satellites so everyone can have internet access, and .

He doesn’t exactly know how we’re going to accomplish all those things, but he has more than enough money to turn any and every single good idea he’s ever had into a functioning industry.

Who cares if Tesla’s 10, 20, or 100 years away from actually solving the driverless car problem? are in near-unanimous agreement that $TSLA is doing just fine with its current amount of progress.

What the scientific and machine learning communities think is usually irrelevant to the mainstream when it comes to Musk. The entire field’s views on driverless cars are usually relegated to a mumbling sentence in the next-to-last paragraph of articles about Tesla’s endeavors.

It typically goes something like this: “some experts think these technologies may take longer to mature.

And who cares if Neuralink’s already and is currently about to “invent” a brain-computer interface that’s exactly as sophisticated as the one ?

People who get the opportunity to invest in Neuralink will make money as long as Elon keeps the hype-train going. Never mind that the distant technology he claims will one day take the his company is making today and turn it into a magical telepathy machine is purely hypothetical in 2021.

The reality is that AI can’t do the things Musk needs it to do in order for Tesla and Neuralink to make good on his promises.

Here’s why:

  1. AI has a serious “mapping” problem that Tesla, Neuralink, Google, Amazon, Facebook, Microsoft, OpenAI, DeepMind and the rest of the players in the field currently have no idea how to solve.
  2. Elon’s money is useless here.

AI’s “mapping” problem

When we talk about a mapping problem we don’t mean Google Maps. We’re referring to the idea that maps themselves can’t possible by one-to-one representations of a given area.

Any “map” automatically suffers from severe data loss. In a “real” territory, you can count every blade of grass, every pebble, and every mud puddle. On a map, you just see a tiny representation of the immense reality. Maps are useful for directions, but if you’re trying to count the number of trees on your property or determine exactly how many wolverines are hiding in a nearby thicket, they’re pretty useless.

When we train a deep learning system to “understand” something, we have to feed it data. And when it comes to massively complex tasks such as driving a car or interpreting brain waves, it’s simply impossible to have all of the data. We just sort of map out a tiny-scale approximation of the problem and hope we can scale the algorithms to task.

This is the biggest problem in AI. It’s why Tesla can use to train its algorithms in millions, billions, or trillions of iterations – giving its vehicles more driving experience than that of every human who has ever existed combined — and, yet, it still makes .

We can all point and shriek “Autopilot is safer than unaugmented human driving!” just like Musk does, but the fact of the matter is that humans are far safer drivers without Autopilot than Tesla’s Full Self Driving features are without a human.

Making the safest, fastest, most efficient production car in history is an incredible feat for which Musk and Tesla should be lauded. But that doesn’t mean the company is anywhere near solving driverless cars or any of the AI problems that plague the entire industry.

No amount of money is going to brute-force human-level algorithms, and Elon Musk may be the only AI “expert” who still believes is the key to self-driving vehicles.

And the exact same problem applies to Neuralink, but at a much larger scale.

Experts believe there are more than . Despite what Elon Musk may have recently tweeted, we don’t even have a basic map of those neurons.

Replacing faulty/missing neurons with circuits is the right way to think about it. Many problems can be solved just bridging signals between existing neurons.

Progress will accelerate when we have devices in humans (hard to have nuanced conversations with monkeys) next year.

— Elon Musk (@elonmusk)

In fact, neuroscientists are still challenging the idea of regionalized brain activity. indicate that different neurons light up in changing patterns even when brains access the same memories or thoughts more than once. In other words: if you perfectly map out what happens when a person thinks about ice cream, the next time they think about ice cream the old map could be completely useless.

We don’t know how to map the brain, which means we have no way of building a dataset to train AI how to interpret it.

So how do you train an AI to model brain activity? You fake it. You teach a monkey to push a button to summon food and then you teach them how to use a brain computer interface to push the button – as Fetz did back in 1969.

Then you teach an AI to interpret the whole of the monkey’s brain activity in such a way that it can tell whether the monkey was trying to push the button or not.

Keep in mind, the AI does not interpret what the monkey wants to do, it just interprets whether the button should be pushed or not.

So, you’d need a button for everything. You’d need enough test subjects wearing BCIs to generate enough generalized brainwave data to train the AI to perform every single function you desired.

The equivalent of this would be if Spotify had to build robots and teach them to play the actual instruments used to make every song on the platform.

Every time you wanted to listen to “Beat It” by Michael Jackson, you’d have to put a training request in with the robots. They’d pick up the instruments and start making absolutely random noises for thousands or millions of training hours until they “” something similar to “Beat It.”

As the AI changed its version of the song, its human developers would give it feedback to indicate if it was getting closer to the original tune or further away.

Meanwhile, a semi-talented human musician could play the entire composition for just about any Michael Jackson song after .

Elon’s money is no good here

Robots don’t care how rich you are. In fact, AI doesn’t care about anything because it’s just a bunch of algorithms getting smashed together with data to produce bespoke output.

People tend to assume Tesla and Neuralink are going to solve the AI problem because they have, essentially, unlimited backing.

But, as Ian Goodfellow at Apple, Yann LeCun at Facebook, and Jeff Dean at Google can all tell you: if you could solve self-driving cars, the human brain, or AGI with money, it would have already been solved.

Musk may be the richest man alive, but even his wealth doesn’t eclipse .

And, what the general public doesn’t quite seem to grasp is this: Facebook, Google, and Tesla, and all the other AI companies are all working on the exact same AI problems.

When DeepMind was founded its purpose was not to win chess or Go games. It’s purpose was . It’s and just about any other multimodal AI system being developed today.

When with his take on neural networking in 2014, he and others working on similar challenges lit a fire under the technology world.

In the time since, we’ve seen the development of that push the very limits of compute and hardware. And, even with all of that, we could still be decades or more away from self-driving cars or algorithms that can interpret human neuronal activity.

Money can’t buy a technological breakthrough (it doesn’t hurt, of course, but scientific miracles take more than funding). And, unfortunately for Tesla and Neuralink, many of the smartest, most talented AI researchers in the world know that . 

Perhaps that’s why Musk has expanded his recruitment efforts beyond researchers with a background in AI and is now trying to lure any computer science talent he can find.

A background in “AI” is not needed, just exceptional skill in software or computer design

— Elon Musk (@elonmusk)

The good news is that absolutely no amount of sober evaluation can dampen the spirits of Musk’s indefatigable fans. Whether he can or not has no impact on the amount of worship he receives.

And that’s as likely to change as a Tesla’s ability to produce a self-driving car or Neuralink’s ability to interpret neuron activity in human brains.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Safari 15 may have a serious security flaw, and there's no patch in sight

Security experts have uncovered a major flaw in the latest version of Apple’s internet browser which is leaking browsing history and even some identity data saved in associated Google accounts. ... Read more »

Apple's MR headset is sounding less and less appealing by the day

Even more rumors suggest that Apple’s mixed-reality headset could be priced at over $2,000 at launch (around £1,500 / AU$2,750). While Apple has yet to officially announce its VR and ... Read more »

Un exempleado de Google, quien trabajó para la empresa durante 7 años, hizo acusaciones públicas sobre la cultura de consumo excesivo de alcohol y acoso sexual dentro de la organización

Un exempleado de Google, quien renunció en 2015, criticó públicamente a su antiguo empleador mediante una publicación en Reddit y con Insider; alegando una cultura “tóxica” del consumo de alcohol  ... Read more »

Apple may make these changes to iPad Pro and iPad Air in 2022

Apple is reportedly planning to launch a fifth-generation iPad Air soon. According to a report by Japanese blog Mac Otakara, the tech giant will likely launch the new iPad Air ... Read more »

Chingari raises $15 million funding from Republic Capital, others

Short-video platform Chingari on Monday said it has raised USD 15 million (about Rs 111.4 crore) in funding led by Republic Capital. The extended Series A round also saw participation ... Read more »

Agritech startup DeHaat acquires Helicrofter

Agritech startup DeHaat on Monday said it has acquired Maharashtra-based B2B agri-input marketplace startup called Helicrofter, for an undisclosed sum.With the integration of Helicrofter, encompassing over 2,000 agri-input retailers and ... Read more »

PS5 backward compatibility looks to be inching closer

The prices of several PS3 games have appeared on the PS5 store, leading fans to speculate that backward compatibility for some PlayStation titles is on the way. PS3 games listed ... Read more »

Where is the new Scream 5 movie streaming?

The fifth instalment in the iconic Scream franchise is one of the most anticipated new horror movies of 2022, and audiences are flocking to see Ghostface in action once again ... Read more »

Here are the countries fighting Apple's App Store monopoly

Apple has benefited a lot from the App Store and the developer ecosystem. Heck, it’s probably made more than $100 billion from its fees since 2008. However, many companies and ... Read more »

3 mindset shifts your bank needs for a successful digital transformation

In a previous article, we discussed how a whopping initiatives and that banks experience specific issues like legacy processes, tightly coupled technical systems, failure of innovation labs, lack of proper ... Read more »

UK aviation authority says it has no concerns about C-Band 5G

The Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) says it has no reason to believe that 5G services using C-Band spectrum could interfere with sensitive aircraft equipment, putting it at odds with its ... Read more »

Cryptobros splash millions on rare ‘Dune' book, think they own the copyright

A collective known as Spice DAO spent €2.66M ($3.04M) on a copy of Alejandro Jodorowsky’s Dune book. The problem is they want to turn the book into an animated show: ... Read more »

Moon Knight release date leaks ahead of trailer debut

The release date for Marvel Studios’ Moon Knight has leaked online ahead of the Disney Plus show’s trailer, which lands today (January 17). We previously reported on the rumours that ... Read more »

HBO Max free trial: is it currently available?

Newbies to the streaming game almost always offer tasters, and when first launched there was a 7-day HBO Max free trial available for anyone in the US. However, much like ... Read more »

Nvidia RTX 3090 Ti GPU leak suggests eye-watering power demands

Nvidia’s GeForce RTX 3090 Ti will hopefully arrive shortly, and purported specs for an MSI version have been leaked which include a major revelation on the power consumption front. In ... Read more »

The UK government has an interesting strategy to oppose E2E encryption

The UK government has hired a top ad agency to help it launch a campaign against Meta’s plans to introduce end-to-end encryption (E2E) for Messenger on the grounds that it ... Read more »

Garmin Fenix 6 gets a huge firmware update, including some surprises

Garmin has released a hefty firmware update for the Garmin Fenix 6, which adds a host of new sports tracking profiles, and improved fitness tracking algorithms. We’re still awaiting confirmation ... Read more »

Good news - Amazon will still accept Visa credit cards

Amazon has stepped back from its plans to stop accepting Visa credit cards in the UK. The ecommerce giant had said it would halt Visa credit card payments from January ... Read more »

Windows 11's best app is getting even better

Microsoft is working on making the best app in Windows 11, Your Phone, even better in an upcoming update to the operating system. The Your Phone app connects to your ... Read more »

Walmart planning to enter Metaverse, sell NFTs: Report

Amid the buzz around Metaverse, retail giant Walmart has revealed plans to enter the field of highly immersive virtual reality/augmented reality (VR/AR) and Blockchain-based world.Walmart’s trademark filings indicate that the ... Read more »

Destructive malware operation targeting Ukrainian govt, firms: Microsoft

Microsoft has identified evidence of a destructive malware operation targeting multiple organisations — government, nonprofits organisations and IT firms — in Ukraine.According to Microsoft Threat Intelligence Centre (MSTIC), this malware ... Read more »

Beware: Nintendo warns buyers about Switch scammers online

Nintendo has warned gamers about fake websites that are supposedly selling Switch consoles at a heavily discounted price. The company issued a statement via their Japanese site (thanks, Siliconera) and ... Read more »

Could the next Spider-Verse movie look even better than the original?

Spider-Man fans, get excited. If you thought 2018’s Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse was a visual delight, the filmmaking duo behind its upcoming sequel have promised an even more ambitious artistic ... Read more »

Malware targeting Linux systems hit a new high in 2021

The Linux operating system is growing more and more interesting for malicious actors, a report from Crowdstrike has claimed. The company’s latest threat telemetry data has shown that malware for ... Read more »

US-China tech war: Chinese semiconductor output surged 33 per cent last year, double the growth rate in 2020

China’s output of integrated circuits (ICs), including those produced by local companies and foreign-owned factories, last year grew at double the rate seen in 2020, according to Chinese government data. ... Read more »

Apple AirPods Pro are nearly $60 off at Amazon — 'Audio and mic quality is amazing'

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. This is one great small package! (Photo: Amazon) Good things come ... Read more »

Brooklyn Beckham seriously divides fans with new photo – fiancée Nicola Peltz reacts

Brooklyn Beckham has come under fire after posting a new snapshot on Instagram. READ: Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz's living room inside $10.5m home is not what we expected The ... Read more »

New Assassin's Creed games could stream on Nintendo Switch and mobile – here's how

Ubisoft is looking to enhance its game streaming services – and might soon be bringing Ubisoft Plus other platforms – thanks to a new partnership with Gamestream. This collaboration will ... Read more »

Oppo Find X5 Pro leak says it'll even have the same camera brand as OnePlus 10 Pro

Read more »

A huge Google Pixel 6 update is here to fix loads of annoying bugs

If there’s one thing the Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro might be remembered for, it’s the ongoing issues with the phones many users have been experiencing, which have ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S22 Plus leak points to a bright screen and surprisingly fast charging

There’s not much about the Samsung Galaxy S22 range that hasn’t been leaked at this point, and we’re largely down to small details such as screen brightness. But we now ... Read more »

‘I'm so afraid': Child refugees forced to share rooms with adults after being wrongly deemed over 18

Ministers have been accused of ‘washing their hands of’ child asylum seekers by operating an age assessment process that often wrongly labels them adults (AFP via Getty Images) Child refugees ... Read more »

Apple reportedly adding this classic MacBook Pro model to ‘vintage' list

Apple is reportedly planning to add another MacBook to its vintage list of products this month. According to an internal memo obtained by MacRumors, the tech giant will be adding ... Read more »

Ptron Force X11 smartwatch with Bluetooth calling launched at Rs 2,799

Smart wearable brand Ptron has expanded its product portfolio in India. The company has launched the Ptron Force X11 smartwatch with Bluetooth calling feature and 1.7-inch HD full-touch display.Ptron Force ... Read more »

Investor disappointments continue for Kakao

Kakao’s corporate identity (Kakao)Started as a mere app developing company, South Korea’s platform giant Kakao has been on the fast track of success, becoming the nation‘s fifth-largest business entity just ... Read more »

Metaverse: Walmart hints at introducing NFTs and cryptocurrency in trademark applications

Photo credit: Marques Thomas / Unsplash Some of the biggest brands around the world have been launching new products and campaigns that would put them into the metaverse over the last year. ... Read more »

Air carriers expand mileage services before merger

The Korean Air fleet (Yonhap)Korea’s two leading carriers, Korean Air and Asiana Airlines, plan to expand mileage services to encourage customers to spend their points that would otherwise be left ... Read more »

Entrepreneurs Are Leveraging the NFT World In the Name Of Polar Bears

Many buzzes have been created of late around the NFT space as projects associated with saving endangered species like polar bears are doing the rounds. Handout There have been quite ... Read more »

China gaming crackdown: Tencent prompts young gamers to adhere to 14-hour playtime limit during four-week winter break

Tencent Holdings, which runs the world’s biggest video gaming business by revenue and China’s largest social media platform, is reminding its game subscribers aged under 18 to strictly follow their ... Read more »

‘Halo Infinite' Shop to get lower prices ‘across the board' and more bundled items will be sold separately

From the “Halo Infinite – Fracture: Tenrai” trailer | Photo credit: HALO / YouTube screenshot “Halo Infinite” marked a massive shift in the franchise after introducing its online multiplayer mode ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic