Nettie Davis, Charles Penson indicted by grand jury over election raffle comments

Oct. 13—TUPELO — Nettie Davis, a 20-year member of the Tupelo City Council, and Charles Penson, the chairman of the Democratic municipal executive committee, have both been indicted on misdemeanor charges of violating state election laws, according to documents obtained by the Daily Journal.

Davis and Penson stand accused of proposing or conducting an unlawful lottery as a voting incentive.

Mississippi statute makes it illegal for anyone to “put up or in any way offer any prize, cash award or other item of value to be raffled, drawn for, played for or contested for in order to encourage a person to vote or to refrain from voting in any election.”

Neither Davis nor Penson have yet made an appearance in court related to the indictments, which are still under seal.

District Attorney John Weddle had no comment.

Jim Waide, a defense attorney representing both defendants, told the Daily Journal on Wednesday afternoon that he has not yet seen the indictments.

The charges lodged against Davis and Penson are only misdemeanors and carry no possibility of jail time. Instead, both could face maximum fines of $5,000 if convicted.

However, the political stakes for Davis could not be higher. If convicted, state statute appears to require that she be removed from office, though her defense counsel has suggested in civil court filings that the relevant criteria for her removal from office have not been met.

An indictment only means that a grand jury believed there was reasonable cause to believe that a crime has been committed, but it does not determine guilt or innocence.

Only prosecutors present a case to the grand jury. Very rarely are defense counsel or other representatives of the potential defendants present. A grand jury met in early September in Lee County, during which Davis and Penson were both indicted.

Municipal campaign rally at root of criminal charges

The indictment of Davis stems from a June 5 campaign rally, which occurred just days before the general election for municipal offices in Tupelo. In a video of that rally that first appeared on the social media platform Facebook, Davis solicited donations for a raffle intended to award cash prizes to people who voted in the general election.

“We'll pull names after they have voted, and what we'll do is give this money away the day after the voting is over,” Davis said on the video.

The raffle never actually took place, according to court filings and people who attended the rally.

Penson's indictment is likewise linked to evidence that originated on Facebook. In a May 29 Facebook post, Penson said that local clergy were using financial incentives to encourage voting.

“Stay tuned for details on cash prizes to church with most absentee voters, church with most voters, oldest voter and youngest voter for the June 8 election,” Penson wrote at the time.

On the eve of the municipal general election, Weddle and Secretary of State Michael Watson both released public statements indicating that investigations were ongoing into these remarks.

“These actions will not be tolerated,” Weddle said at the time. “I am dedicated to handling this matter and any other violations aggressively.”

Controversy has rallied Davis allies, Democratic Party offers muted response

With two prominent local Democrats now under indictment, local and state party leaders are largely holding their silence.

Jim Newman, the chairman of the Lee County Democratic Party, did not wish to comment in detail on the charges set out in the indictments, but said that Penson and Davis “are well represented by counsel.”

Newman, who was present when the election raffle comments occurred, said on a previous occasion that he believes Davis has been targeted in order to advance a partisan agenda.

Tyree Irving, the chairman of the Mississippi Democratic Party and a former Mississippi Court of Appeals judge, did not immediately returns calls on Wednesday afternoon seeking comment.

In recent months, as expectations mounted that Davis would face criminal prosecution, local ministers, progressive activists and local Democratic Party leaders have rallied around her.

Some voices have accused the district attorney, a Republican, of carrying out a “political vendetta” against Davis, a Democrat, and believe the charges should be dropped.

“There is a day of reckoning coming for the DA,” the Rev. Jeffrey Gladney previously said at a press conference. “He has an election coming up, and I will do everything in my power to get every vote against him. We want to stand with Ms. Davis.”

Davis and Penson have long history in local politics

Davis and Penson are both prominent figures within local politics and the city's Black community. A longtime elected representative of the city's Ward 4, Davis was the first Black woman elected to the Tupelo City Council.

She was active in the Civil Rights movement and was one of around 200 students who participated in a mass sit-in protest at a lunch counter in the Nashville area to advocate for desegregation and for voting rights for Black citizens.

Penson is a minister and has sought elected office on several occasions, including a state House of Representatives seat and an at-large seat on the Tupelo City Council. He was also worked for 10 years as the personnel director for the City of Tupelo.

He was also a plaintiff in a lawsuit that eliminated the city of Tupelo's two at-large seats on the City Council on the basis that they diluted Black voting power.

Davis claims law against election lotteries unconstitutionally restricts free speech

In anticipation of her indictment, Davis already brought suit in August initially asking a Hinds County Circuit Court judge to find unconstitutional the law she is accused of violating.

That civil claim, which is seeking a declaratory judgment, is now pending in federal court rather than state circuit court.

In filings on behalf of Davis, Waide claims the statute in question is unconstitutionally vague and that it violates the free speech protections of the U.S. Constitution. In support of this argument, he cites U.S. Supreme Court precedent finding that campaign contributions are constitutionally protected free speech.

“The offering of a possibility of obtaining a small 'item of value' if a person votes constitutes speech,” Waide wrote in court filings. “The United States Supreme Court has held that even large campaign contributions made in order to encourage persons to vote for a particular candidate are protected by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.”

This civil lawsuit names Watson as a defendant. He has requested that the case be dismissed.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Coca growers capture 180 soldiers destroying crops in Colombia

Colombian coca growers have taken hostage about 180 soldiers who were eradicating crops of the cocaine-yielding plant near the Venezuelan border, a military official said Thursday. © Raul ARBOLEDA View ... Read more »

Jury awards $10M to executive who says he was fired because he's a white man

David Duvall, a former top executive at North Carolina-based Novant Health, was awarded US$10 million on Tuesday by a federal jury after he filed a lawsuit claiming he lost his ... Read more »

Biden hails 'historic' deal, urges support

President Biden on Thursday defended his social spending framework while attempting to sell the public on a pared-back economic agenda, even as a number of congressional Democrats appear uncertain about ... Read more »

Education blunder igniting suburban parents driving McAuliffe panic in Virginia

In a Virginia gubernatorial debate on Sept. 29 with Republican opponent Glenn Youngkin, Democratic nominee and former governor Terry McAuliffe declared: “I don’t think parents should be telling schools what ... Read more »

$555bn in climate action but no new tax on billionaires: what's in Biden's plan?

Joe Biden on Thursday released the framework of a $1.75tn social and climate spending proposal after of weeks of fraught negotiations with congressional Democrats. © Provided by The Guardian Photograph: ... Read more »

NHL Yahoo Cup: DFS strategy, lineups for Round 4

On Thursday, the puck will drop on Round 4 of the free-to-enter NHL Yahoo Cup. Canucks’ Elias Pettersson and Quinn Hughes are worthy of a spot on your roster in ... Read more »

Suncor is an 'underappreciated' cash machine: analyst

Suncor Energy’s (SU.TO)(SU) plan to double its payout to shareholders on the heels of a strong quarter boosted by higher oil prices sent the company’s stock to its highest level ... Read more »

Fans Think They've Spotted Selena Gomez in the Reflection of Chris Evans' Piano

Good morning to everyone who’s still convinced that Selena Gomez and Chris Evans are dating even though much of the the previous evidence turned out to be fake! Ahem, there’s ... Read more »

Movistar Riders scrape by TYLOO to remain alive in PGL Stockholm Major

© Provided by Dot Esports Movistar Riders’ all-Spanish CS:GO team get to fight another day in the PGL Stockholm Major Challengers Stage after narrowly defeating TYLOO 2-1 today in the ... Read more »

British tourist, 24, drowned after jumping off waterfall in Australia

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A British tourist tragically died after jumping off waterfalls in Australia in the middle of a fun-filled afternoon with friends, an inquest heard ... Read more »

Tyson Fury vs Dillian Whyte declaration made for 'early 2022' fight

Eddie Hearn has stated that Dillian Whyte is ‘more likely’ to face Tyson Fury in his next bout rather than a rearrangement of the clash against Otto Wallin. The Brit ... Read more »

At Meeting With States Over Covid, Mandaviya Creates WhatsApp Group For Easy Communication

© Provided by News18 At Meeting With States Over Covid, Mandaviya Creates WhatsApp Group For Easy Communication One positive outcome of the meeting between Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya and ... Read more »

Australia vs Sri Lanka, ICC T20 World Cup 2021, Live Cricket Score: Hasaranga sends back Finch after AUS make quick start

22:00:22 IST Hasaranga doesn’t make a good start to the over as Warner pulls him for FOUR and then takes 2 runs off the next ball. Warner uses the gap ... Read more »

Excited AbRam waves to paps from Shah Rukh Khan's Mannat post brother Aryan Khan's bail; WATCH

© Provided by Pinkvilla Three weeks after his arrest in connection to the Drugs Bust Case by the NCB, Bollywood superstar Shah Rukh Khan’s son, Aryan Khan has been finally ... Read more »

Lee Bowyer's answer to the wing back riddle - Birmingham City's predicted XI vs Middlesbrough

Life is never straightforward at Birmingham City and any hopes of not changing a winning team look to have been scuppered ahead of this weekend’s clash with Middlesbrough. News that ... Read more »

Italy blocks hate crime bill after unprecedented opposition from Vatican and far right

Italy has voted down a bill to tackle hate crimes against women, LGBT+ people and those with disabilities, all in the name of religious freedom. The bill – known as ... Read more »

Camilla praises Commonwealth during award ceremony for essayists

The Duchess of Cornwall has paid tribute to the “unity, purpose and friendship” of the Commonwealth, saying those who belong to it are “incredibly privileged”. The duchess, delivering a speech ... Read more »

Emily Maitlis stalker tells jurors he ‘had to breach' order to prove innocence

An “obsessive” stalker who has harassed BBC presenter Emily Maitlis for more than 25 years has told a jury he had to breach a restraining order “to prove my innocence”. ... Read more »

Climate crisis: The 5 biggest environmental challenges facing London as COP26 kicks off

© PA 2.60400382.jpg World leaders will hope that the COP26 Conference in Glasgow this coming weekend will prove to be a milestone in the fight against global warming. Boris Johnson ... Read more »

Valerien Ismael must unleash "vocal" 18 y/o colossus, he could save West Brom millions - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Ismael When Valerien Ismael took over as the new West Bromwich Albion manager this summer, the Frenchman arrived with a reputation of playing a direct ... Read more »

Bath suffer second ACL injury in as many weeks to add to struggling season

© Getty Images for Bath Rugby Beno Obano has ruptured his ACL – Getty Images for Bath Rugby Bath Rugby have suffered another blow to their struggling season as Beno ... Read more »

Darren Gough: Ashes won't be far from thought during World T20 clash

Darren Gough believes England’s T20 World Cup match with Australia is the perfect chance for either country to gain the early upper-hand ahead of the Ashes. © Provided by Cricket365 ... Read more »

No. 1 Sophomore Naasir Cunningham Focused on Staying on Top

Cunningham has already visited Connecticut, UCLA, St. John’s and USC. Coming into the summer, Naasir Cunningham didn’t set out to be considered the top player in the 2024 class. Sure, ... Read more »

Biden is heading to a meeting of world leaders with a massive new effort to fight the climate crisis - the biggest investment in his scaled-down $1.75 trillion spending plan

© Provided by Business Insider President Joe Biden. AP Photo/Evan Vucci Biden unveiled a $555 billion effort to fight the climate crisis ahead of the UN climate summit in Glasgow ... Read more »

Artefacts recovered from the ruins of Hiroshima to be auctioned

A rare enamel sign that survived the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima in August 1945 is due to be sold at auction. The piece of twisted metal, baring the words ... Read more »

Heart-stopping moment massive great white shark breaks open diver's cage as SEVEN beasts circle

THIS is the heart-stopping moment a diver managed to fend off a great white shark as several beasts circle him. Nail-biting footage captured by an onlooking cameraman, showed the huge ... Read more »

Pfizer says Biden administration has ordered 50M more vaccine doses for kids

© Getty Images Pfizer says Biden administration has ordered 50M more vaccine doses for kids Pfizer and BioNTech announced in a press release Thursday that they will be providing the ... Read more »

Sainsbury's says some items could run low this Christmas - but no food shortages

The boss of Sainsbury’s has hinted that shoppers may have less choice when doing their food shopping this Christmas. The supermarket chief said that there should be plenty of food ... Read more »

Poland: Parliament to debate bill banning LGBTQ pride parades

© Provided by Poles demonstrated against the proposed “Stop LGBT” bill Wednesday night Poland’s parliament is set to debate a law banning Pride parades and other public gestures in ... Read more »

RIBA reveals top 20 British homes in House of the Year 2021 longlist

A skinny home in an alley, a low-rise brick Passivhaus and a converted stone barn are among the varied projects on this year’s longlist for the RIBA House of the ... Read more »

Mortgages rise within HOURS of Budget: Natwest, HSBC & Barclays all put up rates

The warnings come as five high street lenders put their mortgage rates up today signalling that others will soon follow suit. At the same time, the Office for Budget Responsibility ... Read more »

Australia's Covid-19 cases increase anew

© The Manila Times Victoria State Premier Daniel Andrews addresses the media during a press conference in Melbourne, Australia, Monday, Aug. 31, 2020. Australia recorded its deadliest day of the ... Read more »

P&G PH supports Red Cross Covid-19 vaccination program

© The Manila Times Philippine Red Cross Secretary General Elizabeth Zavalla with Red Cross Calabarzon’s chapter administrators at the virtual turnover ceremony of a P5-million donation from P&G. CONTRIBUTED PHOTO ... Read more »

This festive season, balance your cravings with these simple tips

© Provided by The Indian Express The festive season is synonymous with scrumptious food, especially flavourful sweets. As as result, it becomes difficult to stick to workout regimes and healthy ... Read more »

Fussballstar Cristiano Ronaldo wird wieder Vater von Zwillingen

© FilmMagic Cristiano Ronaldo ist seit 2016 mit dem Model Georgina Rodríguez zusammen. Cristiano Ronaldo freut sich erneut auf Zwillinge. Das gab der Starkicker per Instagram-Post samt Ultraschall-Beweis bekannt. Cristiano ... Read more »

Deutsches Gericht erkennt Lücke: Gefälschte Impfausweise sind nicht strafbar

Wer geimpft ist, der kriegt ein digitales Zertifikat. Damit stehen einem alle Türe offen. Und deswegen versuchen einige Betrüger ihr Glück in Apotheken, um mit einem gefälschten Impfausweis an das ... Read more »

14-year-old boy allegedly caught with loaded gun at NYC high school

A teen allegedly tried to get a loaded gun into Automotive High School in Williamsburg on Oct. 28, 2021. Helayne Seidman for NY Post A 14-year-old boy was busted Thursday ... Read more »

Tiger Woods' niece Cheyenne engaged to Yankees outfielder Aaron Hicks

Luckily, Tiger Woods is a Yankees fan. The golf star’s niece, Cheyenne Woods, is engaged to Yankees center fielder Aaron Hicks. Cheyenne, who’s also a pro golfer, announced the news ... Read more »

Sainsbury's says some items will be in low supply this Christmas in letter to shoppers

The boss of Sainsbury’s has hinted that shoppers may have less choice when doing their food shopping this Christmas. The supermarket chief said that there should be plenty of food ... Read more »

Assange extradition appeal: lawyers cite new claims of CIA plot to harm him

Photograph: Tolga Akmen/AFP/Getty Images Lawyers for Julian Assange have cited new allegations that the CIA plotted to kidnap or kill him as “grounds for fearing what will be done to ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic